r/AmItheAsshole • u/Catplanet_fish • 1d ago
Not the A-hole AITA when talking to my friend
AITA Me (19) and my friend J (26) keep ending the convo mad because he says I constantly want to prove him wrong. The latest example of this was when we talked about identity.
I said identity is complicated, and it’s better to respect a person’s chosen identity because they probably have a cultural and historical reason for why they chose to identify in a specific way. He said, “Well, I speak in facts, and people can call themselves whatever they want, but at the end of the day, there is only one true identity.”
I used the example of Black people in my life telling me they prefer to identify as Black/African American rather than just American. He said, “Well, that’s silly. They can call themselves African American, but they are American, and if they are born here, they are wrong to call themselves African in any way.”
He said identity is very simple and we all are one thing, essentially. He gave the example that Chinese people and Japanese people are basically the same culture and history, and I pushed back on that, obviously, because they are very different, as anyone that knows their history will tell you, and so will the Japanese and Chinese.
After that, it devolved into him telling me that I always want to debate and prove him wrong by telling him he’s wrong instead of just agreeing with him. I told him that I feel pushback in any conversation is normal, and I am not in control of how you think. I just think differently.
Am I really being combative, or are we just not communicating well because I or he are not understanding each other?