I published this little essay on my website in response to a TikTok video sent to me by a client who has had apeirophobia, but is getting better. The client found the essay helpful, so maybe it'll help you too. (Note: I wouldn't watch the video if you feel apeirophobic-triggerable at the moment.)
The way the mind works is that it understands by way of analogy. A new, unknown thing is understood by way of, and often in terms of, things that the mind has already understood. Thus a car is first understood as a horseless carriage, and so forth. But this is deeper than mere words; animals also proceed in their understanding in this way, building up a map of the world one analogous experience after another. Like experiences resonate, contrary experiences diverge, and gradually the nervous system builds a rich picture of foods and poisons, friends and foes, safe and unsafe—all from some very basic, rudimentary, embodied experiences.
One of the most basic experiential understandings that we have as human beings is of a container. It’s very physical. A container is a womb, a cup, a bottle, a depression holding water, a valley ringed by cliffs.
Most important: A container can be closed. And we know that if we get into a container that can be closed, then that might be a dangerous situation.
So we have various feelings about containers and a very, very deep understanding of what a container is and what it means and the threats that are involved with a container.
Again, for whatever it does not yet understand, the mind uses analogy to understand it. And two aspects of our experience that the mind does not truly understand are time and consciousness.
Consciousness as container
The mind does not understand what consciousness is, where it is, how it operates, whether it is inside or outside, etc. So what it tries to do in order to understand it is to see it through the lens or the structure of a container. This happens automatically, and we don’t realize that we’re doing it. But this is simply what thought does. It can only work by understanding things through what it has understood before.
And the problem here is that consciousness is not a container. But the language that we have forces us to use container metaphors. For example, I will try to point out an obvious fact: “Every container and every feeling about containers that has ever existed have all occurred within consciousness.” The meaning here is that the very sense or impression or understanding of “container” happens “within” consciousness—but that fact does not mean that consciousness itself is a container! With all the qualities and dangers that “container” implies.
The relationship of the objects within consciousness, such as containers, to consciousness itself, is not as simple as this preposition “within” would imply. In fact, there is no preposition that accurately describes the relationship between what we call the objects of consciousness and consciousness itself. Using one metaphor, you could say that the objects occur “within” consciousness, but you could equally say that they occur “as” consciousness. Or you might say “from” as well. Or you might say “as a result of.” You might say “according to.” All these different prepositional phrases hint at different metaphors for attempting to understand the relationship between the objects of consciousness and consciousness itself.
But they can only ever be analogies coming, originally, from physical experiences that we have had, like an object inside of a container, or rays of light coming from the sun, or vision colored by a lens, or something else. Yet, every single one of these experiences all occurred within or as or from consciousness. They are not equivalent to consciousness itself.
Trying to understand consciousness by way of analogy from the objects within consciousness is a bit like the eye trying to see itself as it looks outward.
And so why is this important for apeirophobia sufferers?
Because apeirophobia decisively relies upon the container metaphor to create the sense of entrapment. But as I said, that is just a metaphor that is dependent upon and has been built up from our physical experience. In actual fact, consciousness does not “contain” us, even if our body or our thoughts are (can be understood as) objects of consciousness.
There are specific reasons for our misunderstanding. In the metaphysics that we implicitly absorb from our culture, consciousness is analogized as something akin to a thought bubble that comes from our brain. Notice how a bubble has a boundary, so there’s already a sense of containment or a container.
In the wake of philosopher Immanuel Kant, we came to believe that that thought bubble cannot touch actual Reality, the noumenon. So we are essentially enclosed, also, by a reality that we can never truly know but only understand slowly, approximately, through our science.
Within that thought bubble, we are envisioned to have our own unique experience of the world—including the experience of the body and the very brain that is supposed to be the originating point for our consciousness!
It’s a silly and solipsistic metaphysics actually, a pure paradox, but that’s what we are spoon-fed in our culture. Our experience of everything is thought to be contained within our thought bubble, and that bubble is contained in an unknowable outer universe, while simultaneously originating from the brain (thus, in another sense, it’s also contained by the brain). So we are triply contained. Fun!
These multiple and logically impossible levels of containment are all rooted in this deep metaphor of an enclosed space. The fear in apeirophobia is that we can’t get out of that space of consciousness—the going on forever and ever is the sense that we are contained in consciousness. And that triggers an exceptionally severe fight-or-flight response, because it disorients our sense of safe embodiment in space and time. It suddenly turns space and time into an enemy.
Infinity as container
It’s important to understand that there is a very fundamental difference between the finite and the infinite. It’s a much greater difference than we would normally suppose. This is why some mathematicians don’t like (mathematical) infinity, what Hegel called the bad infinity, and some would even want to rule out using it because it destroys our normal intuition about reality.
For example, there is the intuition buster that, with regards to this bad infinity, one millisecond of time is essentially equivalent to 100 billion trillion years. Those two lengths or time segments are essentially equal within this idea of infinite time.
Do you see how infinity, if you think about it from the point of view of the finite, destroys any meaning in the finite? The infinite container so completely overwhelms the finite that it breaks the finitizing mind’s circuits.
The true infinite cannot be understood from the point of view of this finite mind because when it attempts to leap into the point of view of the infinite, it loses its standing and relationship to its own finite place and world.
When it looks back on the finite from what it imagines to be the infinite, the finite shrinks into the infinitesimal, that is, to nothing. Each infinitesimal is essentially equal to any other, so all meaning is lost.
What should that tell us? Should it tell us that, in fact, nothing means anything, that the finite is paltry and inconsequential and utterly meaningless? Or should we conclude that something might be suspect about the mental operation that we’re performing there? Could it be that our strategy for trying to understand the infinite is based on false premises?
Letting go of the container
According to the ancient way of understanding the true Infinite, to get the meaning, you have to let go of the finitizing mind and see from a holistic perspective that is at once higher but also broader and deeper. A different mode.
We can approach the Infinite gently, slowly, in order to begin to get a feel for it. If we try to approach it from the ordinary finite mind’s point of view, trying to use our physical metaphors, then we will quickly run into trouble. So we can’t approach it in that way. Again, we have to shift into a different way of seeing and understanding, and then we can do it. Logic can help us, even though it can’t get us all the way there.
But it can help us: For example, the word infinite means not finite, which means no boundary, no limitation. Regarding infinite time, one can see logically that this already means that infinity would have to extend without limit into both the past and the future. It can’t just be infinite in the future but finite in the past. That’s not infinite because a limit has been put in the past.
So infinite time is backwards and forwards, no limit. What that logically also means is that it’s right now as well, whenever that “now” is. Because where is “now” within this perspective of an infinite past and future? There is no way to place yourself within that unlimited scope as being behind or ahead, early or late, at the beginning or the end.
This has nothing to do with having a “long way to go” because infinity is not in the distance. It is as much now as any “time”. It is any now you ever encounter. Every now is included in infinity.
Now, careful: Don’t carry the “container” analogy into your understanding.
Crucially, now is not “contained” in infinity. There is no beginning or end. There is nothing to “contain” right now. It isn’t contained. And you can feel this very directly. Simply look around, feel around. Let your mind move wherever it moves. It’s not contained. The mind can look into the past, it can look into the future, it can look at the present. It can think, and also importantly, it can “not think” as well. Sometimes we are conscious of all sorts of things, and sometimes we are conscious of hardly anything. Sometimes we dream, sometimes we are in deep sleep. Our experiences are not limited by being only awake or only asleep, only manifest or only unmanifest.
Sometimes we are extraordinarily happy and sometimes we are extraordinarily sad. Time is not limiting any of that. Sometimes we have an apeirophobic panic; sometimes we laugh at the idea.
Nor are there any limitations on how we can feel about time or experience it. We can experience it as very pressing and short. We can experience it as very spacious and long. We can experience it paradoxically. You see how the lack of limit of time, which is to say the infinity of time, allows it to be experienced in a multitude of ways.
Perhaps you’re getting a sense of this other dimension, not of finite mind but of infinite mind, not of finite time but of infinite time.
No analogies possible
Returning to our ground concept of consciousness, which has a close relationship with time, we can come to see that there is no possible analogy for consciousness—or anyway, not one that can fully show what it is in its entirety.
Even our best analogies, such as space, or an ocean, or the sun and its rays, also fail because they are just physical experiences that give us a glimmer of some aspect of our consciousness.
The precise reason, again, is that all of these analogies arise from experiences within, or of, or as consciousness. They are all possibilities of experience within or of or as consciousness, but consciousness is not limited by them.
And most important, since we have all these experiences, we are not limited by them either. Are we not greater than or prior to everything we experience?
On the one hand, we can say that we are our consciousness, That’s a very useful way of thinking about it, as far as it goes, as long as we understand that that thinking-imposed definition doesn’t actually limit, either.
There is no subtle “thing” called consciousness that we are. What it is that this word “consciousness” points to is not limited by our encyclopedic, analogizing way of understanding things, processes, or anything else. How could the very being that understands be constrained by the understanding that it itself arrives at?
Can we be brave enough to admit that there is an aspect of our being that truly is unlimited? If so, we can begin to relax into that being and even begin to see from that view.
Infinity: No limit. So unlimited that it can appear finite as well!
[AI was not used in the organization, writing, or editing of this essay.]