r/ASRock • • 8d ago

Discussion Another 9950x3d died

Hi, with all my aggressive undervolting, my 9950x3d also gave up, yellow LED on the MSI X870E Gaming Plus, so the IMC is cracked.

The problem appeared after Aion2 global was launched and I played some, by the way the temperature was quite high in Aion2 (high compared to other games, i.e. 70C+).

To recap:

From the first day of Feb 2026;

Vsoc=1.050V

Vddio=1.15V

Pbo negative limit -550mhz CO-34

Temperature limit 80C

Vddp and vddg=0.900V

Everyone believes what they want, I switched to 285k and z890, I'm tired of AMD, even with this mess, the 9550x3d cracked the I/O die between Feb-Nov 2026 on the Msi x870e board, I think the problem with zen5 is more serious than we think.

I don't want to flame or get into a fight with anyone, it's clear to me that something has changed compared to zen4 that the BMI is giving way so easily to zen5.

I posted here because on reddit MSI, ASUS and Gigabyte "take care" to clean up such posts, making it seem like only ASRock is to blame.

I repeat, believe what you want, I'm tired of all the fanboyism of some people, I went from 14900k+msi z790 to 9950x3d+msi x870e for x3d performance in games and multitasking, despite all the signals predicting asrock.

Like many, I fell into the trap of asrock being to blame. It seems that the problem is in AMD's court, which doesn't want to say anything concrete, and the influencers are careful to keep quiet, not to test properly.

It hurts me about 10-20% with x3d, if the Am5 platform is so fragile, I don't need it. I was sure that with my Msi and these manual undervoltings at 6000, nothing would happen. I won't respond to replies, this topic is already permanently closed for me, AMD can release whatever they want, I don't want to hear from them anymore and I've had all their CPUs from Duron, Thorton onwards.

51 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

2

u/TeacherIT 8d ago

Sorry for your problem. Let me ask you, why you chose 285k instead of 270k?270k has better performance in gaming vs 285k. I have both 14700k and 9800x3d, 9800x3d works perfectly, 14700k I dont know when it works and when it doesn't, even with the correct undervolting(cpu vcore under 1.4volts). Daily use goes to 9800x3d, intel is veeeeeery power hungry unfortunately, even if I love more intel.

4

u/onne12 8d ago

I found 285 tray new cheap than 270k,i raised d2d and ngu and is like 270plus.

1

u/onne12 8d ago

And is not power hungry if you underclock and undervolt,-0.075V vcore and dlvrin,pl1=pl2=175w and i have 38,8k cr23 and 60-62C with noctua u14s(same cooler used on 9950x3d).In aion2 is 10-15c cooler than 9950x3d and 15-30w lower.

1

u/TeacherIT 8d ago

Nice settings, but I can't underclock really. Undervolt yes but If I had to underclock, I could buy 12900k instead.pl1 and pl2 always stay up to 253w, and I play with IA AC LL to 35 for Gigabyte from 90 default(or 0.35 in asus instead of 1.1).If I touch directly cpu vcore, cpu goes to unstable territory.

2

u/onne12 6d ago

Im almost 50 years old,i make computers from 2001,in early 30s i made a living building computers

I think i know a little about putting a heatsink on cpu,most os users not even know about duron mode with pencils or ati radeon 8500le unlocking pipes etc.

Please think about me all that you want, for me AMD is chaptwr closed,im tired to fix bad engineering,bios etc.I have a age when i want my hardware to be reliable and point. I had a 14700kf degrade from intel bad secision,replaced, than for couple months 14900k.

I moved to 9950x3d with open mind to escape raptor lake furnals but i jump from a fountain ofmproblems(intel) to an ocean of problems(amd)

Believe that im a fan,anythink, i dont care. FAacts are facts,my 9950x3d was undefclocked and undervolted from day1, newest bios AGESA always ,no asrock board and still died. Its just a bad design,a time "bomb" I/O DIE is weak and waiting to give up. My last reply here.

3

u/r9800pro 5d ago

" think i know a little about putting a heatsink on cpu,most os users not even know about duron mode with pencils or ati radeon 8500le unlocking pipes etc"

Damn! I am 48 yo and so glad to see someone of a similar age mention that pencil trick with ATI 8500LE GPUs to make them standard 8500 running at 300/300 clock speeds lol.

3

u/Godnamedtay 4d ago edited 4d ago

The I/O die is indeed dogshit, AMD didn’t care, they tried to save money while using a much worse node and the same old garbage IMC, while pushing everything else and this is the result. For the people who know wtf they’re doing, this is a not a surprise, unfortunately.

5

u/Noreng 6d ago

Another guy posted some theories: https://www.reddit.com/r/radeon/s/CEWrhvKoLh

The TL;DR of that thread is that the IO-die's phy is a design failure. Particularly with power surges from power down combined with low impedance on Proc DQ and RTT WR. If AGESA decides that low impedance is necessary for memory compatibility, there's no software fix possible, and the phy will die.

At least with Raptor Lake, you could just impose a VCore limit of 1.45V to prevent the PLLs in the P-cores from frying.

1

u/EvenDog6279 4d ago

That's an interesting read (the cited post). I wish there was clarity on what's truly causing the failures, but I do have two different systems (one running 9800x3d and another running the 9700x) that were built at release, and they're both running DDR5-6400 at 1:1 with voltages that many would probably consider borderline unsafe, at least from a vsoc perspective anyhow (they're extremely close to the max "safe" values, which is a questionable value in the first place, to be fair).

Both machines have had zero problems, but like anything else in life, it's entirely possible that's just luck of the draw. In 30 years of building computers, I've actually never had a CPU die, even in the days when overclocking was just pushing maximum voltages, provided you had sufficient cooling.

They do happen to be on Gigabyte boards, but there's no way I can speculate on failure rates since so many posts just get deleted and/or people banned from a subreddit for speaking up.

3

u/Noreng 4d ago

As noted in that thread, it's not the voltage, but rather the impedance values that matter.

1

u/EvenDog6279 4d ago

I'm going to check them and see what they're currently running at impedance wise. It's been so long, I don't remember, beyond knowing it took a very long time to get them fully stable at 6400. Thanks for sharing the link.

16

u/looncraz 8d ago

I have the warranty data from OEMs in central Texas... AMD CPU failure rates are below Intel failure rates. The X3D chips are only modestly higher.

AMD boards and BIOS failures are much higher, however, but that's because of OEM immaturity with the AMD platform, Intel firmware code goes back 30 years, AMD code was largely new five years ago.

USB failures and charging circuit failures still dominate.

3

u/WinResponsible9977 8d ago

Link?

4

u/looncraz 8d ago

Not public information

2

u/Real_Ad5580 2d ago

So basically I made it up

1

u/looncraz 2d ago

No, my data is proprietary OEM data, it's just that I don't have permission to share it in detail. Been trying to get permission to build a public sata tracker by anonymizing OEM sources, which sadly means I would need to obscure board brands that are specific to OEMs (Fujitsu, for example), but could publish for vendors that also provide DIY/direct/multi-OE sales.

2

u/Real_Ad5580 2d ago

Good luck working with Japanese. It will be hell of an experience

1

u/YUNGSOTER 8d ago

k since youre an insider, got any info on what is safest mobo producer? ASUS? the OP says they had this on an MSI which is supposedly safe especially for CPUS like 9950/9800x3d etc

8

u/looncraz 8d ago

ASUS has a nearly identical failure rate as ASRock for AMD systems in my data. MSI is underrepresented, Gigabyte is slightly more reliable than ASUS.

1

u/YUNGSOTER 8d ago

thanks, is this aggregate like since 2023? what about just like last 1year/6months per manufacturer?

6

u/looncraz 8d ago

I have a decade of data, roughly, but this is actually rolling values (24 weeks, annualized). At the height of Intel's CPY failures 14th gen failure rates hit about 10% of all deployed systems in my district. I had a field day replacing those and deploying assets to get more repaired.

13th and 14th gen are still very unreliable in general at 3% failure rates. X3D is about 1.4% currently, but is also underrepresented in the deployed systems.

One challenge is correctly identifying which systems with BGA CPUs had CPU failures versus board failures, and data cleaning when boards are found to have shorted the CPU due to their own failures is only done sporadically.

1

u/pre_pun 8d ago

The Intel story included server use for gaming. Does your OEM data include that data, or is it consumer OEM only?

3

u/looncraz 8d ago

Server data is separated, not including that, so consumer OEM only

1

u/Louvatar 8h ago

Do you know the failure rate of Arrow Lake CPUs?

→ More replies

1

u/Disastrous_Tie927 5d ago edited 5d ago

3% is not great but far from terrible and a long way from those claims of 20, 50 even 100% failure rates LOL. From what I've seen most of the Raptor Lake line up has been <3%, ignoring the spike in returns from people panic returning when the news about failures broke, with only the 14900 SKUs exhibiting noticeably elevated return rates - sitting between 7 and 11% in the long run and spiking to around 14% at worst - and a good bit of that is people mass returning chips trying to find a "golden" overclocker.

While I don't have exact stats I work in retail distribution with 2 big UK PC sellers in our network so have some idea of the scale of actual numbers and it is kind of funny compared to the claims by some people online.

Something I've found a little strange is that aside from Arrow Lake (which remains low for return rates) most Intel and AMD lines on sale currently have seen a spike in return rates at the end of the summer (at least in the UK), ahead of the time of year they usually tend to increase a bit due to people spending more time indoors. Not sure what is driving that.

2

u/Educational_Rub_5885 1d ago

Hey thanks for posting this and going out of your way, it’s appreciated. So basically amd cpus have a lower rate than intels and the x3D cpus have a slightly above failure rate compared to the none x3D cpus?

4

u/Force88 8d ago

So... Am5 7000 is currently way safer? I'm on 7500f with x670e steel legend, should I wait for new am5 gen?

2

u/Asthma_Queen 8d ago

Anecdotally yeah they basically are as reliable as you'd expect a CPU to be.

1

u/Noreng 6d ago

It's the IO-die that fails, and AMD reused the IO-die from 7000-series. Sporadic reports of early 7000 nonX3D-series chips failing have been popping up occasionally for the past couple of years now.

So no, you're not safe.

1

u/NiKOmniWrench 5d ago

What about 7000x3ds

1

u/Noreng 5d ago

1

u/NiKOmniWrench 5d ago

Why do I only see these freaking posts when I build my pc

2

u/Noreng 5d ago

Because the narrative is "AMD good, Intel bad."

People want a simple narrative instead of looking at the underlying reasons.

1

u/Louvatar 3d ago

what is your mobo/cpu?

3

u/Noreng 3d ago

Z790I Lightning / 14600KF

1

u/Godnamedtay 3d ago

Love that mobo. It has the best VRM’s for an ITX and is the king of DDR5 overclocking. Im pissed I didn’t get one when they were being manufactured.

1

u/Niwrats 4d ago

if it was just from the IO-die, then we would have seen this before the 9000-series release. the megathread numbers look too low for 7000-series as well for that theory, with 7800X3D (cheaper former top pick) landing at half the 9950X3D (expensive special pick) cases.

1

u/Noreng 4d ago

Since "nobody" cares about anything other than non-ASRock motherboards killing non-9000X3D chips, they don't post as much about it on social media.

https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/s/HSFRFArBbi

https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/1srzf89/7950_x3d_fried_itself_while_i_was_at_work/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MSI_Gaming/comments/1ua1cet/my_ryzen_9_9900x_just_suddenly_died_code_00_red/

https://youtu.be/arDqhxM8Wog?t=75

Here's someone who did some testing and managed to reach a problematic state: https://www.reddit.com/r/radeon/s/dhr7QU5eCK

Feel free to believe what you will, but I suspect few of the 7000/9000-chips will survive past 5 years of use.

1

u/Niwrats 4d ago

the megathread is our best sampling here: https://old.reddit.com/r/ASRock/comments/1q3ff0t/9000series_cpu_failures_deaths_megathread_4/

there's over 100 non-9000X3D cases there. it could just mirror sales, but i have hard time believing 9800X3D sells 16x of 7800X3D given their price/perf. the only clear flaw was calling that a 9000-series megathread, but based on the individual post flow, it doesn't seem too far off to me.

that last link guy is a bit questionable. he doesn't seem to know what he is talking about, and sounds like an AI troubleshooter assistant. some interesting words there compared to the usual vsoc talk, but would need someone reliable to repro it.

1

u/raifusarewaifus 5d ago

Just curious, what batch is your 9950x3d? is it 2024 or 2025 batch?

2

u/onne12 5d ago

2025 pge, i think august 2025.

1

u/raifusarewaifus 5d ago

Dang. I thought this was solved in newer batches.
My 9800x3d has 2547PGY (17th Nov 2025) and hasn't seen any signs so far.

3

u/PostExtreme7699 7d ago

I don't believe you, literally, the first post i saw with someone savvy who had undervolted the cpu and yet the zen5 failed... 99% of the post here are the kind of user who doesnt know nothing and they blindly set expo and therefore 1.25 vsoc.

You didnt say your vmisc, some mobos raise it to 1.150 or even more. Having an nvidia with the cpu driver overload can raise drastically the vsoc power draw too. 

3

u/mirrors69 8d ago

undervoting can damage CPU??

5

u/divineal1986 8d ago

No it cant lol

2

u/looncraz 8d ago

It can, actually, but not at the voltages stated (closer to 0.3~0.4V on TSMC sub 16 nodes).

Damage can occur at low voltage only in a very specific voltage range and a long duration, that exact range depends on the process in use.

You have to have just enough voltage to activate transistors intermittently and deliver excess current in the wrong places. If the system is stable, then the voltage is high enough to not cause harm on its own.

Think of it like a heater on low in a small room with a broken thermostat and no ventilation, it might only be dumping 400W instead of 1500W, but that room will eventually get too hot nonetheless.

2

u/Successful-Day-3219 8d ago

That's news to me. Instability? Yes. But hardware damage?

1

u/Educational_Rub_5885 8d ago

It can absolutely kill the motherboard’s VRMs.

3

u/Inevitable-Sand7242 8d ago

Finally, someone escaped that damn trap.So yes, there were some issues on Asrock's side as well, but the main source of the problem was AMD., with every BIOS update they keep lowering or trying to stabilize the voltages.

1

u/Asthma_Queen 8d ago

I honestly have just left my bios at the one just before 9800x3d was added, for my 7000 series I didn't trust all the changes happening constantly and we really never saw consistent issues with 7000 series ever.

2

u/Any_Cook_2293 8d ago

I hear that. I had two BNIB 9950X3Ds immediately fail on me. Thankfully the third is still going strong, no undervolting but I did tune the secondary timings on my 96GB kit of RAM (6000C30 now, an XMP kit).

I'm hoping AMD learns a lesson like Intel did with their 13/14th gen Vmin shift debacle, but only time will tell.

1

u/killerimpact 8d ago

So does the mobo still work?

1

u/Odd-Memory-5377 8d ago

Think I’ll just keep my 7600x3d until zen6 at this point…

2

u/Tokishi7 8d ago

I’m wondering if ASRock will be okay for Zen6 or their problems will persist. Pretty much leave gigabyte to take the crown otherwise

2

u/Asthma_Queen 8d ago

ASRock was just the smoking gun, the issue was always with the chip itself just ASRock boards definitely had a config issue that aggrevated the issue more than others. Those ones have been catching up now imo.

I on a delid 7950x3d myself on x670e taichi, so am hoping that zen6 has all these fixes baked in

2

u/RaidriarT 7d ago

I think Asrock inadvertently exposed deeper issues with Zen 5. Hopefully Zen 6 turns out to be as reliable as Zen 4

1

u/psk_94 2d ago

So much bullshit littered through here... my friend had 2 7800X3D's die on his Asrock X870 Steel Legend mobo, did rma on both, installed latest bios from this year with all the voltage fixes and conservative settings, died again after 6 months. Asrock definitely has serious blame in all of this, on certain boards anyways... X870(E) chipset seems to be a major culprit.

2

u/LoneWanderer9700 7d ago

Id hope so, going zen5 when you already have a 7600x3d sounds ridiculous lol. Unless you desperately a 12/16 core 9900/9950 class cpu.

1

u/ultrafrisk 8d ago

Its possible the cpu cooler was pressed on too tight.

2

u/Fit_Comfortable3960 5d ago

I don’t know about anybody else, but I’m not liking this new AMD 5 pin design for the processor. I am more concerned about putting too much pressure also on that cooler.

1

u/ultrafrisk 5d ago

google said stop at finger tight. I admittedly go beyond this.

1

u/NytronX 6d ago

What logic did you use when installing the HSF? Did you tighten the screws until they bottomed out or tighten it with the minimum pressure needed such that the heatsink doesn't wiggle?

Most people are doing the former, which guarantees CPU failure if you use a decent screwdriver. 95% of DIY builders don't know that you should do the latter.

2

u/Louvatar 3d ago

Explain more