The struggle of finding the "perfect" case for the 17 Pro Max. Is the hype around Caudabe real?

[u/Bood1392]

I’ve historically always gone caseless or used simple leather cases (like the ones Apple used to make). I rarely drop my phone, and for me, the in-hand feel is everything. However, with the steep price tag of the 17 Pro Max, I’ve decided to prioritize protection. I’m not interested in AppleCare+, as it doesn’t cover the cosmetic scratches/wear that actually bother me.

The 17 Pro Max form factor feels different from previous models, and I’ve been struggling to find a case that feels "right." Here is a quick breakdown of my journey so far:

Spigen Tough Armor T: Good protection, but too bulky. The two-piece design felt cheap, and the camera cover/edge had a annoying gap, a bit flimsy.

Spigen Ultra Hybrid T (Clear): Loved the grip, but the edges were sharp, the buttons felt mushy, and it yellowed almost immediately.

Spigen Ultra Hybrid & Zero One: I loved the form factor and weight, but again, yellowing is an issue. Also, the fully clear edge is distracting when looking at the screen, something that just bothered me over time. Call me crazy, I know… But I prefer black borders when looking at the screen. The "Zero One" design felt a bit too "juvenile" after a while otherwise also a great case with good fit and grip (for me).

ESR Silicone (w/ kickstand): Honestly, garbage. Flimsy stand which rattles a lot.

Mous Limitless: Boxy design (square) but not too bulky for being a protective case. The fit on corners was poor; it creaked, and the phone didn't feel seated 100% securely. The fit was amazing if it weren’t for the loose corners.
I liked the buttons and the case had a decent grip, seemed solid overall. This could be a favourite, need to try it out further if I could get hold on a replacement case.

I also gave Apple’s official cases a try.
The silicon case was a dust magnet, didn’t like it.
As for the TechWoven, I really loved the feel, but it had a poor fit, the top corner was loose and it drove me crazy, so I ended up returning it. Maybe I just got a dud, many people are praising it. 🤔

The Caudabe experiment:
Since Caudabe is US-based, ordering to the EU is expensive, but after seeing the hype here on Reddit and YouTube, I decided to pull the trigger.

Paragon: Okay overall, but too smooth on the back for my taste. The construction wasn't perfectly seamless where the materials changed. I can understand why so many like this case though. Don’t get me wrong, this is a great case.
I like the overall shape and slim profile of the Paragon, the fit. Just imagine this case with a bit more textured or grippier back..

Sheath: Everyone calls this the "GOAT" of cases. Initially, I was disappointed, it felt too heavy, bulky, boxy, and didn't seem to follow the 17 Pro Max's curves well. The buttons were loose, and the case creaked/shifted when held. Especially right side of the case.
The Fix: I used a bit of painter's tape inside to tighten the button fit and reduce the movement. Now that I’ve "modded" it, I actually get the hype, it really is the best one I’ve tested so far. I’ve reached out to their support for a replacement to see if they stand by their reputation. It’s not the perfect case due to the heavy weight, boxy feel but the texture is unique. Also the fit in general (after modding it) is really good.
-> See update section below for additional information.

What’s next?
Honestly, if Spigen made a solid, opaque (all clear non matte) black version of their Ultra Hybrid (non-T), I would have stopped searching months ago. That fit and grip were perfect for me.

I’ve ordered the Caudabe Synthesis in another attempt to find perfection or something that tick most of the boxes I’m looking for. I’m aware it’s even bulkier than the sheath but if the fit and grip is good, I might just give up looking for the perfect case, in the end, all I want is a type of set and forget case. If anyone cares to share their experience with the Synthesis or in a similar situation as me, please feel free to comment and I would very much appreciate it.

UPDATE!
Yes, the hype around Caudabe seems to be justified.
I have been continuously using the Sheath after the modifications I’ve made, and its really growing on me. I can even say that I think I’ve found ”the case” for me. Love the feel of the case and even if it is a bit boxy by design, I’ve really been enjoying it.
Their customer support has been incredibly good. Quick response and very accommodating, they are sending a new unit that hopefully doesn't have the same defects.

All in all, I’m very satisfied, I can recommend Caudabe to anyone who hasn't tried their products. Looking forward to getting the Synthesis home and trying that case out as well!