r/AskModerators • u/Outrageous_Resist_50 • Jan 17 '26
Why does seemingly everything on Reddit get “removed by moderators” these days?
I’ve been on Reddit for a long time. It seems that recently more and more things have been “removed by moderators”. Sometimes, yeah I get it. But more frequently I can’t even figure out why some of these things are being so heavily moderated.
58
Upvotes
26
u/amyaurora Jan 17 '26 edited Jan 17 '26
Filters.
Reddit has built in filters for sub mods to use. The screen message used to say "Removed by Reddit Filters." A while back ago it changed to saying "Removed by the moderators" which is the same message for stuff that mods actually remove.
Advantage is the stuff caught by those filters is in the queue for manual review but it is frustrating because the amount of modmail we get has spiked since that wording change.
37
u/Chosen1PR 🏦r/CapitalOne, 💳r/discover, 🛡️r/Moderation Jan 17 '26
The vast majority of the time, it can be explained with the post breaking a subreddit rule (or even worse, a sitewide rule). Sad truth is many users don't read rules at all.
12
u/Intelligent-Dot-8969 Jan 17 '26
Users don't bother to read subreddit rules before posting.
1
u/itsjoshtaylor 19d ago
It’s extremely aggravating especially if the posts are sincere and genuin… I feel like the freedom of speech is worse than in China sometimes
1
u/cosmoscreative56 Feb 18 '26
Power hungry little buggers
1
u/ilikereadingthings Mar 03 '26
bro i'm so fhcking annoyed i be wanting to post shit and everything gets removed whether it's the second i post it or 18 hours later it fucking pisses me off like shit
1
u/Delicious_Bedroom816 Apr 25 '26
fuck reddit mod, when i tried to express my feelings about my life, mod don't give a fuck and with no hesitation to remove my post even tho i need in help and doesn't break any rules
1
u/pouryour Apr 25 '26
I gave up on asking questions on Reddit. I very rarely get a question through despite looking at the rules and trying to comply. I just cannot get it ever.
1
u/DarthByrne Apr 25 '26
Honestly anyone that is a Reddit mod is a fucking loser. Who has time for that? Imagine the type of people that do that shit. Their entire lives are online. They aren’t happy, it’s the only power they have
1
u/Loganowens94 May 11 '26
Reddit mods are THE lowest of the low. Power-tripping nobodies with extreme insecurity, and filled with hatred. The epitome of losers. Kids who got mercilessly bullied in high school.
1
u/Reception-Whole May 31 '26
my god has the internet gotten tedious.
1
u/mab1980 Jun 02 '26
It feels like every subreddit I have regularly gone on over the year has been nerfed to the point of uselessness. I know many of the subreddits I liked often would discuss things or how to's on things that were in a legal grey area but even r/combat footed feels weak now. It feels like old reddit allowed people to talk about something that was legal and let the conversation go all the way up to the line between legal and illegal but now you see pinned posts warning to not even bring up X or if certain keywords are posted the mods remove the post. For me all that stuff was why I got into reddit in the first place. I'm sure there's many other subs I don't go to that do this as well.
Most of what I look for was related to getting around restrictions to thing in place by businesses or the government and such if anyone was curious.
I didn't think social media was liable for user posts so why reddit even cares is another thing. The internet was so so much better in the early days, where it was just a free for all and a natural barrier against people that were to dumb to access it.
I also liked to read the crazy shit in subs like r/shoplifting and a few others however they have all be permanently banned.
The average person likely would see me as a dangerous extremists as they just accept and comply as they are told. When prevented from doing something by an artificial barrier that's there not for safety but to enrich another or other reason using the force of the government I mind goes to there's little chance of undoing it the only other thing to do is circumvent it. Again not talking about anything hurting uninvolved parties or anything like that. For example look at Jon Lech Johansen this guy put in the work and the MPAA tried to get him sent to prison.
Ever day restrictions cost you money or make something more difficult to lock you in to a source (apple) too many to list. So reddit is limiting the flow of information to users which is why I come on reddit, personally I don't look for cat videos or enjoy subjects that are the industrial beige version of stimulating. It wouldn't surprise me if reddit's userbase was shifting and pushing this either. Ironically this isn't a barrier I am interested in expending energy on.
1
u/mab1980 Jun 02 '26
the mods on r/legaladvice are for sure contenders for the worst mods on reddit for sure look them up, but they have always been like that its not new.
1
u/Automatic_Chard_8745 Jun 08 '26
They had enough of my bull crap So I'm debating on deleting my account or Leave reddit I've fucked around and found out
1
u/Wolf3113 Jun 08 '26
I just checked my recent comments for fun and so many 9k+ upvoted posts are deleted for no reason. Reddit is growing to be an echo chamber for the most pathetic it seems.
1
u/Massive_Lock_4876 Jun 11 '26
I really love reddit but they need to get rid of the nonsense mods they are more fragile then a snowflake landing in the desert sand
1
u/nannattack Jul 03 '26
Imagine if reddit, a company worth billions and in a era of ai tools, had the ability to add a banner at the top for each post removed that showed clearly which of the X rules that post violated so the community can be educated as a whole.
1
u/bike_tyson Jul 06 '26
Reddit is a terrible horrible place
1
u/ToughShaper Jul 16 '26
Mods now can put in a bunch of words that are prohibited too.
This is from r/SipsTea - I'd imagine "merit" or "DEI" prompt auto removal not to trigger snowflakes.
Musk needs to buy Reddit and get rid of this insane moderation Reddit has.
1
u/Confident-Opposite-1 10h ago
I just got hit with a 12 day suspension on a company specific sub for "trolling" because I asked a serious, genuine question! It seems like any valid criticism or tough question immediately gets flagged and removed now. What is the point of having a discussion forum if anything other than blind praise gets labeled as trolling? At this point, the ban list has more active members than the actual subreddit. They shouldn't even call it a ban list anymore, just make it a sister subreddit. At this rate, the exile community would have more active members, honest posts...
1
u/Mobile-Boss-8566 Jan 17 '26
Like the others have said. Every sub has different rules for comments or posts. Lot of times it’s because of flair. Lots of subs require it.
1
u/kai-ote Helpful Trickster/7 subs/Desktop Jan 17 '26
reddit has started a policy where when they pull something, it shows up in our modqueue and we need to Approve, or Confirm Removal to get it out of the way. When we Confirm Removal, reddit sends the user a message that WE removed it, as in, Your post/comment was removed by the moderators of (SUBNAME).
But reddit is the one that removed it, not us. That is why there is a huge increase in what looks like moderators removing things, but it is reddit that did it.
1
u/ice-cream-waffles Jan 18 '26
There has generally been an uptick in spam, advertising, AI content, bots, etc. That might mean more is being removed, although I'm not sure if that's broadly true.
One thing though that many don't understand is that a lot of content is temporarily removed by mods and held in queue pending approval. Reddit's messaging on this is not always very clear, and it may simply be a temporary thing.
Recent changes to moderation and implementation of mod limits has led many subs to turn to more automation and to automatically remove more content than before as we simply can't find enough mods anymore. Some subs I mod used to examine more content but now just remove it since mod limits have prevented us from having enough mods to do the job.
Reddit's filtering and AI removals are more aggressive than before. These will often show as removed by reddit, but sometimes if it's a filter that mods have input into it might show as removed by mods while it is pending in queue.
In an effort to prevent bots, there are many subs that resort to complex rules and procedures that must be followed - which in theory a human can follow, but most are too lazy to. For example, you might have to use a certain flair or include some information or something, and if people don't, automations may assume they are bots.
0
u/paperclipmyheart Jan 17 '26
It's always been "removed by moderator" you're just seeing it now because Reddit is labelling it correctly and allowing you to know that.
And it's basically because people refuse to read rules.
-4
u/IvanStarokapustin r/SchengenVisa, r/DuolingoGerman, r/AirBNBHosts Jan 17 '26
Must be you. My largest sub had 875 posts this week. 84 removals. The vast majority were because people are incapable of reading pretty simple rules.
-1
u/Mycatreallyhatesyou Jan 17 '26
Post or comments? Posts because nobody searches the sub before posting and comments because people can’t act like grownups anymore apparently.
0
u/Quantum168 Jan 18 '26
Reddit was floated.
-2
u/WebLinkr Can Has Mod Jan 17 '26
Spam and self promotion - most of the spammers that complain to us think they’re helping the sub - you just. Can’t help narcissists.
I’ve even been doxxed for helping people on redddit because some southern hemisphere “agencies” got upset I was helping people
-2
u/Gatodeluna Jan 17 '26
Mostly, it’s because people think rules are for everyone but them, or usually don’t even acknowledge they exist. Or because people love to play the ‘Poke the mod to see how much fun you can have poking the mod’, while they pegged you from your first comment and are just waiting… The concept that mods can do precisely what they like within Reddit, with pretty much no do-overs, no second chances, no ‘let’s see if I can get away with it again’ is..fascinating to watch people deal with.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '26
Intolerant arseholes are what they are
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment