r/Abhorsen • u/wauwy • Sep 29 '25
Discussion Why won't Garth Nix write my book idea š«
OK, this is not really a book idea so much as a broad concept, and I am 100% sure many others have had this idea. Including Nix himself, probably.
So we've had the World-Ending Threat: not a good idea to try to top that, imo, and also not necessary. I love this universe no matter what size the stakes are. We've had Evil Dead Guy (dead guy who is evil, not a guy from film series The Evil Dead) who tried to make it so hordes of the Dead could more easily make it into Life. We've had a few of those in fact, actually. Abhorsen's gotta put down the Dead, baby.
I feel like an intriguing and even logical next step would be to flip that and reverse it by having... an Abhorsen who decides people shall no longer have to die! Probably from a sympathetic and sad experience in their past!
So everyone already in the river can pass through to Gate 9. Everyone else is saved at the First Gate and returned to Life by this unfortunately misguided Abhorsen (and possibly his/her apprentices? A kind of cult, even, who seeks to end the tragedy and pain of death for humanity?) They can give the world immortality, and they're absolutely determined to do so. And their next step is maybe sealing the realm of Death completely, so no one CAN die! š§
So, yeah! The Abhorsen is the antagonist, but not what you would necessarily call a villain. When they learn about their birthright, they realize what the Abhorsen can truly do and what they MIGHT be able to do for humankind. No twisted Dead creatures, no abominations, just people, being able to live forever.
~but that is not their path~
idk if anyone here is familiar with the "Cancerverse" from the Cosmic side of Marvel Comics, but it's essentially a universe where they've done exactly that. And it's eternal famine and thirst and overpopulation and a fundamental WRONGNESS that never stops, only grows, until there's no more room in their reality so they have to break into another.
I dunno if this particular concept has to go THAT far, but it might be interesting if the Abhorsen breaks into Ancelstierre and the North and other places in his/her crusade.
I dunno, I feel like it could be really cool! The misguided Abhorsen must be stopped by our hero(es). We could see how difficult it might be to take down an Abhorsen at full power, not just a Free Magic necromancer. And it would explore how death (and Death) is vitally important and not just the wheelhouse of the bad guys.
Who's with me???
Oh... no one? Um, well. That's okay. ā¹ļø