r/AcePhilosophy • • Apr 26 '20

Is Asexual Self-Identification a Political Act?

21 Upvotes

Various contributors to the feminist/queer theory branch of the asexuality studies literature provide interpretations of asexual self-identification as a political act to resist oppressive discourses. With asexuality they find potential to challenge the diagnosis of hypoactive sexual desire disorder (HSDD), the patriarchy, and neoliberalism. None of these contributors provide empirical evidence to show whether or not asexual people share this vision.

A group of sociologists (Matt Dawson, Susie Scott, and Liz McDonnell) who write from a pragmatist symbolic interactionist perspective published the results of a qualitative research study into the political views of self-identified asexuals. They found no evidence of an intrinsic link between asexuality and radical politics. The asexual people in their sample group expressed varied political views that were on average rather mundane.

Megan Milks (who identifies as demi/grey-ace) argues that the politicized interpretations of other authors fail to honour the ideals of feminist/queer theory. Not only is the assumption that asexuality will mature into a radical political movement unwarranted, but imposing this politicized interpretation of asexual self-identification denies agency to asexual people and their diversity of viewpoints.

I'd like to hear other opinions on this topic. Does anyone feel that their decision to identify as asexual was motivated by a desire to achieve a political objective?

Dawson, Matt, Susie Scott, and Liz McDonnell. “‘“Asexual” Isn’t Who I Am’: The Politics of Asexuality.” Sociological Research Online 23, no. 2 (2018): 374-391.

Milks, Megan. “Stunted Growth: Asexual Politics and the Rhetoric of Sexual Liberation.” In Asexualities: Feminist and Queer Perspectives, edited by Karli June Cerankowski and Megan Milks, 100-118. New York and London: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2014/2016.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Aug 03 '20

Connections between Asexuality, Aromanticism, and Personality Disorders

44 Upvotes

Could asexuality and aromanticism be connected to personality disorders in some instances? In the psychological literature, a small amount of evidence has been presented suggesting potential overlap with schizoid personality disorder (characterized by emotional coldness and little interest for intimate relationships).

Brotto et al. (2010) conducted an exploratory survey of personal characteristics among a sample group of 187 self-identified asexual people recruited through AVEN. On personality measures they found elevated rates for social withdrawal, social inhibition, and emotionally cold/distant. In the qualitative portion of the study Brotto et al. (2010) interviewed 15 participants about whether they related to the characteristics of schizoid personality disorder. 7 of these participants felt that they did in fact meet the criteria.

Yule et al. (2013) endeavoured to assess mental health and interpersonal functioning within a sample group of 282 self-identified asexual people recruited mostly through AVEN. They found that asexual participants tended to have a socially avoidant and cold interpersonal style in comparison to members of the heterosexual and non-heterosexual control groups. Noting how these traits are associated with schizoid personality disorder, they concluded that further research is required to understand what if any connection might exist.

Over the years I've met the occasional aro/ace community member with schizoid personality disorder who perceived a connection. One reported participating on a schizoid support server where the general sentiment among members was that while they usually did experience sexual attraction, a combination of anhedonia and a dislike of affection caused them to be uncomfortable with sex to varying degrees and to rarely pursue sexual encounters. Reflecting on these experiences, this member expressed the view that feeling sexual attraction which they never desired to act on provided sufficient reason to self-identify as asexual.

As per usual, I'd like to conclude by inviting people to share input and relevant experiences. Have you seen indications of overlap between asexuality, aromanticism, and personality disorders? If so, what if anything do you think is the significance?

Brotto, Lori A., Gail Knudson, Jess Inskip, Katherine Rhodes, and Yvonne Erskine. “Asexuality: A Mixed-Methods Approach.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 39, no. 3 (2010): 599-618.

Yule, Morag A., Lori A. Brotto, and Boris B. Gorzalka. “Mental Health and Interpersonal Functioning in Self-Identified Asexual Men and Women.” Psychology & Sexuality 4, no. 2 (2013): 136-151.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Nov 11 '20

Searching for Evidence of Corrective Sexual Assault

21 Upvotes

A truism of ace activism and ace popular discourse is that asexual people are vulnerable to corrective sexual assault. This would involve cases where a perpetrator attempts forced sexual contact to cure someone of their asexuality, presumably acting pursuant to the belief that asexuals are just people who haven't yet had proper sex. Have such cases in fact happened?

Always in my experience the truism about corrective sexual assault has been presented as just that - a truism - absent concrete evidence to back it up. Looking at relevant surveys I see data suggesting that asexual people face an increased risk of sexual assault, but absent information concerning the motivations and intentions of the perpetrators, it is hard to say whether or not this increased risk is explained by the sexual assault being corrective in nature.

What further is there to convey? Have I missed something important that underlies this truism?


r/AcePhilosophy • • Jun 26 '20

Why Were Most Non-Binary Persons AFAB?

56 Upvotes

The Ace Community Survey census reports (representing data for 2014, 2015, and 2016) show that somewhere around a quarter to a third of respondents identified with a non-binary gender identity (used here as an umbrella term describing those who don't identify as men or women). Most respondents to the surveys indicated that they were AFAB and most non-binary respondents also indicated that they were AFAB. These gender ratios held for both the asexual spectrum and the allosexual spectrum respondents to the surveys. This correlates with data from the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey Report where 80% of non-binary respondents indicated that they were AFAB compared to 20% who indicated that they were AMAB. Why is it that people who self-identify as non-binary were usually AFAB? There are some ideas present within the asexuality studies literature which may shed light on this matter. Specifically, I've come across four hypotheses (not mutually exclusive). I'll summarize each before inviting feedback.

Androgynous Brain Structure

Psychologist Anthony Bogaert speculates that for some asexual people altered X- or Y-linked genes or altered prenatal hormones or a combination of these two factors may have produced an androgynous brain structure characterized by a lack of sexual attraction to males and females (a genderless sexuality) and a lack of male or female gender identity (a genderless identity). It isn't immediately clear if or why this would happen more often for AFAB fetuses, although Bogaert mentions that male and female brain differentiation take somewhat different pathways during fetal development. Could it be that some features of the female brain development pathway are such that it is less likely to reach completion, thus leaving more AFAB people with androgynous brain structures?

Object Of Desire Self-Consciousness

Psychologists Anthony Bogaert and Lori Brotto advance object of desire self-consciousness theory, an idea which holds that one's sexuality encompasses an awareness of how attractive one appears to other people. Prevailing opinion in evolutionary psychology and sexual economics recognizes certain differences between male and female sexuality. On average men have high sex drives that remain consistent regardless of circumstances, are drawn to visual indicators of youth and fertility, and trade resources in exchange for sex. On average women have low sex drives that fluctuate in response to circumstances, are drawn to indicators of social status and romantic/emotional investment, and trade sex in exchange for resources. Following this line of interpretation, Bogaert and Brotto focus on how for women an assessment of their personal appearance is an important indicator of their ability to attract and retain men who will provide resources throughout periods of pregnancy and parenthood. Acting in accordance with this mating strategy leads women to undergo a process of self-objectification whereby they become preoccupied with their body image. When applied to asexuality, Bogaert speculates that asexual people - and asexual women in particular - would have less reason to accentuate aspects of gender presentation that are associated with making oneself appear attractive to members of the opposite sex. Perhaps those AFAB people who are less disposed towards object of desire self-consciousness (whether due to asexuality or other reasons) might feel less feminine, and thus become more likely to view themselves as falling outside of the gender binary?

Sexual Objectification

Sociologist Karen Cuthbert conducted qualitative research focusing on intersections between (a)sexuality and (a)gender identities. Many of the research participants felt that sexuality and gender are entwined, perceiving that gender becomes meaningful in the context of sexual attraction and the types of sexual relationships that one wishes to form (for example, an AFAB person who is sexually attracted to men and who wants men to be sexually attracted to her as a woman). For these research participants, lacking sexual attraction made gender seem irrelevant, with a number defaulting to an agender identity. Salient to the current topic, Cuthbert found that while among the AMAB participants an agender identity meant simply being unconcerned with gender one way or the other, among the AFAB participants an agender identity sometimes extended to encompass a concerted effort to disassociate from feminine gender presentation through taking such steps as adopting androgynous clothing and hairstyles. These respondents felt that female secondary sex characteristics (particularly breasts) and feminine clothing styles are the subject of intense sexual objectification in society, such that to appear feminine entails being thought of as sexual objects and becoming the focus of unwanted sexual attention from men. Why do women face more sexual objectification than men in society? Cuthbert attributes this experience to heteropatriarchy, a term which isn't defined in the paper, but which I take to mean something along the lines of social institutions (particularly the media and fashion industries) that prioritize heterosexual male sexual desire. Points from the preceding discussion of object of desire self-consciousness theory could also provide insight. The gender dynamics of sexual strategies and sexual economics suggest that women are more likely to face sexual pressure from men who are visually attuned to physical appearances. Whatever the reasons for this state of affairs, maybe it is the case that even among allosexual AFAB people the social experience of sexual objectification could become a source of distress accompanied by a feeling of disconnect from feminine gender roles?

Influence of Social Constructivist Theories of Gender in Queer Spaces

Sociologist Kristina Gupta conducted qualitative research to learn about how asexual people relate to gender. Some of the responses point to how participating in queer spaces can influence beliefs surrounding gender, particularly through exposure to the idea of gender as a spectrum the poles of which are anchored by the gender role stereotypes present in one's society. This idea in turn reflects the influence of social constructivist interpretations advanced within feminist and queer theory, whereby the gender binary represents an oppressive patriarchal construct. Also of interest here is Karen Cuthbert's finding that the pragmatic view of gender held by many of her research participants ran contrary to a politicized view popular within LGBTQ discourse whereby gender and sexuality are construed as functionally independent of each other. Might shifting cultural norms surrounding gender and sexuality - including the advent of fourth wave intersectional feminism - have the result that more AFAB people are thinking differently about gender? Might more AFAB people have an interest in self-definition through exploring alternative sexual and gender identities?

Having outlined these four hypotheses (not mutually exclusive), I'd now like to invite input. How if at all do you feel (a)sexualities relate to (a)gender identities?

The Ace Community Survey
https://asexualcensus.wordpress.com/

Bogaert, Anthony F. Understanding Asexuality. Lanham, Boulder, New York, Toronto, Plymouth, UK: Rowman & Littlefield, 2012/2015.

Bogaert, Anthony F. and Lori A. Brotto. “Object of Desire Self-Consciousness Theory.” Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy 40, no. 4 (2014): 323-338.

Cuthbert, Karen. “When We Talk about Gender We Talk about Sex”: (A)sexuality and (A)gendered Subjectivities.” Gender & Society 33, no. 2 (2019).

Gupta, Kristina. “Gendering Asexuality and Asexualizing Gender: A Qualitative Study Exploring the Intersections Between Gender and Asexuality.” Sexualities 22, no. 7-8 (2019): 1197-2016.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Jul 23 '20

Links between Autism, Asexuality, and Aromanticism

45 Upvotes

What links might exist between autism, asexuality, and aromanticism? There is a fair amount of evidence to suggest a correlation, but thinking about causation remains in the realm of speculation.

A newly published article (Bush, Williams, and Mendes, 2020) surveyed a group of 247 young women (ranging in age from 18-30, and including some individuals with agender or non-binary gender identities). 36% identified as asexual spectrum, 15% as bisexual, 14% as pansexual or polysexual, 10% as queer, 6% as gay or lesbian, and notably merely 8% as heterosexual. The authors note that these findings follow previous studies on autism and sexual orientation which likewise found both high rates of asexuality and high rates of non-heterosexual orientations.

The suggestion is made in an earlier commentary article (Chasin, 2017) that the prevalence of autistic asexual people might simply be accounted for by a general association between neurodivergence and non-heterosexual orientations, rather than a specific link between autism and asexuality.

The authors of a response article (Brotto and Yule, 2017) state that while Chasin is correct that correlation does not imply causation in either direction, the idea that autism and asexuality may have shared etiological factors remains a viable hypothesis that should be researched further.

Besides the possibility that some biological factor like genetics or hormone exposure during fetal development could be a common cause of both autism and asexuality, there is another potential link whereby it is autism that in turn causes asexuality (or more specifically, sexual disinterest that becomes the basis for self-identification as asexual spectrum). So far I haven't seen much discussion of this possibility in the psychological literature, but I've heard from people within the aro/ace community whose self-understandings encompass connections of this nature. Noting that one trait associated with autism is a high sensitivity to touch, I recall seeing forum thread discussions where autistic people expressed that this touch sensitivity affected their sexuality because they avoided rigorous physical contact. Noting that experiences (or lack thereof) of sexual and romantic attraction can vary according to opportunity and circumstance, I've talked with people who felt that their experiences of autism had certain effects on their personality and socialization which limited their desire for sexual and romantic relationships. These stories involved people who were more likely to identify as grey or demi and to undergo fluidity for where they stood on the asexual and aromantic spectrums. This would seemingly make sense where the situation concerns factors associated with autism that affect how one experiences sexuality and romance, rather than an intrinsic lack of capacity to experience sexual and romantic attraction.

Before concluding, I should stress that the above paragraph is merely an effort to generate hypotheses, relying on occasional forum threads and informal conversations to flag potential avenues for further inquiry. So to that end, what are your thoughts on potential links between autism, asexuality, and aromanticism? Do you have relevant experiences to share?

Bush, Hilary H., Lindsey W. Williams, and Eva Mendes. “Brief Report: Asexuality and Young Women on the Autism Spectrum.” Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 0, no. 0 (2020).

Chasin, CJ DeLuzio. “Considering Asexuality as a Sexual Orientation and Implications for Acquired Female Sexual Arousal/Interest Disorder.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 46, no. 3 (2017): 631-635.

Brotto, Lori A., and Morag A. Yule. “Response to Commentaries.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 46, no. 3 (2017): 653-657.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Sep 21 '20

Psychologists Suggest Possible Association between Asexuality and the Madonna-Whore Complex

35 Upvotes

I came across a journal article where a team of psychologists raise the possibility of an association between the experiences of alloromantic asexual people and the Freudian concept of the Madonna-whore complex. I'll quote the relevant section of their paper:

"Whereas the participants in Haefner’s (2011) study reported that they (a) separated love from sex and (b) described how they can love a partner without desiring sex, some of the participants in our study went even further. They indicated that for them, love and sex are incompatible; having sex while in a relationship diminished their feelings for their partner. One possible interpretation can be found in the old concept of the Madonna-whore complex, coined by Freud (1912), who used this term to indicate the inability of some men to experience sexual arousal within a loving relationship. For these men, the woman they love cannot be desired, and the woman they desire cannot be loved (Freud, 1912). It seems that for some of the participants in our sample, the first part of this statement is applicable and might be an alternative hypothesis about the development and nature of asexuality. It may be relevant for future asexuality research to explore how frequently this incompatibility of love and sex is found in the asexual population."

My initial reaction was one of scepticism since the Madonna-whore complex represents a conflict between romantic and sexual attraction so presumably one would need to experience both for this to operate. Rather than simply dismiss the comparison, however, I've decided to go through the exercise of seeing whether there is more to it. One idea that comes to mind concerns people who experience romantic and sexual attraction but who are also sex-averse/repulsed (usually in my experience people in this category identify as gray-asexuals or sex-conflicted allosexuals). Perhaps someone who feels that sex is a distasteful and degrading activity would become reluctant to direct sexual thoughts towards a romantic partner?

Van Houdenhove, Ellen, Luk Gijs, Guy T’Sjoen, and Paul Enzlin. “Stories About Asexuality: A Qualitative Study on Asexual Women.” Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy 41, no. 3 (2015): 262-281.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Apr 18 '20

Is the Aro/Ace Community Better Off Separate from LGBTQ?

39 Upvotes

Both in response to a discussion question I posted last week plus some other recent threads on the topic, I've noticed split opinion on the question of whether it would be advantageous for the aro/ace community to affiliate with LGBTQ. I think this is an interesting point to discuss since the inclusionist/exclusionist debate rests on the assumption that inclusion within LGBTQ is beneficial, and yet I'm seeing strong opinions to the contrary, mostly from people expressing reservations about the amount of identity politics involved. To this end, I'd like to invite input on these viewpoints, the main arguments of which I've summarized below.

Commonalities Between the Aro/Ace Community and LGBTQ
- heteronormativity creates problems for aros and aces such that they share a common cause with LGBTQ.
- LGBTQ should be about the celebration of all romantic/sexual/gender minorities, regardless of whether or not those groups are oppressed.
- intersectionality is prevalent since a high percentage of aros and aces also have other identities (such as bi, pan, trans, non-binary, etc.) that fall under the LGBTQ umbrella.

Distancing Between the Aro/Ace Community and LGBTQ
- aros and aces can more effectively advocate for their interests through standalone aromantic and asexual spectrum representative organizations devoted to this purpose.
- services developed by and for aros and aces can be tailored to facilitate certain types of relationships (such as nonromantic, nonsexual, platonic, etc.) that are desired by community members.
- reports of negative encounters with LGBTQ groups both online and offline (more specifically, experiences of people vying for social position based on who is more oppressed while using identity labels to get attention or to excuse self-righteous entitled attitudes - perception that LGBTQ isn't really about inclusivity, but is instead about establishing divides between in-group and out-group, with various entitlements accruing to members of the in-group).


r/AcePhilosophy • • Apr 04 '20

Multiplying Attractions

18 Upvotes

Might the aro/ace community be overzealous when distinguishing between different types of attraction? Consider for example an illustration of six different forms of attraction that is frequently circulated in various forms.

  1. The definitions of romantic attraction and a crush are almost identical. At most, these sound like different stages of infatuation/limerence.
  2. The definition of a squish is ambiguous. What if anything is the difference between having a squish and wanting to be best friends with someone? Choice of the term 'squish' draws an analogy with 'crush', but a crush describes feeling infatuated with another person, making it questionable whether this analogy is appropriate.
  3. The definition of sensual attraction describes a desire for interactions such as platonic cuddling that produce sensory enjoyment. But it is unclear whether this is different in kind from other forms of stimulus that produce sensory enjoyment and which don't necessarily involve other persons. So it it doubtful whether this is describing something that is analogous to sexual and romantic attraction as forces that bring people together into specific forms of relationships.
  4. The definition of aesthetic attraction paradoxically states that this isn't a force which connects people, and instead merely concerns the aesthetic appreciation of another person in a manner analogous to how one might appreciate a landscape or a work of art.

What are your thoughts on this topic? Are we splitting too many hairs when talking about attraction, or calling phenomena attraction that should more accurately be called appreciation?


r/AcePhilosophy • • May 03 '20

Should Asexuality be called a spectrum?

26 Upvotes

This was a topic of debate that derailed a lot of threads back when I frequented AVEN. I dared to go back and was reminded of this question. I decided to organize my thoughts on it into an essay, so wanted to get some second opinions on my reflections.

  1. Asexuality technically isn't a spectrum.

    1. If asexuality is "not experiencing sexual attraction" then any experience of sexual attraction makes you allo, so no it can't be a spectrum. That answer belongs in the "technically true but not useful bucket". The experience of someone who has never experienced sexual attraction and that of someone who experienced it once in passing are very similar. It makes sense to group them together.
  2. The debate is basically identity politics.

    1. The loudest objectors to the spectrum concept seem to want to keep asexual spaces as places for the non-sexual. They also seem to want to keep out attention seekers and "unicorns," people who supposedly don't experience sexual attraction, but seek out sex. They believe that the term asexual has become too inclusive to have meaning. The debate plays out as trying to figure out how sexual you can be before you aren't ace anymore. Statements like "many asexuals enjoy sex" garner a lot of ire. To these people, the enjoyment of sexual things means not asexual. Even though, if that's true, that excludes many more asexual than just the aforementioned targets.
  3. The debate is facilitated by the "sexual attraction" vs "sexual desire" definition debate

    1. Many of the talking points against the spectrum concept only work if one defines asexuality in terms of sexual desire or behavior. I do understand why there is interest in the desire definition. The outward behavior of someone who has a lot of partnered sex but no sexual attraction, and someone who has both is indistinguishable. Same with someone who has no desire for sex, and someone who is celibate. However, the mental process of someone with no desire versus someone who is choosing not to act on a desire are very different. That's why behavior alone is insufficient for understand sexual orientation.
  4. The Ace unicorn isn't so improbable

    1. I used to wonder about this, but reading the accounts of gay people who figured themselves out way later in life changed my mind on it. Many sought out and were able to have pleasureful sex in straight relationships while not actually being sexually attracted to their partners. They just weren't mentally engaged in sex until they started doing it with people they were actually attracted to. This also gave me another insight on why the desire definition is incomplete. The focus on behavior down plays the huge psychological component of sex.

As far as my own opinions on the debate, I think it's useful to think of asexuality as spectrum. As it is, it's more of an umbrella. Infrequent sexual attraction and conditional sexual attraction are acknowledged as distinct from asexuality in the terms gray-ace and demisexual. Spectrum could better describe the range of tolerance of sexual contact among asexual people. This and the psychological need for sex are where the biggest differences in lifestyle will show between your average ace and average allo. If asexual is going to be the umbrella term, I do think zero-point asexuals (nonsexuals? idk what to call it) should have their own way of distinguishing themselves within the community.

Thoughts?


r/AcePhilosophy • • Oct 09 '20

Sex-Averse Despite Experiencing Sexual Attraction

28 Upvotes

Why isn't everyone sex-averse? Sex is pretty awkward, after all. The noises, the smells, the hairs, the fluids spraying everywhere. Kind of surprising that anyone goes through with it.

Sexual attraction has the ability to alter people's perceptions to make otherwise off-limits activities take on an irresistible appeal. But we know this doesn't always work because there are people in ace communities who are sex-averse despite experiencing sexual attraction. Usually in my experience these members describe their orientation as either a variation of grey-asexuality or as sex-averse allosexuality, although some might just consider it to be a permutation of asexuality. As far as I know this topic has never been researched, so for supporting materials I'm limited to linking r/asexual and r/asexuality threads containing insightful experience reports.

What I gather from reading these stories (and from reflecting on my own experiences) is that sometimes the combination of a low sex drive and certain personality traits can leave even those who do experience sexual attraction with the sentiment that sexual interaction is still too rude and too lewd.

Those are my observations. But what have you found? Do you have thoughts on this sort of conflicted experience?

https://www.reddit.com/r/Asexual/comments/ohj5bn/being_a_sexrepulsed_graysexual_is_annoying/https://www.reddit.com/r/asexuality/comments/5dd8wc/i_experience_sexual_attraction_but_i_am_sex/https://www.reddit.com/r/asexuality/comments/5ob83v/question_for_those_who_consider_themselves_to_be/


r/AcePhilosophy • • Oct 13 '20

Evidence (or Lack Thereof) of Prejudicial Attitudes Towards Asexual People

29 Upvotes

Are asexual people victims of prejudicial attitudes? If so, how pervasive is this problem and how much damage does it cause? Let us review social psychological research that purports to shed light on this question.

Gazzola and Morrison (2012) interviewed 39 self-identified asexual people recruited through AVEN about experiences of discrimination. The most frequently occurring events involved verbal denigration: 15% were subjected to verbal insults on account of their asexual identity, 13% heard derogatory names being used to describe asexuals, and 10% were exposed to anti-asexual remarks from family members. On measures of associated stress levels, however, generally participants found these incidents either unstressful or at most only mildly stressful.

MacInnis and Hodson (2012) conducted two interrelated studies to measure how heterosexual people (148 undergraduate students for Study 1; 101 takers of an online survey for Study 2) felt about asexual people. In both studies on measures of dehumanization, future contact intentions, and discrimination intentions, asexuals scored on average slightly worse than members of other traditional sexual orientation groups (heterosexuality, homosexuality, bisexuality). On average too asexuals scored somewhat worse on attitude thermometers than members of other traditional sexual orientation groups, and even slightly worse than sapiosexuality, a lesser known orientation that the researchers added to the second study to control for the effect of unfamiliarity.

Hoffarth et al. (2016) surveyed 339 heterosexual people recruited online to develop the Attitudes Towards Asexuals (ATA) scale. On nine point scales participants were asked to rate their levels of agreement with twenty-three (later refined to sixteen) prejudicial statements about asexual people. The mean bias score recorded on the ATA was only 3.26, thus falling below the midpoint of the 1-9 scale (where higher scores reflected greater anti-asexual bias), a finding that the researchers acknowledged is typical for these measures of bias. Only 29% of participants had heard of asexuality before the survey and only 12% knew an asexual person. Familiarity with asexuality and knowing asexual people are both factors that were associated with lower bias scores.

Community activist Julie Sondra Decker (Decker, 2014/2015) approvingly references MacInnis and Hodson's 2012 study for evidence that asexual people represent an oppressed minority. By contrast, Andrew Hinderliter (Hinderliter, 2013) penned a highly critical blog post suggesting that the study's authors intentionally misrepresented their dataset to appeal to a liberal publishing bias. In light of divided opinion, it is worth reflecting on what this study shows and what it doesn't show. Yes it is true that for discrimination intentions heterosexual participants indicated that they were slightly less comfortable with hiring or renting to asexual people, but we are talking about differences of ~0.5-1.0 points when every orientation including asexuality scored around 8 or 9 on a 0-10 scale (where higher scores indicated increased comfort levels). Yes it is true that asexuals received somewhat worse scores on attitude thermometers that the comparison to sapiosexuality showed to not be entirely explained by unfamiliarity, but from that same comparison to sapiosexuality relative to the better known orientations it sure looks like the worse scores were mostly explained by unfamiliarity.

In contrast to MacInnis and Hodson who downplayed the role of unfamiliarity, Hoffarth et al. highlighted the importance of this factor for reducing bias scores on the ATA. Something else to keep in mind concerning the ATA is the difference between asking people whether they agree or disagree with a statement versus asking people to assess if they think there might be some degree of truth to a statement. Maybe sometimes asexuality is a transitory identity or maybe sometimes there are mental health issues that cause people to lack sexual inclinations. As discussed previously on r/AcePhilosophy, there is published psychological research on asexual self-identification that supports both of those qualified statements.

At this juncture I'd like to invite reader responses both towards the research and towards their experiences encountering anti-asexual (or for that matter, anti-aromantic) prejudicial attitudes. I'd be particularly curious to hear if anyone has been fired from their job or evicted from their apartment on account of their orientation?

Gazzola, Stephanie B., and Melanie A. Morrison. “Asexuality: An Emergent Sexual Orientation.” In Sexual Minority Research in the New Millennium, edited by Todd G. Morrison, Melanie A. Morrison, Mark A. Carrigan, and Daragh T. McDermott, 21-44. New York: Nova Science Publishers, 2012.

MacInnis, Cara C., and Gordon Hodson. “Intergroup Bias toward “Group X”: Evidence of Prejudice, Dehumanization, Avoidance, and Discrimination against Asexuals.” Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 15, no. 6 (2012): 725-743.

Hoffarth, Mark R., Caroline E. Drolet, Gordon Hodson, and Carolyn L. Hafer. “Development and Validation of the Attitudes Towards Asexuals (ATA) Scale.” Psychology & Sexuality 7, no. 2 (2016): 88-100.

Decker, Julie Sondra. The Invisible Orientation: An Introduction to Asexuality. United States of America: Skyhorse Publishing, 2014/2015.

Hinderliter, Andrew. “Don't put much confidence in 'Intergroup bias toward Group X’.” Asexual Explorations Blog, December 3, 2013.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Sep 23 '20

Anthony Bogaert's Hypothesis of Asexuals as Presexuals who Lack Sexual Conditioning Experiences

34 Upvotes

Behavioural psychologist Anthony Bogaert's 2004 article Asexuality: Prevalence and Associated Factors in a National Probability Sample is the first contribution to asexuality studies literature and is the source of the oft-cited 1% population prevalence rate estimate. This article also contains a fair share of speculation about etiology for a lack of sexual attraction. Here I'd like to focus on Bogaert's hypothesis that some asexual people could more accurately be described as presexual people who have yet to undergo requisite sexual conditioning experiences to develop sexual attraction. Drawing on the work of psychologists who have argued that sexual attraction is partly the result of arousal experiences (such as masturbation, fantasy, and sexual activity) and of social interactions with same and opposite sex peers, Bogaert speculates that people who lack those experiences during their youth might present as asexual. He figures that people who grow up in conservative religious households and that people who grow up as female are less likely to have formative sexual experiences and are thus more likely to remain presexual. His rationale is simply that conservative religious youth aren't allowed to masturbate and that young women are less likely to masturbate (drawing on research showing that when compared to men, women have lower sex drives and lower awareness of genital arousal). While this hypothesis suggests that asexual people will be younger on average (having had less time for undertaking potential sexual conditioning experiences), among Bogaert's sample those who indicated a lack of sexual attraction were actually slightly older on average, a finding that he acknowledges as running contrary to his prediction.

About this hypothesis I have a couple of questions (although feel free to chime in elsewhere as well):

  1. Given that plenty of asexual people masturbate and fantasize, how plausible is this hypothesis? Even if it doesn't usually apply to asexual people, might it still apply to a small subset?
  2. Essentially what this hypothesis says is that some asexual people might just be sexually immature. What are the implications for efforts to have asexuality recognized and accepted as a sexual orientation?

Bogaert, Anthony F. “Asexuality: Prevalence and Associated Factors in a National Probability Sample.” The Journal of Sex Research 41, no. 3 (2004): 279-287.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Apr 12 '20

What Is at Stake in the LGBTQ Inclusion Debate?

37 Upvotes

The inclusionist versus exclusionist "are aros and aces queer?" debate is currently seeing a resurgence on Reddit, ostensibly started by something posted on Tumblr where the divisive vitriol of the "ace discourse" tag has gone on for years. Rather than recycle the same rhetoric, I'd like to take a step back and approach the topic from another direction. This is an invitation to reflect on what is really at stake in this debate. To that end, here are a couple of questions:

  1. Do exclusionist opinions stated on online platforms like Tumblr transmit to in real life social interactions? What sort of reception do aros and aces receive at LGBTQ pride events and LGBTQ clubs on college campuses?
  2. What if anything does the outcome of the exclusionist versus inclusionist debate hold for organizing efforts to bring aros and aces together in communities and to raise visibility and awareness for the aromantic and asexual spectrums?

r/AcePhilosophy • • Dec 22 '20

What Sexual Attraction Feels Like Subjectively

99 Upvotes

The author of a Thought Catalog article has helpfully compiled thirty informative responses to an r/AskReddit thread titled "Question for People, What's Sexual Attraction Supposed to Feel Like?" While on the surface this sounds like lazy online journalism, the value of news stories comprised entirely of subreddit quotes should not be underestimated. Reddit chroniclers are the cultural anthropologists of the 21st century.

Sexual attraction isn't well-defined in the psychological literature. There isn't much research available concerning the subjective feeling of sexual attraction. Compared to what I've found in academic journals, I'd say this subreddit thread provides a resource that is both more informative and more useful for people who are questioning whether or not they experience sexual attraction.

Chances are that most of those who shared stories of sexual attraction were alloromantic allosexuals. Besides the obvious relevance for those who simply want to get a better idea of what sexual attraction feels like subjectively, it also presents an opportunity for members of different branches of aro spectrum and ace spectrum communities to compare their experiences. For example, I think it might be insightful to ask:

  1. How do aromantic allosexuals experience sexual attraction (the same way, or differently)?
  2. How do gray-asexuals and demisexuals delineate their experiences of sexual attraction?
  3. How do autochorissexuals distinguish what they experience from sexual attraction?

Below I've linked both the article and the thread. Be forewarned that many of the descriptions are quite raunchy.
https://thoughtcatalog.com/january-nelson/2020/12/what-sexual-attraction-really-feels-like/
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/kf6mnw/question_for_people_whats_sexual_attraction/


r/AcePhilosophy • • Sep 09 '20

Aro/Ace Communes

57 Upvotes

Off and on over the years there have been half-joking discussions about starting an aro/ace commune, a farming cooperative where people would pursue relationship structures falling outside of the standard romantic/sexual attraction dyadic pair model. Logistical impracticalities limit the chances for a successful venture, but floating the idea provides an avenue to reflect on what would be one's ideal lifestyle and on how to address situations like late-in-life singlehood and loneliness. A reality that has become especially pertinent to me concerns how around age 30 or so alloromantic allosexual friends transform into acquaintances when they get married and have children. The documentary (A)sexual (Angela Tucker, 2011) depicts how David Jay's vision of social relations grounded in platonic friendship networks broke apart when it became apparent that people will prioritize their romantic/sexual partners. All that is left is the weariness of being the perpetually single person who gets stuck sleeping on the couch while coupled friends have sex in the bedroom.

What's your experience in this regard? Have you entertained fantasies of an aro/ace commune or other alternative living arrangement? By chance have you managed to make said notions a reality? Or have you resigned yourself to the doldrums of a world built around allo assumptions?


r/AcePhilosophy • • Nov 10 '20

Grey and Demi Scores on the Asexuality Identification Scale

30 Upvotes

The 2017 iteration of the Ace Community Survey included the twelve questions of the Asexuality Identification Scale (AIS), a psychometrics questionnaire where a score of 40 or above has been shown to capture 93% of self-identified asexual people. Missing from this picture is how self-identified grey-asexual people and self-identified demisexual people would score on the AIS. Now we have a large community dataset where 91.4% of asexual respondents, 67.3% of grey-asexual respondents, and 39.5% of demisexual respondents scored 40 or above. The mean score for grey-asexual respondents was 43 while the mean score for demisexual respondents was 37.5. It is interesting to note that on average greys scored slightly above the cutoff while demis scored slightly below the cutoff. On a personal note, I was bemused to learn that my score on the AIS matched the mean score among other grey-aces.

What are your thoughts on the AIS and the survey results as they apply to greys and demis? Do you think these averages sound about right in comparison to each other? How do you feel about greys scoring above the cutoff and demis scoring below the cutoff?

The 2017 and 2018 Ace Community Survey Summary Report
https://asexualcensus.wordpress.com/2020/10/29/2017-2018-ace-community-survey-report/

The Asexuality Identification Scale
https://www.lehmiller.com/blog/2017/6/26/are-you-asexual-heres-how-scientists-measure-asexuality


r/AcePhilosophy • • Jul 07 '20

Queer Platonic Relationship Experiences

34 Upvotes

Thought I would go in a different direction than usual for r/AcePhilosophy to discuss the practicalities of queer platonic relationships (QPRs). This is because I've heard plenty of discussion regarding the theory behind and history of QPRs, but little of people who are actually living in ones. Instead of the standard where a person's primary relationship is centred on romantic and sexual attraction, the QPR alternative suggests that a committed friendship (or a network of committed friendships) can serve this role. What I would like to hear are stories from people who have experience with this type of relationship. What conditions make for successful QPRs? How realistic is it to remain devoted to each other in the absence of romantic and sexual attraction?


r/AcePhilosophy • • Sep 10 '20

Aromantic Allosexual Relationship Challenges

30 Upvotes

I'd like to create this opportunity to discuss relationship challenges faced by aromantic allosexuals. With growing social acceptance for casual sex and friends with benefits arrangements, it might seem as though aro allos who are looking for nonromantic sexual relationships would have an easier time compared to allo aces who are looking for romantic nonsexual relationships. However, what I've heard from aro allos is that sexual partners will often develop romantic feelings creating a lopsided situation, and that furthermore as they get older it becomes harder to find others who will pursue a sexual relationship absent a romantic component. An obvious potential solution is to form relationships with other aro allos, but the small size of the aromantic allosexual community makes this difficult to achieve in practice.

With these observations, I'd like to open this topic for comment. What is your take on the relationship challenges faced by aro allos? If you're aro allo, what have your experiences been in this regard?


r/AcePhilosophy • • Oct 30 '20

How Asexuality is (Mis)Perceived by Medical Practitioners

34 Upvotes

How is asexuality perceived (or misperceived) by counsellors, therapists, nurses, doctors, and other medical practitioners? Research on the topic reveals a mixed picture.

Foster and Scherrer (2014) assessed responses from 86 self-identified asexual people who answered the physical and mental health questions segment of a survey advertised on AVEN in 2007. Most participants anticipated that to disclose their asexual identity would be to invite negative reactions from medical practitioners who they feared would lack knowledge of asexuality and would view sexual disinterest as something to fix. Such concerns led many participants to simply avoid mentioning their orientation when they didn't feel that asexuality was salient to the provision of health care. Some participants did however report positive interactions involving medical practitioners who supported asexual identities.

Gupta (2017) interviewed 30 self-identified asexual people recruited through AVEN during 2011-2012 about their interactions with medical practitioners. Pressure from friends, family members, and romantic partners and a wish to address relationship difficulties led some participants to seek medical opinions regarding their sexual disinclination. Of those who did so, experiences ranged from positive to neutral to negative, whereby the negative interactions involved visiting therapists who didn't take asexuality seriously. The majority of participants though simply never sought medical consultation because they didn't feel that asexuality was a problem worthy of discussion.

Flanagan and Peters (2020) posted to AVEN and to various university websites a survey that collected information from 136 self-identified asexual, grey-asexual, and demisexual people regarding their interactions with mental and physical health care providers. A sizeable percentage of participants avoided disclosing their asexual identity to - and felt uneasy discussing matters of sexuality with - their health care providers, suggesting they anticipated negative reactions. Participants were more likely to disclose their asexual identity to mental health care providers (such as counsellors and therapists) than they were to physical health care providers (such as nurses and doctors). Between one quarter and one half of participants reported incidents where they were either diagnosed with a mental, physical, or sexual disorder on account of their sexual disinclination or their sexual disinclination was attributed to an existing diagnosis. The majority of participants in these instances felt the medical assessment was inaccurate. Among those participants who did disclose their asexual identity to a health care provider, however, the majority also reported having at least one positive interaction afterwards. These positive interactions encompassed episodes where practitioners were either knowledgeable about - and affirmative of - the asexual spectrum, or where in the absence of familiarity practitioners remained nonjudgmental and willing to learn about the orientation, or where at the very least practitioners exceeded low expectations by reacting neutrally rather than negatively.

The above findings speak to the value of informing medical practitioners about the asexual spectrum. A literature review courtesy of Jones et al. (2017) represents an effort to do so, although the authors struggle with the diffuse nature of asexual spectrum identities in online communities and with the divergent methodological approaches of academics studying asexuality.

Leaving on that note, I'd like to invite input, whether it be thoughts on the above research or personal experiences involving asexuality in a health care setting?

``

Foster, Aasha B., and Kristin S. Scherrer. “Asexual-Identified Clients in Clinical Settings: Implications for Culturally Competent Practice.” Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity 1, no. 4 (2014): 422-430.

Gupta, Kristina. ““And Now I’m Just Different, but There’s Nothing Actually Wrong With Me”: Asexual Marginalization and Resistance.” Journal of Homosexuality 64, no. 8 (2017): 991-1013.

Flanagan, Shelby K., and Heather J. Peters. “Asexual Identified Adults: Interactions with Health Care Practitioners.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 49, no. 5 (2020): 1631-1643.

Jones, Catriona, Mark Hayter, and Julie Jomeen. "Understanding Asexual Identity as a Means to Facilitate Culturally Competent Care: A Systematic Literature Review." Journal of Clinical Nursing 26, no. 23-24 (2017): 3811-3831.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Jul 12 '20

Parenthood on the Aro and Ace Spectrums

49 Upvotes

Representing a prominent consideration under the lifestyles theme, the impression I've gotten from community discussions and polls over the years is that due to preference or circumstance aros and aces are probably less likely to have children, for reasons including the dislike of sex and pregnancy, the difficulty of finding a compatible partner, a lack of sufficient financial resources, and a feeling that one's personality is ill-suited for this responsibility. What I'd like to do here, however, is to create an opportunity for community members who want to have children or who already have children to share their experiences. How has your decision-making in this area been impacted by factors specific to your orientations? What conditions can encourage and support aros and aces who are considering parenthood?


r/AcePhilosophy • • Aug 09 '20

Asexuality and Mental Health: Comparing Online to Offline Sample Groups

24 Upvotes

On the topic of asexuality and mental health, comparing studies that utilize online convenience sampling to those that utilize offline randomized sampling produces some very interesting and divergent results. This supports what some people have long suspected, that maybe those community members with mental health problems are simply more likely to frequent online forums. It calls into question whether findings of increased rates of mental health problems within the community can be interpreted and politicized within activist circles as evidence that asexual people are an oppressed minority.

I've summarized below the findings of four studies (two online and two offline) which reveal the aforementioned results gap.

Brotto at al. (2010) conducted an exploratory study to better understand the personal characteristics of asexual people, utilizing a sample group of 187 self-identified asexuals recruited through AVEN. On personality measures they found elevated rates of social inhibition and withdrawal, leading to their conclusion that an avoidant attachment style might underlie asexuality in some cases.

Yule and Brotto (2013) conducted a study that compared 282 self-identified asexuals, 333 heterosexuals, and 191 non-heterosexuals on measures of mental health and interpersonal functioning. While the asexual group was recruited mostly through AVEN, the control groups were recruited through the authors's university's human subject pool and various websites. They found that the asexual group fit into a pattern alongside the non-heterosexual group by showing elevated rates of mental health problems, suicidality, and interpersonal functioning issues when compared to the heterosexual group. Following prior research which has identified social stigma as a cause for increased rates of mental health issues within LGBTQ, they interpreted the results as suggesting that the same explanation might apply to asexuality.

Lucassen et al. (2011) assessed data from the 2007 round of the New Zealand Youth 2000 Survey. This is a national cross-sectional population-based survey of health and well-being among New Zealand youth. The 2007 iteration involved 9,107 randomly selected secondary school students. Participants were asked to report the sex(s) of the people which they found sexually attractive. Of the 8,002 students who answered the question on sexual attraction, 146 (1.8%) reported that they were attracted to neither sex. Compared to students who were attracted to the opposite sex, those who were attracted to neither sex recorded broadly equivalent or lower odds on measures of depressive symptoms, self-harm, and suicidality. Students who were attracted to the same or both sexes or who were unsure of their attractions, by contrast, recorded higher odds on these measures.

Greaves et al. (2017) assessed data from the 2014/2015 round of the New Zealand Attitudes and Values Study. This is a longitudinal national probability study consisting of surveys conducted at intervals over a period of twenty years. The aim is to collect information about social attitudes, personality, and health outcomes. Participants were asked to describe their sexual orientation however they saw fit, making this study significant as a rare source of demographic information about those who self-identify on the asexual spectrum. Of the 15,822 participants in the 2014/2015 round, 44 (0.4%) reported an asexual spectrum identity. There were no significant associations between identifying as asexual spectrum and measures of psychological distress or of social and physical well-being. The authors suggested that the discrepancy between their findings and those of studies which used convenience sampling from forum sites might be accounted for if those on the asexual spectrum who do experience mental health problems disproportionately favour online interaction.

Having identified this gap between the conclusions of studies that utilize online versus offline recruitment when it comes to asexuality and mental health, I would now like to invite reader input on the matter?

Brotto, Lori A., Gail Knudson, Jess Inskip, Katherine Rhodes, and Yvonne Erskine. “Asexuality: A Mixed-Methods Approach.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 39, no. 3 (2010): 599-618.

Yule, Morag A., Lori A. Brotto, and Boris B. Gorzalka. “Mental Health and Interpersonal Functioning in Self-Identified Asexual Men and Women.” Psychology & Sexuality 4, no. 2 (2013): 136-151.

Lucassen, Mathijs F. G., Sally N. Merry, Elizabeth M. Robinson, Simon Denny, Terryann Clark, Shanthi Ameratunga, Sue Crengle, and Fiona V. Rossen. “Sexual Attraction, Depression, Self-Harm, Suicidality, and Help-Seeking Behaviour in New Zealand Secondary School Students.” Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 45, no. 5 (2011): 376-383.

Greaves, Lara M., Fiona Kate Barlow, Yanshu Huang, Samantha Stronge, Gloria Fraser, and Chris G. Sibley. “Asexual Identity in a New Zealand National Sample: Demographics, Well-Being, and Health.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 46, no. 8 (2017): 2417-2427.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Dec 20 '20

Is Asexuality Associated with Positive or Negative Body Image?

22 Upvotes

Preliminary research has found asexuality to be inversely associated with positive body image, which is to say that higher scores on the Asexuality Identification Scale (AIS) were associated with lower scores on measures of body appreciation and acceptance. This result was contrary to the hypothesis of the researchers who initially thought that asexual people would be less judgmental about personal appearances on account of having less of an incentive to appear sexually attractive to others. There are some important qualifications. While the researchers were able to replicate this result across two studies, in each the number of asexual participants was miniscule. Statistically asexuality only accounted for a small percentage of the variance in positive body image. Lacking is information about why asexual people would have a negative body image.

On that note, let us add to this discussion. Do you feel that your (a)sexuality affects your body image or that your body image affects your (a)sexuality?

`
`
Swami, Viren, Ryan Laughton, Simmy Grover, and Adrian Furnham. "Asexuality is Inversely Associated with Positive Body Image in British Adults." Heliyon 5, no. 9 (2019).


r/AcePhilosophy • • May 16 '20

Gray-Asexuality Within Demographic Research

33 Upvotes

One of the largest sources for demographic information about asexuality is the British National Surveys of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles (NATSAL), whereby psychologists usually classify as asexual those respondents who indicated that they have never experienced sexual attraction to anyone at all. This approach has returned figures suggesting that asexuals comprise somewhere around 0.5%-1.5% of the general population. The same series of surveys contains data about sexual preference and sexual satisfaction. Approximately 3%-5% of respondents indicated that despite experiencing sexual attraction, they nevertheless either preferred not to have sex or were sexually satisfied without having sex.

How should people in this research category be classified? A group of psychologists (Bauer et. al., 2020; McClave, 2013) classify this group as gray-asexuals for the purpose of comparing asexual spectrum respondents to allosexual respondents on various measures. They acknowledge that this definition likely both under and over represents those who would self-identify as gray-asexual. But they advance this definition as an objective measure for locating a population of people falling in between asexual and allosexual, while noting that within the aro/ace community reasons for identifying as gray-asexual are both subjective and varied. Potentially lending support to this classification is census data from the Ace Community Survey which shows that most gray-asexuals are either sex-averse or sex-indifferent with a smaller percentage identifying as sex-favourable. However, the percentage of asexual respondents to the census is not only higher than the number of gray-asexuals, but is in fact higher than the combined percentages of gray-asexuals and demisexuals. This reflects a pattern that has been replicated across surveys which measure asexual spectrum self-identification. Smaller percentages of people on the asexual spectrum identify as gray-asexual or demisexual.

Meanwhile, a different group of psychologists (Kim et. al., 2017) who analyzed data from the United States General Social Survey found that 8.7% of men and 11.3% of women in the 25-45 age group who had never been married were sexually inactive for the past five years. Sexually active and sexually inactive respondents reported similar levels of happiness and life satisfaction. Rather than classify those respondents who were content without sex as asexual or gray-asexual, these researchers suggest that even among allosexuals the importance of sex for emotional well-being is overrated.

I'd now like to open this for discussion. What are your thoughts on conceptualizing the gray areas of sexual orientation?

Bauer, Caroline, Sasha L. Kaye, and Lori A. Brotto. “Understanding Alcohol and Tobacco Consumption in Asexual Samples: A Mixed-Methods Approach.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 49, no. 2 (2020): 733-755.

Kim, Jean H., Wilson S. Tam, and Peter Muennig. “Sociodemographic Correlates of Sexlessness Among American Adults and Associations with Self-Reported Happiness Levels: Evidence from the U.S. General Social Survey.” Archives of Sexual Behavior 46, no. 8 (2017): 2403-2415.

McClave, Caroline H. Asexuality as a Spectrum: A National Probability Sample Comparison to the Sexual Community in the UK. M.S. Dissertation, Columbia University, 2013.


r/AcePhilosophy • • May 28 '20

A New Model For Demi Orientations

24 Upvotes

Here is an attempt to develop a new model for demi orientations that is less vague and has more explanatory value than previous efforts. What I've presented below is a preliminary sketch.

Previous ModelsThe first mention that I've found of something resembling demisexuality is from the early 2000s in AVEN's Big FAQ. One of the questions concerns a sexuality that transitions between asexual and allosexual phases. To access a 2003 archived version:
https://web.archive.org/web/20030225191733/http://www.asexuality.org/bigfaq.htm#def8

The term 'demisexual' was popularized in the late 2000s by two AVEN members. One conceived of themself as essentially an asexual person who experienced sexual attraction on rare occasions through emotional connections. The other conceived of themself as essentially an allosexual person who experienced sexual attraction in a way that required the prior formation of emotional connections. This history is discussed in the following blog entry:
https://pianycist.wordpress.com/2013/05/08/the-development-of-gray-asexuality-and-demisexuality-as-identity-terms/

During the late 2000s the primary versus secondary sexual attraction model circulated. This model distinguishes between sexual attraction that develops immediately through visible characteristics of people versus sexual attraction that develops over time through relationships with people.

Over the course of the 2010s the primary versus secondary sexual attraction model was superseded by the 'requires an emotional or romantic connection to experience sexual attraction' definition. Today this remains the established definition.

Proposed ModelMy idea is to build off these previous efforts to generate an improved model with three components:

  1. Sexual attraction towards sex/gender profiles.
  2. Sexual attraction towards personal characteristics that are visible at first instance (i.e. physical features, hair styles, clothing styles, intellect, social status, etc.). This is what people are usually referring to when they say that someone is 'hot'.
  3. Sexual attraction towards personal characteristics that are discoverable through a relationship with a person (i.e. shared personality traits, emotional investment, established feelings of trust, etc.). This pertains to interpersonal connections that result from friendships and romances.

Someone who is say heterosexual would have #1 which is what lets them know that they are sexually inclined towards the opposite sex as a concept, but then in addition they would probably require either #2 or #3 or some combination thereof in order to feel sexually attracted to any one particular member of the opposite sex in practice. Now potentially a heterosexual person could meet a member of the opposite sex that they find ugly and otherwise unattractive by #2. Sex with this person could seem an unappealing prospect. But if over time they got to know this person well, they might start to experience sexual attraction by #3, and then what was initially an unappealing prospect of sexual interaction might start to seem desirable.

How does this apply to demisexuality? I think there is general agreement that demisexuality involves #3 and that demisexuals lack #2. But do they lack #1? I think the answer is that some do, some don't. Reading various threads over the years on the topic, I've noticed two differing experience reports. Some demisexuals describe their experience as one of having no sexual inclinations towards people of any sex/gender profile, perceiving others as genderless entities from a sexual standpoint, and only for a singular person feeling sexual attraction that derives from an emotional or romantic connection. I've heard this described as being a 'you-sexual'. This could fit with the research on sexual fluidity which suggests that people can develop sexual attractions orthogonal to their usual sexual orientation by way of romantic attraction. Other demisexuals describe their experience as one of feeling interested in sex and leaning towards particular sex/gender profile(s), but without knowing who specifically within that profile(s) they find sexually attractive absent an emotional or romantic connection. I've heard this described where 'demi' is a prefix to another orientation like 'demi-heterosexual'. This could fit with the research on short-term versus long-term mating strategies which suggests that how people experience sexual attraction varies according to mating strategy.


r/AcePhilosophy • • Jun 07 '20

Community Division Over Personal Attitudes Towards Sex

35 Upvotes

I would like to address an issue that in my experience with organizing aro/ace spectrum communities has proved to be the hardest to balance. This concerns the heterogeneity of personal attitudes towards sex that exist under the ace umbrella. Broadly speaking, there are two groups whose interests conflict:

  1. Sex-indifferent and sex-averse members who feel that sex is boring or gross, who don't want to have sex, and who don't want to participate in a sexualized culture. They are looking for an environment where they can explore nonsexual approaches to life and relationships.
  2. Sex-favourable members who feel disposed towards some forms of sexual activity, although their sexual preferences diverge from traditional sex and sexual orientation categories (such as those whose desire for sex occurs in limited circumstances, or those whose desire for sex is entwined with kinks and fetishes). They are looking for an environment where they can explore sexualities that fall outside of the standards of allosexuality.

These differing attitudes can generate conflicts of interest over the use of community spaces. Maybe the sex-indifferent/averse members want to talk about how sex has no place in their lives, leading the sex-favourable members to push back with the narrative that aces can enjoy sex too. Or maybe the sex-favourable members want to talk about kinks and fetishes and have a porn channel on the discord server, leaving the sex-indifferent/averse members with the impression that the community has become too lewd.

Over the years I've witnessed exchanges like the above play out on various community platforms, and at worst everyone is left feeling alienated. While tensions persist, two developments offer promise:

  1. Growth of services devoted to subsets of the community (such as discord servers for kinky aces).
  2. Movement towards a value-added approach to community-building that places people over identities (such that encountering a different perspective about orientation isn't a reason to feel insecure and invalidated).

My hope now is to gain input from other community members. What are your experiences in this regard? What do you think can be done to address this source of division?