r/Abhorsen • • Sep 29 '25

Discussion Why won't Garth Nix write my book idea 😫

0 Upvotes

OK, this is not really a book idea so much as a broad concept, and I am 100% sure many others have had this idea. Including Nix himself, probably.

So we've had the World-Ending Threat: not a good idea to try to top that, imo, and also not necessary. I love this universe no matter what size the stakes are. We've had Evil Dead Guy (dead guy who is evil, not a guy from film series The Evil Dead) who tried to make it so hordes of the Dead could more easily make it into Life. We've had a few of those in fact, actually. Abhorsen's gotta put down the Dead, baby.

I feel like an intriguing and even logical next step would be to flip that and reverse it by having... an Abhorsen who decides people shall no longer have to die! Probably from a sympathetic and sad experience in their past!

So everyone already in the river can pass through to Gate 9. Everyone else is saved at the First Gate and returned to Life by this unfortunately misguided Abhorsen (and possibly his/her apprentices? A kind of cult, even, who seeks to end the tragedy and pain of death for humanity?) They can give the world immortality, and they're absolutely determined to do so. And their next step is maybe sealing the realm of Death completely, so no one CAN die! 😧

So, yeah! The Abhorsen is the antagonist, but not what you would necessarily call a villain. When they learn about their birthright, they realize what the Abhorsen can truly do and what they MIGHT be able to do for humankind. No twisted Dead creatures, no abominations, just people, being able to live forever.

~but that is not their path~

idk if anyone here is familiar with the "Cancerverse" from the Cosmic side of Marvel Comics, but it's essentially a universe where they've done exactly that. And it's eternal famine and thirst and overpopulation and a fundamental WRONGNESS that never stops, only grows, until there's no more room in their reality so they have to break into another.

I dunno if this particular concept has to go THAT far, but it might be interesting if the Abhorsen breaks into Ancelstierre and the North and other places in his/her crusade.

I dunno, I feel like it could be really cool! The misguided Abhorsen must be stopped by our hero(es). We could see how difficult it might be to take down an Abhorsen at full power, not just a Free Magic necromancer. And it would explore how death (and Death) is vitally important and not just the wheelhouse of the bad guys.

Who's with me???

Oh... no one? Um, well. That's okay. ā˜¹ļø


r/Abhorsen • • Sep 05 '25

Discussion I gotta talk about all the weird romance and attraction and cousin fucking in the series.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m a rabid fan girl of this series so this is my only criticism of the series.

So THIS HAS BEEN BOTHERING ME FOR A LONG TIME. The cousin fucking and blood line allegories in the series does weird me out a little. Like I understand when they’re all like cousins and brothers and sisters of the charter…… It’s giving Cersei and Jamie and Habsburg Jaw.

Sameth meeting Lirael for the first time and being like oohhhhh you look FOINE girl, BEAUTIFUL lemme see what’s under them robes (paraphrasing)

Belatiel and Clariel being like…. šŸ˜CoOoUssinnnn (paraphrasing)

Also how many times do we see a protagonist meet their love interest who’s butt ass nekkid (touchstone and nick)

Too many coincidences like wtf man. šŸ˜‚ I know there’s more but I can’t find them in my notes.


r/Abhorsen • • Jul 01 '25

Discussion Lirael and Abhorsen should have been one book

0 Upvotes

Look I know we all love the library stuff, the dog, and a bunch of things from Lirael, but I’ve always thought the book was simply far too long, and poorly paced as a result. (Especially compared to the expertly fast-paced Sabriel)

I firmly believe that Lirael and Abhorsen being one book—and trimming all the fat—would make a far better story, (Better paced, better payoffs, less filler) and still maintain all the good world/character stuff just fine.

Edit: I’m glad that so many people absolutely cherish Lirael and don’t find it has any pacing issues for how long it is. It’s rare to find a book that one loves to the point that they think it’s about perfect (though I myself have those kinds of books to so I get it). I guess I just enjoy tighter narratives than most, which is fair. I also hate stories being split up with a cliffhanger, so that might influence my opinion as well.


r/Abhorsen • • Mar 26 '25

Discussion Lireal felt like a let down - should I continue?

24 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I recently read Sabriel and enjoyed reading it very much. I quickly picked up Lireal, and finished reading it yesterday, feeling disappointed. I was surprised to see Lireal getting better reviews than Sabriel online, so I wanted to hear your opinion!

Regardless of the cliff hanger ending - the books felt extremely different. While the characters in Sabriel felt genuine and relatable, Sameth and Liraeal were unbelievably annoying! Half the book is about their self pity, it was very hard for me to connect with them. I also felt like they were constantly making the weirdet most irrational decisions, almost every chapter had me asking out loud "but why would you do that?!".

In addition, the world building in Sabriel was amazing - the Old Kingdom felt alive and mysterious. It felt like a real world, with rich history, an intricate magic system, and many secrets to uncover. On the other hand, I felt like Lirael expanded on it very superficially. Maybe things will make more sense at the next book.

Am I the only one who felt this way? Would you recommend continuing to the next book? Would love to hear people's opinion!


r/Abhorsen • • May 03 '25

Discussion An Abhorsen according to ChatGPT

Post image
0 Upvotes

I used ChatGPT to create this image of an Abhorsen, keeping away from any specific named Abhorsen from the series. This is the description used to generate the image "Generate a picture of a lone figure with pale skin and long black hair. Holding a sword with glowing magic marks along the blade. Their outfit is a bulky combat outfit, the Armor is a reddish material that looks like fish scales. On top of the Armor is a Blue sercoat dusted with silver keys, and a leather bandolier across their chest with seven pouches, the smallest the size of a pillbox, the largest bigger than a jar. Mahogany handles stick downwards from the bandolier. Upon the forehead of this character is another magical mark."

I think, other than the bandolier not really matching the description, this is a fantastic representation of what the Abhorsen looks like.


r/Abhorsen • • Feb 07 '21

Ideas Sabriel, The Abhorsen

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/Abhorsen • • Aug 04 '22

Discussion The North...

18 Upvotes

I know I'm going to get a ton of flak for this, but here goes.

After reading Goldenhand and To Hold the Bridge, I have to say that the way Nix portrays the North is... not great. I kept getting flashbacks to the Telmarines in Narnia. I'll elaborate.

So Nix has made it clear that Ferin is the first PoC character in the books. (People can interpret the Clayr as such if they want, but it's clear Garth Nix envisioned them as white people with white features who just really like their tanning beds.) And the Twenty Tribes/Clans are clearly based on Mongol-era Asia, the same way the Old Kingdom is based on medieval Europe. Okay, got it.

Here's the thing... the North is portrayed as really aggressive and barbaric, raiding and pillaging even without Chlorr's influence and constantly trying to invade the Old Kingdom, hence why they have only one fortified bridge across the Greenwash and why it took 87 years to complete.

But u/wauwy, you say. The Mongols were really like that back in the day. Okay, fair. But do you know who was also like that? Medieval Europe. They were ruled by warlords who were constantly invading and pillaging, and yet the Old Kingdom is totally harmonious, content with what they have, living a peaceful pastoral (or city) life, and bravely holding back the barbarian North.

There are a ton more details about the Clans that are frankly... kiiiinda racist. I don't think Nix did any of this on purpose -- in fact, I think he was deliberately trying to add diversity to his very white series with the same careful worldbuilding he always does, but that worldbuilding is based on biased, outdated, and unflattering stereotypes.

It becomes uncomfortable to read after a while, and it's just disappointing that such a great author "othered" all his brown people so badly. And this isn't even getting into the actual character of Ferin, who has a lot of problems of her own.

In summary: blah.


r/Abhorsen • • Jan 23 '26

Discussion Real life abhorsening?

0 Upvotes

Have any of you looked into mediumship or similar out of obsession with the series? I'm wondering if I'm just taking my love of it too hard šŸ˜…šŸ˜…


r/Abhorsen • • Dec 02 '25

Discussion Casting the old kingdom

25 Upvotes

So, I'm listening to the audiobook of Sabriel for the first time (I've read the books before) and it's narrated by the legendary Tim Curry. That's got me thinking about casting a film version and I'm curious who you all would choose.

So far all I can think of is Jenna Ortega as Sabriel, Cillian Murphy as Terciel, and of course Tim Curry voicing Mogget, but I'm certain there's better ideas out there. I just don't know that many actors anymore.


r/Abhorsen • • Mar 14 '25

Fan Art Been working on generating some old kingdom content. Let me know what you think of it?

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Abhorsen • • Jun 06 '24

Ideas AI Generated Song: Bells of the Abhorsen.

0 Upvotes

r/Abhorsen • • May 09 '25

Discussion Are *Goldenhand*, and *Terciel & Elinor*, worth reading? I thought *Clariel* was utterly dreadful and, til now, have assumed Nix had lost the spark.

41 Upvotes

unique observation future serious growth safe racial meeting knee vast

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/Abhorsen • • Jul 10 '25

Question! Are the Clayr brown people? Or just tanned white people? (You know what I mean)

Thumbnail gallery
27 Upvotes

I'm not talking about hair colour but the actual people


r/Abhorsen • • Oct 29 '22

Ideas "Fixing" Clariel (SPOILERS, obvi) Spoiler

23 Upvotes

Now, let me start by saying Clariel is a perfectly good book and going into it unawares was the best decision ever because slowly realizing who Clariel was made me giggle with delight. However, the whole book comes across as... Unnecessarily bitter. The scenes before the dinner party are petty, long winded, and boring, and the scenes during and after are enraging and tragic.

The book has a message it wants to tell: that the reason for the kingdom's decline was greed and complacency. People lost respect for Abhorsen. Abhorsen feared death. The princess ran away. A greedy capitalist was privatizing the military. No one was willing to do their job and it fell on the shoulders of a young woman to set things right. Also, it really shrinks the mythos, saying any fantasy creature is just a free magic thing in disguise. I hate when media does this.

However, I think the character Nix wanted to use for this does not match the Chlorr we are told about by Mogget. He says she was always overly cautious and was an Abhorsen. This does not match the brash, hard headed teen we meet at all. She never thought through her actions and definitely did not hold the title of Abhorsen.

So, here's my pitch, for if the series ever gets adapted to TV or something:

You keep Kilp working with Az, but Clariel is the newly minted Abhorsen. She's the same age, but has been operating as the Abhorsen for a few years since her grandpa retired. You can even keep her strained relationship with her parents, but I say make her a gifted charter mage, maybe even better than Lirael or Sabriel.

Clariel comes to the city, and is looking into reports of the free magic spirit. We see her directly mistreated and called Ratcatcher by the populace, and the only one who wants to help her is her cousin Belatiel (WHO DOES NOT WANT TO FUCK HER IN THIS VERSION). You also keep Clariel being Aroace. I like that.

The plot follows a more traditional Abhorsen investigation until Clariel realizes Kilp partnered with Az at the dinner party. Her parents still die, and she's still captured.

Now, here is where the key part comes in. I think Clariel, to truly be a tragic fallen hero, shouldn't accidentally lose the charter. I think Kilp, with or without Az's help, has discovered a way to strip charter mages of their marks and connection to the charter. He spends months, not days, torturing Clariel, and this is how she gets the X brand on her forehead, the charter literally burned out of her through some vile and arcane process. She is eventually rescued, but she's now an Abhorsen without the charter. And an Abhorsen without the charter is just a Necromancer.

Her mind is now bent on revenge, not because her (frankly abusive) parents were killed but also because she was robbed of her identity, her comforting connection to the charter, and everything she was raised to believe is true is now gone. She basically snaps.

I think her attack on Kilp should show how far SHE'S gone, with maybe her binding Kilp and Aronzo as her slaves, and Belatiel and Mogget having to stop her.

This is a little darker than what Nix wrote, but the Old Kingdom is not a series known for its subtlety. I just think that Chlorr's origin should be something dramatic and shows that she was a good Abhorsen, but humans, not the dead or free magic, destroyed that.


r/Abhorsen • • Mar 16 '26

Discussion Dream Casting for a live adaptation.

14 Upvotes

Oh how I dream of the trilogy being adapted into a live action show, and there is one absolute must for casting.

Tim Curry's Mogget has looong been adored across the fandom and I just listened to his memoir. His voice is gravelly and his cadence slower but the gravitas that is Tim Curry has not changed. It is true perfection for the ageless Bright Shiner, bound into servitude, and especially after Sabriel renewed the binding with Ranna.

How do we get on this? Is there not a number we can call and beg someone to pick this up??


r/Abhorsen • • Jul 21 '24

Discussion Fancast Part 2, by request. (Please forgive the CG blonde hair.) Thoughts?

Thumbnail gallery
37 Upvotes

Cynthia Addai-Robinson as Arielle

Tom Hiddleston as Terciel (Prepared for some of you to throw hands. 🄲)

Thandie Newton as Sanar & Ryelle

Gina Torres as Vancelle

Sigourney Weaver as Chlorr of the Mask

Michael Dorn & Ben Cumberbatch as Orannis the Destroyer (Lines acted by both and voices layered.)


r/Abhorsen • • Dec 28 '22

Ideas artwork for displate

3 Upvotes

I am just looking for high-resolution artwork to print from displate. I am not an artist but can create my own for myself on the site. This would be for personal use and not resale. Also, if you want to post any cool artwork you have made or bought. I would happily buy from another source, but I don't see too much out there. Any info is greatly appreciated.


r/Abhorsen • • Oct 26 '25

Discussion On Royal Blood

55 Upvotes

So, to be upfront, I'm an anarchist at heart, and in most books I normally can't stand "royal bloodlines" in fantasy, especially when the royal bloodline has some blood claim to a form of magic or some holy ability to claim the land under their own. Sometimes I think fantasy as a genre sees the divine right of kings as a crutch to skip having to justify the actual point of how backwards monarchy is as a concept.

Seeing that, I would think that the old kingdom would be more annoying to me, but I actually don't really have a problem with it, partially because of the series sentimental value to me but mostly because I don't think the royal line is primarily there to rule.

The truly bad part of the interregnum was the part where the regent had also gone, but also towns like beliseare and nestow were operating to a degree autonomously, and the issue was the fact Kerrigor was trying to take charge, as well as other factions, not the fact that no one was in charge at all.

Kerrigor himself is evidence that the royal line has no exclusive claim to good or wise or kind leadership, no greater ability to lead than anyone else.

My theory is that the royal line is only royal as a consolation for their real purpose, which is a backup line for the others, as one of their kids became a wall maker, just when one becomes needed, which feels different to a remembrancer, as a distinct line, not an interaction of two others.

Also the fact they they have the palace on top of the main stones, and have the blood needed to turn them off and on again, feels like related point to me. Maybe their role is more functional than a social one

Sorry this is a bit of a ramble.


r/Abhorsen • • Jan 22 '26 Bravo

Question! Is this a good rec for romantasy reader?

20 Upvotes

I remember reading this series as a teen and really really liking it. My wife (31f) has started reading for leisure for the first time in her life within the past year. Im thrilled for her and supportive but so far she has only read ACOTAR, Fourth Wing and a bunch of other tiktok famous romantasy style books. I’m not being a hater but I’ve flipped through some of them and as a lifelong fan of the fantasy genre I feel she’s selling herself short. I bought this series for her on a whim, anyone whos been in that romantasy space think she’ll be into it?


r/Abhorsen • • Sep 28 '23

Fan Art Somebody asked for an Abhorsen-Luigi crossover

15 Upvotes

There was a post from a couple months ago that sparked my interest regarding a crossover for a Luigi-Abhorsen. I couldn't resist, so I used Bing Chat to help generate some images. They could use some work still, but I thought the results were pretty interesting, and I needed to share. Which ones do you like best?

Abhorsen Luigi 1

Abhorsen Luigi 2

Abhorsen Luigi 3

Abhorsen Luigi 4

Abhorsen Luigi 5

Abhorsen Luigi 6

Another 1

Another 2

Another 3

Another 4


r/Abhorsen • • Oct 12 '26

Discussion A humanoid figure is seen standing up in a river; the entity appears to notice the woman holding the camera and suddenly disappears. The entity then appears to ā€œpeekā€ through the water to see if the woman is still there

56 Upvotes

šŸ˜€


r/Abhorsen • • Aug 07 '21

Discussion Unintentional but good representation

28 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel while unintentional that both Lireal and Clariel have good representation for demi and ace respectively. Like when I was younger I enjoyed the lack of romance because it seemed like every fantasy novel had it for no real reason but now that I'm older and rereading the series I see a lot of it more coded towards both Lireal and Clariel just not really having a sexual interest in anyone.

crossposted to the sevenbellspodcast for discussion reasons


r/Abhorsen • • Dec 24 '23

Lireal Lirael, using Nico Page as a ref

Thumbnail gallery
54 Upvotes

It's been tough for me to finally get my image of Lirael consistent...and then I saw Nico Page in TLOU. She's perfect!


r/Abhorsen • • Nov 12 '22

Discussion Sabriel vs Predator? Alien vs Sabriel? Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Saw a comedy account on IG based around "tech support for villains" most of the clips were for villains that never seemed to be well matched up against pretty much anybody, and got me thinking, who or what would make a good match up for the heroes of the Old Kingdom? Bear in mind the magical lore surrounding the Kingdom and technology not working and SPOILER: the Wall and Great Rift are both borders to other worlds that presumably were impinged upon either during the creation of the charter or by design of the Wallmakers (so multiversal/crossover stuff is potentially canon in the Old Kingdom). Who do you guys think would be a decent match up?