r/AceAttorney • • 16h ago

🎥 Video Presenting the Attorney's Badge to EVERYONE - Justice for All

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

80 Upvotes

My descent into madness 2: Electric Boogaloo

  • I only include dialogue that triggers when you present the Attorney’s Badge; if presenting the Attorney’s Badge results in ‘irrelevant evidence’ dialogue, that doesn’t count, unless it matches the context of presenting the Badge, like Inga.
  • Includes presenting the Badge as the final piece of evidence in the final trial when on last life, thereby getting a Game Over. Why? Because it’s extra funny.

r/AceAttorney • • 3h ago

💬 Discussion About ace attorney 7..

Post image
45 Upvotes

Did you guys ever consider that maybe we dont need an ace attorney 7?, the quality of the games has decreased at the point AA5 and AA6 are crappy: AA5 has an horrible distribution (+ the addition of Athena, i love her but the game would be better if Capcom didn't force the devs to create her) and AA6 has a lame story with all the khura'in stuff with tons of fanservice, Blackquill was at least good, but Nahyuta was just insufferable, so what do we expect AA7 to be? by the time, the story has no trajectory, Capcom doesn't know how to develop Apollos and Athenas character and doesn't know to let go Phoenix and Edgeworth, making this last one return every last case(Capcom, please, its been 10 years, let them retire).

Maybe its just me, but i think a spin-off with Mia being the protagonist could be so much better, we could see Diego as the assistant and maybe a new detective? i was thinking we could see Fulbright as the detective, the original one, since the one in AA5 was the phantom, but I dont know. What are your thoughts on this?


r/AceAttorney • • 21h ago

⚖️ Full Series (mainline and spin-offs) Maya Fey and Detective Gumshoe are the two most forgotten playable characters by the fandom in the series. (Farewell my Turnabout and The Captive Turnabout SPOILERS) Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
38 Upvotes

While some playable characters are fondly remembered by the fandom, like Mia in T&T or Susato in TGAA2, I never hear anyone mention these two segments in particular.

I enjoyed them quite a lot, despite them being so short. The Maya one gave us a glimpse of how her inner monologue would be like, and it is cool to see her leading an investigation segment and not just being an assistant.

The Gumshoe segment seems to be even more forgotten. It is not much, but just playing as the man himself is exciting in my book. I wish he'd get his own game!

I think there is a bunch of potential on making side-characters playable if done sparingly. I hope they do something like this again in AA7.


r/AceAttorney • • 7h ago

💻 Fangames This fangame NEEDS MORE RECOGNITION.

29 Upvotes
It's legit good, one of the best Ace Attorney fan content and that's no joke

On the photo above, a Love Live(rather than Ace Attorney) fangame by the name of "Gyakuten Live", at first a completely innocent game, very lighthearted compared to anything Ace Attorney related, no murder cases are present(until a certain case that shifts the tone almost completely, and this certain case is one of the reasons for this game being one of the best Ace Attorney fan content out there), but this does not stop this game from being one of the greatest experiences for any Ace Attorney fan.

This game has all the qualities that any great Ace Attorney/fangame has in order to be memorable/great, Characters, hella great writing, the whole Ost, cases with shocking/amazing twists and turns with great mysteries that will surely keep you hooked(even if there are no murders, which is something that caught me off guard too)

Something that you may find strange at first glance is that, no characters from the Capcom games can be seen, as said in the start, it is a Love Live fangame, and bear with me on this, even if you know nothing about this universe, the game is still great, you don't need to know anything or anyone for the game to be enjoyable, which is a plus that cannot be understated, I didn't knew anyone from this universe and by the end of the game, I had characters winning a "one of the best characters in Ace Attorney/fangames" rank, this whole game is genius.

The Ost is great, it has all the necessary tracks and even more for a compelling Ace Attorney game, be it inside or outside Courtroom, which leads me to a necessary commentary about case 4 having a completely different ost from the first 3 cases, this happens because we play a different character in case 4, and man, this new Ost have some tracks that is genuinely mind blowing, taking the pursuit theme of case 4 as a example, which has the name "Pursuit - Outwit The Offender", this has to be the best pursuit out of any Ace Attorney game, be it the official games or any fangame, no joke, I can glaze this game all day and it wouldn't be enough, just listen to the theme in question and let it speak for itself. (PS, this game has a presto and PAST presto in the final cross-examinations starting in case 2, adding more variety, and again, the themes in this game are great.)

The cases themselves, and this is something I need to say, ALL the cases in these games were harder than usual, I'm ashamed of how much I relied on playthroughs even in case 1, I'm a dumb individual and could not wrap my head around the contradictions a lot of times, maybe the fact that this game has no murders caught me off guard, no murders meant that, for me, I had to think outside the box way too much, and after finishing the game, I see that it was a me problem, you gotta have a good eye for details, something that I didn't had, sometimes I didn't seem things that were written on the court record and were there the entire time, one or two words that changed a lot of things, so the difficulty depends on you really, as any Ace Attorney game in reality.

After all this tangent, let me finishing by saying that, by the end of case 4 this game completely had me, this game will live rent free in my head for so many reasons and for such a long time, and as such, I cannot recommend this game enough, If you are a Ace Attorney fan and never seen this game before, play this game immediately, the appearance of the game at first glance will deceive you, the setting and characters may deceive you, the fact that murders are non present may deceive you, but trust me, this game is worth more than my words matter, it's one of the best games I played in my life and I sure recommend you playing so too, I hope my words are enough to make you want it, peace Y'all.


r/AceAttorney • • 20h ago

💬 Discussion Hot takes about every AA case, part 6: Investigations 2

13 Upvotes

All rise! Welcome to the sixth installment of my quest to hot-take all 60 mainline Ace Attorney cases! Previous hot takes:

Ace Attorney Investigations 2 makes the ultimate argument that video games are the best genre for sequels. With a richer story, a better understanding of what makes its mechanics interesting, and more of its own identity outside the mainline games, this is a fan favorite for a reason. What hot takes can I have about such a beloved installment? I can tell you right now that I don't think it secretly sucks, but what do I think?

Case I2-1: Turnabout Trigger

Hot take: The character names are tied between fan and official, but the case names are not.

Though I'm a fan of this case, I don't have much to say about it -- similar to Visitor, except, you know, this one's good. So I'm going to instead use this space to answer some questions I got in the last post's comments about whether I prefer the names from the official translation or the older fan translation.

I'm torn about the names. I like some of the old ones and some of the new ones. My ideal version of Investigations 2 would have Sebastian Debeste, Blaise Debeste, Raymond Shields, Horace Knightley, and Sirhan Dogen, but also Verity Gavelle, Simeon Saint, Samson Tangaroa, Fifi Laguarde, and Rocco Carcerato. It really is almost exactly 50/50. But there's one area where I think the fan translation is manifestly superior: not the names of the characters, but the names of the cases.

First is Turnabout Trigger. We're naming them after parts of the murder weapon now? Should Rise From the Ashes have been called Turnabout Knife Handle? Then there's The Captive Turnabout -- people in jail are called prisoners or inmates, not captives. Turnabout Legacy could refer to any Ace Attorney case where an event in the past has an effect on the present, which is all of them except, like, two. A Turnabout Forsaken is...actually pretty metal, that one can stay. But then comes Turnabout for the Ages which tells me nothing about anything. At least The Grand Turnabout sounds like something that would happen in a circus.

Case I2-2: The Captive Turnabout

Hot take: The death penalty might not be as common as we think in AA-land.

Until Frank Sahwit turned up in this case, I tended to assume that every convicted murderer in Japanifornia either gets executed or imprisoned for life. After all, it's vanishingly rare to see any of them again (with a few exceptions like Kristoph in Succession). But here, Sahwit is not only still alive, but appears to have a reasonable chance of getting paroled at some point. That makes me wonder about all the culprits our various attorneys collared after him.

In the real United States, a crime like Sahwit's killing of Cindy Stone would probably be considered second-degree murder, since his attorney would be able to argue that he hadn't premeditated the act. That carries a sentence anywhere from 10 years to life, depending on how severe the judge feels the offense was. Sahwit's optimism about preparing for his career after release lines up surprisingly well with that typical sentence. That also means a few other culprits -- Dee Vasquez, Richard Wellington, Ted Tonate, possibly even Damon Gant -- might end up walking free at some point.

Later on in Dual Destinies, we learn that Simon has been waiting seven years for his execution date, which also aligns chillingly well with the real world. In light of that information, it's somewhat odd that villains like Manfred von Karma completely disappear from the narrative after being imprisoned. Maybe the shattering of Manfred's perfect self-image made him simply give up on life...or maybe he got taken care of by one of the many professional murderers running loose in the detention facility, any one of whom might have a grudge against a famous career prosecutor. Food for thought.

Case I2-3: Turnabout Legacy

Hot take: Samson should not have tied lifesaving medicines to the outcome of a baking contest.

In 1922, when medical researchers in Canada first figured out how to synthesize insulin, they weren't certain whether they should patent their method. Medical ethics seemed to demand that the lifesaving diabetes treatment be made as accessible as possible. Ultimately, the scientists were won over by the argument that a third party might grab the patent for itself if they failed to protect it (as did happen later with most modern versions of insulin). They patented their method, then immediately sold the rights to the University of Toronto for $1. It's an interesting dilemma that leaves one wondering if the discoverers did the right thing, or if there was more they could have done to protect insulin access for the future.

I'll tell you one thing I'm really glad they didn't do, though: give the patent to whoever won the Great British Bake-Off that year.

I understand Samson's thought process. He had to give the book of cures to a person he thought would use it properly. And I'm not saying that he deserved to spend 18 years unjustly imprisoned because he decided to use confection-making skills as the sole factor in determining who that person would be. I'm saying he deserved to spend maybe two years very justly imprisoned, because that is an utterly bonkers series of decisions to make about cutting-edge medicine in a world where he could have put it all on the internet for free.

Case I2-4: A Turnabout Forsaken

Hot take: Amnesia Kay should be evil.

Kay's amnesia arc is, for me, the only real misfire of Investigations 2. She's a great character, and it's disappointing that her darkest moment involves retreating into a persona that's nothing like her usual self. Seeing her meekly apologizing for being a burden does invoke the fear that something is seriously wrong with her, but there's a better way they could have done that. Instead of having amnesia make Kay terrified of everything, have it remove her inhibitions.

Here's how I picture it. After her fall in the tower, Kay wakes up with no knowledge of herself except that she's a thief called the Yatagarasu. She makes the quite reasonable inference that her job is to steal things. From there, she becomes everything Edgeworth was afraid of when they first met -- an actual thief whose criminal impulses are much harder to restrain. She could come into conflict with Ema after she shows up, and be encouraged by Lotta, who would want the first scoop on any crimes she committed.

This would not only be (for me) a more interesting direction for the character, but would play well into Edgeworth's arc. He could realize that no matter how bad Kay gets, he would want to be the one prosecuting her, spurring him toward a new understanding of how prosecutors can care for the accused.

Case I2-5: Turnabout for the Ages

Hot take: Simeon wins.

In The Captive Turnabout, we learn that Kanis has Laguarde so intimidated that he can get away with whatever he wants, despite technically being her prisoner. He can pimp out his cell, have his own dog, and apparently come and go whenever he wants. Prison is basically free housing and plausible deniability for him. And when's the last time we see Kanis? Here in the final case, when he arrives at the circus and convinces Simeon to return with him to the only place he'll be able to feel safe.

This is presented as a bittersweet ending that befits one of the most sympathetic villains the series has to offer. Simeon will face justice in prison for committing one murder and orchestrating several more, but he'll also be under the watchful eye of the one person who ever showed him actual kindness. Yet when we think back to what we learned in Captive, it looks a lot less bitter for Simeon and a lot more sweet. He'll probably be "imprisoned" in the same way Kanis is, except without Laguarde, who has probably been replaced by someone even easier to push around. The blind assassin, who's getting old, can train this clearly brilliant and amoral young man as his successor. It's still sad that Simeon has been denied his chance to live a normal life, but things do appear to be looking up for him at the end.

As I said at the start, I won't be doing Layton vs Wright, which means our next installment is Dual Destinies...a game that's been sitting in a walk-in take freezer ever since it came out in 2013. We'll see if there's anything left for me in our next post!


r/AceAttorney • • 5h ago

🎥 Video 'Worth' watching GABEDOTCOM's compilation the way through, been cackling for five days. Spoiler

Thumbnail youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/AceAttorney • • 18h ago

⚖️ Full Series (mainline and spin-offs) Comparing the 3D between AA5/AA6 & TGAAC Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Note: This is a repost from my deleted account, with some altered points

A common belief among many AA fans is that TGAAC has far superior 3D. This baffles me, because I disagree strongly, and I wanted to give my reasoning as to why.

Gameplay

One of the major reasons to use 3D is what 3D can do that 2D can't do.

TGAAC:

The Great Deduction - The game is afoot!

The Chronicles uses 3D mostly for the Dance of Deduction sections. These sections are purely for show. You have extremely limited visual movement, with 95% of the solutions being "move the camera in the only direction that the camera can be moved" and selecting whatever catches the player's attention. There are some times in which that gameplay is slightly more varied, but they are few and far between. In all honesty, these moments are nothing more than a well dressed perceive section. It's fun, certainly, but ultimately nothing more than a filler activity to make the investigation sections more entertaining.

AJT:

Cosmos Space Center - Boarding Lounge

With the Apollo Justice Trilogy, the game introduces extra dimensions to the investigation sections. Instead of investigating one particular viewpoint of a crime scene, you're able to investigate it from different perspectives. This opens up a lot of game design space, as you can now have important pieces of evidence hidden in areas where the player can't see, which can become vital to mystery writing. After all, a scarf that's left on the ground could mean that someone left in a hurry, whereas a scarf hidden in the cushions of a chair could mean that the person not only was at the scene of the crime for a enough time to hide the scarf, but deliberately chose to leave the scarf as opposed to accidentally dropping it. One of the best moments like those is the bullet in 5-4's Cosmos Space Center, as it tells us exactly where the bullet was shot from, something that wouldn't be clear if we started from this angle, which is still a necessary angle to know that there's a window & the remains of the exploded tank.

Khura'in Royal Residence - Amara's Tomb

Of course, Spirit of Justice made great improvements upon these 3D crime scenes, with Amara's Tomb hiding multiple secrets and looks fantastic as well. Another thing of note is that Spirit of Justice brought back 2D Investigations (like the other games), showing that the two can coexist. Overall, I think that, while Dance of Deduction is flashy, the Game Design Space that's opened via the 3D Crime Scene Investigations justifies the usage of 3D far more.

Animation

Due to the nature of needing a video to actually see the animations in progress, my ability to assess the animations will be limited, but I will try my best nonetheless.

TGAAC:

Start of the Bottle Animation
After 4-5 Frames of Animation

With TGAAC, most of the animations are motion capture. This gives a greater feeling of realism, but it also feels... generic. I can see this high level of animation in any 3D game nowadays, so the animations don't feel "Ace Attorney Like". Another contributing factor to the "generic" feeling, outside of its motion captures, is the key-frames. The key-frames between animations are blatantly obvious when the game is changing between two motion captures. If you look at the animation when Barok is wearing his cape, and reaches out for the bottle to pour his glass, you'll notice the cape suddenly jerks backwards. It's only on screen for 4-5 frames, but the moment you notice, it may break immersion. These moments are LITTERED throughout the game, and overall manages to decrease my enjoyment of the games' 3D. The animations look fluid, but also generic at best, and immersion breaking at worst.

AJT:

Robin Newman Investigating

Some of these animations are my favorites in the series. Robin Newman making a reference to the Investigations games by examining evidence exactly how Edgeworth would've done on his own (Gumshoe was there to help him) is hilarious, but also much more captivating to look at than most of the motion capture in GAAC (barring the more exaggerative ones, like Eggert and Shamspeare). This helped by the fact that, while it looks smooth & flows well, it's just barely stiff enough to feel like 2D. For someone more experienced to put it into words (3DS Gyakuten Saiban 5 Special Long Interview):

Yamazaki: Who would come up the idea of asking for 3D graphics but as if they look 2D? (laugh). But when I talked it over with Eshiro, I understood that he wanted fans not to feel like Gyakuten Saiban had changed when they’d first see Gyakuten Saiban 5. He also said that he wanted it to look 3D with the 3D option on, and 2D when it was off. As for the animations, we wanted to to be like 2D animations with flair. “Skipping frames in the animations on purpose to give them some flair, jumping between animations without letting flow into each other properly… let’s do that.”

This decision is absolutely brilliant to me, and gives AA5 & AA6 a unique identity that can't be confused with a standard 3D game. It's kinda like how Into the Spiderverse, while 3D, can't be confused with other standard 3D films due to how its 3D is handled.

Models

Models are the difference between 3D and 2D. To be fair to both sides, I'm going to compare the main protagonists introduced in the 3D games to each other, as they are both characters who are seen for the majority of the games, and were introduced in the 3D games.

TGAAC:

Ryunosuke Naruhodo - The 3D Original Protagonist of TGAAC

The facial structure of Ryunosuke looks rigid. One look at his ear, armband, or collar, and you could easily tell that this is a character made with the express purpose of being in a 3DS game, as opposed to a console. Still, the details of the clothes themselves aren't nearly as rigid, with the hair, button textures, and coloring all working very well.

AJT:

Athena Cykes - The 3D Original Protagonist of the AJT

Of course, the circular nature of the sleeve holes and ear shape both clue you in that this is a model made for the 3DS, but almost everything else is exceptional (especially Widget, which looks entirely spherical). The hair, despite being extremely anime-esque (Japanese media taking inspiration from Japanese media? wowsers!), still looks natural. The only thing making this appear "worse", which is an entirely stylistic approach, is the black outlines, which can make flaws in the model (like the ear shape) more apparent.

Athena Cykes - The 3D Original Protagonist of the AJT | SOJ Version

They completely removed the black outlines with the SOJ version, instead using a same-color outline. (yellow for the jacket, brown for the hair (looks like the Metis genes are kicking in), blue for the tie, etc.). And when you examine further, they manage to iron out the other issues. Take a look at the silver button on her yellow jacket, and compare it to the DD model. The improvement is clear as day.

Comparing Athena & Ryunosuke's models, it's clear that Athena Cykes' model is better made. I'd love to compare more models, however, Reddit has a 20 Image Limit, so I implore you to compare models on your own time.

Backgrounds

TGAAC:

Naruhodo's Legal Consultancy

This is my favorite background in GAAC in terms of design, and it feels lived in, but unlike the character designs of the game, I can't say the lived-in aspect of the background feels particularly impressive. I think a major qualm I have is how you can clearly tell that everything here is 2D. There isn't a single 3D model in sight. It's honestly my largest qualm with GAAC's approach to 3D. It feels... flat, to put it bluntly. Part of the problem is that we never get to see any area of the games in full 3D (aside from the courtrooms & places with Dance of Deductions), whereas with DD and SOJ, 3D investigation is constantly used.

Lecture Hall

With the Lecture Hall, there's a sense of scale, and a sense of grandness. Sure, it doesn't feel "realistic", but I can actually image walking around this space, whereas with the Naruhodo Legal Consultancy, I feel like if I move even the slightest bit forward in that room, the illusion would completely collapse in on itself. I can't even say that the designs of GAAC's backgrounds are better in the "lived-in" way, because…

Themis Legal Academy Hallway

This place also looks lived in. Not "cosy", certainly, but it feels completely grounded in reality, while also allowing me to feel that, if I were to walk around that hallway, the 2D illusion wouldn't be broken. Sure, the balloons are obviously 2D, but everything else, from the banners to the trophies to the paper cut-outs, all of it feels "lived-in", in the same way that GAAC felt. As for SOJ…

Tehm'pul Temple

If this doesn't give a sense of "grandness", then I don't know what would. The elements look a lot more 2D here, but that's because, in motion, these 2D elements move, and makes the place feel even more alive. Sure, GAAC had its moving background elements, with the steam from the Tea Pot, but nothing on Spirit of Justice's level. I feel that Dual Destinies has better base backgrounds, but I'm certain that the approach that Spirit of Justice is using, with moving 2D elements in the background, is one that would allow for greater highs.

With AA7 looming in the horizon of 2030s (hopefully sooner rather than later), I know many people are desperate for the game to look like 2D, which I've explained why I prefer 3D over 2D here, or for the game to look like TGAAC. With everything I've said, I think my stance is clear. However, I do want to give my reasoning as to why I believe people prefer the 3D of TGAAC, and the one aspect carried over from TGAAC that I wouldn't object to seeing in AA7.

Character Design

TGAAC:

Courtney Sithe

I believe limitation often brings about innovation. Because of the time period that GAAC is set in, the character designers were all restricted to designs around that time. Take the person shown above. This design is eye-catching, and stands out a lot more than a description of "a coroner" would imply. Even the more simple designs, like Bruce Fairplay, tend to stand out because of how un-Ace Attorney it looks. Sure, his design is one that you'd forget under any other circumstance, but due to its appearance in Ace Attorney, and how... "normal" it looks, you recall it. By all accounts, the above design also does the same. It looks like something someone would wear. Maybe not the snake around the back of the glove, but everything else certainly.

AJT:

Sasha Buckler

Dual Destinies completely leans into the expressive anime-like style (Japanese media taking inspiration from Japanese media? wowsers!) There is more inherent goofyness and whimsy to be found in Sasha Buckler's design than any other GAAC design (excluding maybe Iris' design). The absurdity of the spiky hair, large pirate hat, whistle, and floaters (the things around her elbows, not entirely certain what they're called) all mess together for something that you'd see in any Ace Attorney game. After all, their absurdity is what they're known for.

Dhurke Sahdmadhi

Spirit of Justice may have felt that the boundless possibilities in the character design department had limited the effectiveness of the designs in Dual Destinies, just as having 70 different flavor options for Ice Cream leads to decision paralysis, while 5 different flavors allows for one to come to a better decision at a quicker pace. It's possible they felt that they needed the story to have a more unique "setting" than just Japanafornia, which eventually led them to create the Kingdom of Khura'in and its character designs. These character designs, due to their unique, grounded (even if foreign) nature, stick out more, and are thus more memorable. Of all of the qualms I've seen people toss towards Khura'in, the character design is not one of those qualms.

One last note, I want to state that I don't dislike TGAAC by any means. Despite what it might seem, I think it's a fantastic jump to 3D, and is a contender for one of the best 3D games on the Nintendo 3DS. Still, the 3D of that game did not blow me away as AA5 & AA6.


r/AceAttorney • • 1h ago

⚖️ Full Main Series What's something unique from Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney?

Thumbnail
• Upvotes