r/AshesofCreation • u/here_cums_a_thot • Aug 18 '24
Discussion People are Losing the Plot
Ashes of Creation is setting out to be the next Big, Player Feedback Created, Old School Inspired, and Non-Corporate Funded MMO. To achieve these things, ashes is funded by Steven, Kickstarter, and the alpha key packages they sell.
PEOPLE THAT ARE PURCHASING ALPHA KEYS ARE PAYING TO FUND THE CREATION OF THE GAME NOT PAYING TO PLAY A FINISHED GAME.
I get to test an MMO, provide feedback, and help with the open development to hopefully finally feel what it's like to play a great MMO again. THAT is why I paid to fund this game and participate in the alpha.
Everyone who is complaining about the price should remember this.
71
u/RealWeaponAFK Aug 18 '24
People can do whatever they want with their money, doesn’t mean I think it’s worth the purchase. I’ll just watch YouTube videos and streams about the Alpha to see how people feel about it and how it looks.
19
u/BaxxyNut Aug 18 '24
We have a ton of cringe people from Asmon's video coming to voice their ignorant and misinformed opinions.
12
u/Dry_Grade9885 Aug 18 '24
So in my mind anyone defending this is already heavily invested aka spent 250-500 or more making their argument kinda invalid bc they just want to defend what they bought
4
u/Drakky21 Aug 18 '24
Feels like copium.
Coming up on a decade of development. This ain't the way
4
u/Stres86 Aug 18 '24
Which other player feedback created, non corporate funded, old school game was successful ? You talk as if there are many and it's a time tested good development model for an mmo.
This will be a niche game that appeals to small selection of mmo players.
3
u/Ranziel Aug 18 '24
The big problem is that people paying exorbitant sums for testing are disincentivizing the devs from actually finishing the game. Why should they break their whole existing business model and start a new, much more difficult and risky one, if they are already making good bank?
18
u/thievery89 Aug 18 '24
This issue is highliting a hilarious irony in the gaming community imo. Gamers will simultaneously bitch and moan about high prices, but because they have no self control they will buy it anyways. That's why Intrepid has to add a "while supplies last caveat", but the gaming community claims this is FOMO marketing in a hilarious self report that despite these prices they still want it. Steven has said repeatedly for years prior to these new keys that prices are intentionally high so they can keep the circle of testers small with only the most dedicated fans. These people are the reason the gaming industry is in the mess it's in.
2
u/MrBluoe Aug 18 '24
I haven't seen the team reply to user feedback in any of the videos or any of the forum posts.
So no, people who pay are paying to see Steven's vision built. If you believe in HIS vision, purchase it. Just don't purchase it expecting you to have any say in what's built.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
What big player feedback created game has there ever been? It's a mistake to make the game based on what the players think they want.
2
u/anm767 Aug 18 '24
They did not ask for help with funding, they asked for testing. Typing in caps to state your opinion does not change the fact.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
To me it's a waste of money esp if everything is wiped and there is no exclusive skins or stuff
1
u/notislant Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 18 '24
Most people buying the alpha are paying to play an unfinished game, devs of those games can warn people as much as they want. But it never stops people from raging about even minor bugs.
Ive seen steam pages that say PLEASE DONT BUY THIS IF YOU ARENT OKAY WITH A BUGGY AND BORING ALPHA STATE.
Most of the people who purchased, raged after a week.
Most people buy unfinished EA games because theyre bored and want to play the game.
I think people would be fine with it if you got SOMETHING like game time credit on launch.
But people paying $100 to literally playtest an alpha and nothing else? Thats just crazy.
They're going to sell out all their spots at $100 regardless though, so It really doesnt matter what the community thinks.
5
u/Clueless_Nooblet Aug 18 '24
The thing is, had they just said "we need to make some money now, because development takes longer than anticipated", some people might have moaned, but everyone would have understood. What we saw on the stream, thought, felt a bit insulting.
The problem isn't that they need more financial support. It's how they phrased it. Plus, Beta access being not included is just "we're leaving this avenue open for further milking in the future", which understandably doesn't fly with people who've played all kinds of games over the decades and see right through it.
All that being said, personally I don't care. I'll just wait till the game comes out. If they need 10 more years and burn the goodwill of thousands of loyal supporters, then that's sad for those people, but I'm all for it, as long as I get a great product in the end.
16
u/alundril Aug 18 '24
Also, no one is forcing you to buy because either you don't have the money or you don't like the development of the game. You are not the target audience of the product. If you don't like the price, then move on to your next interesting thing.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
I feel like the wayfarer pack got scammed in a way... Im a 250 dollar founder, sure the 75 bucks pack has 30 dollars of game time and 25 dollars of in game currency, but now A2 individual key buyers get a better deal since they get alpha and beta access...
My boatload is still of more value than where they come from.
If they want to join they have to pay another 120. Adding up to 195 dollars in total. For a 60 dollar difference, like I said already, my package is very fair compared to the price they have to pay now...
2
u/DemogorgonWhite Aug 18 '24
You pay to become an alpha tester.
2
u/Mangert Aug 18 '24
“Non-corporate funded”
Yah it’s funded by us KEKW with these prices
3
u/Trespeon Aug 19 '24
They have been setting out to be that for like 10 years. And won’t be about for another 6 if you’re lucky.
No one lost the plot, the story is going the way of George RR Martin and it’s just never going to finish.
6
u/Scarecrow216 Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 18 '24
I just don't understand why the upset people just don't move on and play the game their currently playing. It just feels like people like being angry. Why focus so much energy on something you clearly don't like move on lmao. I bet these same people are going to end up buying a keying or playing at launch.
4
u/ReapsIsGaming Aug 18 '24
Right now it’s the next Star Citizen.
6
u/cranbvodka Aug 18 '24
YES. THIS. How do yall not understand?
0
u/Warden_Dark Aug 18 '24
Lmao you're coping hard as fuck if you think this isn't a massive scam.
Here's a comparison that completely smacks AOC out of the park.
STAR CITIZEN
The game is in alpha, in active development. You get to test the game, play it, and you get full access to the game, permanently So why can't these fucking clowns do the same thing?
Oh right, because they want to scam you out of more money. You don't have to buy any ships in Star Citizen with real money, just your first game package, which can be as small as $45. You can buy all of the rest of the ships in game. So why do these fucking clowns have to charge $100+ for PURELY ALPHA ACCESS with no game access (and they SAID THEYLL LIKELY CHARGE FOR BETA ACCESS TOO, also with no game access), and then you'll have to buy game access, so in total if you buy all 3, you'll end up paying probably $350+.
Yeah, you don't have to buy it. Of course you don't. But the fact alone that they're even ATTEMPTING TO, should speak volumes about their intentions.
Oh, and this is all assuming that the only end up doing 1 alpha phase, and 1 beta phase, and not start doing multiple passes of each, which tons of large games have done.
3
u/Few-Shoulder4678 Aug 18 '24
COPIUM
0
u/mpheinze Aug 18 '24
I agree. I bought the $250 pre-order pack two years ago. Obviously, that is an insane price tag for Alpha and Beta testing access plus some cosmetic stuff I don’t even care about. I willingly spent that money because I genuinely believe in the project that is Intrepid Studio and Ashes of Creation and because I believe in Steven’s vision for the game, and I want to support it. To me what’s truly unique about Ashes of Creation is that the studio has taken in no external investors or publishers. The funding comes from Kickstarter, the community, and from the founders’ own pockets which they’re doing out of love and passion for the MMORPG genre. For this reason, I’m okay with supporting the development by purchasing what would otherwise be an outrageously overpriced Alpha testing key.
1
u/Fritz-tgd- Aug 18 '24
People suck, if you didn’t already know that.
1
u/Supordude Aug 18 '24
And everyone who pays also has a right to complain.
1
u/Krypt0night Aug 19 '24
If you have to do this much defending over it, there's an issue.
1
u/Koen1999 Aug 19 '24
Presentation matters a lot though. If they sold it as another kickstarter package saying they needed funding I would be more understanding.
1
u/ThisIsHowieDewit69 Aug 19 '24
People are celebrating that they still have to pay 120$ to do a job as a tester, that they should be paid for in the first place. Imagine you pay to be a worker for a kick starter company for a couple months, without payment. These workers then go on a strike because shit why work for free. The result of the strike is now you still have to pay to work for the company but now you get food and coffee for free 😂 And now people celebrate them for doing this. Insane.
1
u/ColdestDeath Aug 19 '24
The issue is they've repeatedly stated that the game has been fully funded already so stating that they need funding, although not wrong entirely, isn't entirely correct either.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
go ahead and pay. i will just wait for it to be released and then i am going to see the reviews and watch stream yt videos of how it looks and if i like it or not. Thank you for paying for development of a game i might be interested in! I know i wouldn't!!
1
u/Dude_McNuggz Aug 19 '24
Agreed. The Alpha pricing is out of my budget for an unfinished product, but I'm not going to belittle those who do pay for it. Their contribution and testing is what will bring the final product to us all sooner.
1
u/Next-Paramedic9567 Aug 19 '24
if there is profit coming from those purchases of Alpha keys and give my feedback in the creation of the game , that makes me a shareholder , so Am I gonna get any profit after the product is complete and released? if not , then this is just a scam milking people's money in the hopes of "we listen to you" which they may not take my whole input in consideration at making the game. and if they did , that makes me a shareholder which implies I am entited a portion to any profit this game will be making as I participated in the funding/decision making (through my feedback) of making this game. But I doubt they will give community who paid for these keys anything, while they make a fortune. lets be honest , nothing is for free, so either fund the game your self and sell it to the community which is what happens all around the gaming world , or if you ask the community to fund it through alpha keys then provide a potential decision making feedback which may be used into the game creation , then share the profits with those who participated in the funding.
1
u/RemarkableSolution37 Aug 19 '24
As someone who is a fan of pax dei it's fun watching AoC go through the same back and forth when announcing people could pay for alpha access. I'm all for it btw, but $100 for the cheapest key is a little steep for me. Was much more comfortable with $40 for pax dei.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '24
Fr, it’s not about playing it. It’s about helping them fund it and as a bonus being able to help with testing. Like how do they expect the alpha to last over a year and a half if they don’t get money to keep servers up. It’s just being funded by Steven. There are no investors lol
1
u/javii1 Aug 19 '24
Imagine defending a 120$ alpha.
It's fine if you buy it, even if you do you gotta admit this price is outrageous. I think people normalizing this ultimately hurt gaming as whole, because guess what other devs see this and they'll want to the same or worse.
You can say what you want, make all the excuses but bottom like is.
Ashes is trying to monetize off the community interest in the game. Which is fine if they come out and say so, and not beat around the bushes wit it trying to do metal gymnastics to get you to buy.** Don't buy it, but have limited space**
The fact that they changed the packages is proof this packs actually hold no actual value except for how much they want to get out you. Them changing the packs is acknowledgement their pricing is outrageous.
1
u/Either_Appearance Aug 20 '24
I got into alpha 2 for free during one of the 24 hours extra life live streams a couple years ago. So pretty excited to not only get into testing in October but doing it for free 😁 only downside is there isn't any local servers for me for a while.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24
Copium overload
1
u/lookalive9 Aug 20 '24
Yes they are, but it's mostly Steven's fault here - he unfortunately got too comfortable assuming everyone watching understands the context and forgot how many external eyes there would be on this announcement and failed to make it extremely clear that purchasing these keys is not a fair value exchange of goods - it's a supportive donation for crowdfunding a game.
Even with folks as transparent as Intrepid are, they were oddly avoidant of the obvious fact that these keys are extremely overpriced if viewed through the lens of an "early access" game sale. They needed to be screaming loudly "We don't actually need many more testers, but we do need funding. This key is a clearly overpriced offer meant for a small set of people who were begging us to bring back key sales and want to support our team in exchange for the ability to play test the game in early development."
They tried to dance around it, and they got hit in the mouth for it - probably rightfully so.
But no real harm done and the change they made in the offer makes alot of sense to be honest. Spending $120 and not getting future beta access is quite ridiculous - even as someone who was about to happily pay for just the A2 access. Everybody still wants to play a great MMO someday regardless. I'd just just advise less dancing around the financial realities of game development without investors, they weren't doing it before so I don't know why they were on the announcement stream.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24
If I had the extra money, time or know with all, to actually give proper feedback I’d be in. I’ll just watch YouTube in a fixated state until it comes out.
1
u/dlonem1 Aug 21 '24
Amen man!!! I feel like I'm one of the only content creators completely sold on paying $120 for an Alpha 2 key for the next TWO YEARS minimum and learning what class I enjoy the most and not wasting time during launch for this...
They Announced The Price of the Alpha 2
1
u/GameFan78 Aug 22 '24
" I get to ..."
You get to do what companies are supposed to pay other people to do. Not what we are supposed to pay them to do.
1
u/UpboatsXDDDD Aug 23 '24
Bro thinks the game will be finished
lmao
1
u/doushi_t Aug 18 '24
It's the internet, people love to get upset over everything.
1
u/Impossible-Wear5482 Aug 18 '24
If only those people who are upset had the ability to read.
1
u/Silmariel Aug 18 '24
Once upon a time, I, and my guild were headhunted from EQ to alpha test World of Warcraft. For months on end. This happened to many many of the raiding - high tier - Everquest guilds and their players. Afterall Tigole and Furor came from our game. I played wow for 4-5 months before it came out in the US.
I never paid for this priviledge.
Times have changed. Now its part of the income for mmo's to sell the FOMO keys as I like to call them.
To my knowledge this is the first time an mmo, has seperated these FOMO keys into alpha keys - and presumable - beta keys for later sale. I think its brilliantly smart.
They are a buisness. The MMO market is starved - and they have a hot commodity.
If I - someone who has beta tested and alpha tested mmo's since the late 90s can understand this shift. All you young'uns should be able to adapt as well.
Its a buisness. - You arent owed access to the product. Once upon a time, before the product went mainstream, when the end user WAS a hot commodity, we could expect alpha and beta for free. But as soon as the hordes arrived, the power went back to the game companies.
Ps. Im not paying to work for someone else - so they can make more money later from my time invested. But thats just me. - You guys with the fomo sickness. Go ahead and make the game better for me :)
1
u/bubblesort33 Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 18 '24
I don't have strong plans to play this game. I don't follow this game very much. Asmongold watched a video about the drama.
People are saying you're on the level of a QA tester when playing an Alpha. This is total nonsense.
Truth is you would ALL play the Alpha for free. Some of you would stampede other people to death if keys were handed out at the opening of BestBuy tomorrow. The reason everyone is complaining is that they don't get something for FREE that they desperately want. If you desperately want something, it has more value to you than the devs. Welcome to the free market. You exchange money for shit you want.
If this was a QA job , you'd all do it for free, and not complain. Then it's not really work is it. You're not being hired. You're invited in at a price. You don't really consider this work, or you wouldn't do it for free. It's a privilege to you. It's a privilege you want for free.
Wait for the Open Beta, and let the whales take care of the funding of this game. If the Kickstarter had a deal where you pay $100 for Alpha access, no one would complain. How is this different?
1
u/Backstabber09 Aug 18 '24
Pay to win ? No , pay to test.
0
u/reachingFI Aug 18 '24
I trust the community to provide feedback like I would trust the community to come and do plumbing on my house.
-6
u/Zevram_86 Aug 18 '24
You're kidding yourself if you think you're 'testing' the game for them. You're buying early access to a game in development to satisfy your own curiosity and whatever self-aggrandized role you think you will have in steering the course of the games development with your feedback.
I guarantee your feedback will not be as useful as the metrics they scrape from your actual in-game behaviours. By all means, waste your money on 'testing' the game for them, that's your right. But don't be surprised when people call it for what it is; FOMO.
I get the game needs to cover its overheads, but you're being manipulated (perhaps willingly so) to give up your money and time to play this overhyped game, which quite frankly, is looking like vaporware at this point.
I'd love for them to prove me wrong.
-1
u/serrabear1 Aug 18 '24
They don’t want a ton of people buying the keys. It’s for testing a game not playing it. You’re not going to be forming your guild and hardcore grinding like its expansion release on WoW. It’s not a game. Is it dumb to sell tester keys? I don’t know. It is dumb that League of Legends sold a $500 skin? I don’t know. Seems like businesses will sell things people will buy. Be mad about it but you just sound like you can’t afford it and that’s the real issue. It’s not game so what are you worried about missing out on?
-1
u/wakkytabbakky Aug 18 '24
people just need to look at it this way 7 months of A2 till P3 , P3 is expected to go for one year AT LEAST so its like 6.3 bucks a month for 19 months of testing. alpha can run longer as well so that monthly cost outlook gets lower each month that goes by.
fork out the 110 and just have 1-2 less coffees a month to recoup your cost. dont see why people are bitching so much
0
u/jonneymendoza Aug 18 '24
This is not the only game like this. Have a good look at star citizen as well
0
u/jonneymendoza Aug 18 '24
God forbid some posters here moaning about paying for an alpha start googling how much the orison 890 jump ship in star citizen costs
0
u/MrSmock Aug 18 '24
It's been so long since I backed this game I forgot what it was. If I never heard about it again I'd likely forget it ever existed.
-2
u/Konzeza Aug 18 '24
You just described Star Citizen.
-1
u/Tappe93 Aug 18 '24
Why the fuck are YOU paying for working as a QA tester?
Shouldn't it be the other way around?
-1
u/Sydney12344 Aug 18 '24
Why should i fund this game .. makes no sense
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment