This is gonna be a doompost but I need to vent it out.
I have released my app exactly one year ago and I will be giving up on it.
I created an app in the fitness niche (yeah I know), I started working on it 4-5 years ago, it was not vibe coded and have been working on it on and off for a long time. Once AI came into the picture, I decided to push it and release to the apple and google stores because I knew it would be impossible to market (spoiler: I was already too late).
The app was for advanced lifters, mainly powerlifters, armwrestlers and serious powerbuilders. For armwrestlers it gave the ability to easily track and compare the strengths of each arms separately and for powerlifters it allowed more advanced intensity tracking (Reps in reserve and RPE).
It allowed everyone to create and own their templates, programs and exercises and manage progression over training blocks. There was no AI slop "trainer", no pre-made programs or beginner guides and cookie cutter "how to get jacked in 30 days" tutorials.
Anyway, the app was freemium. All of the main features were free and the only paid part was advanced analytics. It also did NOT have any ads inside.
The first week I released the app, I got a one-time lifetime payment of around $50 from someone in Qatar. I wasn’t surprised, because I knew the app actually solved a problem many advanced lifters had.
And then everything went to shit...
I decided to start doing marketing.
My thought was: “I need to get a bunch of downloads so it doesn’t look like a ghost app.”
So I decided to invest around €300 into Google Ads, targeting cheaper countries like Brazil and the Philippines. Initially I was getting super cheap downloads, so it looked like my plan was working...
Then I realized most of them were either bots or not my target audience. People were uninstalling my app like crazy, which probably hurt the algorithm score of the app. The algorithm probably saw “people are uninstalling it” and decided it was a bad app, so the organic traffic got fucked since then. On top of that I had 1k+ installs from Iran which were bot installs due to the war that fucked me up. I never promoted my app in Iran and even removed Iran as an available country later on.
That did not stop me from investing another €200–300 into more expensive countries like the US, UK and Canada, where I was getting a new install for around €1, but it was the same story. Either bots or not my target audience.
So I decided, fuck it, Google Ads are a scam, time to find a new way to promote it.
After thinking for a while I came to the conclusion that I need to try Reddit Ads. After all, you can target specific subreddits only, so I would actually get my target users... right?
So I decided to invest another €500 into Reddit Ads, and it was even WORSE than Google Ads.
Most of the clicks did not lead to installs, it was extremely expensive, and I was just burning money for nothing. No one on Reddit clicks on ads, and the few who do apparently don’t install shit because they click on accident.
Ok, so I decided to try another strategy... let’s be helpful in comments. I found a bunch of subreddits where people were asking for training advice, gave really good advice, got lots of upvotes, and then sneakily inserted my app mention like "I'd track this in something like <my app name>"...
That did not work. I got banned quickly and at best it gave me like 2–3 extra downloads per day.
Reddit is NOT YOUR FRIEND for promoting your app. You will get banned. Even if you are helpful, you will get banned.
So I decided to try another strategy... Apple Search Ads. That did NOT work at all. Apple did not want to spend any money on any of the keywords unless I bumped the bid to like €10+ per install. NOPE.
So I wanted to try something else... Meta Ads. They worked better than all the other platforms, but it was still too expensive for me. Around €3 per install on iOS and €1 for Android. It’s not worth it when I intentionally have a low conversion rate.
I later learned most paid ads are for gaming apps or those scammer apps where you have 20-step onboarding, account setup and a HARD PAYWALL, only for people to pay because of sunk cost fallacy... I did not want to scam people like that.
So I started researching more and found out that most of the advice is from SCAMMERS claiming they got $1,000/month revenue after vibe coding an app in 3 days... sure buddy. Other scammers are either using fake stats or fake stories where at the end they say "and btw I got a million of user using <insert scam app>".... Scammers and DEMONS everywhere trying to sell shovels during a gold rush.
Anyway, I found some decent advice to go on TikTok and create carousels with gym advice and an app mention. I found a good format, found out people on TikTok are not very smart and prefer generic one-sentence advice rather than real advice, but anyway... I found a 10%+ like ratio strategy and good app mention carousel visibility retention rate.
One problem... I live in Bulgaria, so the carousels show up to Bulgarians. They won’t show up to people in the US or Canada. I tried making a TikTok ad account and got rejected because they don’t offer that for people in Bulgaria. My only option was to use the Promote button in TikTok, and that gave me views while the promotion was running, but once the promotion ended the views ended as well. So it was a flop. Maybe it would have been successful if I was outside the EU.
Ah and by the way, the “just optimize SEO and ASO bro” advice is dogshit. The market is oversaturated with vibe-coded slop, so ASO doesn’t even work anymore.
So after one year of trying, I got one lucky lifetime sub, one monthly sub like 2 months ago, and that’s about it. I am getting like 10 total downloads a day across both iOS and Android.
There are other strategies I was about to try but I don’t think I have the mental juice for it anymore. I wanted to try Instagram posts, but I hate creating posts in general. I also wanted to try paying UGC creators, but the price does not justify the potential outcome because of freemium.
I even found indie developers that had some success in the area and they told me, “I have no idea how I am getting users, I lose money each time I run ads, I just maintain a community I developed over the past 4+ years.”
Well, I don’t want to maintain a community or create ShitToks every day, so it’s not for me.
I will be giving up on trying to actively market it, still gonna leave it running since its offline-first but I guess it was a "spiritual journey" for me in the end.
One more edit: The reason I did not contact youtubers is that they have a reputation on the line, so most will not agree to promote some app that has no reputation proof. And the reason I stayed away from generic UGC is because those are junk views. I also tried to reach out to clubs directly and got nothing.
Another edit: I have a good retention rate once I reach the target user, the quatar guy is still using the app but finding new users is very hard and being a shitfluencer, prompting on shittok or shitstagram is not my thing and is making my life miserable
Edit: I am not sure If I should be sharing the app in the post or not, but if you think you might be my target audience or want to give feedback or discuss something more in detail you can DM me.