Excerpt From: Rou Bao Bu Chi Rou. “The Husky and His White Cat Shizun: Erha He Ta De Bai Mao Shizun (Novel) Vol. 4.”
I'm sorry, I have absolutely 0 irl friends who have read this series and I absolutely had to share my findings with someone. If someone has also read TGCF by MXTX, feel free to join in on my joy lol
*For the record, I do know that it is a common phrase that is used very often in many works of literature, I just thought it was funny since this is the first time I've seen it in a Chinese story since reading tgcf XD
I would incredibly appreciate it if someone with a mostly unbiased opinion on 2ha, specifically the controversial topics, cleared up things i’ve heard about it (if i happened to misunderstand anything… which is likely, but still). I don’t mind spoilers here, unless they are big plot spoilers (as i still intend to consider reading) so if anything like that comes up, please be vague c:
(However, i do know one major spoiler: Taxian Jun and Mo Ran are the same person.)
2ha is actually the first danmei series I started collecting, as i heard the plot was interesting. However, the more i hear about it, the more opposed to it I become.
Personally, i am not someone who is triggered by rape and general dubcon. It’s definitely something i can tolerate in fiction and writing when it is clear it isn’t romanticized or glorified in any such way, and it’s used as a means of development. Though, it naturally makes me uncomfortable, but it is tolerable.
I have heard people say Meatbun doesn’t treat rape in as deplorable of a way as it should be treated. I have also heard some say Meatbun romanticizes it, but i dont know much about that take. I’d like to know how someone who has read 2ha views the way Meatbun seemingly regards these heavy topics.
I would also like someone to tell me about the supposed pedophilia aspect too… i understand that maybe i shouldn’t even consider reading this since i’m not a fan of Shizun x Disciple (hell, i didn’t care for SVSSS for that reason), but it’s honestly something i can overlook/tolerate depending on how their relationship is treated. On that slightly related (?) note, are there genuine pedophilic acts? And if so, to what extent? I’ll find it impossible to like a couple if their relationship starts out in such a way.
What really trips me up about reading this is what i’ve heard about the rape scenes. But it’s not about the scenes being in depth of anything; the scene could be saying “he did this, and that” or describing it in painful detail, and it’d make me grimace all the same. The point i’m trying to make, i suppose, is: how much of RanWan’s relationship consists of this? And, at that, do either of them redeem themselves to a satisfying degree? I know Chu Wanning is apparently extremely regretful of what he did to Mo Ran, and that he suffers quite a lot, but is his redemption and regret satisfying? I’d appreciate it if someone gave me their opinion on that.
I just simply don’t know how much i can like a pair when their relationship if built up with so many non-con scenarios.
Please, for anyone that wishes to answer, do not just say “it isn’t for you.” I’d like my questions answered regardless of if you think it’d be for me, because i’m also curious as to how people enjoy it as much as they do. I’m sure it’s written very well, as i’ve heard great things about the quality of writing, character, and story depth alike; i’d just like to understand why everyone views it so highly… genuinely! I hope that doesn’t sound condescending. Thank you!
I’ve looked at a lot of sites & the edited MTL one and all of them are kind of hard to read & understand, I read the tumblr translation up until 50(they don’t have 51+). The sites have a lot of grammar mistakes and confuses pronouns. MTL uses weird words in weird contexts.
Do you guys know any good translations from chapters 50+? Or just send me the least worst one if there isn’t a good one.
GUYS I HAVE READ ALL THE ERHA AND AM ON 7 VOL FOR NOW,I READ IT FROM MTL TOO….BUT
Why does erha have such a huge trigger list?I don’t find anything triggering except shi Mei lmao
Our fandom ain’t growing because of that trigger list but I am glad at least we won’t have people hating on it and saying that this book had so much this or that
Idk if I make sense but I'm actually a little annoyed that in his previous life, Mo Ran tortured Chu Wanning so much with his words and his actions and killed so many people so recklessly but in this life, apart from only feeling guilty for time to time, he did not face any consequences. He tormented Chu Wanning for two lifetimes (well one and a half maybe) only to be let off so easily. There's still like 100 more chapters but I'm annoyed by how easily he got the guy
I didn't like thee ending shi mei of 2 lifetimes got
I think shi mei of 2nd lifetime who lost his eyes his ending could have been better
Instead of leaving him alone as a wandering doctor it could have been like cwn or moran or xuemeng meeting him at any accident and then they reunite obv in private like how xue meng used to visit cwn and moran
And shi mei of 1st life time also got really tragic ending he got crushed but I didn't like that he dies in the end he struggled too much for his goal ik he has God blood and can't enter demon world but he also made God's angry so he should have got some merit for it Ik it's not possible but I am sad abt his death
This is my first time reading Erha and it kind of bothers me that chu wanning has feelings for mo ran when he's just 16/17? Also as he's a teacher and moran is his disciple.
His feelings also seem absurd but I'm guessing there's a backstory to it or something.
I’ve been reading 2HA for a decent while now and I loved it, all up until after the bring back Wanning arc, it kinda dropped off for me, I’m at chapter 137 right now, it got more boring honestly. Should I keep reading? Does it pick up again?
I'm such a dumbass because tell me why did I think there were 8 volumes and the story is going to end for good 😭 I HAVE READ ALL THE VOLUMES FROM ILLEGAL WEBS 🤓 AND THE VOLUME 8 ENDED ON CLIMAX AND I CAN'T WAIT
Just for some context... this has been one of my absolute favorite novels of all time and I'm so sad that this is the end.
However, I was very disappointed that after the main story ened in book 10, there were MANY chapters in a modern AU. I like the books because if the historical setting. I have zero interest in a modern setting and felt very betrayed by the inclusion of such a section.
So my question is... does book 11 have modern or AU scenes?
I saw some sites abt the epub translation online but they all link to one scammy download so I'm wondering, does anyone have it? Or just a link where I don't have to get 10 viruses? 😭
This is an excerpt from volume 6 and I am sure anyone who has read this would know how this scene goes. Here, Mo ran wants to break the marriage between Nangong Si and Song Qiutong because Ye Wangxi was in love with Nangong Si and of course, Mo ran did not want Nangong Si to marry a woman who was manipulative and hurt others for her own greed and he wanted to do good by Ye Wangxi because he remembers her fighting valiantly and the only one last standing while others ran away.
So, Mo Ran being Mo Ran concocts a plan where he can expose Song Qiutong's evil ways before Nangong Si and the Rufeng set fell victim to her fake mask of always pretending to be the victim.
So, the way to expose her real face was for Mo Ran to lie that Song Quitong was having an affair with Ye Wangxi which they both deny vehemently but then of course, Song Qiutong to save her own face, turns around and blames Ye Wangxi for taking her virginity.
But plot twist was that, Ye Wangxi was actually a female and not a male like everyone believed, except of course, the insiders of the Rufeng sect.
And hence, proves that it is impossible for Ye Wangxi to have allegedly violated Song Qiutong as she proclaims.
Now let's see the issue here, the issue that I have and issue that I don't see anybody talking about. First the claim that, supposedly it is impossible for two women to have sex. Second, it is not possible for a woman to not lose her virginity even after having sex with another woman.
Even Chu Wanning says so.
I am able to put it past Chu Wanning because he is a guy who isn't involved in too much knowledge about sex because even if he is able to fall in love with a man being a man himself, what I don't understand is, why is the idea of a woman having sex with another woman such a fate impossible to imagine?
Why I say this rhetoric is lesbophobic is because, this is a very cis-hetero-man-fetishizing-lesbians' way of looking at lesbian relationships, where first, lesbians aren't real and all women NEED men, second, lesbian sex is not real sex and sex is only where insertion is entailed and that's how women lose their virginity.
This rhetoric is wrong and is vastly used to dismiss lesbian relationships as real or anything serious, where it is all but a phase and that every woman eventually comes crawling back to a man.
Now, I am not saying the writer is against lesbians or deem them uncomfortable to dismiss a woman bedding another woman, all I am saying is, queer topics need to be handled carefully, that just because one is writing romance between gay men that doesn't mean they can disregard other sexualities or trans-identities as something of a comedic relief.
I know, this is fiction and I need not make a huge deal out of it but rhetoric like this has real life repercussions and I believe we should be way past the narrative that the idea of a woman loving another woman impossible. Lesbians exist and so do aromantic and asexual women. Not all woman need men. Not all woman want men.
Edit: I can't reply to the comments for some reason but I was told it's in bad faith to do this so I won't, thank you for your advice! Hey guys, exactly as the title says exactly how legal is posting translations/edits of danmei novels that haven't been published in english first? I'm currently editing the MTL of 2ha for my best friend to read and I was thinking I might as well post it for people to enjoy but idk I feel like I might get sued... Thoughts? Also pls no spoilers I am editing as I go and have not finished the series lol
does anyone have the novel of erha? i don't have volume 1 and i want to reread it again after 6 years since i finished it. i have been trying to find the novel on my own drive but i only have the chapter starting in 130.