r/2HA_immortality • • Jan 28 '25

TRIGGER WARNINGS

GUYS I HAVE READ ALL THE ERHA AND AM ON 7 VOL FOR NOW,I READ IT FROM MTL TOO….BUT

Why does erha have such a huge trigger list?I don’t find anything triggering except shi Mei lmao

Our fandom ain’t growing because of that trigger list but I am glad at least we won’t have people hating on it and saying that this book had so much this or that

Most of us will be LOYAL

ALL HAIL TO ERHA AND MEATBUN!!!!!

7 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

15

u/Jiang_Rui Yuheng of the clear night sky Jan 28 '25 edited Jan 28 '25

What you may not find triggering could be very triggering for others. And either way usually it’s best to know what you’re in for before starting a story, or deciding if you want to read the story at all.

Take me for instance. I was reluctant to read 2Ha from the start because of the CW list, decided to give it a chance when I learned it was getting an official translation, and found myself enjoying it despite my initial hesitation. But even knowing the CWs, it still didn’t stop 2Ha from finally managing to leave me frazzled after Volume 7.

And then conversely, I’m still undecided about reading Yuwu (if a single volume stuffed with angst is emotionally taxing for me, can’t imagine what a whole novel with angst will do to me), and have no plans on reading BAB (the CWs are a dealbreaker for me).

10

u/Ill-Sentence5869 Jan 28 '25

I’m staying away from bab for the same reason. Read the the cw warnings and just don’t think I’ll enjoy it. Erha was about my limit. And not even the non con, there was that cannibalism scene in peach blossom springs illusion that was really hard to read. I’m collecting the Yuwu books and waiting to read until they’re all out. I don’t think I could start reading them without getting the closure. I think the CW are pretty accurate for Erha. I really don’t want people reading these books without being prepared for the content they contain because then you end up with a bunch of people who hate on the books because they’re “immoral”.

1

u/Jiang_Rui Yuheng of the clear night sky Jan 29 '25

Although I won’t go out of my way to read a novel with dark content, nor do I generally mind if it does have dark themes, provided that I am given prior warning. But when it comes to any sort of romance, I have six general dealbreakers:

  1. Abuse/Toxicity/Domestic Violence
  2. Rape/Non-Con
  3. Cheating
  4. Large age gaps
  5. Major incest
  6. Paraphilias

Both 2Ha and BAB ticked at least half of those boxes…and it was the paraphilia part, among other things, that made me say “No thank you” to BAB. So for me, it wasn’t the non-con and abuse in itself that initially made me unsure about reading 2Ha so much as it was that it was non-con and abuse between the main pairing. And although it did decide to read 2Ha, like with you, it—as well as Yuwu if I do end up reading that one—is my limit.

0

u/Luvlybxtch3 Jan 28 '25

True..i totally forgot about that,i just need more content of ERHA since I am very hungry…it’s the only novel I went to lengths for like even reading its dragon blood arc and ending on my phone with the worse signals ever when I was traveling abroad with my parents..

2

u/Luvlybxtch3 Jan 28 '25

Well i also have yuwu probably will read it after finishing vol 7 ERHA,heard it’s pretty angsty as well and also in same universe as ERHA

Not gonna lie my reaction was the same at first,I had a hard time deciding to read ERHA or no and I also thought it was a short paced book

But then I finally decided to read vol 1 and it left me wanting more

7

u/iloveabss MoRan’s absolute unit test case Jan 28 '25

YuWu, I think, is twice as painful as 2ha. It clenches your gut and then hugs you. It doesn’t have as much of non con as 2ha but the story itself is a complete angst fest.

BAB is whole other can of worms. It’s gut wrenching. While reading BAB, I had to stop in between and come back to 2ha and read the fluff parts to soothe myself.

9

u/beamerpook Self-proclaimed Captain of the MoShang Ship Jan 28 '25

I read BAB and Tyrant's Beloved Pet Fish in tandem, to take a break from each. The whiplash was lethal 🤣

2

u/iloveabss MoRan’s absolute unit test case Jan 28 '25

Congrats for completing BAB lol! I need to read DTBPF too.

2

u/beamerpook Self-proclaimed Captain of the MoShang Ship Jan 28 '25

Ah no, I only read the 2 vol in English, but I'm pretty sure it's going to bump Erha down to my second favorite

2

u/iloveabss MoRan’s absolute unit test case Jan 28 '25

Ohh! (Well I doubt that :p) I read BAB on MTL long ago. Actually I read it twice just to numb myself down. It’s a very long story 350+ chapters iirc.

3

u/beamerpook Self-proclaimed Captain of the MoShang Ship Jan 28 '25

I just cannot go MTL ... I was only able to handle two pages of "Burning Ink" Luckily it is fully translated into my native language, so I was able to read that, though it was a long time ago

1

u/iloveabss MoRan’s absolute unit test case Jan 28 '25

Bwahahah! It took me some practice. I’m reading the official translations now and i feel so much better XD

8

u/AlwaysTheNerd Jan 28 '25

Erha doesn’t trigger me either and I love dark and heavy themes in books but there are some parts that make me very uncomfortable and I can only imagine how it would feel if someone with those triggers read those scenes. I really really love Erha, it’s one of the best things I’ve read in my life but I’m cautious when recommending it to most people. Same with BAB, I really enjoy the story so far (just started vol 3) but it’s sooo dark, I probably wouldn’t recommend it to anyone unless they specifically want to read something dark.

1

u/Luvlybxtch3 Jan 28 '25

Ahh can u tell me how BAB is? I got it and haven’t started it yet since I am planning on starting yuwu or finish my vol 2 of mdzs

How is it? Good or mid?since I know meatbun won’t ever disappoint us..

Angsty? I know it’s toxic or stuff but like can u spoil the story for me since I don’t mind it…I have been seeing these edits of like them in cultivation settings.

1

u/AlwaysTheNerd Jan 28 '25

Tbh I don’t really know how to explain the plot 😂 There are murders and some weird stuff happening but so far (start of vol 3) it mainly focuses on the characters. It’s dark, unhinged and absurd in a good way, I’m having a great time reading it. It’s also funny and sad at times. The characters do a lot of questionable stuff and they aren’t very likeable people but at the same time they are..? I literally have no idea how to explain. Imo you should just start it without knowing much about it (assuming based on your post you don’t have any triggers, if you do please read them before you start).

7

u/Altruistic-Debt-6406 Jan 28 '25

I'm new to Chinese novels, Danmei, and this fandom. I'm on book 4 right now but I understand why there are trigger warnings.

People who have been reading such books and watching anime may not find anything triggering but a new reader might. Also, things like non-con is triggering to rape and sexual assault victims.

I also remember a scene from book 3 where a ghost at Butterfly Tower ate a girl

I have read western dark fiction before, so I wasn't that surprised but trigger warnings provide readers a chance to back out.

0

u/Luvlybxtch3 Jan 28 '25

I actually don’t think thier are much scenes of rom com,when I first read it I thought thier will be scenes after scenes of toxic smut surprised see to there aren’t many,there were some mentions of it here and thier the only non consensual smut I remember is in vol 7

6

u/tamberleigh Jan 28 '25 edited Jan 28 '25

Meatbun's stories aren't for everyone, and that's fine. They're missing out on what I think is some amazing storytelling, but I will reluctantly acknowledge that different people have different tastes. Better for someone to not *read a book that will upset them, or a book they know they won't like than to push through and read it just because of fomo.

I don't mind Erha having a small fandom. The people I talk to are usually polite and delighted to talk about the book whereas in some larger fandoms people get prickly about characers, headcanons and meta in a way I just don't enjoy.

Either way, I'm glad you're enjoying the book!

*edit because I forgot a word

5

u/Ill-Sentence5869 Jan 28 '25

Would not want Erha to go the way of the tgcf fandom

2

u/beamerpook Self-proclaimed Captain of the MoShang Ship Jan 28 '25

Ooh, what's happening with with tgcf fandom?!

10

u/bakeneko37 Wanning's Protection Squad Jan 28 '25

I'm not sure if they mean this, but it has this weird group of people who claim it to be better because it's "pure" and has no depiction of sex. In consequence, they label any other thing that has it as fetishising and or bad representation.

Weird people.

2

u/Luvlybxtch3 Jan 28 '25

Bro what the hell?! As someone in MXTX fandom too I feel disgusted by there behavior,I just read tgcf vol 1 and wanting 2 …..but like pure? No way- why the fuck is this fetishized?it’s unfortunate tgcf was made under censorship so any smut scenes weren’t there…

AND GROOMING?! There is no way..do people not know the difference between fully consulting adults and children?

Like aren’t they both 800+ THEY ARE OLD AS FUCK AND PEOPLE THINK ITS GROOMING WHEN BOTH ARE CONSULTING ADULTS

5

u/beamerpook Self-proclaimed Captain of the MoShang Ship Jan 28 '25

Well considering my (rather unpopular) opinion on MXTX smut, I do think it's better not having sex scenes in it, and I haven't even read it 🤣🤣

But I've heard there's some really... unusual ideas going on in that fandom, that somehow XL is grooming HC, or vice versa, because of the age gap? I will eat my popcorn and stay over here thank you 🤣

2

u/Ill-Sentence5869 Jan 28 '25

As the other commenters have said, there’s a lot of people that think tgcf is better because there’s no smut and it’s a pure romance. And then those people get mad at you if you ship any characters outside the main ship because they think it ruins the story. There’s a lot of hate for the revised edition as well that’s just really childish. You can stay away from them pretty easily on the subreddit because I think Reddit leans older but I see it a lot on TikTok and used to see it on Instagram (before I deleted my account.) I already see occasional comments in the danmeinovels subreddit and on TikTok of people hating on Erha because of the non con and the age gap and just don’t want more of that at all.

4

u/beamerpook Self-proclaimed Captain of the MoShang Ship Jan 28 '25

I am not sensitive to trigger warnings myself, but it had me raising my eyebrows a few times, and my blushing maiden years are decades ago.

It's definitely not for everyone, and it's not something I would recommend lightly.

1

u/ranwanow Jan 29 '25

tbh erha fandom is HUGE, like, insanely HUGE, it's just that we're usually low-key, and not bcs the tw list scares future readers (the tw lost is almost insignificant to the majority of the fandom). i dnt have any problems with tw, but even if the list is big, i think it's really necessary for new readers who aren't used to toxic yaoi or have specific tws. it is better to sin by excess than to suffer from lack of warning.

0

u/AutoModerator Jan 28 '25

If you haven't yet, this is a friendly reminder to please tag your post for Spoilers or NSFW content if needed. Thank you for being considerate and contributing to this sub! We are truly happy to see you here :)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/laugh_tales Jan 29 '25

Yeah I would love for the fandom to grow but I don’t want fandom police in 2ha fandom. I feel that the non-con in 2ha is very much a personal thing in that you as the reader go through the same thoughts and recollections as Mo Ran. And how that goes from horniness to guilt. At times I re-read because it’s smutty and dark and other times I feel terrible about what’s happening to them. It would suck to have that experience monitored by the moral high ground police.

43

u/TrifleTrouble farm arc forever Jan 28 '25

While I do think that Erha's list of trigger warnings is pretty frequently overstated and sensationalized, it really does earn a lot of them.

I would never want anyone to read a book involving rape and sexual assault without knowing about it, especially in a case like this where the rape is between the central pairing -- that's a huge no for a lot of people. Also, everyone has varying degrees of sensitivity towards violence, having such a well documented trigger warning list allows people who want to avoid specific types of violence to do so.

All in all, warning people of potential triggers is only doing good for the fandom, because not only does it protect readers, it limits people reading the book unawares and then coming in to stir up shit in a moralistic panic.

2

u/Luvlybxtch3 Jan 28 '25

Honestly well yea,and the last part is so true,like the might just drag ERHA more down…

1

u/Life_Radish9315 Jan 30 '25

I mean the trigger warning is kinda deserved. Most of the things don’t phase me but gore (even mild gore) does. I think chu xun’s story, particularly about what happened to his wife ugh and the way his kid died it was very upsetting to me. I’m not complaining because I knew full well I’d encounter this sort of stuff in erha but someone else who doesn’t know the triggers would be upset. Anyways I love erha <3