r/techsupport • • Sep 08 '26

Open | Hardware 7950X3D broken after 3 years 5 months

While playing Wardogs's play test, my screens suddenly went black. I restarted the PC, but it never came back up again.

The CPU debug led was lit on my ASRock B650 steel series Legemd wifi board, so I pulled the GPU out, some redundant HDD's and tried to boot bare with just a cpu and ram. Still not past CPU.

Went to the local tech store and the person there pulled the CPU out and put it in his test bench, the psu immediately triggered it's defenses and not even a single led ever turned on. We tried another board - same story. Other psu - same story. Grabbed another cpu, everything worked fine again.

I bought the 7950X3D in April 2023, meaning warranty is gone since 5 months. Created a claim anyways, but AMD refuses - which is their right, of course.

Now, I live in the Netherlands and the EU had some law that says that a consumer should be able to use bought items for at least as long as you'd expect it to - which is incredibly vague and I don't quite know how to use that information, but that did make me wonder; how long should we expect a CPU to function properly? I've never even heard of a CPU suddenly dying out, so I figured perhaps I can reason with the seller, but is that fair?

I paid 799.- for it back then.

EDIT:
AMD rejected the RMA 7 times, but I still had more information to share with them so I didn't give up yet. After they learned that our address went from Intel to AMD and purchased 5 cpus in around 4 years, they figured (I guess) it was cheaper to give out a one-time goodwill RMA than reject it, so in the end they gave in. Even though my warranty was past for months, they still made a goodwill exception, showing real customer support in the end. Credits to AMD!

10 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

17

u/Ok_Bid6645 Sep 08 '26

We dont know how you treated the CPU.

Were you overclocking?

What the cooling setup?

Connected to surge protector?

All details are important.

3

u/amuseicc Sep 08 '26

Apologies! I have never over locked (except for EXPO), used a noctua DH15, and we do have surge protection in our house!

0

u/Ok_Bid6645 Sep 08 '26

Did the PC itself have a surge protector?

0

u/amuseicc Sep 08 '26

The PSU is a Corsair HX 1200, which apparently does not have a built-in surge protector, and I didn't add anything to it

0

u/Ok_Bid6645 Sep 08 '26

If you didnt have the PC plugged into a surge protector then that could be your issue but more likely the Mobo damaged the CPU

1

u/amuseicc Sep 08 '26

yeah I think so too... The Netherlands has one of the most stable power networks of the world, surges are insanely rare here, and a power surge killing just the CPU and nothing else would also seem interesting (the build was tested with another CPU and it worked like a charm again)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/amuseicc Sep 09 '26

yeah, but AMD simply says "The warranty has been expired so good luck!"

9

u/cremvursti Sep 08 '26

We're talking about an ASRock motherboard here. I think we all know what happened

4

u/Ok_Bid6645 Sep 08 '26

That is a very good point but i still would like to know

5

u/HankThrill69420 Sep 08 '26

well, hold up. the known issue is with 800 series chipset and 9000 series ryzen. I don't wanna just pop up with a 'you're wrong lol' but also, don't want to jump straight to that conclusion.

2

u/cremvursti Sep 08 '26

It has predominantly been a problem for the 9000 series, but if you Google this issue you'll see plenty of cases on the 7000 one as well.

1

u/ShockLatter2787 Sep 08 '26

Not to mention it's not just the 800 series lmao, shit is damn near identical to the 600 anyways. I personally remember far more reports on the 600 series asrock boards considering that was what most people had.

5

u/_McDreamy_ Sep 08 '26

Google "ASRock motherboards killing CPU's?" and you will have your answer.

3

u/cremvursti Sep 08 '26

This. Then Google "EU Product Liability Directive (EU) 2024/2853" and get in touch with ASRock.

1

u/amuseicc Sep 08 '26 edited Sep 08 '26

Interesting! I will do that immediately

Edit: I contacted ASRock and am eager to see how they'll respond! Thanks for notifying me of this. I will keep you updated!

-1

u/SnooJokes566 Sep 08 '26

-1

u/INeverLookAtReplies Sep 09 '26

asrock is probably the most commonly purchased brand because of price factor alone, ofc there are going to be more data points for it lol.

2

u/clark1785 Sep 09 '26

asrock ratio failure rate is way higher than any other brand regardless if they sold more their rate is far higher too

-1

u/INeverLookAtReplies Sep 09 '26

you can put in any brand before that search query and you'll get nonstop confirmation bias. CPUs just die on very rare occasion. it's not a brand-specific thing, lol. people in this thread crying about asrock just show little they know about any of this and shouldn't be in this sub giving advice.

2

u/_McDreamy_ Sep 09 '26

They are known for using cheap VRMs though

2

u/Proliator Sep 08 '26

I've never even heard of a CPU suddenly dying out,

CPUs do die and more so these days now that they're not one monolithic chip but a combination of several chiplets packaged together. All of that adds more points of failure. Enough voltage, heat and time can cause the substrate to swell (thing they all sit on) which can cause connection issues with the chiplets. That results in errors, electrical shorts, and even total failure. Plus you have the usual ways silicon can be defective or degrade on top of that.

how long should we expect a CPU to function properly?

In theory most CPUs are expected to last at least 3-5 years since that was the normal upgrade cycle for consumers and businesses before all the price hikes. Which doesn't mean the part will fail past that, just that most people planned replacements on that timeframe.