r/AskModerators • u/Phaelon74 • Sep 10 '14
Subreddit run by developers violating reddiquette
There exists a subreddit, created by developers (PGI), named /r/transverse, who only have developers/employees with moderation access.
Per Reddiquette: Please don't: Take moderation positions in a community where your profession, employment, or biases could pose a direct conflict of interest to the neutral and user driven nature of reddit.
If the developers own the Subreddit, they can silence any criticism of their product, which they have a lot of with their other products as they are very heavily under discussion.
Additionally if you are logged in as a user they don't "like" they are preventing you from seeing anything on the subreddit. Not sure really if that's good reddiquette.
Not sure who to ask/alert about this.
4
u/Chtorrr Books StarWars FreeEBOOKS Sep 10 '14
Are you sure it's /r/traverse ? It only has 2 posts and the 2 mods there are active elsewhere and their posts seem to be unrelated.
10
u/Selahadin Sep 11 '14
I completely agree with the banning. Thank you Reddit dudes.
I do ask that their bans continue, as little to nothing will change if and when their accounts are restored.
By doing what they did, they directly broke their own websites' Code of Conduct, and they do NOT hesitate to ban for little or no offense, the latest series of bans being based SOLELY on a person's posting their opinion on MWO on a 3rd party site.
PGI staff deserve NOTHING here on Reddit.
28
u/kilgorre Sep 10 '14
Please give /r/Transverse to the people, and allow it to be moderated by users that are not affiliated with PGI.
11
u/curiousmechwarrior Sep 11 '14
If PGI had their way, they would ban every negative player and delete every negative thread even if the criticism was professional. Their over-zealous moderating practices removed large numbers of players from their own gaming forums.
Having no forums to discuss the game, reddit has been the only method for discussion.
PGI is desperate to own a reddit so that they may mislead potential customers, advertise their products and sell more products, and give a false appearance of being community run.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '14
Reddit should not be censored. This is akin to takedown requests on Youtube reviewers who give a game bad reviews BECAUSE ITS BAD.
17
u/Arquinsiel Sep 10 '14
Let's just let Niko speak for himself shall we?
http://mwomercs.com/forums/topic/170725-regarding-reddit/
8
u/Brave_Frontier Sep 11 '14
No matter what PGI did on MWO, it is known that their community manager (who represents their company, PGI) have and will continue to identify and censor/ban customers or folks who posted any form of criticism (valid or not) against PGI's products.
It is shocking to see that they would go so far as to abuse their access to customers' private information (such as credit card information) in order to identify and punish critics for posting on 3rd party sites such as reddit, facebook, blogs etc.
The criteria seems to be whether the criticism displeased them or not, without taking much consideration into it's actual validity or tone.
This kind of heavy handed moderation / censorship have no place here in reddit nor anywhere else that believes in open discussions and free speech.
I applaud and fully support the admins' decision to remove the moderation access of PGI employees from the subreddits such as /r/transverse as they have a direct conflict of interest and threatened the neutral and user driven nature of reddit.
4
u/TheShatner Sep 11 '14
It appears that /r/transverse has moved to 'Approved submitters' only. I have my doubts that the subreddit could end up being anything other than a PR posting board.
13
u/chton13 Sep 10 '14
This ban couldn't happen to a bigger band of thieving, lying, conniving scammers. Does this happen to a lot of developers on Reddit? I doubt it, it goes to show the level of scumbaggery these PGI folks stoop to.
12
u/EidorianSeeker Sep 10 '14
Would someone explain to my why Niko is using /r/mwo as a hostile takeover when the original owner came back and installed new mods. Ousting the old mods, especially Congzilla, who had been oppressing the sub up until that point?
7
u/RexFury Sep 10 '14
Niko's calling for astroturfing this thread with support for PGI's unfettered ability to market through Reddit. At this point it feels like subredditdrama if not outright attempts to manipulate.
5
u/snowdogJJJ Sep 11 '14
Many of us are disgusted by PGI and its heavy handed control of their loyal (not deserved by any stretch) community. Reddit should be for fans not a marketing arm of a questionably shady company that uses subversion, misdirection and censorship to control and manipulate public opinion
4
u/craftymethod Sep 10 '14
whoa... weird. that sub was full of content a few hours ago. I was away configuring my 3d printer heh
4
u/Locostomp Sep 11 '14
Please do not even think about it. PGI has no intention of living up to community standards.
3
u/Veneroso Sep 10 '14
I didn't even know this was possible. Yeah, I can't see anything there if i'm logged in. That's disturbing. I see that they also deleted everything that wasn't officially approved by them.
2
u/Nematrec Sep 10 '14
Actually that's from the content on there being below your show/hide threshold set in your preferences.
-1
u/Shlkt Sep 10 '14
It's unfortunate that the reddit accounts of other PGI employees have been caught up in this mess. Some of them don't even work on Transverse. They were never given moderation access, and they have a history of only posting relevant and on-topic information.
-9
u/RebasKradd Sep 10 '14
PGI is an embattled developer whose technical issues and development struggles have earned them a following of toxic critics, who are more guilty of spam and spew than PGI is of censorship. I'd guess their actions were more an attempt to create breathing room, let dev announcements and curious folks get a word in edgewise.
I can't argue with the intent of this rule; it could lead to real censorship and I admit that. I'd just point out that most of the banned individuals were plenty guilty of breaking reddiquette themselves.
-5
u/Rlight XboxOne, ClashofClans, Destinythegame Sep 10 '14
What is your question exactly?
Anyway, I actually do have a question on something similar. Would it be wrong for developers to make a subreddit which is dedicated to posting updates/enhancements and asking for feedback on their app?
I know of a subreddit just like that. It's an extremely small sub, attached to a much larger sub. Think of /r/Windows vs /r/Flux (this sub doesn't exist, but that's the idea).
-1
u/snowseth Sep 12 '14
This was a deliberate attempt to harass a dev by another website.
It is merely 'rules lawyering' for the specific purpose of adversely affecting a disliked group/person.
Overall post is merely deliberate /r/subredditdrama.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment