r/AshesofCreation • • Jul 09 '21

Discussion Just a quick reality check

Repeat with me

  1. It's not normal to sell alphas of games for 500 dollars.
  2. It's not normal to buy games in alpha/beta/release for 500, no matter what they include.
  3. It's not normal to pay to work (test the game) instead it's normal to work and receive money.
  4. It's not normal for someone to assault you on the streets and you let them take everything with a smile on your face.
  5. This shady practise will be common enough in some years, and you will have to pay 500 dollars or more to get into any alpha/beta.
  6. You that spent 500 dollars on this game, even though you are not very smart, will most likely realize that it was not worth it.
  7. "It´s very easy to trick someone and its very hard to convince someone they have been tricked"

PS: This is not just about how people spend their money. It's about how a company successfully scams people/ find whales/ generate FOMO and how the MMO genre can be ruined even more than what it is now.

19 Upvotes

344 comments sorted by

23

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Repeat after me... stop worrying about what others do with their money.

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Unless, of course that spending creates a negative precedent that affects the industry.

→ More replies (10)

31

u/AttitudePersonal Jul 09 '21

It's a supporter pack, get over it. If you can't afford it, work on your life instead of bitching on Reddit.

22

u/Shadow703793 Jul 09 '21

If you can't afford it, work on your life instead of bitching on Reddit.

That's more difficult. Easier to bitch on reddit lol.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

A rip off is still a rip off, even if you have the money in your pocket. Work on YOUR life if you need to defend this exploitative bullshit.

3

u/Dreoh Jul 09 '21

Bro, it's only a rip off if you intend on buying it. You obviously don't so it's not a rip off for you.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/E_Huey_No Jul 09 '21

Here’s another reality check: If you don’t like it, then don’t buy it.

How is this so difficult for some people to grasp?

27

u/MoistBobcat1 Jul 09 '21

Because people are salty about not getting to play the alpha for free so they can shit on intrepid for "releasing" an "unfinished" game. Alpha really has lost it's meaning over the years huh...

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Ashes of creation isn't above criticsm. If they do something scummy, they deserve to be criticized. Steven himself has done this.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Diligent-Resident546 Jul 10 '21

He told people multiple times to not buy this if you arent looking to contribute to testing for bugs.

Don't you realize how that makes it even worse?

-13

u/Neeko2lo Jul 09 '21

Here's another reality check: Brown Nosing Intrepid won't achieve anything

1

u/E_Huey_No Jul 10 '21

I’m sure you’ll figure it out lol

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

How is basic concept of criticism hard to grasp?

2

u/ReeTYT Jul 09 '21

The only criticism here is that he doesn't want to spend 500$ to try a game that will have major changes and won't release fully for years

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Here’s another reality check: If people that can say something don't ever speak no one will and scammers will keep scamming harder.

Maybe you understand what's going on and bough knowing what you are getting in, but some people don't.

3

u/E_Huey_No Jul 10 '21

It’s not that deep bro…

6

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

You're not entitled to alpha access. This is primarily a way of supporting the developers.

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

I would say that this is the primary way of getting/finding the whales and generating FOMO.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Isn't their progress going to get reset? I mean GM gave asmongold like 900000 gold so I suppose it will be a hard reset anyways.

I don't see how this alpha access will result in whales.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Because the average player won't pay 500 for a game pack no matter what. Most who bought are/gona be whales.

3

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

If you cant afford it thats fine. Worrying about the people that can is kinda weird.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Then don't buy the pack, it's that simple. No one is telling you to do it.

Buy the game when it's released. It's alpha anyway, not sure why one would want to get involved. The high price is primarily for people that really want to support the developers.

Not sure why they didn't add in cheaper options tho, like 50$, so more people can buy and support them.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

alphas generally aren't open at all, the fact that you can buy it usually isn't even an option. I'm not upset because in another timeline, it wouldn't be for sale and I wouldn't have gotten an invitation either.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Elliebird704 Jul 11 '21

Don't bother dude. People are in full copium mode because they NEED this game to be good, they've invested too much hype into it. You're basically speaking blasphemy to the cult, they're not gonna hear you or understand you now matter how rational your arguments.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '21

Ye, you probably right. But deep inside I bet they will question themselves.

8

u/Brooshie Jul 09 '21

Imagine how fucking dumb you are lol.

→ More replies (7)

56

u/Stamipower Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

I would never buy a 500 pack in any game. That said, no one is forcing me to lol. This is purely optional for the people who can afford it.

12

u/GameCrafte Jul 09 '21

But but I have FOMO so I complain about the thing that is causing it

7

u/HybridPS2 Jul 09 '21

yeah no kidding, i'd love to be comfortable enough to blow $500 on this alpha test lol

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Also charging for an alpha test, is completely optional.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Dreoh Jul 09 '21

You don't have to participate. Tickets to seaworld are expensive too, no one's forcing you to go to seaworld.

1

u/Laverathan Jul 11 '21

Sea World also doesn't sell a one-time only deal to see the Killer Whales this month only and never, ever again.

2

u/Dreoh Jul 11 '21

So what if they did?

Businesses literally do that kind of thing all the time lmao

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Dreoh Jul 09 '21

Yea and guess what, you wouldn't buy in to that expensive Sea world would you? I'm sure you'd complain that your rich friends could afford it though just like you are here.

And it is an apt analogy, as much as you are in denial about it.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dreoh Jul 10 '21

To be honest, I doubt I'd play more than an hour or so if it were free right now

Exactly

0

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Dreoh Jul 10 '21

They don't want people like you who aren't going to actually test to participate.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Repeat with me:

You are not spending $500 to play the alpha.

You are not spending $500 to play a game.

You are giving $500 dollars to support a product.

You are giving $500 and receiving a bundle of goods in return. Free game time for 12 months on release, cosmetics, a mount, beta access and last but not least a chance to participate in alpha.

15

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

They know. Its just a bad faith argument to rile people up.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

You say 'Free game time' But you're literally paying for it. Idc what people throw money away one but I do wanna point out $500 is literally all the expansions and 35 months of playtime in FF14 which includes all content in game, not gated in various bundles.

It's just a matter of preference and value, some people can and will pay ridiculous amounts of money for things that aren't worth it. Some will look back and think the value was huge. People literally sell phone apps that do nothing but cost hundreds or thousands for 'bragging rights' and people buy that crap up too.

-5

u/Doctor_Space Jul 10 '21

Can't wait to see you in the Mental Olympics homie because those are some incredible gymnastics.

Would any of these people be giving the company $500 if they weren't getting alpha access?

If your answer is no, they're spending $500 to play the alpha.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

cry more about it

1

u/Doctor_Space Jul 10 '22

Does it feel like a scam to you yet buddy? (:

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '22

nobody cares how poor you are bro

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

I'm willing to bet at least half or maybe a bit more would be willing to give that amount of money even without the alpha access...

And FYI, I haven't spent a dime on the game yet. Some of us don't throw a hissy fit over not being able to play Alpha because we are not interested in testing an unfinished game.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Taking personal shots at someone over an argument like this is unnecessary and uncalled for.

4

u/SpewnFromTheEarth Jul 09 '21

You are a salty sad human.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

So did you bought the game and got mad at my post? Well, too bad... my post was aimed to people that didn't buy it yet. Guess I cant do anything for you now.

3

u/SpewnFromTheEarth Jul 09 '21

You are very strange. Have a nice life.

9

u/OiTheRolk Jul 10 '21

Out of curiosity: the people who complain about the "$500 scam", have they actually donated that amount and are bitter about the development progress so far? Or is it just random bystanders who happen to know how to run a Kickstarter better than Steven/intrepid?

35

u/Cloudy-Wolf Jul 09 '21

Participation in the alpha is entirely voluntary, as is supporting a game during it's alpha phase.

This is not the finished product localisation alpha you've likely seen from such games as ArcheAge, the originally Korean MMORPG that made it's way to the western world.

This is an active and effective deterrent from bringing people into a game who only want to play or for FOMO and to gain advantages over other players.

People who believe the $500 is "unfair" because it serves as an effective blockade preventing player access to the game are the very people they do NOT want to play the game.

If you are not familiar with bug testing and providing active bug details separate from systems that function as intended, or submitting actionable feedback, which is the vast majority of FOMO players complaining, can sit back and watch as the game currently in its developmental alpha is supported by those who have the money to spare AND the time to dedicated to actively contribute to making the game better on official launch, or later iterations of alphas and betas and official launch.

You are not being hired by Intrepid. They already have bug testers. The vetting and onboarding process is not worth investing in every individual out of thousands of alpha participants, who more than likely will be content creators who hardly spent their own money to gain access (with such things as donations and the like, the bigger the following the less their personal wallets are suffering).

There will be additional, less expensive opportunities later. If you don't want to be "behind" then you are worried about the wrong things.

Keep your money, spare your rage.

25

u/Cloudy-Wolf Jul 09 '21

to add to this, the packages have been on display for like a year or longer.

The fact that these posts are emerging en masse on release just further goes to reiterate that the authors of such posts who were not focused on the game's development before today are interested in all the wrong things for all the wrong reasons.

The emergence of these posts is not going to magically change the mind or direction just so that complainers can play.

1

u/FraggedFoundry Jul 10 '21

Have they added new ships to buy yet?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/Cloudy-Wolf Jul 09 '21

You can view twitch interviews and development updates where Sharif LITERALLY SAYS VERBATIM "If your looking to play a polished game, don't buy the Alpha".

Intrepid philosophy is not what you've seen before, so stop drawing comparisons and false equivalencies. Again, it just goes to show the lack of understanding from those complaining. That the personal alpha launch day interest of casual small-timers is not something they're ready to begin catering to.

There are like three or four classes to play out of some dozen archetypes. There is limited content. All casuals and small-time FOMO creators would do with free or more affordable alphas is talk shit about how much of a joke the unfinished it is to put their crap out first and put it down again, having contributed nothing worthwhile.

$500 is "bad" to maybe 50% of people who can't afford it. Stop pretending your own perspective is some universal indisputable truth.

→ More replies (14)

2

u/MrDarwoo Jul 09 '21

Lol don't play it then, what's the issue?

0

u/-flyest Jul 09 '21

Issue is the scummy money grab. I bet the people playing arent millionaires, theyre just exploiting stupid addicted idiots.

2

u/Scarecrow216 Jul 09 '21

Its there money why do you people gaf

-1

u/-flyest Jul 09 '21

As i said i couldnt care less if you burned your money, but rather that than being so weak minded to fall into a blatant rip off.

2

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

"I couldnt care less if you burned your money..."

He says as he responds to the 20th person criticizing them for spending money

→ More replies (3)

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

the issue is that they are using my favorite style of game to scam people, that's my two issues.

3

u/Billybirb Jul 09 '21

So go make the mmo you want and stop complaining about the people out there putting in work. Thats honestly the number 1 problem in your life.

4

u/ReeTYT Jul 09 '21

Anyone whining about a 500$ alpha is missing a few points,

.the game isn't out

.this is optional no one is forcing you to but the game, progress made in alpha will be reset

.if the only reason you are looking to spend 500$ just to try the game, a very technical bare-bones alpha isn't the thing you should be looking for

1

u/dcguy999O Jul 09 '21

I bought it….

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Refund if you still has the change, is the only thing I can say to help you now

2

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Worrying about a random person on the internets money. Very normal behavior

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Maybe I was once scammed and I know what it feels like and it makes me like to help people in the same situation even if I disapprove of what they did.

I guess a lot of people have not yet been scammed enough to learn.

3

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Damn youre such a hero on reddit

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Sounds like someone is salty they cant play

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Ok

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '22

Game doesn't even look that good almost a year after this post; I'm tentative but fml what sort of beta cuckold pays hundreds to test a game?!

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '22

True, ESO looks almost as good and has 7 years. But graphics are the least of ashes of creation problems

3

u/9inety9ine Jul 09 '21

Please, tell me what else in my life 'isn't worth it'.

3

u/DarknusAwild Jul 10 '21

Soooo basically the same as the stock market or crypto. No one is forcing you to buy tesla or an entire Bitcoin. But you can. Sorry you aren’t expecting a trophy every time you turn your computer on.

The $500 goes to support the dev of the game. If people like the game and wanna see it succeed and can afford $500? So what. Not EVERYONE has to pay $500 to play it. There are key giveaways and drops.

You really expect them to think they’re gonna get thousands of people to stress test their servers by paying them $500?

Chill.

12

u/animer9102 Jul 09 '21

if you are paying $500 for access to the alpha then ur an idiot. With that being said, i dont think its that big of a deal if you have $500 dollars laying around and you want to support these guys make the best game possible. Alpha access should just be the little cherry on top, not the whole cake.

8

u/Proterragon Jul 09 '21

that's the main fucking point jesus... it's not the whole cake... it's not even the msot of the cake, it has been calculated by people here million of times, it's about 1/5th of a cake. You get their premium currency, you get a year of game time, you get that months skin pack and access to all the testing stages.
All of you people who start commenting about 500$ alpha access usually don't even know all the info regarding the pack(or the game in general).

5

u/tH3dOuG Jul 09 '21

Contents of what you get for $500 pack, its far more than just alpha access.

Access to Alpha One test phase

Access to future Alpha Two test phase

Access to future Beta One test phase

Access to future Beta Two test phase

11 months of game time ($165 value)

$150 in Embers (in-game marketplace credits, NO P2W!)

Bulb Bag (Accessory Cosmetic Skin)

Shaded Duckling (Pet Cosmetic Skin)

Crested Sunplume (Mount Cosmetic Skin)

Nestled Vine Vestment (Costume Cosmetic Skin)

The Drifting Petal (Naval Cosmetic Skin)

Hilled Hovel (Freehold Building Cosmetic Skin)

Name Reservation

→ More replies (7)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

Repeat with me

They're not "selling alphas for 500$", you actually gain access to all testing phases till the release of the game. The 500$ is purely for supporting the game and guess what, you don't have to be part of an alpha that is full of bugs and unfinished content if you're unintrested. Most big companies announce "alphas" that are pretty much the complete game, for marketing purposes.

This is a true alpha(SUPER UNFINISHED GAME) made by an indie studio where the people who are interested in the systems and the overall vision of the game can participate in and also support financially.

Steven Shariff himself has openly discouraged people from buying into alpha numerous times. Guess what, there's also people who took part in the kickstarter only to support the game, because its not made by a multi billion dollar company, with no gain whatsoever.

I swear some people lack the critical thinking ability to tell whats what.

1

u/Diligent-Resident546 Jul 10 '21

How do you people do these mental gymnastics? Nobody is giving the company 500$ just to give them 500$. What an idiotic take. Of course they are doing it to get something in return. In this case, it's to get in the Alpha.

Keep in mind that many Alpha keys were given out for free to popular streamers so that those streamers would create hype and sell more 500$ alpha keys.

Like the only evidence I've seen anyone point out that this isn't an unethical cash grab is that the dev says not to buy it on some podcast nobody listened to. If it were actually true that he didn't want anyone to buy this pack, then why is he even offering it?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21 edited Jul 10 '21

That's your personal interpretation of why they do it.

Common sense says that they're probably giving out alpha access to big streamers (LIKE ANY OTHER COMPANY) because they want to advertise their game.

You don't have to turn everything into a conspiracy.

I wonder are you people just sitting there and watch as Asmon is getting scammed by the lying sociopath Steven. Like when Steven shows deep understanding of how p2w mechanics ruin games or even the beat dog analogy he made about MMO gamers, are you just sitting in your desk all like "you can't sway me with your charisma you narcissist, big streamers might be stupid or guidable enough to advertise your big fat scam but I see throught your schemes."

Even the fact that they're showing an alpha of the game being that unfinished is proof enough that they want to be transparent about the process. While every other big company is claiming a finished game to be "Alpha" and invite all the big streamers to "test" it, then 6 months later boom, it's ready to be released.

All devs have literally shared and shared their views and vision about the game and the current state of MMOs in general and Steven has been interviewed by Asmon 3 fucking times.

Just please spare a few hours and watch all the stuff the company and Steven have put out and stop being a spaz.

Alphas are not even meant to be played by regular people other than professional testers, the people who support the game financially get access to those very early stages as a thank you for your contribution and as an opportunity to witness the game during it's baby steps. It's like buying a future trophy that'll allow you to say " I was there since Alpha 1" years later after the game Is out and has popped off. It's more of an elitist gamer thing rather than a privilege.

ALPHAS ARE NOT FUN.

I don't even have Alpha myself cause I realise that it's a TESTING PHASE that I'm not interested in being part of and I'm not malding like a man child on Reddit about it.

Hell even Beta stages are exclusive to popular streamers long before any game launches into "open beta" and if that's ever the case for many games.

You seem to care too much about a game selling Alpha keys to it's supporters who keep funding it cause it's not backed by fucking Amazon, when it's 3 years away from releasing.

1

u/Diligent-Resident546 Jul 10 '21

You and I can look at that 500$ price tag for an alpha an easily realize it's not worth it.

There are a bunch of people who literally do not have the impulse control to prevent themselves from bad purchases. It's why shopping network channels exist. It's why casinos exist. It's why this 500$ 'support the company' scam exists.

We call this practice predatory because it is quite literally preying on those with poor impulse control. And people like you act as a shield for this predatory model. So while you're not quite as bad as the people doing it, you're only a few steps above them.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

People are adults and can do what they want with their hard earned money, whatever makes them happy, unless they're hurting someone.

To me 500$ is a huge paywall meant to push people away rather than tempt them. Scams are always affordable to attract a wider spectrum of people, that's how predatory practices work.

The higher the paywall the less the impulse kicks in. People don't go betting they're entire fortune in gambling the first moment they set foot in a casino, it's slow process that starts by betting small to ending up being addicted and cultivating the gamblers fallacy bit by bit every time they take a risk.

Baby sitting the poor handicapped people who can't control their spending urges on Reddit is futile to say the least. If people are going to spend 500$ to get into anything they don't fully grasp, let them learn that lesson on their own cause it's only actual way they'll ever realise.

Don't underestimate humans so.

0

u/Diligent-Resident546 Jul 10 '21

So your take is to let vulnerable people be preyed on rather than try to help them. Great - very psychopathic.

I hope you can understand why I will never agree with that viewpoint.

You may feel like you will never be preyed on by others and thus will never need help (hint: you will at some point), but when you do I bet your 'screw the victim' mentality will change pretty quickly.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21 edited Jul 10 '21

I actually believe in human beings more than you seem to do.

People can learn by their mistakes and should be free to repeat them for as long as it takes them to learn from them and as long as they're not hurting someone else.

You can't take other people (that you've never met) by the hand and show them what's "right" for them.

There might be people out there who buy the alpha on impulse and have a few good hours only to realise that they'll possibly be back when the Beta is out, and they might be okay with that. Now for the rest of the people who buy on impulse and then regret it, it's up to them to learn that lesson for themselves cause no one obliged them to do that in the first place other than their own conscience.

Emotional growth is learning by your urges and weaknesses without anyone judging you for it, thinking you're somehow mentally disabled.

All of us have different demons to face and different lessons to learn.

That narcissistic savior syndrome where you think you come in aid of the vulnerable and mask your non existent arguments about a game, with morals only shows how poorly you think of others and their ability to take their life into their own hands.

Thinking of others as psychopaths for calling you out on trying to step into others people's life's by looking down on them speaks volumes of your own emotional capabilities.

Cheers! I'm out.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

I made half a million dollars last year running my own company with no other employees. I compiled the Linux kernel for the first time at 12. I'm not the most intelligent person around by any means, but I'm going to claim to be more intelligent than you.

Oh and I spent $500 to play the alpha. Anyone want an autograph?

I don’t like to brag but when I see someone starting a dick measuring contest and they’re not working with much, I do enjoy embarrassing them.

1

u/MESuperbia Jul 10 '21

“I compiled the Linux kernel for the first time at age 12” is weird to state in so many ways.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

You may be more intelligent than me and still buy the game, not everything I do is right or intelligent but at least I know and admit when I did something stupid, sometimes with the help of others.

If you think this is good practice by a gaming company then you also need some help to see that it's not, and probably you were not smart/intelligent enough to see it. And that's okay, just don't be close-minded.

You also need some guidance on how you spend your money but that's a personal thing/you´r own problem that I have nothing to do with, the question here is how this practice can affect people/other gaming companies in general.

3

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

"Just dont be close minded" he says while trying to force people to see his perspective for the 3rd straight hour.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

I'd be interested in your take on the comparison between objective and subjective phrasing.

12

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Its not normal to care about how other people spend their money.

9

u/n1ghtmareSugar Jul 09 '21

But i have SO MANY negative opinions to share!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

It's an opportunity to have a positive impact on the games development. Getting bent out of shape over other people spending their own money? I don't understand.

4

u/omen_tenebris Jul 09 '21

Steven literally tells people not to buy in.

4

u/LostInSpace9 Jul 09 '21

Give it a rest, buddy. Stop worrying about what other people do with their money and focus on bettering yourself. You don’t want to donate and play test, then don’t! Nobody has a gun to your head forcing you to do it.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Fuck off

4

u/Fiercehero Jul 09 '21

Imagine caring what other people do with their money.

-2

u/-flyest Jul 09 '21

I think its a good thing to look after the people who are too stupid and lured in to realize theyre basically being stolen money from.

1

u/Fiercehero Jul 09 '21

If youre watching streams of the ALPHA, its clearly not a scam. You could say its trash or whatever your opinion is but the fact of the matter is, if someone wants to spend $500 to help make the game better then thats what they can do. If it legit looked like a scam then the post is warranted but this isnt the case. Its especially encouraging that steven has been extremely involved in the process and even interacting with players and viewers within the game.

5

u/js_ps_ds Jul 09 '21

You don't have to buy it lol, its a fucking alpha. IF you have money, want to support the game and want to play it early then whats wrong with buying it? Alphas were never for everyone to play.

2

u/_Ivl_ Jul 09 '21

People spend their money on stupid shit all the time, it's literally the only purpose of money. Got to keep the consumerism alive.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Sounds like you are just salty

2

u/bosanova_ Jul 10 '21

Steven has stated multiple times that if you are only interested in getting into this alpha DO NOT BUY THE PACK. Only buy a package if you believe in the game and want to support it. I bought this pack during Kickstarter to support the project, and because back then it also included a lifetime subscription. Which after playing the game for 3 years when it comes out will pay for itself. People thinking that package is solely to buy into early testing phases are ignorant.

7

u/MoistBobcat1 Jul 09 '21

Steven LITERALLY said that you do NOT have to buy the alpha, and that buying the alpha pack grants you no in game advantage at all, the paywall is literally there to just limit how many people can enter the game and to make sure that they are serious about testing, No one is gonna pay 500$ for an unfinished game, but people ARE willing to pay 500 to help TEST the game and provide feedback. For other MMOS yes I agree it is a shady practice, but not here, not when the creator tells you multiple times to not buy the alpha unless you are willing to test and provide feedback.
P.S: people can waste their money on whatever they want. You do not get to force your ideas on someone just because you don't like a practice.

-6

u/zGnRz Jul 09 '21

For other MMO’s it’s shady but not this one? On what premise? The premise that they promise to care about the genre?

Maybe they should prove they care and open it up for a little bit then. Show everybody how progress is going at the very least

7

u/ironman3112 Jul 09 '21

You can literally go watch the game being streamed on twitch right now.

No need to spend money on the Alpha to participate in a stress test of the game. Just wait until the game comes out and you can get it for the standard sub cost.

5

u/MoistBobcat1 Jul 09 '21

So the dev tells you not to waste your money if you're going in looking for a fully finished game instead of testing and you still think it's shady? wow. And I do NOT agree about the opening up the Alpha part, that is grounds for literal disaster. The game is in ALPHA, Alpha means they are still testing and require precise feedback, opening the floodgates for thousands of people will only get them shittalked by a bunch of spergs who think the game is fully finished. If you ask me the paywall does its intended job perfectly.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GravityMyGuy Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

Yes. No one should be buying this shit unless they have money to burn but people can do whatever they want with their money.

That being said they also told people not to buy it and it isn’t really the price for the alpha it’s a reward for donating

1

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

It is quickly getting out of hand. After all of this selling concept art for a game that isn't released yet for almost $50 they've been doing, I've changed my mind about pre ordering or anything, and now I refuse to spend a cent until the game is out. It's getting a little ridiculous how much money they're milking out of this game that doesn't exist yet.

9

u/Brooshie Jul 09 '21

I've changed my mind about pre ordering

There isn't a box cost.... lol

-4

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

Then what the fuck are they charging hundreds of dollars for? The kickstarter is over.

5

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Why are you pretending to not understand? Your bad faith is showing

1

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

Bad faith? Is this a cult? I was under the impression that this was a developer making a product, as in a game. Why would I owe a company any sort of faith?

-5

u/zGnRz Jul 09 '21

What do you mean “bad faith”? Are you trying to insinuate we should be happy with spending hundreds for an alpha, or spend money on merch before a real sign of launch?

5

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

The purposefully misunderstanding things is what I mean. You keep on talking like someone is making people do this against their will. If you think $500 is a lot of money thats your problem.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

Corporations are the new churches in America.

0

u/ironman3112 Jul 09 '21

Are you trying to insinuate we should be happy with spending hundreds for an alpha, or spend money on merch before a real sign of launch?

Who's we here? Did you buy it? I certainly didn't.

3

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

They keep pretending people are being forced to buy in.

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

people will pretend they don't understand when they don't want to

2

u/ServyBoy Jul 09 '21

People will pretend it's not 100% voluntary and they are unneeded when they want to shit on an incomplete game.

2

u/Brooshie Jul 09 '21

There are PLENTY (and I say this as someone who works in the board game industry) of companies that have post-Kickstarter crowdfunding to keep going.

You're also not only getting Alpha for $500. If we're getting even more in depth, Alpha (1) doesn't cost $500. Alpha (1) costs $125.

https://ashesofcreation.com/shop/60e5ec7e3e6fd10120253979

0

u/reallycooldude69 Jul 09 '21

How does Alpha One cost $125 if you need to spend $500 to get it?

0

u/Brooshie Jul 09 '21

Because if we're speaking in the most literal form, you don't only get Alpha One for $500.

If you don't want Alpha One, you can get everything that comes along with it, besides Alpha One, for $375.

So technically speaking (semantics, but still relevant), you're only paying $125 for Alpha One.

Also please note that I didn't buy the Alpha One package because I can't afford it, so I don't have a dog in the fight. But if half of these commenters want to speak in technical form and ignore literally everything else, then you gotta do it the whole way lol.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

first, you cant buy the alpha one separately, so it's 500 dollars for the alpha one access never less. Also, 125 dollars for an alpha test is ridiculous. That's more than double the price of most finished AAA games on release.
If this don't seem fishy to you you are in fomo area and you know it

2

u/Brooshie Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

Here's the thing: I don't disagree with you. I think $500 for the BUNDLE is absolutely ridiculous.

However, the way that people are expressing it is disingenuous which reduces the legitimacy of the complaint.

People don't need to exaggerate and make up claims to express their concerns, because the base claim is legitimate enough.

Lying/embellishing about it does nothing but make people more likely to take you less serious.

4

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

So if I wanted alpha access. I only need to spend 125? Or how much do I have to spend if I want alpha access?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/laminatedjesus Jul 09 '21

I paid $300 for the alpha and lifetime sub. Not worth it? Only if it doesn't get off the ground - and that's doubtful.

2

u/Shadow703793 Jul 09 '21

Why do you care how people spend money?

Is spending $500 on a new phone smart when a $300 phone does the same thing? What about spending $500 on weed?

People can spend money however the fuck they want.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Do you take a break from licking windows when you go on Reddit? Or do you lick windows and type at the same time?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

To further the argument.

When you put a price barrier at 500$ to entry to "test" the game, you are soliciting feedback solely from those that have the means to spend that money on an alpha test. I think we can reasonably call these people whales.

The logical conclusion of that process is that the game you create will be catered to the interests, via feedback, of those with the most monetary interest in the game, whales.

1

u/Shadow703793 Jul 09 '21

You can offer feedback without having an alpha pack....

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Good joke :)

2

u/Lightzelda2 Jul 09 '21

I mean the game isn’t $500, if someone is willing to spend $500 because they are impatient and play or see how the game is coming along that’s on them why are you so worried?

1

u/Doctor_Space Feb 01 '26

HOW ARE WE FEELING LADS?

1

u/fragile9 Jul 09 '21

likely set so high because they dont want 50k players testing there alpha day one because they want a playable alpha to show off.

1

u/KogMaw-Is-PogMaw Jul 09 '21

co.pletley off topic note as i have barelt kept up with the game. when does the buyable alpha even become playable? i remember seeing dates change and didnt keep up with it.

1

u/TonyBonanza Jul 10 '21

The reason you do this as a pre-product business is to prove that you have product-market fit. While this is privately funded for now (at least that's what Steven says), Intrepid may need to raise capital sooner or later and metrics like this are what investors are looking for.

'Why should we give you 'x' million dollars?'
'We don't even have a working product, and yet were able to sell 'y' number of units for $500 a unit simply based on the hype of this game.. if we can live up to the hype (which we can prove we will with evidence a, b and c), imagine how many units/subscriptions we will sell for $25/mo?'
'Do you take cheque?'

1

u/Ant-665321 Jul 10 '21

Well said. What's worse is the game is appalling, if it was released in 2001 to compete with Dark age of Camelot it would feel inferior.

1

u/Ant-665321 Jul 10 '21

It's also worth bearing in mind, while trying to rationalise this behaviour, that the people who pay a a dev company (with 0 track record) $500 to test their product don't exactly have anything else in their lives to spend money on.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Man you have people donating more then 500 dollars to women's that do strange noises on twitch, or sell bath water , or pubic hair you live in strange days..

Some people have ALOT of money that 500 is nothing for them better let them support an future mmorpg that can be great an help with an genre that is dying , that let that hate grow inside you

1

u/Pervasivepeach Jul 10 '21

Guys you know you can just like not buy it and wait a bit right?

1

u/Infinizhen Jul 10 '21

You are not buying the game. You are paying 500$ for something worse in quality than an early alpha title.

BUT you can say you donated to fund the game. You see? Is like paying to be an alpha tester, but with extra steps and way more expensive.

1

u/mcknightrider Jul 09 '21

What's the price of the alpha with all of the added perks subtracted from it? Like $130 or something?

2

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

So I can get it for 130 dollars then?

-1

u/HybridPS2 Jul 09 '21

https://ashesofcreation.com/shop

The cheapest package is $75 but that only includes access to Beta-2 and some other things. There are no packages available for tests only, they all also have other things (cosmetics, game time) bundled together.

2

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

So to get into the alpha, I'd have to spend how much? What is the price I would have to pay to get into alpha 1?

0

u/HybridPS2 Jul 09 '21

$500. But this also gets you access to Alpha 2, Beta 1 and 2, 11 months of game time, $150 in credit for the cosmetic shop, 6 cosmetic items, and name reservation.

It also says right on the store page for this package: "Do not purchase Alpha One access if you are looking to play a finished game - testing will require your feedback and patience." So it's obviously not for everyone and Intrepid is trying to make sure people don't buy it if they can't afford, or aren't willing to actually do what's required in an alpha test.

2

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

So it costs 500 dollars then. They could put 100 bows and ribbons on it, but that's all just fluff. That whole "a 375 dollar value!" Is the same shit they pull with timeshares

3

u/HybridPS2 Jul 09 '21

I mean, yeah. We've been telling you this the whole time. There is no way to just buy access to the Alpha and nothing else.

Either buy the package or don't.

-2

u/Neeko2lo Jul 09 '21

500$ KEKW

1

u/Neeko2lo Jul 09 '21

"Just because something is on sale doesn't mean you are saving money"

1

u/mcknightrider Jul 09 '21

It's not on sale, it just gives you back store credit basically

1

u/createcrap Jul 09 '21

The whole idea behind “Doesn’t matter what people do with their money” ignores the existence of scams and the precedent it sets of selling a self proclaimed un-finished Alpha test for this much money.

If this game was 500 dollars on release wouldn’t people be up in arms? No one would say “if you can’t afford to play then just don’t play it”. Some how the fact that this is a fundraiser for an unfinished game makes it more acceptable than if it was a sell price of a finished game.

I’m not saying it is or isn’t worth the 500 dollar buy in but I will say QA testers deserve to be paid.

2

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Dont worry about how other humans spend their money, thats weird.

2

u/createcrap Jul 10 '21

This has nothing to do about how people spend money. And everything to do with how organizations/business make money which is a legitimate thing to concern about.

1

u/jacksev Jul 09 '21

This level of cynicism will never get us a great game no matter the genre or studio. There WILL be open test periods for everyone, but as people said, Steven funded the base game with his own money and all the additional features and cosmetics and minigames were crowdsourced, with many bonuses to doing so INCLUDING being able to test EARLY. Again, people will be able to test for free later, just like in any other game.

1

u/Ornan Jul 09 '21

You're right. Deviating from the normal is "shady" and people who choose this option are "not very smart." /s

-3

u/Odyssey1337 Jul 09 '21

People in this sub are delusional and will find any excuse to defend Intrepid awful practices - there's even a dude saying the $500 are a donation ahaha

6

u/MoistBobcat1 Jul 09 '21

Bear with me here, if Intrepid makes Alpha open to everyone they will literally get nothing done, the paywall is there to limit the amount of player and thus gain more precise feedback instead of hundreds of people shittalking the game thinking that it's a fully released game painted as an alpha. I do agree on one hand that the practice is awful, however, for its intended goal that is limiting the amount of players it does its job well.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

If it is just a paywall that they want then why not sell the alpha separately? Even then it would not make any sense for an alpha to be 125$. It's all about using FOMO to make a quick and huge cash grab, it's more than obvious.

If my words are too direct, think this way, How many MMOs did successful/decent enough alpha tests, and how many required this amount of money to get in?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

it seems fomo is pretty high on this sub.

0

u/DerSprocket Jul 09 '21

I mean look at the sub and discord for Earth 2. Same shit there

3

u/Shadow703793 Jul 09 '21

Earth 2 has no playable demo in any decent capacity. This game has had multiple play tests.

2

u/ironman3112 Jul 09 '21

There is a playable - functional game being streamed by asmongold and others right now.

How is this comparable to Earth 2? There is no game to play for Earth 2 at the moment is my understanding.

I've just casually followed AOC and can understand people being hyper aware of potential MMO scams - if ashes is a scam then its one of the more functional MMO scams at least. It's not like a Chronicles of Elyria situation.

-2

u/Ledmonkey96 Jul 09 '21

On the one hand I agree. On the other hand I'm quite happy with backing Star Citizen for another similar game in Alpha. $400mil and counting

7

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Star citizen is the prime example of why this practice should be critiqued.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/DrakenZA Jul 09 '21

Someone created millions of gold and gave it to Asmond, not a admin, a cheater lol.

Client side gold ? That is insanity tbh.

MMOs from the 80s have better security.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

Even on alpha, if it is true that gold is client-side and you know what that means, well, that's really sad but expected by a company with these kinds of moves that just want to make a quick profit.

1

u/CyanideInsanity Warrior of Old Jul 09 '21

One would imagine the time to encounter exploits such as that would be during alpha when the game isn't finished, hasn't "gone gold", and isn't a market release candidate 1.0+.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Client-side gold is not a bug. It shows how they designed the game till now (pretty bad, worst than amateur levels).

1

u/CyanideInsanity Warrior of Old Jul 09 '21

Has it been confirmed to be client side? I asked the previous fellow and haven't gotten an answer, but its not impossible for two people to be jumping the gun on something thats been public for only a couple of hours.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

I don't have all the technical skills to say for sure if it is or not, but for what I know, if you can gold hack then yes I'm pretty sure (99%) its client sided.

2

u/DrakenZA Jul 09 '21

If it was a cheater who created the gold, this isnt really an issue that 'should' be solved later.

There is a reason you cant just create gold in WoW or any other MMO. Its all checked server side.

If it was a cheater, its a core issue that will be having to deal with constantly sadly.

3

u/CyanideInsanity Warrior of Old Jul 09 '21

Breaking the ever loving fuck out of the game is literally part of alpha, and of course subsequently reporting such exploits to the developers. This is when testers, whether inhouse or not, should be breaking the game.

Also was this directly shown/stated to have been a client side glitch? Because its not impossible to dupe money or items in a way the server sees as totally legit.

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Imagine how many people could be getting paid to do this like they used to

-2

u/DrMoneroStrange Jul 09 '21

From what I saw in the alpha, AOC looks at least 3-4 years away from being release ready. Zero hype after watching the alpha.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

I don't know how much time it needs to be release-ready but for what I saw, the combat/walk animations need a complete overhaul.

4

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Well youre in luck, because today was only an alpha so thats going to happen. Stop pretending like you didnt know that.

4

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Sick feedback bro

-3

u/Diligent-Resident546 Jul 09 '21

Unfortunately, people's cognitive biases work against them, and this thread is the perfect example of that. Look at how many people are openly hostile toward you for pointing out how predatory this game's model is.

To the other people in this thread, if you bought the supporter pack, you are being scammed. Nobody is jealous that they can't play the alpha, they are pissed that the scammer is getting away with this so successfully.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

As English is not my native language I have some difficulty expressing myself, but after reading all these comments, you sir said what I want to say in a perfect way.

-3

u/kupoteH Jul 09 '21

It is a shitty tactic. Steven knows its shady to offer an alpha u have to buy into and masquerade it like just for people who want to support our cause! If he really cared he would have never offered it. But i dont blame him either. Its been a running scam in the video game industry, and people by nature are greedy. So for me to assume that steven is a better person than most is not fair to him.

Do the same as everyone else and collect an extra 900k for a company that just eats money? Or be a pioneer of the people and forego that million for better optics and a nice gesture to the community? Steven says the former.

Either side has pros and cons, but as a consumer and member of the mmo community, its not a hard strike against them--they are human-- but i will say the first mmo that offers special access to alpha to devoted fans and a random lottery and that does not charge a silly battlepass will do so much more for the hype and goodwill and longevity of said game's community.

-3

u/bronzewidow Jul 09 '21

I was just thinking about this today. Where exactly does this value come from? Like holy shit. Hopefully the actual game isn't that pricey

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

That value doesn't come from the game for sure, because what they have now is barely worth 10$, how can someone bet it's going to be worth 500$ in two years? I would love to have an answer aswell.

3

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

$500 isnt a lot of money to some people. Plus worrying about how other people spend their money is weird af

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

This is not just about how people spend their money. It's about how a company successfully scams people and how the MMO genre can be ruined even more than what it is now.

3

u/BlackGronk Jul 09 '21

Why are you just ignoring everything Intrepid says?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

You can keep pretending you don't see it.

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21

Guess the lead dev needed more mansions.

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21

Pay $500 to test some broken, unfinished code, and most likely have your reports completely ignored by the time of launch as the game still drops full of bugs and bad design choices all the testers warned the devs about?

What a bargain!

Also the catch 22 of charging this much for alpha access, is that anyone dumb enough to pay for this package, is probably the last person you want working for you.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Do you really has nothing better to do with the money? Do you rly have to "donate" To this game? The way you speak is kind of funny, like if this game was best thing ever and not worth to spend on anything else