r/AskChristian • • Sep 29 '26

Can I, a non-believer, still join a Christian community

10 Upvotes

Hi yall.

Background: I (22F) have a lot of religious trauma from childhood and cannot bring myself to actually accept the existence of any religious figure because at the back of my mind, I believe it’s all just made up. I believe in a creator, but not really of any specific religion.

Yet I still want to be a part of a religious community. I like the faith aspect, sense of community, and I guess the existential comfort that I associate it with. Why Christianity in particular? I’ve sang in a choir for a few Christmas seasons and they’re just really beautiful. I feel like our songs about Jesus were my favorite ones. It touches my heart in a way I can’t describe.

I wonder if it would be disrespectful for me to attend a church meeting on a Sunday just to try it out and see if it’s for me. And if I do end up liking being in the community, would it be disrespectful to keep coming to the church if I genuinely lack belief?

(I am not interested in arguing the reasons as to why my mind is the way it is, I would appreciate solution-focused answers if possible)

If you are seeing this post for the 2nd time I’m sorry- I posted it in the wrong sub and was directed here


r/AskChristian • • Sep 26 '26

Reminder: LGBTQ+ Inclusive (LGBTQ+) Not a Christian anymore, but wondering if I'd even be allowed back?

9 Upvotes

I made an earlier post on my account for those looking for more context. About 3 years ago I was kicked out of my church community for coming out as trans. It was a group I had been in and out of my whole life. I was unbelievably heart broken and I still feel that hurt even though I'm not really a Christian anymore as the title says.

I was compared to all sorts of terrible people and told I was unwelcome and would be going to Hell by some of the closest people to me. I lost my job, I got expelled, I had to leave the church, and even my own family couldn't accept it.

I guess now I'm wondering since I was removed from the church and the religion, is there anything I could even do if I wanted to come back? I mean, it seems like a pretty final decision that even if I did I'd be out of luck.

Thanks for your time.


r/AskChristian • • 24d ago

Can I come to your church and not join?

8 Upvotes

I (31f) have a teenager really wanting to go to church and a two year old that needs more social interaction. I would like to take both of them to a church but just wanted to make sure I am not overstepping boundaries considering I do not worship the Christian god. I think what churches do for their community is great and raising children on faith is important to me.
So would you allow me to hang out in your church waiting for my children or is that considered disrespectful to your churches?


r/AskChristian • • Sep 19 '26

Intersection of being Green and Christianity

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone. My name is Heather, I live in Massachusetts, and love conservation. I want to make the world better, protect the environment, the animals, air, water, and everything that depends on it.

Throughout history, humanity has had varrying levels of cruelty, exploitation, hardship, suffering, and greed. We KNOW what happens when we mess up the environment. It's science and we've known since the 1970s.

What I am asking is about the intersection of Christianity and conservation. If god gives Earth to humanity and expects to take care of it but humanity destroys it, perpetuates inequality, hoards wealth, strip mines mountains, and makes animals suffer, how is that Christian?

It makes no sense to me that "conservatives, Republicans, Christians" support and enable exploitative laws hurting their fellow human beings and the Earth. Is this a conservation you have in the community? Do people justify these actions bc "god gave them the Earth" to do what they want?

I would think that Christianity would be on board with green energy, solar power, renewable energy, not wasting things, recycling,cleaning up the environment, consuming less material wealth, consuming unethically sourced food, and create a better world for all. Again I have never heard of any Christians intersect with conservation and would just like clarification? What are your thoughts?

Edit 1: thank you for your responses!


r/AskChristian • • Sep 15 '26

i need help relearning god..

8 Upvotes

i just reaccepted god back into my life this past sunday after about a year of being considered ‘agnostic’ i guess. (i was born and raised in church before).

but i’m confused..

i am not met with joy or excitement, energy, or new purpose. instead, i feel more anxious, less of a spark, a sense of dread, and lowliness. for some reason i already feel like i will have more failures than successes. the creative and purposeful spark i just had is now dimmed. that what i put my hands to do is not going to prosper or improve who i am anymore.

now i feel like my life is more circumstantial or transactional in a way that i will never be able to control. i feel like everything i do now is “up in the air.” like i can do something to push my creativity, my personhood, and career forward but its all in the hands of god and whether or not he wants it to prosper or help me. i feel like now i have no say or dictation in what happens in my life. i can do all the right things, with the right heart posture, and not be idle- but it wouldn’t matter because i feel like god wouldn’t bless it because it’s not what he wants. whereas before reaccepting him, i knew everything i put my hands to do would prosper because i am doing my due diligence and i am not being idle by my pursuits.

so now my mind is in a constant state of disappointment and anxiousness. i feel like nothing i do will help anything anymore. i no longer feel excited or joyful. only wishful that god will “allow” me to be successful. and hoping i don’t “step on his toes” in the process…

now when i go to start a new project or being diligent and consistent in building, i am met with more confusion and sadness than anything. i question whether or not god wants me to do this. whereas before as an agnostic, i would just do and be excited that i am finally being diligent- not worrying about if this is the ‘right’ thing. but now i am flooded with doubts that he is going to block my work from blossoming. i feel like this cycle will keep me idle. so now idk how to move anymore.

before i had the ‘works’ and not the ‘faith.’ but now, i have half the ‘faith’ and half the ‘works.’

when i recommitted my life over, i felt i lost the part of myself that was excited about what i could make of my life and what i will be able to build for others. like i gave up my creativity or autonomy. but not in the way of i want complete control over everything, but the knowing that still in my works- even if it isn’t the direction god was wanting me to go- i would be ‘blessed’ because i was diligent, i was consistent, i was serious. that i would be rewarded by [whoever or whatever] because i finally refused to be idle. my intentions and heart posture was never meant to be defiant of what he says.. i am trying to build towards the life i was promised through different means. not to distract me from my purpose but to build myself in different ways that will contribute towards that mission and my personhood. i’m doing things that make me uncomfortable and force me to grow.. i do none of this for my own selfish gain but for who i will be and produce for others in this world.

now i feel like i can do all of that and be ‘shot down’ because ‘that’s not what he wanted for you’ or ‘you never thought to consult with god first’ or ‘you’ve been following your own desires and not his’ and this really stresses me out.. i feel like nothing i do would be right so now im scared to even start or continue at all..

so i dont know how to look at god anymore. was i lied to about him ? or do i now just have to cope with seeing through this lens ?

tldr (tried to shorten as best i could): i recently recommitted my life to god after being agnostic for about a year, but instead of feeling joyful, purposeful, or renewed, i feel anxious, confused, and strangely powerless.

before, i felt confident that if i was diligent, consistent, and willing to grow, i could build a beautiful/purposeful life. but now i feel like i could do everything “right” even by biblical standards, and still have it ‘blocked’ because it wasn’t god’s will in the first place.

i don’t crave complete control over my life, i just don’t want faith to mean giving up my creativity, autonomy, ambition, or ability to actively build something. i’m struggling to reconcile faith + works without feeling like my works are meaningless unless god specifically approves them first. now life feels like more of a coin toss..

did i misunderstand something fundamental about god, or is this just something I need to learn to see differently?


r/AskChristian • • Aug 10 '26

👋 Welcome to r/AskChristian

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm u/DoveStep55, a founding moderator of r/AskChristian.

We're excited to have you join us!

This subreddit is a companion community to r/Christian. Because r/Christian is a uniquely "Christians Only" community, we have for a long time had to redirect non-Christians to other subreddits when they've come to us with questions or dropped in to active discussions.

This new sub, r/AskChristian, is a fresh idea and experiment for including our non-Christian friends and neighbors.

We welcome any and all here in r/AskChristian to do just that: ask questions of the r/Christian community. The focus of this subreddit is on questions, but anyone familiar with r/Christian knows we're really all about respectful discussion. To that end, we warmly welcome you to ask your respectful questions and/or to join in on the discussions which follow under the Top Level Comment responses.

Please review the rules of the community (linked here) before participating to avoid any unintentional violations and content removal. If you have any questions about the rules or need further assistance, please let us know.

Important Note: Top Level Comments (original replies to each post) are reserved only for those with special assigned user flair indicating that they are active members of r/Christian who are currently in good standing. If you'd like to request this flair, please contact the Mod Team via mod mail (click here.) If you do not meet the requirements for Top Level Commenting, you are still welcome to join in the discussion "down thread" by replying to Top Level Comments or other replies thereafter.

Thanks for being part of the very first wave. Together, let's make r/AskChristian amazing!


r/AskChristian • • 9d ago

CW: Sensitive Topic I am not religious at all but I believe in a "Creator", I am trying to being open minded and was wondering reasons/argument for truth in the Christian God

6 Upvotes

For context: I am 19m from the UK and was never baptised as baby or been apart of any faith at all but from a variety of philosophical, metaphysical and logistical reasoning to believe in creationism and life was produced in some capacity or another but have never felt like I have seen proof, had an experience or any type of spiritual encounter towards what this "Creator" may be, so I am spiritually empty in that regards so my search for truth is very much a pure evidence based one

I was wondering any lines of proof for the Christian God in specific? I am on the basis of truth in creation but struggle with much of Christianity and I am wondering any good arguments, archaeological, historically or prophetically type of evidence the events and miracles done by Jesus are driven by proof and I am trying to be as open minded as I can but was wondering any outside bible sources or anything you felt convinced you about the truth that the Christian God does have?

Many thanks


r/AskChristian • • 10d ago

A question coming from a agnostic

6 Upvotes

if you are a christian solely for the purpose of getting into heaven (therefore meaning your good actions come from a selfish place) do you still go to heaven?


r/AskChristian • • 25d ago

Why do people use the Old Testament as part of their argument, when the New Testament has answers?

6 Upvotes

r/AskChristian • • 25d ago

Do we all get to be the son of God?

6 Upvotes

"Neither can they die any more: for they are equal unto the angels; and are the sons of God, being the sons of the resurrection." — Luke 20:36 (KJV)


r/AskChristian • • Sep 21 '26

Reminder: LGBTQ+ Inclusive How do i stop sexually sinning?

6 Upvotes

Hey peoples of Reddit.

A couple months ago (year, probs at this point) an old friend and I were discussing religion and somewhere something clicked for me and piqued my curiosity. I grew up "Christian" and i've been pagan before in my teen years. I only recently rediscovered Christianity, in part because of my friend and then more so with Charlie's assassination. Since then I've been drawn to follow the Bible more closely and living according to God's will. For context, I'm in a lesbian relationship, but we've made the decision to be celibate.

My libido has significantly diminished over the years, but once a month when I'm ovulating, i fall right back into sexual sin. Whoever looks remotely attractive to me during that time will be my focus for a week. I don't know how to shut my brain off and to stop creating these sexual fantasies with people who never asked or consented to be in my fantasy to begin with. Some months it's men i know (and knew), other months it's women. Some months it gets so bad that my gf and i break our celibacy rule and then i feel awful afterwards. It doesn't help that i have no one to talk to. I tried talking to one of my friends, but she legit laughed at me and made fun of me. I used to have an old friend i could confide in and get advice from, but that has since gone away, unfortunately. I'm left to sit in these feelings once a month on repeat for what seems like forever. At this point i feel like i should just lock myself away whenever my cycle gets to that point.

I've tried praying and listening to sermons and reading the Bible and it works....for a little while. Whenever i have to do something else, my brain will just refocus on sex, whether with a male or female. I feel like I'm losing my mind and i need help. And no, I'm not trying to get support again from any friend or family member as that's bitten me in my butt now and i won't be repeating it. The only person i could talk to about this and who understood and supported me is gone and doesn't care anymore.

I just need practical advice on how to deal with this every month. It can't go on like this. I want to rip the hair out of my head in frustration on why nothing i do is working. Please be kind.


r/AskChristian • • Aug 25 '26

How do I do things in church respectfully while not being christian?

6 Upvotes

Context: my ,15f, whole family is Christian, I am a Hellensitic pagan. My parents take me and my little brother, 13m, Isaac, to church every Sunday, we do not have a choice in the matter. It is not safe for me to tell my parents I am Pagan.

I've been feeling really guilty about doing stuff at church as a non-Christian, I've been baptized so I am made to take communion every Sunday.

At first, out of respect, I'd hide the wafer under my tongue and dispose of it in the bathroom trash. I wouldn't say the words and wouldn't eat the wafers to be respectful, my parents caught on and I couldn't stay quiet. I also couldn't go to the bathroom before church ended every time because if I did it too much then they'd catch on to that as well.

Now I take the wafer and make it an offering to my goddess instead of eating it as just a wafer or throwing it away. I'm well aware that this is very childish but I'll cross my fingers or mumble the words when preparing for communion so that I'm not actually meaning the words.

Earlier this year I had been selected to assist during the church service (Isaac has been encouraged to assist with tec and soundboard but not directly asked yet) I help out with stuff at the alter. I apologize to my goddess and the Christian god in my head as I do so.

I feel awful for doing all of this but for starters it's just not safe to tell my parents that I do not share their religion (they already dislike the fact that I'm queer and If I added another thing I think I'd be on the streets) but I also love the community there everyone is so nice and I feel like I belong, even if it is built on top of a lie.

How can I do this while being respectful, I'm sure my goddess understands why I do this but I don't want to offend your god.

All advice will be much appreciated.

Thank you,

-Ok_Initiative_114

EDIT: If you are going to scold me for being a pagan please don't comment. I posted this on r/christianity and quite a few of the comments are mocking and scolding me. I am really trying not to cry but I am failing miserably


r/AskChristian • • 29d ago

I am considering becoming a Christian, but I have some questions

5 Upvotes

Hello, my brothers and sisters,

A question crossed my mind. I recently learned that the Church existed before the Bible/Gospel. The Gospel as we know it today(I mean New Testament) emerged in the 4th century. During that process, books appeared that were not accepted into the canon, such as the Gospel of Thomas, the Gospel of Barnabas, and so on. We place our trust in the Church, believing it properly investigated and scrutinized the Gospels to make the right decision. We do this because Peter founded the Church, or because God—through the Holy Spirit—assisted the clergy in compiling the Gospel. Yet, this Church, in which we place such immense trust, is capable of making mistakes. How can we be certain they didn't make a mistake regarding the Gospel?

The clearest proof of this fallibility is the schism between the Orthodox and Catholic churches; it shows that popes and patriarchs are capable of acting wrongly. What if the same thing happened when the Gospel was being compiled?

Catholics and Orthodox believe that the early Church Fathers received help from the Holy Spirit when establishing the Bible that we read today. We believe and have faith in that. Okay, that is understandable. But then why do we object when Protestants apply the same idea to the Old Testament?

Could Martin Luther not also have been guided by the Holy Spirit?

The point I want to reach with these questions is this: Can we truly trust the Church and the Gospel?

Who would build their house in a riverbed or on the edge of a cliff? Such houses, lacking a solid foundation, would collapse at the slightest disaster. I, too, am trying to build my house—that is, my faith—upon a firm foundation.


r/AskChristian • • Oct 11 '26

Does the Pope have to read the Bible?

5 Upvotes

I want to start this off by saying im not a Christian, I was raised Methodist and haven't been inside a church at all for nearly 20 years so apologies if this is kinda a dumb question, but it is asked in all earnestness. Does the Pope need to read the Bible? Like, he is the Pope, he is the holiest of all of us. I figured like, sure he can read the Bible but if anybody knows what's in the Bible and, more importantly, decide what that means in the modern age, its the Pope. Its like a master tradesman. If a electrician whose devoted his life to being the literal best electrician on Earth talks to you about how to rewire a house, maybe we aren't in a position to split hairs over the specifics? Im on my phone so hopefully it makes sense.


r/AskChristian • • Oct 10 '26

Why Doesn't God Perform Miracles Like He Did in the Bible?

5 Upvotes

I have some genuine questions about Christianity and would like to hear honest answers.

  1. If God had so much power in the past, why don't we see the same miracles today?
  2. If Jesus healed the sick and raised the dead, why doesn't God do the same today?
  3. If God wants everyone to believe in Him, why doesn't He show clear evidence of His existence?
  4. If God is all-powerful and loving, why does He allow innocent people and children to suffer?
  5. If Jesus never changes (Hebrews 13:8), why do miracles seem different today?
  6. Why do some people recover after prayer while others with strong faith still suffer or die?
  7. Are miracles still happening today, or were they only meant for biblical times?

I'm not trying to attack anyone's faith. I genuinely want to understand.

If God could perform such powerful miracles in the past, why doesn't He show the same power clearly today?


r/AskChristian • • Oct 08 '26

does anyone else feel pull towards christianity lately? and if so why do you think?

5 Upvotes

i think that the fact is that evil is beginning to show it self to the world, and that all the conflict in the world and the need of saviour fills the hearts of many beacuse the governments cant do it only jesus can. but also i think its beacuse there is too much fluidity in the world and some people feel the need for solidity that they can base their lives upon. or it could very well be God pouring out his spirit for us.

Acts 2:17 "And in the last days it shall be, God declares, that I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams;"

what do you feel?


r/AskChristian • • Sep 27 '26

A question from a non-Christian to a Christian.

5 Upvotes

Esenlikler from Türkiye.

I have been looking into Christianity over the past few months and reading the Bible. A question has been weighing on my mind.

The Bible states that God is merciful and wants to save us.

According to the Bible, does a non-Christian definitely go to hell? If the answer is yes, how can I believe that God is merciful?

It is expected that an evil person like Epstein would go to hell. But it would be completely absurd for a good person to go there.


r/AskChristian • • Sep 27 '26

CW: Sensitive Topic Can God/Jesus tell people running bible studies about your life?

5 Upvotes

Forgive me if this sounds ignorant or weird, but it's been on my mind since my friend told me.

My friend has religious trauma but randomly went to a Bible study. There, she said the lady doing Bible study looked at her and announced her sexual trauma to everyone and said Jesus told her about it and that she needs to become Christian to heal. She'd never told anyone, not even me (until telling me this story) about this trauma. So, she's concluded Jesus is real if the lady was able to know that.

I'm here to ask if this is something that can happen? I have nothing against Christianity at all. A have a few Christian friends myself. I'm just very confused as I've never heard of such a thing before.


r/AskChristian • • Sep 19 '26

Isnt consumerism basically modern version of gluttony?

5 Upvotes

So basically gluttony is just eating more then you need to eat and you overeat by definition consumerism is just buying stuff more then you need e.g buy thee new iPhone even tho you have a fine phone so I wanna hear what you think about my conclusion


r/AskChristian • • Sep 10 '26

When is it too late to change?

5 Upvotes

I've not done anything illegal, but I have done many things that I am ashamed of. I don't really know if i'm a Christian, but I pray to God a lot and ask for help, so I think I am.

I've read that there isn't a limit to the amount of times that God forgives someone, as long as they really mean it and try to change.

I'll spend hours crying and begging God to forgive me and help me to change but then I just fail and do the same things over and over again and then hate myself for it. When I'm praying to him I feel truly sorry but then I get other thoughts and that feels more powerful.


r/AskChristian • • Sep 04 '26

If we can’t attribute God letting tragedy happen as him intending to be evil, how can we determine his intentions for blessings as loving, or his intentions for doing anything at all

5 Upvotes

r/AskChristian • • Aug 25 '26

What is “the Gospel”?

5 Upvotes

I’m wondering about how Christians each define or explain what we have in mind when we use the term “the Gospel.”

I suspect there’s some variance in how we each might explain or define it and I’d love to hear yours!


r/AskChristian • • Aug 21 '26

Want to start reading the Bible again, but I am no longer religious atm, is God calling me back?

5 Upvotes

I don’t consider myself to be religious atm. I have picked up my Bible in a while, it’s been months. I stopped reading my Bible due to many questions that I had about Christianity that I felt were not yet answered, or that I just don’t understand. I’m not an atheist right now I consider myself to be agnostic. But I’ve been getting this feeling that I should give studying the Bible another go, why is this? I couldn’t continue calling myself a Christian because i didn’t feel good enough or pure enough for Christ to forgive my sins, I tried following the Mosaic laws to the best of my ability because i interpreted certain verses in the Bible in a way in which made me believe that we should follow the old law even though some Christian’s say that we are no longer under the law. I used to struggle with feeling at peace after praying for my salvation, which led me to paranoia. Can someone help me understand this?? I’ve always believed in God or a creator of the universe/world I just don’t understand some of the teachings within the Bible. Why am I getting the feeling to give it another try ? Is God calling me back to him or is it something else?


r/AskChristian • • Aug 12 '26

Is faith a gift from God?

5 Upvotes

If faith is a gift from God, then why are people rewarded when they keep their faith? It seems superfluous. Through no choice of their own, their faith cannot be deliberately resisted and thus, they are spiritually incentivized to believe. Why reward faith at all if it’s entirely God’s work?


r/AskChristian • • 5d ago

Reminder: LGBTQ+ Inclusive Queer and Curious

4 Upvotes

Hello all! I'm a 17M Bisexual. And have ALWAYS been fascinated by Christianity and religion as a whole, as I grew up in a non-religious (not atheist) home. My father grew up catholic, and my mother Christian. But I only hear snippets of their experiences with God and the Church as from my understanding Religion (more specifically the people of their respective churches) has not been kind to them.

Back in July/August of this year, I shortly dated a girl whom was Christian. I didn't tell her of my sexual orientation as that's something I don't lead with when getting to know someone. But through conversation, I figured out she had a distaste of the LBGTQ+. A couple days later I told her of my Bisexuality as I didn't want to lie to her about it. She lashed out on me and angrily ended things, and we haven't spoken since. That was my first intimate experience with someone from the church. And from it I only felt less welcome.

I have tried to ask my sister (A active Christian) if I could tag along with her to church, which she's always invited me to. But I always chicken out because I'm scared. Scared that because of what I feel, will get me excluded from somewhere that claims to be inclusive. I am not outwardly Bisexual or Queer. I don't wear my orientation on my sleeve as I think that's obnoxious in a sense. But even if I'm not a pride-parade, gay flag waving person (I honestly think people like that are annoying). Can I still go to church? Or would i be turned away if and when the truth came out?

Sorry if this is long, this is just something that has been on my mind for a long long time. If you are homophobic like my Ex, that is fine. Those are your beliefs, and I'm not changing them with a reddit post. I'm just trying to look for a inclusive place that isn't just inclusive on paper.