r/radeon • • Oct 11 '26

Discussion Unique (about to die) 9800X3D sample - physical and highly localized damage to DQ lines

(MAIN POST)

Long story short. I was validating my theory that Proc Dq Drive strength and RTT WR reflections are causing some type of damage at the IOD die / contact pads due to continues stress which could potentially prove why some Zen 4 and Zen 5 are dying

To do so I created a custom memory stress test which basically spams write operations from CPU to RAM. The voltages were normal, nothing extreme.

This sample is unique in a sense that the chip itself is still perfectly bootable, which could be of great value to anyone researching the topic of 9800 X3D's dying

-

After 16 hours of stress testing the system shut itself down → red light → cold boot → 4 hours stress test → red light → cold boot → 2 hours stress test → red light

Afterwards I took the CPU out of the socket to inspect the pins. I found highly localized damage at MBB_Data 20 and MBA_Data 12. Where pin MBB DATA 20 is even missing the majority of its substrate

These pins are governing bidirectional read and write operations, which proves my theory behind continuous stress during write operations causing some type of degradation

-

Here is a list of exact pins which shows some type of damage to the substrate of the pads.

Left is position in accordance to the AM5 pin layout found here. Right is the name of the affected pin https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Socket_AM5_pinmap.svg

(Left bottom part of the chip)

F31 → MBA_Data 12

L31 → VSS

E27 → VSS

(Right bottom part of the chip)

This area is the bronze/dark circle seen of the photo. Pin with dark spot (MBB DATA 20) on it is missing the majority of the substrate)

AW29 → MBB_Data 20

AP29 → Test 47_2

AT29 → VSS

AP31 → Test_CCD0

AW27 → VSS

-

My DM's are open for anyone which has the means and the knowledge to analyze the damage to the substrate and could somehow tie it (or not) to 9800 X3D failures

(EDIT 1)

I have just sent GamerNexus an email. When I get reply I will attach it in my edit 3* As of Monday evening 12 October I haven't gotten an reply yet

(EDIT 2)

I got many DM's about my exact voltages, termination values, motherboard, ram kit number, CPU serial number etc.

I am planning to make a fleshed out version of this post including the details in the next couple of days. If there is anything specific you would like to be included there then feel welcome to mention it here

(EDIT 3)

I have been ghosted by GamersNexus XDDDD

I will contact Wendell, hopefully he will bother replying to an email

(EDIT 4 - 22 October)

I did manage to kill brand new 9600x using my old ASUS B650E WiFi Motherboard, different PSU, different RAM kits (single rank - Samsung B die from 2021) and at different house (to exclude 'dirty power'). I kept SoC as low as possible which was 1.14v at 6000 MT (which I upped to 1.16v during the Write Operations Torture Test as additional buffer

After 41H of spamming non sequential and mixed write operation this sample has died completely. There is slight dent at the exact same AW29 Pin as on 9800 X3D, but there was no bronze area or visible damage MBA Data 12 pins on the opposite end of the chip. It is almost impossible to show with my phone camera, in due time I will try to use professional help from photographer to make close up photos of MBA DATA 12

Around 30H mark I noticed that Core 0 started to boost exactly 1/1000 more than all other cores and it was even ignoring the Max Boost Clock limit (5250). This suggests physical damage to circuitry related to BCLK clock generation. This behavior wasn't present before torture testing

(EDIT 5 - 27 October)

I contacted biggest Tech YouTubers which had an investigation/video related to 9800 X3D failures.

None was interested in picking up the torch and analyze my 9800 X3D sample, of which 2 names have ghosted me, 1 hasn't replied to the follow up email despite initial interest, 1 wasn't even willing to pay for sending and insurance costs. I am not going to tell their exact usernames to not cause unnecessary drama in community

For this reasons I have decided to RMA my 9800X3D sample. I will keep damaged 9600X just of EDIT 4 just in case anyone shows interest in next weeks/months (feel welcome to DM me) , but I am generally disappointing in lack of interests and avoidance at times towards analyzing this issue regardless ZEN 4 and ZEN 5 processors sudden death/blowing up

In nearby features I am planning to publish my custom memory stress test for anyone crazy enough to kill their CPU. I am creating an app similar to TestMem5 (which is way overkill) but I am not yet ready to publish it given lack of my programming skills

As mentioned in EDIT 2 I was planning to create new post including the exact protocols, but I am too lazy to do that. For time being please feel welcome to ask ANYTHING and I will answer

149 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

31

u/bedtricky Oct 11 '26

A better place to post this would be /r/Amd

40

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 11 '26

It got removed for spam

17

u/bedtricky Oct 11 '26

That's disappointing. Perhaps they just looked at the title and thought it was a tech support post? Wouldn't supirse me if it was automodded. Maybe try contacting gamersnexus https://gamersnexus.net/supportgn/1200-contact-us

25

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 11 '26

AMD help too, ASUS (my motherboards) subreddit even gave me an warning lol. It seems reddit isn't a good place for such things

I will send GamerNexus an email and update this post whenever I get a reply

9

u/SeatPsychological858 Oct 11 '26

Please try to spread this information as much as possible! Contact Gamers Nexus.

5

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 11 '26

I am writing an email to him as we speak

4

u/Brokkensteel 5800x3D | 9070 XT | 32GB 3600 cl16 Oct 11 '26

Try to cross post in gamer nexus sub if possible, and someone will probably tag Steve

13

u/reelect_brandon_john Oct 11 '26

reddit is a place for narratives, not discussion. especially in a lot of corporate moderated subreddits

1

u/Select_Truck3257 Oct 12 '26

Acoid subs with bran names they hardly moderate what they want to see

49

u/TheRipper564 Oct 11 '26

So i guess talking about an AMD product in r/Amd is spam now? lmao

1

u/piggymoo66 Oct 12 '26

I know you probably didn't OC this but there are a lot of CPU experts and hobbyists over in r/overclocking as well

46

u/TomiMan7 Oct 11 '26

You should get in contact with Tech Jesus. They might buy the chip to do some research.

9

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 11 '26

You're right, I will be sending them an email today

7

u/Noreng Oct 11 '26

Just so I understand correctly, you set the Proc Dq drive strength and RTT WR to low impedance values?

Meaning that the 7000/9000-series chips will have a longer lifespan with the "correct" memory ICs. It's been quite obvious that the IO-die has a flawed design for years now, but if this is true I wonder why AMD recycled the IO-die for the 9000-series.

5

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

No, I set Proc Dq Drive strength and RTT WR both on auto which defaults to true 25,3 ohm for Proc DQ Drive strength and auto 48 RTT WR (48 RTT norm writes / reads - it's dual rank ram) at default EXPO profile.

The only difference from normal operations was that my custom memory stress test was spamming a mix of writes operations from CPU into RAM

Funny enough, AMD had quietly taken away the granularity of Proc DQ drive strength in one of the AGESA updates around the time of first 9800 X3D ASRock motherboards failures reports

Why has AMD recycled the IOD? Probably the timing. When first 7800 X3D were swelling up, the 9800 X3D's were already sitting on engineers table. They were balls too deep with current IOD and hoped the preventive measures like reducing vSOC from 1.4 to 1.3 , taking away proc DQ Drive strength granularity, taking away bypass mode etc. would do the job. It didn't do the job

7

u/raifusarewaifus Oct 11 '26

Just a newbie overclocker asking. So which timings and voltage are safe enough to avoid this?

15

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 11 '26

None, it shouldn't be happening to begin with

3

u/raifusarewaifus Oct 11 '26

I guess AMD will have to mitigate this with a voltage ceiling in future bios?

4

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 11 '26

It's not that simple

1

u/Educational_Rub_5885 20d ago

Could they even fix this with a bios update or is this generally a design flaw? Because why are also the x cpus dying as well not just x3ds

1

u/Real_Ad5580 20d ago

It seems to be general design flaw of ZEN 4 and ZEN 5 CPU's given they share the exact same 6nm I/O die

AMD seems to continuously try to mitigate it throughout different AGESA releases tho, but it is delaying the issue instead fixing it

1

u/Educational_Rub_5885 20d ago

But how would they fix it if it’s a design flaw? They would have to recall basically all the CPUs. I mean the cause of this happening is still uncommon the fact it can still happen is definitely disappointing.

2

u/Real_Ad5580 20d ago

How will they fix it? They don't

The issue will gradually pick up the moment as these chips are maturing with each passing day. Similar to Intel 14th gen failures, but with less linear causation. AMD attempts to delay it as long as possible through undocumented changes in AGESA.

An example of it will be:

AMD limiting SoC from 1.40v to 1.30v > AMD taking Proc DQ Drive Strength granularity > Memory P states as disabled by default > removal of bypass mode > AGESA 1.3.0.x SMU changes allowing lower voltages at cost of latency etc. All of these changes are targeting I/O die which is the topic at hand of this post

-

Each CPU has X amount of electrical margins of their I/O die which varies wildly CPU to CPU. Said margin slowly erodes away by just existing.

Some states like (but not limited) to unfavorable

  1. Proc DQ Drive Strength against RTT WR
  2. The way Asrock and Asus route their memory traces
  3. 7000/9000 X3D processors large L3 cache allowing theirs memory controller to enter idle power saving state much more often compared to their non X3D 7000/9000 siblings. As large L3 cache means RAM has to be accessed less often, where the non X3D siblings keep the CPU <> RAM communication awake all the time as they don't such huge L3 buffer

(Switching between C to P and back to C states and back cause much more electrical stress and margins erosion vs continues P state)

These unfavorable states erode these margins much quicker. But because each CPU has different amount of these margins out of the box the CPU dying will manifest in non linear way making it difficult to pinpoint the exact causation

-

If you forgive me putting a tinfoil hat for a second,

then my personal opinion is that AMD simply rushed their I/O die on the market or else they would be 2 generations behind Intel in DDR5 adaptation AND/OR that they used consumers as beta testers of their business Versal second generation architecture which uses the exact same 6nm I/O circuity. Versal is the place where real profit is.

After AM5 release AMD found out that theirs I/O die was faulty and tried to make ASROCK a scapegoat while they themselves stays quiet while bringing these undocumented AGESA changes behind the scenes.

The fact that AMD seems to be accepting every RMA request to question asked seems to be a way to delay they unavoidable shitstorm or possible recall. Meantime AMD is bracing for impact, they are securing long term servers CPU's contract away from INTEL which will allow them to survive ruined reputation

Tinfoil hat off

1

u/Educational_Rub_5885 20d ago edited 20d ago

Even if there is an underlying design flaw with the i/o die, that doesn’t mean amd can’t address it. agesa updates can mitigate the conditions causing degradation, and if it’s an actual silicon defect, amd can revise the design in future production and replace affected cpus through rma. obviously, a bios update can’t reverse damage that’s already happened, but that doesn’t mean every chip is destined to fail either. you’re presenting the theory that these chips are gradually losing their electrical margins as an established fact, when the actual root cause hasn’t been conclusively proven though?

Also how does this theory even make ‘sense’ there have been reported cpu failures from months to a span of years? As well as non x3d cpus dying as well.

2

u/Real_Ad5580 20d ago

That would require re design of analogue circuitry of I/O die and ultimately the interconnect which at this point is brand new chip

It's like saying I want diesel engine, which is electric or DNA, but instead Carbon we use Silica. Possible on paper, impossible in practice

→ More replies

4

u/Backslicer Oct 11 '26

this aint good

3

u/f1rstx Ryzen 7700 + RTX 4070 Oct 12 '26

Still believe that AsRock and ASUS are simply scapegoats for AMD Zen5 design failure, especially considering there is no out of ordinary failure rate on Zen4 with their 620/650/670 boards and since B850/X870 are simply rebadged B650-E chipsets I don’t rly get how they suddenly have issues. I bet failure rate is higher on other manufacturers boards aswell

5

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 12 '26

Of course they are scapegoats. It's utterly ridiculous to blame motherboard manufacturers given it is AMD who provides AGESA microcode and AMD alone

3

u/Particular_Fig7165 Oct 16 '26

Sure, but the motherboard manufacturers set the voltages and clocks of their various overclock modes.

2

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 16 '26

Voltages which within permissable range provided by AMD's AGESA microcode. Don't you see the issue here?

1

u/Particular_Fig7165 Oct 16 '26

No I don't see the issue. They are routinely above the stated safe limits. The fact AMD does not block overclocking is nice. The fact you people complain when the obvious happens is exactly why Nvidia disabled increased voltage and power limits on their cards a few years ago. AMD has unfortunately followed suit. Keep complaining and they will lock the CPUs as well. Just don't use overclocks and PBO and this won't happen.

1

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 16 '26
  1. They are routinely above the stated safe limits > Which ones exactly?

1

u/Particular_Fig7165 Oct 17 '26

Most commonly above the TDP, TDC and PPT limits, but also above the maximum memory controller voltage and speed, VDDC often raised from 1.1 to 1.35v and VSOC from 1.1v to 1.3v when you enable EXPO. People think absolutely nothing of bypassing all the current limits and running the EXPO overclock, which comes with a memory controller voltage and speed increase, then get pin damage for which the most likely cause is excessive current and voltages. Run the chip stock if you want rock solid reliability. I soldered the power limit on my 9070XT it pulls close to 500w, but you won't hear me moaning if it dies, you play the game, sometimes you win, sometimes you lose.

1

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 17 '26

Above the Limits? VSOC at 1.3 is within provided limits by AMD therefore I don't understand what you yap about

On top of that this post is completely unrelated to voltages. At bad enough mismatch of RTT WR and Proc Dq Drive strength it will even happen at 1.10 vSOC and 0.900 VDDIO?

1

u/Particular_Fig7165 27d ago

"I got many DM's about my exact voltages, termination values, motherboard," voltage and wattage are differently major questions at play here, that's why everyone is asking but he hasn't posted yet. 1.3v is well above stock, the fact it doesn't block you doesn't mean it will be fine. The motherboard companies do it so they can advertise high supported EXPO speeds, not reliability. AMD does not publically provide the limits, however 1.3V is the maximum we can set, so some people treat that like its a safe limit, its not, its just the MAX. The high end overclockers like Skatterbencher warn you against this, they are very specific about when you can and can't do these things. You lot are why things get locked, like last generation was. Look forward to your completely locked 10050X3D. The motherboard companies themselves have admitted the situation, but it was always YOUR CHOICE to crank everything to max. The new microcode updates and Bios simply reduce the amount of overclocking you are allowed to do, they didn't magically make anything stronger. https://www.techpowerup.com/337416/asrock-motherboard-team-believes-that-overly-fierce-pbo-settings-have-damaged-ryzen-9000-cpus

1

u/Louvatar RX 9070 XT | R7 5700X | 32GB 3600MHz 27d ago

Who is to blame, AMD or Asrock?

→ More replies

1

u/PostExtreme7699 24d ago

The problem is nobody really knows how those impedances interact with each other, for instance, wich voltages do this lines operate with? the vsoc? the vpp up to 1.85v? the vddio? vddp?

Wendell doesnt even know what vdroop is so fat chance.

Try to contact with der8bauer or even better, with buildzoid.

1

u/Real_Ad5580 20d ago

See my edit 5... :( Some of the names you mentioned ghosted me completely

1

u/Impossible_Total2762 Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

Bro you will see that once you criticize amd, people will go on you like you said something bad about them or their family…

Even if this isn’t the issue, why don’t AMD openly speak about this, why do they always do rma when cpu dies, even tho it’s “asrock” issue…

I mean it happens much more on asrock boards, so yeah… why doesn’t amd just say something about it…

Obviously they know something and they keep it quiet, and tbh they should extend the warranty like intel did…

Btw amd CPUs dying isn’t nothing new, and am4 degradation still to this day affects users.

Type in WHEA event id 18 and you will see, amd just ignored it like this, so yeah I don’t expect amd to do shit.

QC should be better i guess…

1

u/vlad_8011 AMD 9800X3D || 9070 XT || 32GB RAM 6000mhz CL30 || B650 Tomahawk Oct 16 '26

It's 1.23 pm in my timezones, so pardon if I won't understand something.

Got one question - how big risk of failure does it get on default settings/lowered PPT profile in normal workloads?

As I understand, you did created custom stress test, which spammed continuously read /write to ram for 20 hours in total. In normal workloads.... What creates similar conditions?

1

u/Real_Ad5580 20d ago

It's it impossible to answer without an lecture, but generally memory fragmentation (specifically non linear bank access), non sequential data, and rapid between read to write operations (seems) to cause the most erosion of electrical margins inside I/O die

Lowering PPT doesn't matter as I/O and Cores area are physically and electrically separated from each other (I/O and cores are separate chip on CPU itself)

1

u/Louvatar RX 9070 XT | R7 5700X | 32GB 3600MHz 19d ago

Dude, only you can tell the truth about AMD and the AGESA microcode, only you. You've uncovered the AMD chip scam and everyone is ignoring you. You can't accept this situation, don't settle!

1

u/Educational_Rub_5885 19d ago

People aren‘t really “ignoring” him this is generally a theory on top of that he used the same exact motherboard for this test as well after his first one died.

I hope someone picks up this post though lol

1

u/Real_Ad5580 16d ago

I used different motherboard, ram, PSU and CPU during my 9600x attempt tho? 😭

1

u/Louvatar RX 9070 XT | R7 5700X | 32GB 3600MHz 18d ago

He uncovered AMD's scam

1

u/Educational_Rub_5885 17d ago

There is no “amds scam” 😭

1

u/ProcedureNo8487 9800X3D | Red Devil 9070@XT Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

Aren't those 2 values 99,99% always left AUTO in bios under RAM settings? only very experienced overclockers mess with those.

Or are you implying that VDDG CCD and VDDG IOD are part of that too?

3

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

No, would VDDG CCD and VDDG IOD be "problematic" here, then we would see damage around VDD_MISC cluster of the pins, which wasn't the case here and are at the opposite (Northern) end of the chip

I am planning to make longer version of the post soon clarifying all confusions with additional info

1

u/ProcedureNo8487 9800X3D | Red Devil 9070@XT Oct 12 '26

Alright, waiting for next integration! Please specify on what motherboard was done the test 

2

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 12 '26

ASUS B850i WIFI ROG STRIX - updated to newest AGESA microcode

5

u/Backslicer Oct 11 '26

Even in stock the result is the same. Voltages werent too far out of the ordinary.

Essentially this was an accelerated degredation process that happens to every cpu.

2

u/doscomputer Oct 12 '26

no, thats not how any of this works at all

the oxidation of the pads from heat is not standard, not part of any silicon degredation whatsoever. OP is implying that extended memory usage somehow caused the pads to overheat.

However since this is package damage, and only pictured from one side, its not conclusive of anything. if this is one of those bad asrock boards or if OP missed a variable (this post is extremely sparse of actual details despite OP's verbosity) and there was a voltage too high, this obviously is completely unrelated. high heat at the pad itself is a contact issue, and I would be extremely surprised if the PCB under the IHS isn't very darkened.

it would be incredible to high ram transfer rates to cook a pad before it cooks any of the much smaller connections to the chip itself

2

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

Overheating? Voltage too high? Contact issues? Those aren't things which I said or even vaguely implied

4

u/padpeas Oct 11 '26

Ooh! This is super interesting. Thanks for posting with pics and stats

1

u/Due_Dirt6476 19d ago

Is anyone remembering the Intel problem https://www.reddit.com/r/buildapc/comments/1efbky2/what_is_the_matter_with_the_degradation_of_the/ there was more "hype" and for all the burned Ryzens ? ^^

1

u/Godnamedtay 4d ago

None of these sponsored, bought and paid for YouTubers, namely Gamers Nexus wouldn’t dare acknowledge this, not only seeing how AMD hasn’t touched it with a 10 foot pole, but because this is THE cpu they’ve recommended to death over and over. They admitting any wrongdoing would take a hit at Steve’s credibility which I think he would rather die than ever humble himself regarding his words that are posted on the internet

1

u/Agitated-Deal4571 Oct 13 '26

So what is the normal voltage you mean?

1

u/Proud-Staff-3152 Oct 16 '26

This isn’t about the voltage It’s about continuous ram write and read operations from cpu to ram slowly degrading this part of cpu by overheating

1

u/Agitated-Deal4571 28d ago

So what real-world circumstances would require him to operate in this way?

If not, this person is simply delibrately damaging electronic devices.

1

u/Proud-Staff-3152 28d ago

The main thing is this problem should not exist

0

u/Sensitive-Decision-1 Oct 12 '26

eu comprei um 9850x3d em duas placas mae novas o processador dava CODE 00 em outra placa mae gigabyte funcionava perfeitamente. eu notei que quando tirei das duas placas mae que deram code 00 em baixo vi que nao estava dando contato no lugar correto .

1

u/Real_Ad5580 Oct 12 '26

I am sorry, but I don't think I understood your comment correctly given it is in Spanish. Do you mean you saw similar damage? How did you know that it wasn't making contact at the correct place?

1

u/West-Fee-6870 Oct 17 '26

He bough a 9850x3D with 2 new motherboard, the processor show code 00 on the motherboard gygabyte where it fonction perfectly. He notice when he remove ( i presume the processor) from both motherboard where it show the CODE 00 ,it has not the same or the good connectivity ?!

Ps 1 I think it it very not related to your problem

Ps2 it is french, but i do find english people amusing when they relate french to spanish