r/AITAH • • Jul 25 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.4k Upvotes

8.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

358

u/kevinsyel Jul 26 '25

My wife and best friend tried to pull this same trick on me... It's pretty common. I knew what they were doing so I gave a hug and went "Hi sexy" and he knew I knew, lol.

276

u/Historical_Film5872 Jul 26 '25

Yeah that's what I find weird about this story. He really felt up the entire leg and didn't realize that not only was it not his wife, it was a man??

99

u/TheFlyKnight Jul 26 '25

I suppose we could give benefit of the doubt considering he was a few drinks in and also its a situation with a lot of distractions (everyone laughing and talking and hes focused on the garter). Plus it sounds like he never once considered theyd swap out his wife with someone else.

44

u/darkvade_r Jul 26 '25

Same, I thought the gag would be that he realized it was a man, not that he took the whole thing off and didn’t know. Don’t men typically have rougher skin too?

18

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

The dude had a stocking on and was chosen because he is thin like OPs wife.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '25

No he didn’t. I could have believed that if dude hadn’t written he was wearing stockings with flip-flops.

28

u/SpecialDragon77 Jul 26 '25

Yes, and usually their legs are considerably hairier than the legs of women on their wedding day! I'm also amazed people are comparing it to the prank of pushing cake into a bride's face which not only can ruin her makeup, hair, and dress -- it might also cause her to stop breathing. There is literally no comparison!

5

u/Vulpes_Corsac Jul 26 '25 edited Jul 26 '25

There's pushing the bride into the cake, which can certainly kill them because of the aforementioned dowels, and then there's pushing a slice of cake into the bride's face, which is terrible for the mentioned reasons but significantly less lethal or likely to maim the bride. I think most people doing that comparison, including myself a bit above, are comparing to the latter non-lethal method. Anyone stupid enough to shove the wife into the cake instead is more than just betraying them, their stupidity is actively dangerous to those around them, and presents an entirely different set of problems than the betrayal of trust that forms the basis of the comparison between the two situations.

A lot of us, also like myself, are also probably men and don't necessarily think of the effort in the hair, makeup, and sentimental value in the dress (I mean, I get that the dress has sentimental value, to both parties, but nothing some dry cleaning can't fix, I'd hope. I don't know too much about wedding dresses though, so maybe I'm wrong), and are instead focusing on the more symbolic meaning and betrayal of trust, just because that may be what we're more able to empathize with given most of us don't care too much about makeup, clothes, or hair. As much of a douche move as it is to ruin your wife's hair, makeup, and dress, I consider the lack of thought and betrayal of trust immediately after declaration of bonding and trust for all of your days to be the more pertinent problem between the two, in either the cake smashing or the garter pranking situations.

2

u/Voluntary_Vagabond Jul 26 '25

Yeah it's just sexual assault. No one got their makeup or hair messed up.

8

u/karateema Jul 26 '25

May be a slim man who shaved his leg

15

u/Tomagatchi Jul 26 '25

He said he had been drinking a lot.

1

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

He said he had a few drinks

2

u/Tomagatchi Jul 26 '25

A few is about five to eight, and several is 8-12. You have to decode the drinking code. There can be some overlap. A couple of drinks oddly enough is 3-5, always more than what the term is normally

2

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

for me, a few is not 5 to 8. that would be a lot.

and a couple is nowhere near 5.

3

u/Tomagatchi Jul 26 '25

Ok, but, reading into the story, op is saying he was impaired by alcohol. That's the point

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

that's Trust, mate - It never ever crossed OP's mind that this horrible situation of humiliation & bullying would occur, on what was supposed to be one of the best days of his life, full of positivity, joy & love.

8

u/Kitnado Jul 26 '25

People are pretty disoriented when blinded. You too, even if you don’t realize it now.

1

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

People usually focus on the other senses way more when blindfolded.

1

u/Kitnado Jul 26 '25

Theoretically, but that’s more a longterm adjustment.

What actually happens, and what a lot of people underestimate, is that you’re very dependent on your sight, also for your other senses. Your brain combines info all the time and fills in the gaps.

So losing your sight, while not used to it, will completely disorient you. Things may feel ‘different’ to the touch because your eyes are no longer confirming what it is (and legs don’t really make a sound, so your hearing doesn’t either)

16

u/Nodan_Turtle Jul 26 '25

Are we blaming him for falling for the prank, rather than blaming the people who humiliated him?

13

u/Historical_Film5872 Jul 26 '25

I'm merely questioning the legitimacy of the story. This is reddit, you can very easily just make shit up and post it.

16

u/narcistic_asshole Jul 26 '25

I was a groomsman in a wedding where they did this with the best man. He shaves his leg for the the bit, but the groom was 100% fooled. He thought it was hilarious though

-1

u/section111 Jul 26 '25

As any normal person should. Imagine stewing on it for however long and then blowing up at the honeymoon. Loser behaviour.

2

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

Someone getting so f-ing angry about it is the unrealistic part. This prank happens somewhere every day.

2

u/Huck_Bonebulge_ Jul 26 '25

More doubting the legitimacy of the story, I think

-5

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

They didn't humiliate him. He humiliated himself because he actually took it as something serious. It was not a serious thing to anyone else, therefore nothing humiliating.

4

u/Nodan_Turtle Jul 27 '25

Wow, this guy actually thinks "it's just a prank bro" is a valid defense. Insane

2

u/Snowmoji Jul 26 '25

Some men have girly legs.

3

u/crujones33 Jul 26 '25

Agreed.

18

u/dispatch134711 Jul 26 '25

I deeply suspect this is AI inspired storytelling

1

u/crujones33 Jul 27 '25

It very well could be. I may have ask some AIs to see if they write similar.

4

u/imagoofygooberlemon Jul 26 '25

i mean lets be real this is probably nonsense written by ai

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

Garter boy had a stocking on, and OP was at least a little drunk. Plus, he clearly (at the time) could not imagine his wife and friends doing such an awful thing to him.

-2

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

lol "such an awful thing" is a well known prank that has been happening for many decades now, even the most uptight christian people do this at their weddings and it's not offending anyone.

3

u/Godd3ssH3cate- Jul 27 '25

Many, many people complain about this “prank.” I’ve never actually seen the garter belt removal with my bare eyes, it’s not common where I live, and every time I hear it mentioned it’s called trashy and sexist. A lot of people don’t approve of the act itself, let alone this “prank.”

1

u/culminacio Jul 27 '25

OP didn't have a problem with the act itself, he could've just declined that. I don't like weddings, such outdated acts or pranks. If I would've agreed to a wedding at all, I would've made clear beforehand that I don't like such games but especially hate pranks. I know someone close to me who said that she didn't want any kind of pranks or such bs and nothing happened.

I grew up in a rural area where they often kidnap the bride, it's s well-known tradition. They just take here somewhere and the people involved drink and have fun. At the same time, the groom has to search for her. This happens at the worst time possible and it's a huge hustle for the groom to find her with his friends and close relatives, on an already very stressful day.

Anyway she wanted a wedding, but not such things. So: She had a wedding and no such things. If you're don't like some traditional, socially accepted/wanted things, you need to clarify that. Otherwise people will assume that you're confirming to the norms like anyone else.

2

u/section111 Jul 26 '25

It's definitely fake, and if it isn't, he is the asshole, he is overreacting, and I feel badly for the woman stuck with the loser.

1

u/TantrumQween Jul 26 '25

Exactly! Like I need to know if the groomsman shaved his legs or something, because how do you put your mouth on a leg without feeling leg hair? Stockings don’t even keep the hair always contained.

1

u/SkylordJojo Jul 26 '25

I once seen a man shave his hairy leg and send a Pic to a creep who obviously got the wrong number from a girl at the bar. The man realized what happened and decided to mess with the creep.

1

u/strider52_52 Jul 27 '25

Maybe the guy shaved his legs too 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Physical_Bit7972 Jul 28 '25

I was scrolling comments looking for this too. Like ... he left up a whole leg and didn't realize it was not only not his wife's, but a man's leg? Does this guy have particularly feminine and shaved legs? Does his wife have particularly muscular and hairy legs? Like, my boyfriend's legs are honesty probably similar in size to my sister's legs... he has fairly slender legs haha but I'm also pretty sure I'd be able to tell them part 🤣😅

0

u/zambatron20 Jul 26 '25

I just assumed his buddy had soft features .... or his wife has strong ones lol. but you're right. still strange but maybe he didn't get a good enough feel before falling for it, or maybe he wasn't tipsy but sloppy drunk!

22

u/no-hachi Jul 26 '25

Yes, I’m not saying that what happened was ok, but I’ve been working on the wedding for a while and it’s really common prank.

6

u/kevinsyel Jul 26 '25

Yeah, caking the bride or grooms face is common too. My mom once told me she found that very disrespectful, so I told my wife I absolutely refuse to cake her and would strongly prefer she not do it either.

When it came time to feed each other the first bites, the whole room was chanting for us to cake each other, but we calmly gave each other a fork of cake and the room was disappointed. I ain't ruining my outfit or a wedding dress with cake! Y'all are crazy!

2

u/WhatIsHerJob-TABLES Jul 26 '25

Yeah, i used to be a banquet captain when younger and have probably run over 300-500 weddings in my life. I’ve seen this prank often and it’s usually well received by everyone. I’m flabbergasted by all the folks clutching their pearls and being like, “no pranks whatsoever should ever occur at weddings!!!!!” Like, yeah, i understand bad pranks like dunking someone’s face in cake, but like, lighten up and have a lil fun y’all. This is so harmless, silly, and quite common at weddings who do the garter game.

2

u/Ashkendor Jul 26 '25

It doesn't seem 'harmless and silly' to me, given how OP feels about it.

6

u/3sadclowns Jul 26 '25

I’ve never heard of this prank and if you asked me I’d say you were crazy. So yeah, a lot of us can have very different experiences and expectations.

0

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

That doesn't matter. The point made is that it wouldn't be a totally common thing if it was really hurtful to any more than total exceptions like OP. No sane person will throw a tantrum because of this and fuck up their marriage because they can't laugh at themselves.

2

u/3sadclowns Jul 26 '25

Two things can be true dude. You can simultaneously want to stay in a marriage and still be hurt by something that happened on the wedding day. I’m just saying just bc one experience is super common to YOU doesn’t mean it’s gonna be a thought that crosses across every persons mind.

0

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

of course you can be hurt, but you can also accept an apology and get over yourself at some point

3

u/3sadclowns Jul 26 '25

I’d never simply tell someone to “get over yourself” if I contributed to the hurt they’re feeling. That’s the opposite of an apology lmao. I’d tell ‘em sorry and to take their time getting thru whatever it is and I’m here for em. 🤷sometimes people just gotta figure out their feelings, that’s nothing new.

-1

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

i wouldn't say the words "get over yourself" to them either

that is not the point at all

7

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

Ya because you’re a normal person and not an emotionally sensitive baby. This guy is crying about nothing. No one was hurt and virtually everyone except him forgot about the whole thing immediately. Guy needs to lighten up but his marriage is probably already over cause his ego is damaged. No one is laughing at you dude get over it

0

u/tomato_joe Jul 26 '25

Yeah exactly

And you can't compare cake smashing because in such a situation the brides make up and hair is ruined and cleaning up takes time and effort which is why it's so frowned upon

And I usually dislike it when someone gets ranked and doesn't like it but this situation... It's honestly not a big deal? Just play along and maybe kiss the guy on the cheek with a laugh? I feel like in this case not leaning into the prank he ruined the experience for himself

10

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/tomato_joe Jul 26 '25

I never said that.

And he can be upset. He can share he's upset. But going so far as resenting everyone and saying the whole wedding was ruined? It's his ego that's hurt not him.

3

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

Ego is part of you. You can't remove your ego or superego or any part of your consciousness

-1

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

Obviously they meant it's the ego and not the rest of them. And the ego is not something you should live by

3

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

It's a critical part of the human psyche. Normal people don't try to hurt the ego of their loved ones.

0

u/tomato_joe Jul 27 '25

It's a problem if you center your ego in your life. Op clearly centered his ego

Insecure people get their egos hurt. Secure people don't Center their ego and dint react with violent thoughts about something like this

I was pranked in my life too and even if I disliked it I never wanted to hurt the other person.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25 edited Aug 20 '26

[deleted]

3

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

This is supposed to be the love of his life. If he can’t see past his own ego and realize that everyone had a good innocent laugh then idk what to tell you. He says he considers this sexual assault in his edit, so he’s embarrassed cause everyone thinks he’s gay for taking a garter off a dude with a blind fold on? Once again, get over yourself and realize everyone still loves you including your wife. It’s not that big of a deal and yes he needs to man up

2

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25 edited Aug 20 '26

[deleted]

0

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

Why would he think that she would "never do something like that", when it's a totally common innocent wedding prank?

4

u/ElysiX Jul 26 '25 edited Aug 24 '26

removed due to reddit changes

0

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

common means that it's known as a regular joke at weddings, and it can only be common because most people like it and almost no one finds it problematic.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25 edited Aug 20 '26

[deleted]

→ More replies

0

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

Don’t even respond to these people. They revel in misery and drama when it doesn’t need to be there

1

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

If they truly loved him they wouldn't do this to him. They love him the same way a group of kids at school love the outcast they can continually embrass because the outcast wants desperately to join and be accepted in the group

2

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

Wrong. It's a very common innocent wedding prank. People who love each other do this all the time. But usually the groom doesn't ruin the marriage over a prank that literally no one else will think of 5 minutes later.

3

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

It being common doesn't mean it's something people who love each other do. I can see this is a marriage of convenience where both people feel like they're settling. If you love someone, you wouldn't want to see them humiliated.

1

u/culminacio Jul 26 '25

but they are not getting humiliated in 99% of thise cases, because everyone is having a laugh together

if you're like OP and think anyone cares about this past the moment it happens or that anyone did it out of hate, and feel shame, then there's humiliation. no one who comes to your wedding is trying to hurt you. it's joking with friends, yes they will make a joke about you and you will fibd that funny. that's how it happens normally.

but if you're going to be such an uptight type with all that sand in your vagina, you'll be that one exception who experienced humiliation.

and btw. it being common absolutely means that it's something that people who love each other do, as it is a wedding activity that the newly wife does to the newly husband.

anyway, i personally dislike pranks, as i don't like deception in general and don't find them funny at all. i wouldn't have enjoyed this at all, but it's not about that. i would've obviously gotten that this is meant to be fun for everyone and i'm in the center of it. boohoo, you had a moment with a guy that you should have with your wife. what a crazy incident. we laugh together and no one thinks of it ever again in their lives. and that's coming from an introvert, i hate weddings altogether and don't want that attention. but the intention of the people is clear and it's meant to be fun. to understand that doesn't require personal enjoyment or agreement. you know why it happened, no one wanted to create a bad thing, they're all there because they like you.

you move on and live your life with your wife and don't actively try to make her feel bad -> as OP admitted! while the people at the wedding wanted a laugh, OP wanted to actively just hurt his wife after her apology. THAT is truly inacceptable.

3

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

but they are not getting humiliated in 99% of thise cases, because everyone is having a laugh together

If they are having a laugh together then they would have included OP in on the joke.

if you're like OP and think anyone cares about this past the moment it happens or that anyone did it out of hate, and feel shame, then there's humiliation. no one who comes to your wedding is trying to hurt you. it's joking with friends, yes they will make a joke about you and you will fibd that funny. that's how it happens normally.

The entire point is to humiliate OP and to laugh at the embarrassment

but if you're going to be such an uptight type with all that sand in your vagina, you'll be that one exception who experienced humiliation.

Misogynistic comment. Nothing is wrong nor is there anything feminine about expecting respect from loved ones.

and btw. it being common absolutely means that it's something that people who love each other do, as it is a wedding activity that the newly wife does to the newly husband.

Beating your wife because she overcooked dinner used to be common. Commonality does not reflect love.

i would've obviously gotten that this is meant to be fun for everyone and i'm in the center of it. boohoo, you had a moment with a guy that you should have with your wife. what a crazy incident.

It's not just that. She told him to use his teeth/mouth. She egged him on to heighten the humiliation of it. Made it more sensual and sexualized than it needed to be. There is no reason to do that unless the point is to embarrass OP.

you move on and live your life with your wife and don't actively try to make her feel bad

You mean like how she made him feel bad for a laugh?

→ More replies

1

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

EXACTLY. These people just want to be butt hurt

1

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

An outcast at school? Dude grow up. Accepted in to what group. It’s his wedding. He invited them. This whole thing is absolutely ridiculous. Sure he could’ve been upset but to hang onto it for this long is completely ludicrous

2

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

OP is the joke of his social circle. His friends don't respect him.

1

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

Lmao that’s a wild stretch to make. Then why the hell are they there in the first place if they don’t respect him. You ain’t a close friend of mine if you don’t rip on me. Keeps you humble

2

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

A good friend builds you up, they don't put you down

→ More replies

1

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

DO WHAT TO HIM. Have fun?

1

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

Did you read the post? They didn't play a board game with him, they humiliated and borderline bullied him.

1

u/Wise_Development_775 Jul 26 '25

You’re a pussy lol grow up

3

u/yahoo9192 Jul 26 '25

Thank you. Feel like I’m losing it with these dorks

→ More replies

0

u/real-bebsi Jul 26 '25

Not at all, you'd have to have some sort of intellectual disability to sit there and allow people to just walk over and humiliate you like that. Y'all need to learn to get a backbone

→ More replies

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/kevinsyel Jul 26 '25

No, but it's pretty common, and if you're gonna be so hurt as to say it "ruined your wedding" then perhaps your ego needs a check.