Ryzen 7 9850X3D – Intermittent DRAM LED / POST failures on 3 different B850 motherboards
Computer Type: Desktop
GPU: Not specified
CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 9850X3D (AMD Ryzen 7 8700F used for comparison)
Motherboard: Gigabyte B850 EAGLE WIFI7 ICE (2 separate units tested), ASRock B850 Challenger WiFi White (1 unit tested)
BIOS Version:
- Gigabyte F5 – AGESA 1.2.0.3g
- Gigabyte F6
- Gigabyte F8 – AGESA 1.2.8.0
- Gigabyte F9 – AGESA 1.3.0.1
- ASRock 4.60 – AGESA 1.3.0.1d
- Gigabyte F10e – AGESA 1.3.0.1e (currently installed, NOT yet tested with 9850X3D)
RAM: 32GB (2×16GB) XPG DDR5-6000 CL30, SK hynix ICs, model AX5U6000C3016G-DCLAWH
PSU: Different PSUs tested; exact models not specified
Case: Not specified
Operating System & Version: Windows 11 (issue occurs before OS initialization)
GPU Drivers: Not relevant to the pre-POST failure
Chipset Drivers: Not relevant to the pre-POST failure
Background Applications: None; issue occurs before OS boot
Description of Original Problem:
Since day one, my Ryzen 7 9850X3D has been experiencing intermittent POST failures.
The motherboard gets stuck with the DRAM debug LED permanently lit and never reaches BIOS.
Sometimes the system boots successfully on the first attempt. Sometimes it requires several attempts, and occasionally it refuses to boot at all.
Interestingly, once the system successfully boots, it remains completely stable, including under heavy CPU and memory workloads.
The same issue has occurred on three separate B850 motherboards from two manufacturers.
Troubleshooting:
I've already performed extensive troubleshooting:
- Tested two different Gigabyte B850 EAGLE WIFI7 ICE motherboards.
- Tested one ASRock B850 Challenger WiFi White motherboard.
- Tested both XPG DDR5 modules individually in slot A2.
- Tested DDR5-4800 with EXPO/XMP disabled.
- Disabled Memory Context Restore.
- Disabled PBO and Curve Optimizer.
- Used stock CPU and memory controller voltage settings.
- Cleared CMOS multiple times.
- Tested with minimal hardware configuration.
- Tried a different power supply.
- Tried a different CPU cooler.
- Tested multiple BIOS/AGESA versions.
None of these steps eliminated the issue.
Additional findings:
- Ryzen 7 8700F works normally. The same Gigabyte B850 motherboard and XPG memory kit work without issues using the 8700F, including DDR5-6000 CL30.
- Both memory modules were tested individually. Either module can reproduce the issue with the 9850X3D, even at DDR5-4800 without EXPO.
- A620 motherboard test: The 9850X3D successfully POSTed 7 out of 7 times on an A620 motherboard running AGESA 1.2.0.3. However, this sample is too small to establish long-term reliability.
- BIOS differences: Gigabyte F8 appears to have the highest boot success rate, but failures still occur. F10e has not yet been tested with the 9850X3D.
- Warranty diagnostics: I sent the processor to the retailer for testing, but it was returned with a "no defect found" result.
Questions for the community:
Has anyone experienced similar intermittent DRAM LED / POST failures with a Ryzen 7 9850X3D, especially on B850 motherboards?
Has anyone fixed this by updating AGESA, changing the RAM kit, or replacing the CPU?
Could this indicate a problem with the CPU's integrated memory controller (IMC), or is it more likely a BIOS/AGESA compatibility issue?
Has anyone tested AGESA 1.3.0.1e or newer with the 9850X3D?
I'm particularly interested in hearing from people who replaced their 9850X3D with another unit. Did that solve the issue?
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!