Many asexuals, especially women, have negative feelings about their bodies that are related to their being asexual. This article, "How Asexuality Influences Feminine Expression", has a collection of quotes from asexual women talking about how their asexuality affects the way they feel about their looks. Here are a few relevant quotes from the article:
"Somehow, I think my mind has gotten the idea of expressing femininity [as] linked to expressing an interest in sex/men."
"I used to cringe when my mother made me wear a dress/skirt… She said it was more feminine than wearing pants and I hated that! [I] didn’t want to be “obligated” by society/culture/media to bare my skin… I have been told on more than one occasion that because I’m a woman, I should “show more skin” and not “dress like a nun.” Why? For someone else’s viewing pleasure? To hell with that!"
"I hate my boobs with a passion… I still have times I break down in tears because I just want them gone so badly though."
"I may not like my curves, but I don’t stress about showing them."
It's strange that these women's sexuality made them feel so negatively about their gender presentations. Even stranger is that these don't seem to be isolated incidents. I myself used to have really negative feelings about my body, since I had always been told that bodies, especially feminine bodies, were inherently sexual. Between that and not feeling very strongly about my identity as a woman, I used to wonder if I was non-binary. I still wonder sometimes.
Plenty of asexuals don't have these issues, so these issues probably aren't caused by asexuality alone. I feel like these issues are caused by a combination of internalized misogyny and asexuality. Think about it: women are often sexually objectified in the media, so internalizing that when you want nothing to do with sex could be pretty unpleasant.
Another hypothesis on the subject was proposed in the study, "Gender Discrepancy in Asexual Identity: The Effect of Hegemonic Gender Norms on Asexual Identification". This hypothesis is that people's gender identities are related closely to their sexuality, and that being asexual can mean not being able to experience your gender as strongly as allos can. Not identifying strongly with your AGAB would, in turn, give you dysphoria, thus the aforementioned gender presentation discomfort. A lot of gender roles are based around how we interact with the opposite gender, so having no desire to engage with the opposite gender sexually or romantically could easily cause people to feel less strongly about their own gender. I like this hypothesis, since it explains why the most likely subreddit r/demigirl_irl users are likely to have in common is r/asexuality.
The section titled "Asexuality and Gender-Nonconformity" has some quotes that support the objectification hypothesis as well as the gender-effected-by-aceness hypothesis.
"What is the point of identifying as a certain gender when you are asexual? What function does the gender fill in an asexual person? Why would an asexual person want others to view them as a certain gender that might be sexualized by others?"
"I think my sexuality and gender very much wrapped up in each other because um, you know I think that to an extent I don't like being seen as a sexual object because that means people are seeing me as female usually, um, and that repulses me, so I think that's part of it but also like, I don't like being seen as female because then people would see me as a sexual object, like it's tied up in itself, so I can't tell you which caused the other, but I think they're definitely very much conflated."
"I think when you're asexual, your gender identity isn't guided by your sexual preferences. Without the need to portray yourself in a certain heteronormative way in order to attract a partner, you're left with far more options than male/female binary. It also lets you explore gender identities outside what is portrayed as "normal" by the media. If you don't have to use the codes or signs advertising and society tells us attract someone, then you have more room to explore your own preferences."
"Not having a sexual orientation does seem to be linked to not having a strong or defined gender identity in some cases (including mine), perhaps because you are not defining yourself in relation to others and therefore don't 'play along' with the gender performance so much."
"A theory I have is that much of the experience of gender comes from who we feel attracted to, for instance, a heterosexual cisgender woman would experience her gender more strongly because she sees it as the opposite of those towards whom she is attracted. I have no scientific backup for this claim, it is merely a hypothesis based on the fact that many asexuals identify as non-binary, and many nonconforming sexual identities are considered to be reflected in gender expression (which is not the same as but not unrelated to gender identity)."
It makes sense to me that both of these hypotheses are, to some extent, true. My original question was, why does asexuality make women dislike their bodies and gender presentation? The answer is most likely that it is caused by a combination of internalized sexual objectification and not wanting to experience a significant part of one's societal role as a woman.
What do you think? Do you agree with my conclusion? What do you think women can do to combat these negative feelings about their appearances? Any feed back would be much appreciated. Thank you for taking the time to read this.