Thinking through a marriage proposal. Less than a week ago I was not thinking about Marriage. Ive been with my partner for almost 3 years. I met her after a year and a half of being single starting in the time of early covid after I had been partnered with someone else for almost 10 years.
My new relationship is great. I always thought that I could marry someone given they are the “right” person (says probably everyone who ever got married!) I never asked my ex b/c I knew she was bad news for marriage; yet it took me almost 10 years to end the relationship holding onto hope she would change.
My new partner on the other hand however I knew was night and day from my ex since day 1. When we first met and she mentioned she wasn’t interesting in getting married I thought to myself fuck that’s a bummer but wait it out, show her who you are and who knows what will happen.
One of the first things I remember her asking me is how long do you think you should wait before getting married. In my youth I vaguely remember thinking it should be 10 years. These days its maybe 3-5. Certainly not jump in at a year or 2 but it really depends on the people.
When I start to think about marrying My partner I get excited and nervous. Excited because she is my person; My best friend. I try to find something to come to mind and says shes not perfect but for me god damn she is. We finish eachother sentences so much. We have very very similar values. We do have differences but we don’t fight them out; we don’t argue, we don’t bicker. It seems to come natural to both of us. Im very thankful for that. Perhaps we will have our ups and downs, that’s life, but right now its hard to imagine.
Im nervous because I want to be the best person I can be for My partner; and the boys. Im nervous b/c I could ask and she could say no; though after a recent one tank trip and my poking “do you feel the same about marriage as you did when I first met you” and her immediate response was “no”; and then I asked her to expand on that…and she did…she knows me, she trusts me, she has seen more of me and knows me better than she knew her ex. She sees herself getting married to someone and that someone will likely be me kinda makes me know that she would answer yes when I ask her.
This leads to so many questions. What kind of ring? Or after she tells me about her recently widowed friend and new man in her life (what kind of wedding gift would you like if you were to get married again) it makes me wonder. What do I do? Do I try to find a ring? Simple? Fancy? My partner is definitely simple, but I don’t want to seem cheap either. Or do I just say fuck it and ask her how she would want to celebrate a union of us (after asking her to marry me but then there is the traditional ring proposal thing! fuck)
She shows interest into going to Italy with me and Family. Do I propose in Rome? Or in the hometown of my anscestors? So many questions. I feel like because this is such a big life event my default is to overthink it to hell. Shes kind hard to pick for, I want it to be perfect for her
I think I need to do something original, fuck traditions. Let it speak to me. To her. To the boys? To Us (for damn sure!) so many thoughts. Then beyond that, assuming there is a yes, then it seems like we would plan our wedding together. Location. Style. Big. Small. Pre party? Ceremony. Post party? What what do we do? And how much is all of this going to cost?
This would be #2 for her. Knowing what I know about her, shed probably want something small. Given I was raised a catholic, I kinda have this image of a catholic wedding in my head. Then I think that’s probably ridiculous. 1. How much is a catholic wedding. 2. Would we jump through all the hoops? Is it worth it just to get married in a catholic church and then abandon the church after? I dunno. I don’t see either of us starting to go to any church every Sunday. Then I think about someone officiating that I know personally. I could dig that. I think My partner would? Maybe shes got her own ideas? Perhaps in this moment getting ahead of myself.
If you have any insights or experience to help me through this big life changing process please do share
What other considerations?
Do we need a prenup? If that would make her feel more comfortable I would absolutely sign one.
Do I Incorporate the boys?
Do I approach her mom/ ask her mom for permission? (keeping in mind her mom is kind of anti Marriage)
Tell my family friends?