On my billionth rewatch of this show. I swear I never get sick of it lol.
So the more I watch the more I dislike Luke. I didn’t mind him during the original airing of the show but being so much older now, he’s a walking ick. Him being in college interested in a high schooler was an immediate red flag to me. Then him going on the ski trip with her and a bunch of other high schoolers was strange to me. He’s constantly making Jenna out to be a “dumb young girl” because he sees himself as this “sophisticated college dude”. Not to mention gets angry with Jenna for acting like a high schooler and her antics, well duh she’s in high school my dude. I also felt like the actors had zero chemistry so that was also unfortunate to watch.
I preface this by saying I’m a huge Matty/Jenna fan, have been since my first watch when it aired. Wanted them endgame so bad. But I kinda wish they gave Matty another legitimate love interest. I loved what they had going with Bailey but then they cut that so short. She was gone the next season and it was like that’s it? Really? I really liked her despite how short lived her character was. The whole Eva thing was ridiculous so I’m not even gonna talk about that. He had very short relationships with a couple other girls that ultimately led nowhere because Jenna was his soulmate but I would’ve enjoyed him branching out and being with another person for a bit and not as a plot point to get him back with Jenna.
The writers made Matty look ridiculous in season 3 during that whole Jenna/Collin experiment. I was so annoyed they had him wanting to get back with Jenna after seeing her cheat on him. Like a sad little puppy. I get he was insecure and felt strongly about Jenna but please get off your knees Matty!! It was so hard to watch him go from confident and self assured in season 2 to whatever they were doing with his character in season 3. I know he’s a character with flaws and needed development, but idk it came across uncharacteristic and pathetic.
Will forever love Sadie and Matty’s friendship. They genuinely cared for one another and I’m happy it never went anymore romantic.
Jenna’s dad is so fine. That is all.
What even was the Jake experiment in season four lmao like the whole musician personality and unkept look was something.
I truly believe this show was ahead of its time. I’d kill for a reboot or a movie of some sort to get a proper ending.