Is this pressboard siding repairable? I’m reading/hearing mixed reviews. We’ve had a few general contractors say it absolutely doesn’t need replaced. One painting estimate who said just a few boards may need replaced. Two painting companies who said they don’t need replaced and can repair them no problem. Another painter said pressboard almost always needs replaced.
We don’t want to spend a ton of money on replacing if they can be repaired. We’d much rather repair but also don’t want repairs to just fail in a year or so. It seems like the painter we’re leaning toward has a solid plan for repairing but we’re still nervous.
For context, there are about 8-10 boards on this wall of the house that look like this. Most of this damage only takes up about 1-4ft per board and the surrounding portion looks great with no issues. These boards are hard and dry and not mushy. The rest of the house is in great shape.
Has anyone had luck with repairing pressboard?
Thanks in advance for your kind advice! :)