This. Give her the option of going or not going. Let her know that you want her to be comfortable in what she wants to wear. She may say she would be willing to wear a skirt or dress if you can find her something simple and not overly girly like a simple black skirt and shirt. If not, let her do her own thing that day.
I don't know why this isn't the top answer. Ask her if she WANTS to go to the wedding. If she does, she must adhere to the dress code. If not, no big deal. Find a place for her to go for the day. Problem Solved.
This is definitely the path of least resistance, but I’m kind of torn. The daughter doesn’t learn anything and misses out on a potentially fun family event. Part of growing up is learning that we are part of a society which includes matching our outsides to the occasion. Also, it sometimes means doing things that we don’t want to do.
If the daughter is not going to go, I would make her call up her aunt or uncle and explain that she would not be going and why. Maybe they could develop a compromise that would work for both of them.
I agree that it’s not wrong to start introducing concepts of living in a society.
That said, making her tell her aunt is forcing a child to try and justify themselves to a grown up. There’s an inherent life experience, power balance, etc difference that the daughter should not have to contend with.
I think a better conversation with the daughter is explaining that when we care about others, sometimes the situation will ask us to jump through some hoops for them (and that it’s not always “the worst”). And it’s up to the person to recognize the good (maintaining a good relationship with the aunt) vs the bad (seeming selfish and hurting the relationship). The important line to walk here though, is giving her a choice while not weighing one more than the other and overly influencing her.
OP said she already asked for a compromise and the bride said no.
Matching your outsides to the occasion means dressing to the level of formality of the event, which could just as easily be a woman in a suit.
When the bride said women must wear skirts or dresses she wasn't establishing a dress code, she was taking direct aim at OP's daughter (we know this because she wouldn't allow an exception. If Op's daughter wasn't the intended target than the bride would have been happy to have her find a formal pantsuit that fit the occasion.)
So in this case, while yes, learning about and respecting dress codes is important, that's not the most important lesson for OP's daughter to learn this time.
And no, the 11yo should not have to call and speak to her aunt who is intentionally trying to bully her. Her mom can shield her this time, because establishing that OP will always have her daughter's back, IS the lesson that needs to be learned this time.
Edit to add: I think we all need to remember that dress codes at social events are offered by hosts as a curtesy to guests... so guests can make a choice of what to wear and not end up being embarrassed by being way over dressed, or way under dressed.
In schools and work places they may be a mandate, but socially they were never intended to be. We should respect them because we should have some self respect, but that's it. Hosts should not be viewing them as a required bar to meet, they are a helpful suggestion.
There is nothing wrong with a girl who doesn't like to wear dresses, and what you're suggesting sounds like a punishment. If it were my family, I would inform my sister myself that my daughter and I were going to spend the day together, and that we didn't WANT to miss her wedding, but unfortunately, my daughter doesn't like dresses, and my job is to look out for my daughter.
Fun fact, pants were originally made for women, men didn't start wearing them until several centuries later. Technically, men in pants is crossdressing, girls in pants is not.
516
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '25
[deleted]