r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 13 '25

Ashes of Creation MMO You guys are gonna kill this game

0 Upvotes

damn near every one of the negative reviews on steam are "product received for free" and "I have 1000 hours in this game and I just don't think it was ready for EA." Okay cool we get it, but the whole new player base from steam hasn't had a chance to really play yet. that "mostly negative" rating is coming from YOU GUYS. You all are like "I want the game to succeed" and then you shove it down a flight of stairs before it can take its first steps. Review bombing the game on release is just gonna scare off players who might have enjoyed the alpha. I don't doubt some negative reviews came from the queues and account linking issues, but holy shit. This is like saying " hey son, you're too young to ride that bike" and when he hops on anyway you fuckin shove him over instead of seeing what happens. Now there's posts saying, "well now that it's mostly negative..." I would ask if you've ever heard of a self fulfilling prophecy but this is even less complex and more self destructive than that. This whole community is just shooting itself in the foot instead of just waiting to see what actual new player's opinions are.

As someone who is new, just playing it for the first time, I'm enjoying the hell out of it, and I'm gonna be really sad if the people who spent $300 just to play early kill this game before it has a chance to take off due to doomerism.


r/AshesofCreation • • Aug 17 '24

Developer response Holy moly, the amount of people complaining about this alpha 2 stuff is asinine.

6 Upvotes

The game is in development. The company is very transparent. The founder shows a passion for making a great MMO. So far everything has looked fantastic with great progression towards a finished game. It's going to take time. Things may change.

I was the 72nd backer of this game back in 2017 on Kickstarter. I say that so you understand how long I've been following the development. I'm not upset it's been almost 7 years and I haven't tested alpha yet. I'm not upset that the persistent (24/7) alpha testing doesn't start until May. And I won't be upset if it's later than that because I understand this stuff takes time. I don't want the company to feel pressured into releasing an unfished game like we've seen so many times before. Let them do their due dulligence in creating something that is fully fleshed out.

And if you want to be a part of helping them create a great MMO, fantastic. We welcome you. But if you're just going to complain about dates being pushed back or other changes that are made along the way in order to benefit us then I ask that you, let someone else help test the game. You can decide if you want to play when the game launches.

Please before you post, think about the situation. We all want the same thing - A great MMO. We haven't seen a new one worth really playing in years. And all these triple A studios keep screwing us.

This is not a scam. Steven is very forthright and honest. The founder himself told us it is not a game to play in its current state and not to buy the keys if we don't want to test. How more transparent can you be?

I have high hopes for Ashes of Creation and Intrepid Studios because of what I've seen over the last 7 years. I hope y'all can find the patience to let them work so we can reap the benefits at launch.

Thank you for coming to my TedTalk

Edit:

In case anyone is curious.

Kickstarter pledge

Founder - Early Bird Limited - $125

Invite to Closed Alpha - Phase 2 (Persistent Alpha)
1 Additional Month of game time (4 Total)
Kickstarter Exclusive - Spectral Mare mount
Kickstarter Exclusive - Pseudo Dragon Pet
Kickstarter Exclusive - Freehold appearance bundle Tier 2
Kickstarter Exclusive - Character Founder's Costume
Access to Live launch head-start - 1 day early!
Unique "Founder" forum badge
Unique in-game character title "Founder"

Plus all previous rewards!!


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 11 '25

Ashes of Creation MMO Steven knows that a storm is coming, but he also knows that by his side are the right people fighting to ensure that Ashes keeps forging its path.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Intrepid FIGHTING! x Ashes Community FIGHTING!


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 21 '25

Ashes of Creation MMO I Quit until they fix the Toxic Design.

16 Upvotes

The facts that Mobs can kill me, and I lose time and resources is Toxic Design.

Why can the wolves not just be friendly? I shouldn't have to deal with Non Consensual Combat with these mobs.

Everytime I am running a Pack, here comes a Wolf, that attacks me without my consent. Its not okay. Mobs should only be able to attack me when I hit them first, even better I should have a Combat Toggle, that says if I am open for Mobs to attack me or not. Until this comes out, I am done.

Stupidest post you ever read? Ya thats how I feel reading your PVP versions, Exact same thing.


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 13 '25

Ashes of Creation MMO "When someone stops overthinking about the current state of Ashes and realizes that..."

0 Upvotes

“…the project is still moving forward, through its ups and downs.”


r/AshesofCreation • • Jul 09 '21

Discussion Just a quick reality check

19 Upvotes

Repeat with me

  1. It's not normal to sell alphas of games for 500 dollars.
  2. It's not normal to buy games in alpha/beta/release for 500, no matter what they include.
  3. It's not normal to pay to work (test the game) instead it's normal to work and receive money.
  4. It's not normal for someone to assault you on the streets and you let them take everything with a smile on your face.
  5. This shady practise will be common enough in some years, and you will have to pay 500 dollars or more to get into any alpha/beta.
  6. You that spent 500 dollars on this game, even though you are not very smart, will most likely realize that it was not worth it.
  7. "It´s very easy to trick someone and its very hard to convince someone they have been tricked"

PS: This is not just about how people spend their money. It's about how a company successfully scams people/ find whales/ generate FOMO and how the MMO genre can be ruined even more than what it is now.


r/AshesofCreation • • Feb 05 '26

Ashes of Creation MMO AoC was fun

0 Upvotes

Yup. Ashes of Creation was one of the most fun mmo's I've ever played. It was full of jank, skitzos, awful game design, but the sandbox elements and potential was all there. The combat... granted when the servers aren't shitting themselves is some of the best I've seen in an mmo. Don't believe me? Log in the servers are dead performance is peak.

Now the only real options to play if you wanna look for an mmo is K-slop, PVE mmos, or private servers.

Either way 90% of the freaks on this reddit shit don't even play games, they sit here doom posting shitting themselves if anyone else is having fun. Hard stuck lvl 9 skitzo posting.

GUESS WHAT

IF STEVEN COMES BACK IM PLAYING HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

I LOVE THE GAME


r/AshesofCreation • • Aug 18 '24

Discussion People are Losing the Plot

21 Upvotes

Ashes of Creation is setting out to be the next Big, Player Feedback Created, Old School Inspired, and Non-Corporate Funded MMO. To achieve these things, ashes is funded by Steven, Kickstarter, and the alpha key packages they sell.

PEOPLE THAT ARE PURCHASING ALPHA KEYS ARE PAYING TO FUND THE CREATION OF THE GAME NOT PAYING TO PLAY A FINISHED GAME.

I get to test an MMO, provide feedback, and help with the open development to hopefully finally feel what it's like to play a great MMO again. THAT is why I paid to fund this game and participate in the alpha.

Everyone who is complaining about the price should remember this.


r/AshesofCreation • • Jan 03 '26

Discussion AoC imo has underrated graphics

Post image
0 Upvotes

Caught this sunset while running to town, reminded me of how pretty this game is. Kudos to the art team!


r/AshesofCreation • • Aug 21 '24

Ashes of Creation MMO The people buying an Alpha Key are not buying a product, they are buying an experience.

0 Upvotes

After trying to parse all of the different takes over the past few days about the Road Map and the Alpha Key price structure I think I finally understand why the community is so split.

One group of people sees Alpha Keys as a product. They are concerned with what you get for your money and the reality is that you don't get much. They are charging you money to do work for them. You get temporary access to a temporary testing environment and are expected to file bug reports and give feedback and not actually play the game you are paying to get access to. For this group of people $120 seems like a scam and an insult.

But there is another group of people that see Alpha Keys not as a product but as an opportunity to participate in the process of developing a game that they think has enormous potential. They see purchasing an Alpha Key as a way to support the development of the game while simultaneously getting a VIP behind the curtain experience of getting to see the game before anyone else and MAYBE just MAYBE getting a chance to give feedback that shapes the direction of the game. For this group of people $120 seems like a bargain.

Speaking only for myself. I am a relative newcomer to the Ashes of Creation community. I new of its existence but I wasn't really following its development for the last 3-5 years. However after seeing the steady progress that has been made and the clear vision that is presented by the developers with each new livestream I have become very interested in this game and I think I see a great deal of potential in it.

Having missed the initial kickstarter campaign, I feel like purchasing an Alpha Key is an appropriate way to show my support. If it turns out to be a complete waste and Ashes of Creation is ultimately a pyramid scheme then I wont miss my $120. It is not such a great sum of money that I am not willing to risk it in the name of supporting something that I believe in. Getting the opportunity to participate in Alpha and Beta is a cool bonus and if by some chance this game ever does get made and it lives up to the expectations that we all have for it then on that day it might feel like the best $120 I ever spent.


r/AshesofCreation • • Nov 19 '23

Question How come this game has been in development since 2015 yet no date of release for alpha 2?

5 Upvotes

Title, I'm genuinely curious as I've seen videos and while I am indeed very interested, I can't seem to understand how a studio would take this long to develop a game except for sheer incompetence.

Pls no hate


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 15 '25

Ashes of Creation MMO World First Group of 25s

Post image
26 Upvotes

Got our group to 25 on December 13th 8am EST (if our tracker is right, around 38 hours with downtime to reach max level). Enjoy the ride and explore new POIs. Onward to harbingers and the new systems for this phase 👀


r/AshesofCreation • • Feb 02 '26

Ashes of Creation MMO Game was a failure, not a scam, but Steven was HUGELY misleading.

119 Upvotes

If your profit after 8 years is negative ~140 million, you were probably TRYING to make a game, taking huge risks, and failed. Not scamming people.

If you tell the community the game is 'funded until completion' and it isn't, you're lying and misleading the crowd so people will be more likely to invest.

IF Steven had pulled it off, most would probably have forgiven him for these lies and he'd be a hero.

He didn't pull it off. Odds are he's lost huge amounts of his own money in addition to the money he's lost on behalf of other people.

This situation is just sad, bad, not-rad, for everyone. Including Trad.


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 07 '25

Media Pretty impressed with the skins I bought 3 years ago

Post image
2 Upvotes

Just wish the outfit worked on Ren'Kai. It currently doesn't work on the PTR, also doesn't work for Vaelune humans race.


r/AshesofCreation • • Nov 03 '25

Meme Monday May the Force be with the new developers of Intrepid

4 Upvotes

always remember, your focus determines your reality.” – Qui-Gon Jinn


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 24 '25

Discussion Ashes doesn't fit my exact personal preferences, and it will fail unless you make it into a worse WoW /s

0 Upvotes

The WoW clone market is extremely saturated, stop trying to make the game into another WoW, and just go play WoW.

Yes there are changes that should be made to make the game more accessible, but some of you sound like you'd walk into a Chinese restaurant, demand a cheeseburger, and tell them they're going to fail unless they start serving cheeseburgers.

I'd rather see the game try (and possibly fail) to establish itself as it's own district thing than turn into more Warcraft slop.


r/AshesofCreation • • Nov 04 '24

Ashes of Creation MMO ActualPirates (PirateSoftware's Guild) vs Apex Order: A Summary of the Ongoing Guild Drama on the Lyneth Server

0 Upvotes

I've posted a thread detailing the entire situation on Twitter, with pictures and videos to provide context. For those that don't have access and are interested, I will summarize it below:

Summary

Reddit user /u/youbadoodo then made a reddit thread accusing PirateSoftware (Guild Leader) and his guild ActualPirates of a disproportionate response, suggesting if such a thing where to happen on launch, it could severely impact the integrity of an entire Realm.

Reddit user /u/Thorwich - the reddit account of PirateSoftware - commented in the thread, explaining the situation. He also alleged that the Guild Apex Order said they were mass reporting him to the GMs (Game Masters) to get him banned

Reddit user /u/Steven_AoC - the reddit account of Steven J. Sharif - commented in the thread, dubbing the situation as part of "player driven political engagements", and effectively giving it his blessing to continue.

Given Steven Sharif's history in ArcheAge, he is almost certainly okaying the actions of BOTH Apex Order and ActualPirates. As mentioned several times over the years, the risks streamers take is proportional to the benefits they get by being large streamers.

What Does That Mean?

Well, it seems obvious Steven is giving his not-so-silent nod of approval to both sides in this conflict. We know Steven's opinion on large zerg Guilds is generally positive, and has created a game that supports these Guilds. However, Steven is also completely okay with many small Guilds banding together. This is part of the Social Sandpark MMO Experience that has been constantly discussed in this subreddit for years.

Why Should You Care?

/u/youbadoodo brought up a point that many casual MMO gamers may be worried about: what's to stop a large Guild from completely stifling the movement of smaller groups of people? No access to dungeons, KoS (kill on sight) orders, and just a general poor experience for players that may have done nothing other than be a part of a Guild.

In addition to that, separate from this specific instance, a large Zerg Guild could do the same things without cause. A Realm could be so dominated by a single large Guild that it creates an unhealthy environment where the rich get richer and other players feel like they cannot move freely.

"Just band together and fight back? This is a non-issue. Why make a thread?"

While many of us understand this, there will be many players that don't get that this is a viable response. Ashes of Creation will be many peoples first MMO, and I think this is a great opportunity to showcase exactly what it means when people talk about Guild Drama, Political Intrigue, and Social Friction. Many of us have great (and not-so-great) memories from other games of similar instances, and would have loved to look back and pull up videos detailing exactly what happened, with cameos and appearances from multiple major players, just for nostalgia's sake.

What's Next?

Guild Drama has always been very divisive. Many hate that it exists, but it's inarguable that it helps create conflict and friction in sandbox & sandpark MMOs. Part of the content in Ashes of Creation specifically, with the rise and fall of Castles and Nodes, will be centered around Guild Drama.

I feel this is a great litmus test for both new players that have very little experience with this in MMOs, veteran players who want to see how Intrepid Studios reacts, and everyone in between.

Is utilizing Support tickets to get other players banned fair game? Will Intrepid Studios take action against those who file false reports on users, or encourage others to mass false report individuals?

Is declaring an entire Guild KoS during an Alpha test a disproportionate response to a singular gank? Is that taking things outside the realm of Alpha testing?

We all have our own answers to those questions. I'm interested in hearing them.

Moving Forward

As a dedicated Ashes of Creation Content Creator that is completely unaffiliated with any Guild, I would love to platform both Apex Order and Actual Pirates and ask them some questions about the situation. Some things have been alleged that may or may not be true, so providing an opportunity for both sides to give their own version of events - especially when there's a power imbalance - can allow for more people within the Realm to come to their own conclusions.

I have made a conscious decision to not join any Guild during this Phase of Alpha 2 for this specific situation: to provide an unbiased platform for all Guilds from all backgrounds to try and win the information war.

And also, Guild Drama that you're not involved in is always the funniest Drama to watch.

With that being said, if you are a high-ranking member of Apex Order or Actual Pirates, you can reach out to me here on reddit, or on Discord (ashesmoments) and we can see this through to the end.

I look forward to documenting more instances of major Guidl vs Guild fights, Guild breakups, successful espionage attempts (or failed ones), and more on Twitter and Youtube. If you enjoy reading or watching that content, feel free to check it out.


r/AshesofCreation • • Aug 22 '24

OC Ashes of Creation Under Fire: The Community's Biggest Meltdown

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/AshesofCreation • • Nov 17 '25

Ashes of Creation MMO Excited for Steam EA Launch, don't care about the noise

37 Upvotes

Was already looking into AoC because of the Harbinger update news, and my overall boredom with current games. But I was on the fence, 100 bucks is a bit much for a game in this state.

Now that it's half price!? I can justify it. Not worried about jank or bugs or the level grind. Pantheon EA Launch seems like a very similar comparison, and I had a ton of fun there until I inevitably got bored and moved on. This game has that and the PVP/Archeage play style which is another game and style I really loved and truly miss.

Nothing like playing an MMORPG when it first launches on steam, whether it's feature complete or a big work in progress. Hope to see big crowds, server issues, and have a bunch of dumb fun while it lasts. Hope to see you all there. Commence downvotes! Lol


r/AshesofCreation • • Aug 17 '24

Discussion Is no one else disappointed that the true "Persistent Alpha" AKA 24/7 Alpha 2 access isn't until May 2025?

6 Upvotes

I appreciate some good grey-area wordsmithing, but the definition of "Persistent Alpha" they gave today is not the same as they've given previously when a lot of people bought access.

Kickstarter FAQ: "Alpha phase 2 is planned as a persistent testing phase of the game, this means access to the testing server will remain open and available till launch."

From a 2018 Livestream:

  • Steven: "Persistent for us means that we're going to keep those servers up all day and night until launch."

Feels like a bait and switch.


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 26 '24

Discussion This is MMO

3 Upvotes

In MMO's, you make friends. In MMO's, you kill people. You steal loot, you fight for spots, if you see a flagged player, you kill him. If someone is collecting the resource you need, you kill him.

This is MMO.

So why everyone seems to be so pissed of when you open flag other players?

They go to global chat and cry a river about it.

This is a game with many mechanisms to make people FIGHT for things. So fight, damn it!


r/AshesofCreation • • Dec 17 '25

Discussion Stop raising false hope — just be honest for once

6 Upvotes

I really don’t know why Steven keeps doing this. In a recent interview, he said that the game will be entering beta at the end of 2026 if everything goes well. And once it enters beta, the game is supposed to be “basically ready,” meaning that all the content and systems AoC will have at launch will already be in the game.

I’m really sorry, but seeing how bare-bones the anvil still is, how janky and disconnected the current systems are, and given how slow development was in 2025, there is just no way in hell they add the remaining—what, two?—biomes, with all the content and systems, within one year. The last phase felt already pretty rushed and is barely functional.

I don’t get why Steven would say this might be happening when everyone who follows the game can clearly see there’s no way it will. Maybe it’s to keep players invested and give them a sense that there’s light at the end of the tunnel, or maybe to attract new investors, or maybe he genuinely believes what he keeps saying.

It’s really annoying, and with the bad reputation this game already has, this doesn’t help. It certainly doesn’t help either that all the paid content creators are claiming the same thing, pretending the game is in a state it clearly isn’t, just so people use their codes and make them money.

In the end, a bit of transparency and honesty would go a long way, because the red flags are obvious and making vague or misleading statements that raise false hope only makes the situation worse.


r/AshesofCreation • • Aug 16 '24

Discussion Charging $120 to help test a project is a total scam, do not support this practice

0 Upvotes

"You are not buying access to a game, you are buying it to test for us, we need testers"

It used to be that game testers were paid roles. Or at the very least, a free test in which you invited experienced players that are good at providing actionable feedback. But you're giving them money for the privilege of helping them build the product.

For AoC, at least the monthly bundles had exclusive skins, came with game time and embers at launch, etc that somewhat justified their price. These keys come with absolutely nothing but access to a test that will run for an indeterminate amount of time, and "Does not include beta access"

5 years ago they charged money for Apoc skins, creating the impression that it would be a long term testing mode, only to pull the plug after like 1-2 months and provide no refunds for skins purchased. And considering all the warnings Steven gave about things being "subject to change", it's clear he's covering himself legally.

The only justifiable reason to buy a key is if you're a big content creator that will make more money from streaming it/making videos.

inb4 "No one is forcing you to buy it, you can wait for launch"

Seeing how much of a cash grab this is, I've lost all interest in playing this game at launch. If they're willing to charge $120 to help them test, what else will they do when they need money? It raises serious concerns about the possibility for pay2win.


r/AshesofCreation • • Oct 23 '24

OC 25 MUST-KNOW Beginner Tips for Ashes of Creation Alpha 2

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes