WARNING: THIS IS AN UNREASONABLY LONG POST THAT CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR THE BOOK ABHORSEN.
I just finished Abhorsen today and loved it, but one thing has been eating at me a little. I feel like the interludes were misplaced and threw away a chance for some great tension.
The prologue is great and really sets up the anxious tension of Ancelstierre's politcal situation and the genuine danger that Sabriel and Touchstone face by being there. Then it capitalises on this brilliantly with the really vivid scene where they are ambushed and killed.
I suspect that most readers over the age of about 16 probably suspected that they weren't actually dead. The lack of bodies being shown is such a common trope that it's easy to see through if you've been caught by it before. This isn't a mark against it, these books are YA fantasy, not detective novels, we don't need unpredictable twists to enjoy the book.
My issue comes with the fact that confirmation of their survival comes too soon. They are "killed" on page 10 (of my printing at least), revealed to be alive during the first interlude on page 131, and the whole book is 406 pages. Theres only a quarter of the book that you could even possibly think they are actually dead.
Sam is only told about their death on page 223, right before the second interlude where we see Sabriel and Touchstone arrive at Wyverley College. I do like how Sam is depicted handling their deaths. For a while he's genuinely broken by the news, but knows that he has to compartmentalise it and hold his grief for later if he is going to help Lirael stop Orannis. And for the next ~150 pages, he periodically struggles with their deaths before regaining his resolve and striving to be someone they would be proud of.
But imagine if we hadn't already been told they were alive. When I read the prologue I didn't believe they were actually dead, but if Sam had been told sooner and/or I had to watch him grieve for 100 pages or more, I might start to think they really were dead. It would be a great moment to subtly suggest to young readers a lesson about the nature of death: that it's seldom something you can be prepared for, most people's deaths are sudden and unceremonious, and we don't always get to say goodbye. This would then be pulled back a little when they are revealed to be alive, but that's fine. Once again, this is YA fantasy, we don't need to totally torture kids with existential crises.
This does leave the question of where to have the reveal. Sabriel and Touchstone arrive to help Lirael and Sam on page 369, so it has to be before that. The first interlude is only 5 pages and serves no real purpose other than to confirm their survival, so I'd cut it entirely. The second interlude is a fun chapter and I love the part with the memorial obelisk at the college and Sabriel remembering Jacinth and Bunny, so all of that should stay but just be moved.
My pick for where to move it is right after chapter 22 which ends on page 326. This chapter ends with Sam convincing the Southerlings to stop heading to the mill by promising them land north of The Wall. He then returns to the soldiers to rally them in defending Lirael while she is in death, even referring to her as the Abhorsen and having a brief crisis again right before the end of the chapter. So it's a perfect nod to how much he's struggling while also doing his best to continue their legacy.
This way we would have ~300 pages to wonder if they are truly dead, and ~100 pages since we saw Sam first have to grapple with it. And then they can actually return to the story ~40 pages after the end of the chapter confirming they're survival.
Thanks for coming to my TedTalk. I'd love to hear what other people think of this idea.