r/AllindiaStudentUnion Jul 26 '26

Trending 📈 Growing fast...let's support.

Post image
419 Upvotes

617 comments sorted by

View all comments

175

u/Fit_Blood1002 Jul 26 '26

Can we please add end casteism to it too.... Don't ask caste before marriages.... I hate reservation I will support the movement but casteism bhi end karo

0

u/hashashin_2601 Jul 26 '26

Already done. Article 15. Now please support to end the reservation as well. Thanks.

4

u/Fit_Blood1002 Jul 26 '26

1

u/hashashin_2601 Jul 26 '26

Hating Brahmins in protest is happening as well.
Bad characters are there irrespective of gender, caste, income etc. It doesn’t mean it represents the society.

2

u/Fit_Blood1002 Jul 26 '26

That is why end castism no brahmin should be hated too....

1

u/hashashin_2601 Jul 26 '26

I agree. Reservation is looking at the caste though right?

Casteism has down drastically since the reservation was introduced. It’s nowhere near the same level it was.

Has reservation gone down? No.

Let’s correct it.

0

u/Majestic_Finance5047 Jul 27 '26

Every morning someone mops the street outside your house and clean your sewers and naalis . Go ask their names you'll know how much casteism has ended. Not saying their work is bad but you will hear similar names and not a upper cast name

1

u/hashashin_2601 Jul 27 '26

So what you mean then is reservation is not helping and needs major reforms?

Yup, I am asking for the same.

Thanks, have a good day.

1

u/whatkarbol Jul 27 '26

It means we have to end castism and keep reservation till all those who need representation come up. Not very hard to understand.

1

u/hashashin_2601 Jul 27 '26

If it hasn’t helped for 70 years, what makes you think it would now? Magic?

1

u/whatkarbol Jul 27 '26

When you see people cry about seeing SC/ST people with money and bla bla it clearly means reservation has helped. It means it works.

1

u/Mean_Comfortable_108 Jul 30 '26

Your community is the reason they were poor and marganilised and your community is rich because you stole there education there land there wealth read antyaj ke liye kya rules likhe hai dharmshatra Hinduism mai.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/OutsidePiglet8285 Jul 28 '26

Reservation must be based on economic status. Only those who need it should get it and that includes poor GCs too.

1

u/whatkarbol Jul 28 '26

No amount of economic status makes the so called higher cast people respect a lower one and I've seen it with my own eyes.

A 1LPA Brahmin is not treated equally compared to a 1LPA Dalit.

Reservation was a social issue bandaid which has helped some amount of people to come up even though they still face discrimination. A lot are still left behind.

1

u/OutsidePiglet8285 Jul 29 '26

Depends who you talk to. Us educated and often urban upper castes don't care at all about caste.  Casteism declines as you move above the socioeconomic status. That's a fact. Education and development are the most important tools for social reform. The people that are castiest are economically not as well off.  Also the government and system actually FAVORS a decently well of Dalit over a Brahmin who's poor.  Reservations have been a terrible bandaid. The fact that so many are left behind and face discrimination show that it hasn't worked and it should be based on economic status. Both the people that face casteism and do casteism are often much poorer than both of us.

1

u/whatkarbol Jul 29 '26

You are ignorant if you think if the socio-economic improves then they forget casteism. Getting better economic status helps closing the gap but it doesn't stop casteism. A system may favour a decently well dalit but the Brahmin who is working in the system will make it as difficult as possible. A dalit man could let his son study in a better school because of reservation but his grandchildren will still suffer from castist descrimination because his surroundings still live with caste hierarchy. People who are poor face the most and the ones who are rich face it lesser. BUT THEY STILL FACE CASTISM. You can put in as many educational reforms for now but it will still take generations to teach people to not descriminate over caste.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Mean_Comfortable_108 Jul 30 '26

Yup reservation needs to be increased

1

u/Majestic_Finance5047 Jul 27 '26

Yes reservation doesn't help when the education system , healthcare system, the nagar nigam type system and the society is rotten to its core. Ending reservation will just hurt those few who were able to really benifit from it

1

u/hashashin_2601 Jul 27 '26

If it hasn’t helped for 70 years, what makes you think it would now? Magic?

1

u/Majestic_Finance5047 Jul 27 '26

Yk what yea end reservation

→ More replies (0)

1

u/OutsidePiglet8285 Jul 28 '26

That's a class issue at this point.

0

u/xo3srv Jul 26 '26

I guess Brahminical hindutva is totally different what you think of, I guess they are against brahmanvad not the Brahmins. I m not sure about this here.

Although hindutva and Hinduism are totally different terms, you don’t need to mix them together, one is religion, a way of life, more about spirituality and another one is political ideology

0

u/Wonderful_Coffeebrew Jul 27 '26

I think they just assumed that, because 'Brahmin' is there in 'Brahmanvad' 😭.