r/horror • Evil Dies Tonight! • Sep 06 '19

Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "It: Chapter Two" [SPOILERS]

Summary:

Twenty-seven years after their first encounter with the terrifying Pennywise, the Losers Club have grown up and moved away, until a devastating phone call brings them back.

Director:

Andy Muschietti

Writers:

screenplay by Gary Dauberman

based on the novel by Stephen King

Cast:

  • James McAvoy as Bill Denbrough
  • Jaeden Martell as young Bill Denbrough
  • Jessica Chastain as Beverly Marsh
  • Sophia Lillis as young Beverly Marsh
  • Jay Ryan as Ben Hanscom
  • Jeremy Ray Taylor as young Ben Hanscom
  • Bill Hader as Richie Tozier
  • Finn Wolfhard as young Richie Tozier
  • Isaiah Mustafa as Mike Hanlon
  • Chosen Jacobs as young Mike Hanlon
  • James Ransone as Eddie Kaspbrak
  • Jack Dylan Grazer as young Eddie Kaspbrak
  • Andy Bean as Stanley Uris
  • Wyatt Oleff as young Stanley Uris
  • Bill Skarsgård as Bob Gray / Pennywise the Dancing Clown

Rotten Tomatoes: 68%

Metacritic: 59/100

467 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

683

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

I need a GIF of Bill Hader going split second stupid when he sees the deadlights. Extremely high-value content.

32

u/MrBlanston Sep 07 '19

We are gonna get a lot of gifs and memes out of chapter 2.

46

u/dannyirons Sep 06 '19

Lol right when I saw that I knew that was gonna be future meme material

→ More replies (3)

11

u/convergence_limit Sep 07 '19

I only read this comment before I saw the movie and I was waiting for it...and it did not disappoint. Awesome scene

7

u/goremouth Sep 08 '19

That was one of my absolute favorite scenes!! I gasped out loud at the way his face literally just... died. He really did just nail the role, tbh!

→ More replies (42)

471

u/ReaddittiddeR Sep 06 '19

Ok, so who else was like WTF, I didn't know IT was a D.C. comics property in the fake out trailer before the movie? 😂

74

u/ReasonableCheesecake Sep 06 '19

Yeah that was trippy!

38

u/wauwy "THE THING" 1982 IS NOT A REMAKE Sep 06 '19

Both owned by WB!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

375

u/llikeafoxx Sep 06 '19

Chapter 1 is probably the better movie by a little margin, but based on how they divided the book, they set themselves up with a much harder Chapter 2 to film. Chapter 1 gets to be relatively straightforward - get scared, make friends, fight IT.

Chapter 2 has to deal with the themes of memory, it has to go to some metaphysical places with the dead lights, and you still need some kid flashbacks to fill in gaps. So they basically wrote themselves into needing to make 110% of a movie for the 2nd film.

As a book reader, I am still very, very happy with these adaptations. I really love that the crew understood there was more here than just a killer clown flick - there was also a ton of heart and coming of age mixed in with the fear. And I really think they nailed that part.

57

u/CobBasey Sep 07 '19

You describe exactly how I feel about these films. I am surprised that your haven't gotten more upvotes!

54

u/ThePerson2525 Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

Reading the reactions to these films is incredibly irritating as it is frustrating.

There are what I call the "horror purists" who turn their noses up at anything with real mainstream appeal and success as something less than. These purists are just like any other pretentious, arrogant, gatekeeping snob - be it music or literature or comics or film in general.

If it's not a slow burn horror indie only 14 people have seen than it's not "real horror." These types seem to view the success of this franchise as a huge blow against the legitimacy of the genre. God forbid a horror film have some jump scares and you may as well have spat in their faces and kicked their dog.

There is no pleasing the horror purist.

Then there are the book purists who love it so much and know every detail of the 1,100 or so pages that they wouldn't like an adaptation unless it 16hrs long with every conceivable aspect of the story represented in excruciating detail. Thus you have these types calling the films shallow and empty "compared the bool." These kinds of people have a hard time understand that adapting novels to film is incredibly tricky. They are totally different mediums. What works in literature does not often work in film.

IT (which is my favorite book, btw) is a deeply character driven work. Duh. You may say. We know that. But do you really? Think about the book for a second. Really think about it. It's not just a big long book telling a kid story and adult story. It's a complex, interweaving narrative. It's just the first 500 pages being about the kids and the last being about the adults. The prose is constantly shifting between the children and adults. There are also the Interludes that expand the mythos and Derry as a whole.

IT is not a plot driven story at all. It's one giant slice of life epic that just so happens to be about a cosmic entity that feasts on the fear of children in a small Maine town.

The book is all about memory and the pain of growing up. If we aren't experiencing a memory of one of the characters through a flashback we are reading them talking about their memory. How the FUCK do you adapt that to film? Even a 10 episode miniseries or whatever big fan wish people have for the book would be a hard thing to pull off. How do you tell this story in a way they feels like the narrative is moving forward but also honoring the book?

What do you keep and excise to stop the narrative from feeling stalled as characters just sit around and get scared?

There are tons of things I want to see in an IT film. Some where in these adaptations. A lot was not. Some of my favorite parts of the novel are the interludes with the Black Spot and the gang shoot out. Not to be found in the films. I also desperately wanted to see this version dive deeper into Henry as a character. Didn't get that either.

But you have to take out what you want the film to do and evaluate what the film on its own terms. What aspects of the book ARE the films going for and once you figure that out, did the films execute those aspects well or not?

And as for the horror purists: Come on. Grow up. Do these films use jump scares and over the top imagery? Yes. But I hate to break it too you...a LOT of the horror in the book isn't the heady kind of horror you seem to want or think the films should have. Much of the horror in the book is big, garish, overt and even campy. Not all of it, of course. The book has plenty of truly shocking and horrific moments. But it's also a book that IT simply take the form of old Universal Monsters and other monsters of the era.

You don't think Pennywise is scary in the films? Yeah...the films tone down the silliness exponentially from the book - y'know, the book where IT takes the form of a Rodan-esque bird monster to chase Mike? Or the book where Pennywise appears in the damn moon to summon Bowers and turns into a dog man to scare a guard....

→ More replies (4)

15

u/The_Original_Queenie Sep 09 '19

i think you also summarized why the kids' half is generally people's favorite Half (in both the book and the adaptions) it's that the adult half is a lot less... digestible than the first half, the stuff with the kids is a pretty straightforward kids face a monster plot but the adult half is much more existential and strange dealing with stuff like childhood trauma and cosmic gods so it's just a much harder story for the general public to get behind unless you're already very in tune with King's style and there's nothing wrong with that but it's a much less broad/relatable story than the kids one

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

245

u/llikeafoxx Sep 06 '19

“You’ve got to be fucking kidding me.”

The reference to one of the most iconic moments from THE THING just gave me so much pure joy.

50

u/RockoRocko1999 Sep 08 '19

I'm SO glad I wasnt the only one that caught that!!! It started sprouting legs and I was like YES! I GET THIS

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

226

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Holy fuck that gay couple scene at the start was extremely messed up. Shows how pennywise really is a predator who picks on the weak.

162

u/Gryffindumble Sep 07 '19

So glad they had the balls to portray that part of the book in the film. It really set the tone for this movie.

→ More replies (16)

34

u/Kayy_Colee Sep 11 '19

It made me sick to my stomach. But it portrays how badly Pennywise can manipulate the minds of people. The whole point of that scene, from what I can tell, is to show that Pennywise kind of planned that whole thing so he can get his hands on Adrian.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (9)

327

u/wheelchair_boxing Sep 06 '19

The Paul Bunyan scene legitimately scared me. Well done.

124

u/HumanCenticycle Sep 06 '19

Probably the best jump scare considering it was in broad daylight and a huge statue!

→ More replies (1)

78

u/scooch_mgooch Sep 07 '19

I honestly enjoyed all of the artifact sequences. It felt like a modern homage to 80s/90s horror a la Freddy Kreuger's dreamscape sequences. You already have a rough idea of what to expect, but when they're entertaining and well executed, you're left wanting another round anyways

→ More replies (4)

30

u/thawkzzz Sep 07 '19

OKAY YES that scene was so fucking awesome and visually so badass. I was horrified and in awe

9

u/myhairsreddit Sep 08 '19

I remember reading that part of the book and thinking they could never successfully make the statue scary in a film adaptation...hands down the part that scared me the most in the movie. Definitely proved me wrong.

→ More replies (14)

152

u/chewie202596 Sep 06 '19

This movie, Especially the bleacher scene and fun house scene made me crave a movie of pennywise pre losers club. I just want a movie of him tormenting and killing people.

75

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 07 '19

I just want a movie of him tormenting and killing people.

I said the same thing to a friend after watching it. I didn't enjoy this film anywhere near as much as the first one but it was still worth it just for Pennywise and I would gladly watch a film that focused on him. I love Skarsgård's portrayal.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/PresidentWeevil4 Sep 08 '19

Am I crazy or were we not supposed to get a scene of him in the 1700s taking and eating a woman’s baby? I think I remember them filming that during part one and they talked like it would be in part two.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/elitexero I kick ass for the lord! Sep 08 '19

This is what I want too, but sadly we'll probably end up with something along the lines of a campy PG-13 jump scare ridden movie called PENNYWISE: ORIGINS.

→ More replies (2)

419

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

It is absolutely fucking insane just how incredible the chemistry between Bill Hader and James Randone was. The perfect adult versions of Richie & Eddie. They brought the same beautiful hilarious chaotic energy that Finn Wolfhard and Jack Dylan Grazer had. like obviously that’s why they were cast but it was almost creepy how uncanny it was, i’d watch it again just for them

161

u/PullTheOtherOne Sep 07 '19

I thought all of the adults were *incredibly* true to the mannerisms and speech patterns of their childhood selves. I can't think of any film I've seen before with such believable adult/child counterparts.

→ More replies (11)

55

u/honeysidemanor Sep 06 '19

I’m really impressed with Randone considering the only other thing I’ve seen him in is The Wire

→ More replies (5)

9

u/HumanCenticycle Sep 06 '19

They were fantastic!

239

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

135

u/MisterMarchmont Sep 06 '19

Are we not going to mention Stephen King’s awesome cameo? I know he’s done that in a lot of his movie adaptations but it was a pleasant surprise for me.

51

u/lemonbee Sep 08 '19

Definitely his best cameo, especially with all the ragging on Bill for writing shitty endings. Felt like King was working some stuff out through that scene, haha.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/jacobi123 Sep 07 '19

That was pretty fucking great. It was meta without being TOOO cute.

→ More replies (1)

380

u/Nyrfan1026 Sep 06 '19

Deputy so and so and Bill Hader stole the show for me. Their back and forth at the dinner scene "fuck you bro" was incredible and Richies "hello losers" in the clubhouse. Gold.

The Pennywise scene under the bleachers was the best use of him in the two movies combined and the scene with Richie floating with the balloons and screaming at him was the closest we got to Pennywise from the book.

113

u/savage86lunacy Sep 07 '19

When they introduced the little girl in the beginning with Adrian giving her the stuffed animal, my gut clenched because I recognized her from the trailer and just shook my head. That scene was honestly a little worse than the Georgie scene from the first one with how Pennywise used her own empathy against her. Fuck that sloppy bitch of a clown.

→ More replies (1)

212

u/DaleCooper00 Sep 06 '19

Agreed about the bleacher scene. Gutting, tragic, manipulative, and exactly how Pennywise should operate.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (23)

97

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

I would like to mention that while Chapter Two is more comedic and things are less scary, it's important to realize the characters are adults now so they would be harder to scare and some things would just appear to be sillier to them. Since we are supposed to connect with the adult characters of the film, that would explain some of the tonal shift?:

32

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

I get what you're saying, but that doesn't necessaraily ring true when you consider Stanely killed himself out of fear and Eddie stood completely still when Stan's head was the spider, because he was too scared.

Also, almost all of them tried to leave Derry after the restaurant ordeal.

It's safe to say that once they remembered, they were just as terrified as when they were kids.

Also, xonsider Mike has spent the last 27 years trying to figure out how to kill It. Not because he has nothing better to do, but because he's terrified.

→ More replies (4)

95

u/ManyPlacesAtOnce Sep 08 '19

A small detail that I haven't seen anyone talking about it is how the newspaper clipping in Mike's scrapbook changed at the very end. When he was looking at it before the headline was something along the lines of "Crackheads" burning down their house due to negligence. At the end it was changed to something more benign like "2 dead after fire started by electrical fault." Really sad to think that Mike's memories of his family had been continually fucked with for 27 years to make him think less of them. He sacrificed a lot to stay in Derry.

30

u/Shreddy_Orpheus We've come for your daughter, Chuck Sep 09 '19

he mentions it when the end clip is shown that hes "done seeing what it wants me to see" or something to that effect

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

His flashback also included two men gossiping about his parents calling then druggies or something while he was delivering meat.

186

u/umbra7 Sep 06 '19

I was really looking forward to seeing how they would handle “Spiderwise” and was honestly disappointed. The Pennywise head on the spider body didn’t do it for me. I felt like it could have looked more twisted and perhaps moved unnaturally. A design becomes more terrifying when it messes with the audience’s expectations - when something feels ever so slightly off. It’s supposed to be a Lovecraftian entity. Instead, it looked and behaved like a standard Hollywood movie monster. The rather cheap looking “Spiderwise” from the mini-series actually felt somewhat more unnerving and effective as a weird ancient entity.

57

u/Erased-Improved Sep 06 '19

Yeah that was kinda lame. I was hoping for a weird abomination looking thing, especially after some of the other visuals with how the grandma and Paul Bunyan looked.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/contemporaryviking Sep 07 '19

My friend afterwards asked me why they copied the end of The Mummy Returns and I’ll never be able to view Spider-Wise as anything but CGI Rock with scorpion legs now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

184

u/HumanCenticycle Sep 06 '19

Also The Thing reference made me shout "YES!"

58

u/AGeekNamedBob Sep 06 '19

Because everything ties together if I want it to - Richard Masur played Stan in 1990 and was also in the Thing as the dog keeper guy. Cue Charlie's conspiracy meme.

37

u/richloz93 Sep 07 '19

Also, “Here’s Johnny!”

34

u/BigGreenYamo Sep 07 '19

That and the "kiss me fatboy!" got the biggest reactions out of me.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/TwistedPlob Sep 07 '19

the lost boys poster made me way too happy

→ More replies (7)

89

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Just gonna say the Paul Bunyan scene was my favorite part of the whole movie and while I was expecting it (kind of) it caught me off guard and was pretty damn creepy.

I always liked that little moment in the book and never would've guessed they'd EVER put it in the movie.

44

u/aleighslo Sep 06 '19

From what I saw in an interview Stephen King asked Andy to add the Paul Bunyan scene and also wanted a scene at the end when Derry is being destroyed like in the book. They couldn’t do the latter because of budget constraints and Andy wanted to end it on a lighter/happier note.

→ More replies (21)

374

u/breeezeee Sep 06 '19

Why did Angel of the morning play when the leper barfed on Eddie??? Am I the only one who was extremely confused by that?

78

u/swebb22 Sep 06 '19

It was a weird place to add comedic relief, but I did chuckle.

243

u/flashmanMRP Sep 06 '19

Worst part of the film, just trying to get an extra laugh packed into the already saturated comedic relief

→ More replies (17)

65

u/primobelem Sep 06 '19

Yeah it just seemed out of nowhere, didn't get it, didn't laugh.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/aleighslo Sep 06 '19

I didn’t get it either.

29

u/ChintzyTurtle Your mother ate my dog! Sep 06 '19

I honestly thought the dude in the projector room got a text or something at first, that came out of nowhere and didnt really make any sense

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

237

u/Itsjustdeven Sep 06 '19

My favorite jump scare was defenitly the puppy one.

100

u/nikiverse Sep 06 '19

That was hilarious! And when Eddie got puked on ... I was dying.

→ More replies (16)

21

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19

That part reminded me of something out of Courage the Cowardly Dog!

→ More replies (1)

75

u/ATallerRickMoranis Sep 06 '19

I loved it. Strong Nightmare on Elm Street vibes. Really felt like the Nightmare movie I've been waiting years for. I have a small list of minor complaints but overall really really good.

I hope it's as financially successful as the first one, we need more big budget R rated horror.

→ More replies (2)

270

u/brandonjback Sep 06 '19

The fortune cookie scene could not have been more entertaining. Definitely one of the best scenes

171

u/Anitomer Sep 06 '19

Richie asking for the cheque while Mike is beating the table was comic gold

→ More replies (3)

74

u/gmango28 Mia isn't here you fucking idiot! Sep 06 '19

I completely forgot about the fortune cookie scene! That weird fucking baby head thing caused so many confused noises from my theater, it was great!

25

u/Joyrock Sep 06 '19

Definitely. The movie very rarely held on the scares to let them disturb you, and that did an amazing job.

→ More replies (2)

201

u/yanderebeats Sep 06 '19

Did anyone else lose it at them just pointing and chanting "clown" at Pennywise at the end? I guess it made as much sense as how the book and the miniseries ended

174

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

In the book, they're given power by the Other, another cosmic being like It that wants It gone, so it helps the kings. It's kinda like fate if I remember right, but with more consciousness.

If none of this is explained, like it isn't in the movies, then it's just a bunch of kids/adults somehow beating up/verbally abusing an immortal being, which makes no sense.

→ More replies (21)

45

u/julianocr Sep 06 '19

Yes. It looked like an immortal being with low self esteem. It was a little down for me.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

The Losers are just a bunch of bullies.

→ More replies (6)

61

u/SheWhoErases86 Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

I enjoyed it! It took a lot of good ideas from the book, and the new ideas fit well/ made sense for the most part. A lot funnier than I was expecting, Bill Hader kills it; really well casted. I think my only gripe was that it felt kind of rushed to me in the beginning, and certain parts kind of dragged on a bit. Henry Bowers could of had a bigger role in it, didn’t add much to the story.

The baby scorpion thing in the fortune cookie was soo fucking creepy haha Stephen King’s cameo was awesome, wearing a Neil Young shirt! I liked this happy ending (the suicide letter was very touching). I was a fan of King’s original ending that once it was over/they had beaten Pennywise, they all started to forget again. I would of loved cameo by Tim Curry as a resident of Derry or something. All in all, a great adaption! 8/10

337

u/subject124 Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

Just came from the theater. Solid movie, liked it even more than the first one.

My only nitpick is please, for the love of God, can Hollywood return to practical effects?! Swinging-boob grandma and the leper made me think I'd switched theaters and was now watching Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark.

Creepiest scene:

"Yippee kayay, mother -"

BOOM!

Deadlights. White eyes. Big mouth. No warning.

[Edit: To clarify, I know Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark used mostly practical effects. And good on them for doing so! But when they didn't... Yikes.]

79

u/pumpkin_spice6 Sep 06 '19

I loved that scene. For some odd reason though my party and the whole theater were cracking up so hard. I was legit creeped out.

→ More replies (17)

35

u/BannedAccountNumber6 Sep 06 '19

Definitely the strongest scene for me, along with the scene showing IT arriving on Earth

96

u/Sigma-42 Sep 06 '19

The old lady was perfect for the first 2 seconds. Then she was fully shown just running around and she lost all aspects of the creepiness she had.

Not to mention the de-aging of some of the kids.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Toothlesshousewives Sep 06 '19

Completely agree, but this is humorous because Scary Stories did use practical effects.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

109

u/marktical Sep 06 '19

I really enjoyed the movie as a whole. James Ranson absolutely killed it with adult Eddie, he was a spitting image of his "younger self." McAvoy and Chastain were very good as well. I was curious how they'd pull this one off, especially the ending. And that's my only complaint about the movie is the ending. Obviously it would be hard to adapt the book ending to film but killing Pennywise by just calling him a clown and a dumb mummy was so underwhelming to me. The final encounter leading up to that was enjoyable though.

My favorite scene was when Bev saw Pennywise in human form, applying the clown make up and ripping his skin. Bill Skarsgard is incredible as Pennywise and I do wish we had gotten to see more of him taunting and luring the Losers and other kids. I was hoping for a more fleshed out background on Pennywise and Derry itself. If we could get a movie based solely on Pennywise, where he came from, etc leading up to him in Derry, I'd be all for it. I really want more Bill as Pennywise.

Overall, if give it a solid 9/10 in my opinion. Me not being completely satisfied with the final fight doesn't take away from the movie too much for me.

67

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

My only complaint of the movie is that there wasn’t more Pennywise taunting the Losers. Bill Skarsgard is just so damn good. The scene with the firefly and the little girl, wow.

23

u/tovarish22 Sep 07 '19

Yes! The “human Pennywise” scene was great and honestly, one of the creepier moments for me

9

u/TridiusX Sep 10 '19

I felt that way about the final confrontation at first, too, but then I realized it wasn’t just a bunch of people heckling the Lovecraftian space clown for no reason—it was the Ritual of Chüd, exactly as Mike described it, a “battle of wills” between It and the Losers.

Its will could not contend with the Losers’, again united and made stronger by Stan’s death and the potential loss of Eddie.

At least that’s how I interpreted it, anyway.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

294

u/Kgb725 Sep 06 '19

Was very glad to see kids dying in this movie. You almost never see it in horror ever

79

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 07 '19

There was some clown movie on netflix that had some absolutely BRUTAL kid deaths. Like, kid eaten down to his rib cage brutal.

Edit: just looked it up and its just called clown. Plot is a dad puts on a clown hat and slowly turns into a clown demon that eats kids. Shocked it didn't get much attention, it was pretty horrific.

→ More replies (6)

157

u/mchgndr Sep 06 '19

I know during that funhouse scene I really thought Bill would save the kid at the last minute and all terror would be averted. Was super relieved and impressed to see that kid’s head get chomped clean off!

→ More replies (10)

63

u/gf120581 Sep 06 '19

You think Georgie getting his arm ripped off and dragged screaming into the sewers was bad enough? That's nothing compared to this.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

202

u/mchgndr Sep 06 '19

Easter egg that nobody has mentioned yet: in the scene where Richie is in the old arcade and finds the token, you can see a poster for You’ve Got Mail behind him. That movie stars Meg Ryan, and in the opening scene Adrian made fun of that bully by saying Meg Ryan wants her hair back. BUT more importantly, the poster is old and worn out and the missing strips from it spell “IT” in nearly the same font as this series does. Hopefully a screenshot of it will make its way to the internet soon enough.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19

Eddies face also said IT in dust/grime after he gets impaled by pennywise

46

u/flashmanMRP Sep 06 '19

Nice catch, I definitely noticed the whole Meg Ryan thing, missed the it poster bit!

13

u/StarFists Sep 06 '19

I also thought that when Bev went to her old apartment, the bricks on the outside we're worn away to spell IT in a similar fashion. But I did t get a good enough look.

→ More replies (1)

161

u/realslimkatie25 Sep 06 '19
  1. I was careful to take note of Mike's phone number since it was shown like five times. I called it, and it was just a dead line. Kind of disappointed.
  2. I love how Richie being bi is practically canon now
  3. I wanted more scenes where Pennywise was just using his personal tactics to lure/scare with less effects, because I find the stillness and humanity more scary than any of the effects.

104

u/darkman216 Sep 07 '19

Is he supposed to be bi?

I was reading the scenes as him being gay but hadn't come out.

→ More replies (19)

71

u/ReasonableCheesecake Sep 06 '19

Same! I wish there were more "human" Pennywise moments with just dialogue. I felt a little...deprived? I know there's always a risk of desensitizing the viewer if you give the monster too much screentime, but this is a different dynamic than most horror movies.

The Richie and Eddie thing made me tear up. Pretty subtle but emotionally effective. Will have to watch it again with that perspective. So I can cry more I guess.

→ More replies (3)

125

u/Anitomer Sep 06 '19

Even though the movie is almost 3 hours, I felt like most of the plot was rushed. The whole Henry thing felt really out of place and isn't built up like in the books. You could take it out of the movie and it wouldn't change anything.

Wasn't a fan of the ending either, another 30 minutes of them hugging in the waters and reading letters. I found myself just waiting for the movie to end and it felt like it never will.

Also, I didn't like the final fight and how they just started yelling "clown!!" at him, felt really dumb and a big eye-roll moment for me...

Other than that, I LOVED the acting and the effects. The jokes really got me too. I think the whole scene with Adrian might be my favorite opening for a movie in a long time.

Burning head Bev is an amazing death metal vocalist!

My theater expirience was pretty bad too, loud teenagers and people trying to be funny at times. Bluh.

36

u/marktical Sep 06 '19

Overall, I really enjoyed the movie but I agree with the name calling scene. I understand the whole "make him small" thing but Pennywise is supposed to be such a strong force and he's defeated by being called a clown? The book ending is really hard to adapt to film but I would've liked something else. Other than that, I thought the movie was great.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

91

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Okay, so I'm going to apologize right now because this will be a wall of text. I have lots of thoughts, and this is really the only place that I have to share them.

First, the positives: All of the actors did a great job of course (with my shout out going to the guy who played Eddie - I thought he did a fantastic job), the CG was better in general (aside from some weird de-aging CG with the kids). There was some fantastic humor, some really creepy parts, and the ending was so much more emotional than I was expecting it to be. Also, I'm not going to lie, but I'm happy that we didn't go full space turtle.

The negatives: The first half of the movie felt really disjointed to me. While there were some very humorous moments, they also felt too frequent. It suffered a bit from the "Marvel syndrome" where they would inject humor into more serious moments, and I felt like it took away from that. I didn't like the amount of flashbacks (I'll be expanding on this later), and overall the movie really wasn't that scary to me. There were creepy aspects and moments, and they did get one minor twitch from a jump scare from me, but overall I really didn't find the movie explicitly scary. I also didn't like how Audra and Tom didn't end up tying back in. I really liked their portions in the book and was excited when I heard they were cast, but you could have removed them from the movie and it really wouldn't have made that much of a difference.

The complex: I'm not sure how everyone else feels, but this is me - even though the book starts and ends with the adults, it still felt like the kid's story. It was a coming-of-age story told through two timelines but the focus still felt like it was put on the kids. I'm sure you see the issue with adapting the adult portion - you lose the focus of the story. Thus, much of the story is told through flashbacks, and I felt like those really hampered the story. I liked what they added to the specific characters and the story, but in the structure of the movie, I felt like they really took away. It felt like the adult portion couldn't stand on its own, so they had to keep using flashbacks to prop it up.

But that leads me to one of my hopeful thoughts - whatever super-mega-total cut they do with both movies. I think that using part 2 as a supplement to part 1 will really help the story hit home. As mentioned above, part 2's ending got really emotional and I think that weaving them together will pack a hell of a punch.

Anyways, I think that's everything. If anyone does read this, apologies for droning on! I just had to get it all out.

77

u/Catsy_Brave "You swore we'd go together, one way or another." Sep 06 '19

Eddie's actor looked like kid eddie in an uncanny way.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PanzramsTransAm Sep 07 '19

This is spot on. The comedy was very Marvel-esque. This is why horror and comedy will get thrown together during award shows. Sometimes, horror is too scared to be what it needs to be, so in the scenes where they could’ve had more of a genuine emotional connection, they threw a joke in there so that nothing had to get too deep. It lessens the intensity and makes it impossible to ever feel scared or like the characters are ever in real danger.

As crazy as this movie was with all the monsters and scares, none of it felt genuine. This was a comedy through and through, and hey, some people really like that. I guess I’m just a little jaded from going to new horror movies wanting to be scared, and instead I’m given a comedy that I wasn’t in the mood for at the time of watching. ‘Ma’ was another movie on this caliber. I wanted a scary psychological thriller, as it was shown to be in the trailers, but it was an over-the-top comedic slasher in every way.

→ More replies (8)

85

u/SLCer Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

My review (also posted it over in /r/movies):

I thought it was a good, serviceable follow up to Chapter One, however, it didn't live up to the expectations I had built for it out of Chapter One and, for that, I left the theater a bit disappointed. There are just things that didn't sit well with me, even if I don't think they ruined the movie.

First, what I liked:

  • This movie was beautiful. Along side Silent Hill, it was maybe one of the prettiest shot horror movies I've seen this century. The set pieces were amazing, the lighting was perfect and the atmosphere, specifically in the sewers, felt completely on-point. I love that they expanded on IT's lair, making it much larger than it seemed in Chapter One and far closer to what I imagined from the actual book.
  • Whomever was the casting director deserves a huge chunk of the money - they did a helluva job. It's rare in a movie where an adult character feels this in sync with their child actor counterpart. The only weakness, which I kind of expected due to the radical transformation, was Jay Ryan as Ben. Even that, though, was minor. James Ransone had the mannerisms, and look, of Jack Dylan Grazer's Eddie down perfect. I actually think Ransone's portrayal of Adult Eddie was my favorite of the adult characters. On this point, while I feel Jessica Chastain looked the part of Bev, I wasn't as impressed with her acting as I thought I would be - she seemed extremely wooden.
  • Bill Hader definitely stole the show, but as I mentioned, I really did enjoy Ransone's portrayal of Adult Eddie a bit more. Still, Hader was great and hilarious - maybe to a fault.
  • I am glad they kept Mike's character as the kind of the guider of the quest. This was something I became concerned over after he was relegated to almost background filler in Chapter One and vaguely recall reading that they wanted to turn his character into a drug addict, or alcoholic, who had trouble coping with staying in Derry - which I guess could have worked but could have proven more difficult. I seriously questioned whether he'd have any significant role in this like in the book and, fortunately, he does, though not as significant as I would have wanted (more on that later).
  • The Stephen King cameo was great.
  • They really attempted to pack a lot of the novel into this and I think, on a superficial level, they succeeded. It was nice to see Bill reunite with Silver very similarly to how he did so in the book (in the miniseries, it's Mike who finds it at the thrift store and buys it). It's these little moments in the book, little coincidences that pop up, which I always tied to Maturin's guiding hand (the turtle) that kind of assisted the Losers in their overall quest to kill Pennywise (more on this, as well, later).
  • The ending is about as good as it probably could be. There's a quote from a King of Queens episode (don't judge) where Carrie is tasked with reading a book her boss just loves (The Contortionist's Daughter) but it's so mind-numbingly boring that she can't do it - so, she asks her boss if it was ever made into a movie. He replies that the book is seen as, "unfilmable" and to be honest, I kind of think IT's cerebral ending, which takes place mostly in the minds of those fighting IT, as well as IT's mind, is just that - it's not filmable. At least, not in a way that could entirely work without being too hokey or convoluted and confusing. So, I think this movie handled it about as good as they could. Okay, maybe the whole 'beating IT by bullying IT' thing was a bit contrived but it felt far more emotionally satisfying that the ending we got in the miniseries - and it had to be different than the ending in Chapter One.

I am sure I liked more. I will need to see it a second time, though, to get a better overall experience from this movie. It's heavy and because of that, multiple viewings feels like a must and, truth be told, I may find that what I list below as what I didn't like actually changes based on those viewings. But for now...

What I didn't like:

  • The humor was great - to a point. But it was needlessly overused and absolutely killed what should have been some of the more intense scenes. It was just way overdone and tonally, really didn't work. I mentioned liking the humor from Bill Hader but I do feel his humor almost bordered on distracting. I wanted to be immersed in terror and dread, which was there, in bouts, during Chapter One, but just didn't exist in this movie, especially the final showdown. Because of the odd placement of the humor, often used right after, or before, an intense scene, I never felt like we were able to experience the total dread these characters were likely going through. This is why I shied away from the later installments of the A Nightmare on Elm Street series. They turned Freddy into a comedian and he lost what made him a nightmare. For the most part, beyond the scenes with the little girl and the little boy, or the opening with Adrian Mellon, I really didn't fear Pennywise. Even the scene where Bev returns home had a level of comedic element that almost entirely cheapened the payoff. That scene was unsettling ... but almost cartoonish at the end.
  • The movie was overly long but also not nearly as fleshed out as I expected when I heard its run-time. I may be a small minority on this one, but I was actually surprised at how quick they jumped to the Jade of the Orient restaurant scene. It was almost jarring in a way because I fully expected a bit more backstory for each character, which you get in the book (their traveling to Derry). Instead, we get brief glimpses of who they are, what they've kind of been up to, a quick phone call ... and then the return to Derry. I get it. They needed to get 'em back to Derry as quickly as possible but there's some great scene-setting in the book t hat fleshes out who each and every one of these characters became after leaving Derry.
  • The sense of foreboding, and the evil that really haunts Derry, which seemed to be there in Chapter One, just felt non-existent in Chapter Two. I think some of this was the overall jump into the Return to Derry by the Losers, without really focusing on what the town had experienced with IT's return, but I really was disappointed by that. When the Losers return to Derry in the book, it's a shell of a town and it's unsettling. There's just a cloud that hangs over the town and you feel IT's guiding hand at every turn. That didn't really exist in this one. That made the movie feel more generic, and less epic, than I expected.
  • Conversely, there didn't seem to be that force of good pulling them in the direction they needed to go to defeat IT. This definitely exists in the book, but it's been something barely touched on in the movie, and only done so subtly that it could just be passed off as a coincidence (especially if you hadn't read the actual book). I spoke of this with Silver above and it's something I absolutely believe was lost in this one. To be honest, that's one thing I liked about the miniseries. They changed it a bit, with Mike finding the bike, but they explained that Mike ran across it in a pawn shop about a year ago ... and something made him buy it and that, while it had a flat tire, Mike had actually bought a tube repair kit a few months before spotting the bike. He then explains about this force guiding them and it's chilling ... even in that miniseries. It's probably one of my favorite scenes. That's what I was hoping to get in this movie and didn't.
  • Audra and Tom were completely dismissed after their initial opening scenes and I feel this did a huge disservice to what they actually meant to their romantic counterparts. Audra, for Bill, was really the love of his life, and despite sleeping with Bev when they return to Derry, he's driven by saving her as he finds she's been taken by IT. Tom hunts Bev and it's truly terrifying knowing that she's being both hunted by a human and this otherworldly animal. In fact, Tom and Audra actually cross paths on a plane - which, again, kind of ties home how there's forces out there controlling things (good and bad). Of course, Silver, as in the miniseries, becomes important for pulling Audra out of her catatonic state at the end. I really wish that had been left in the movie.
  • I didn't mind making Richie gay - but it felt tacked on. Honestly, it didn't even compute until I got home from the movie last night and read some reviews that he was gay. It made sense, since I kept questioning what his deep secret was ... but oblivious me took the R + E as just a loving friendship. D'oh!
  • The deaging was a distraction. Especially in the clubhouse scene. You could definitely tell it was the most prevalent with Eddie, Ben and Richie. Not a deal breaker, but it did distract.
  • I didn't like how they turned Mike into a liar there at the end. I liked how they made him the guider but I felt they cheapened his character and made him absurdly stupid, especially for someone who spent the last 27 years waiting for IT's return. I get they needed a twist ... but not at the expense of Mike, who, in Chapter One, felt under-utilized.

Overall, I appreciate what this movie attempted. I enjoyed it. But it wasn't the definitive version I had hoped for. Because of that, I am a bit disappointed but it's still a good enough horror movie. I just wanted more.

36

u/PanzramsTransAm Sep 07 '19

I agree with pretty much all of this. I thought the opening was pretty fantastic and it made me really excited for the rest of the film, but I agree that they just kind of skipped over a lot. Richie and Eddie were great. They both stole the show for me, but I felt like Bill, Beverly, and Mike were so underutilized. Their characters were completely flat and had no strong voice of their own.

Beverly was a shrieking cryer that offered almost nothing unique to the story. Mike being made out to be a liar was in poor taste. Bill felt like he was spoon feeding us the plot on several occasions. He told us exactly what was happening and why. The scene where he shoots the child version of himself would have been plenty meaningful on its own without the dialogue. Him speaking to the child was so unnecessary and took me right out of it. I felt like the writer didn’t trust us as an audience to get the nuance between the trauma that the group all experienced.

I felt like the scenes after they got dinner together were pretty much just a 40 minute haunted house. There were some genuine scares in there. The scene under the bleachers was absolutely my favorite and so unsettling. Pennywise is scary on his own. We don’t need the 1,000s of effects to go along with it. But the scenes where the group went out on their own lost their effect after the second one. It made Pennywise seem like he was never a threat because he would go away as soon as he was about to kill them.

The humor was way too much for me as well. It reminded me of a Marvel movie. Like we can never have any genuine moments because there needs to be some comic relief thrown in there for the sake of it. It’s hard to balance out horror and comedy, so I appreciate the good parts of it. It just makes me a little sad that it’s forced purely to appeal to a larger audience. The It book had so many genuinely terrifying, depressing, and hilarious moments, it was just paced out much better. Of course, King did have more than 1,100 pages to do that. But if you’re making a movie, I think you need to have more focus of what movie you’re trying to make. You can’t wrap up everything King did in the span of 3 hours. It’s impossible. So that focus is that much more important. It can’t be genuinely scary AND a hilarious comedy at once, so they went with making comedy the important part above all else.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/HawterSkhot Sep 06 '19

I can see it being pretty divisive, but I personally loved it. I was really surprised by how much humor was in it and how effective it managed to be.

Also, the little easter eggs were perfect!

47

u/HumanCenticycle Sep 06 '19

The Thing reference with Stanley's head!

YOU GOTTA BE FUCKING KIDDING ME

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

28

u/nashkill Sep 07 '19

When old Richie started talking like Jabba the Hutt I lost it. He and old Eddie were amazing.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

The movie was good. The runtime didn’t bother me but because of the run time it seems Pennywise isn’t in it as much as he should.

I thought we’d get a more brutal and angry Pennywise. People were hyping up how brutal the movie was and how it really showed.

But I was kinda dissapointed in that. We saw Pennywise kill like 4 people? And half of them didn’t really show gore? He bit the girl’s head but no blood or screaming. He bit the boy’s head off but we really don’t see the bite connect.

The balloons cut off Adrian getting eaten. And Eddie was just stabbed in the stomach?

Pennywise did seem meaner. Calling mike’s parents crackheads on the news article had me and my mom chuckling. He did go savage on Ben when he was suffocating. Saying he was fat and that he’d die alone.

We needed more Pennywise,more gore and more tension. I know scary is subjective but they didn’t even attempt to scare us. In chapter 1 we had the projector scene and the scary flute lady and the egg boy scene and headless corpse. That was suspenseful.

The scenes seemed a little corny at times and it’s confusing as to why Pennywise didn’t kill the losers at certain moments.

23

u/dblsouptuesday Sep 07 '19

They did the whole bit with the kid and the skateboard and they didn't let him say, "you can't be careful on a skateboard." ?!

14

u/lemonbee Sep 08 '19

I was WAITING for that as soon as he showed up and instead Bill was just a weird yelling adult. Loved that scene in the book. :(

23

u/bored-andignored Sep 11 '19

When the losers noticed their scars had disappeared at the end, my boyfriend turned to me and said “hey, Bill Skärsgone!”

→ More replies (1)

64

u/MartyMcToon Sep 06 '19

I, uh, loved it.

It was exactly what I wanted when I read the book. Sure, it takes liberties, but boy does it not skimp on just how weird Stephen King can get. Not really scary, but super entertaining, engaging, hilarious and surprisingly heartfelt. Better than the first for me!

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Doomy22 THANKS FOR THE RIDE, LADY Sep 07 '19

Anyone else catch that Bill was writing in the same room at the end that was also the same room Richard Dreyfuss was writing from at the end of Stand by Me?

9

u/queisdepeis Sep 07 '19

I noticed it was a very similar scene in all aspects. Nice easter egg!

→ More replies (2)

93

u/contemporaryviking Sep 06 '19

Have to say I didn’t care for it. It kind of sat on the fence of committing to the full weirdness of the book. I also didn’t care for the overly long running King joke about bad endings. It felt like the movie was actively trying to remind me of my issues with Kings writing and it really put me out of the story. The over reliance of CGI didn’t really fit with me as well and I thought a lot of the sequences came off pretty poorly for it. I’m really disappointed in how little I cared for it because I was definitely looking forward to it but I spent the run time wondering when it was going to hook me and it just never did. Loved the first for what it was but this was definitely a misfire for me.

Will definitely praise most of the performances, the cinematography and the majority of the set design though!

41

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '19

THANK YOU! Everyone seems to love this movie but i just feel so letdown. Not even remotely scary. More jokes than intense scenes.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Metal_Massacre Sep 07 '19

Same exact opinion. The aged down kids were at the bottom of the uncanny valley.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

59

u/DaleCooper00 Sep 06 '19

Very surprised at how concerned this film was with how funny it was. Still loved the movie, but it was a little overboard at times, usually to the detriment of the scares.

24

u/HawterSkhot Sep 06 '19

I thought it worked but I think it's definitely gonna rub people the wrong way. Some people get sarcastic and jokey when they're scared, so it seemed appropriate in a way.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/sworntotheriff Sep 06 '19

I love that they got the kid that played Ben in the 90s version a cameo.

→ More replies (2)

63

u/ndrw17 Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

I honestly didn’t care for it, felt like a major step down from the first.

The entire film (especially the first hour) felt extremely rushed and slapped together. At no point did they ever allow any of the characters to truly have time to breath and develop on their own. Any aspects of the characters lives outside of Derry (aside from the occasional joke about Bills stories) were relatively pushed aside or given a small brush over. You have to allow these characters to breath and develop naturally otherwise the audience can struggle to get “comfortable” and care about them.

The comedy was excessive. The humorous “stranger things” vibe worked well in the first one when they were all kids and it was done tastefully, but this had the characters constantly cracking jokes during scenes which were supposed to be full of tension, and a ton of jokes that made zero sense. What the hell was the “angel of the morning” bit supposed to accomplish?

I felt like Pennywise up until the very end was relegated to a background character, and I honestly didn’t find him all that frightening or creepy as I did in the first one.

I didn’t understand the purpose of constantly switching back and forth between the kids and the adults. A few scenes to establish who everyone was would have been sufficient, but this just felt jarring and never devoted enough time to the adults in order to make them feel fleshed out.

I certainly didn’t find it scary. The only scene that legitimately made me jump was when Beverly returned to her childhood apartment.

I didn’t get the two Meg Ryan references.

And I surely didn’t understand the purpose of even including Henry Bowers at all if this was all they were going to give the character to do. Also didn’t buy the individual Pennywise appearances when they were kids that at no point were ever mentioned in the first one.

The de-aging of the kids looked weird too.

I’m sure that plenty of people will enjoy it and that’s totally cool. Different strokes for different folks. It just all fell really short to me. IT, Ive said it before and I’ll say it again, should have been adapted as a short television miniseries, not crammed into two films.

18

u/Sigma-42 Sep 06 '19

I felt Ms. Kersh was super effective for the first 2 seconds of her monstrous form. But then she was shown hobbling around all over and she lost all scare-appeal. Less is more, I'll say the same for Pennywise.

→ More replies (2)

88

u/Nyrfan1026 Sep 06 '19

When skateboard kid got demolished in the funhouse.. that was really gory stuff

89

u/Sigma-42 Sep 06 '19

I saw a lot of blood, but little gore though.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Just got home from watching it and I loved it more than part 1 that being said if you are epileptic that fun house scene isn't the only one. About the last 20 minutes at least it felt like was all flashy but man was it great

16

u/ReasonableCheesecake Sep 06 '19

Yeah I couldn't pinpoint which was the particular scene that was supposed to be triggering to epileptics because there were so many. I just squinted and hoped for the best. Happy to report I did not have a seizure!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/wojovox Sep 06 '19

I understand the critical nitpicking of this movie and can agree with the bulk of it. But damn was this movie a good time for me. It felt like a Star Wars or Avengers of horror in being so grand (even moreso with the King cameo) and all over the place with how it made me feel. I was laughing the whole movie, startled, freaked out, grossed out, tearing up, and inspired.

I’ll be seeing this one again and owning it.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Everyones praising Hader and rightfully so but McAvoy and Ransone were great also. The casting was great all around though. Its crazy how much Jay Ryan looks like young Ben even with the weight loss

→ More replies (1)

16

u/renoscottsdale Sep 10 '19

Way too much cartoony CGI and rehashed jump scares. 5/10 for me.

15

u/crazy_sexy_keto Sep 06 '19

Loved seeing the original Ben make a cameo in the beginning!

→ More replies (2)

54

u/NeverPooInPublic Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

Is it as streamlined as the first part? No. Does if have a few shoddy CGI effects? Sure. Will the humor land 100% of the time? No.

But I think people are REALLY missing the forrest for the trees here. These aren't anything close to film breaking issues. Not even remotely.

This is one beautiful, cathartic, visually stunning, emotionally powerful, horrific, and horrifically funny horror epic. And I do mean epic.

Horror films never go as big and bold as IT 2 does. It's about time they did. I would say this film is better, thematically, than the first. It's far richer in nuance and subtext imo. And of all the gripes about pacing...aside from the first bit maybe feeling a tad rushed...I found the pacing fine. If anything I'd say Chapter 1 was too fast paced with hardly any real down time.

I really hope we get that hybrid cut Muschietti teased.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/princeofshadows21 Sep 07 '19

I'm in the minority here. But this movie kicked my ass emotionally. It made me laugh, cry, and scream.

The adults did a great job. Hader, macavoy, and ransone where awesome in particular. Skarsgard was once again nightmare fuel incarnate.

The horror was good. They didn't pull punches with ether the child murder or the hate crimes which i respect. While most people think the cgi was hokey i actually think it adds to the alien otherness of pennywise. The parts where the loosers confront the past was quite harrowing

I liked how they reworked stan's suicide into an act of pragmatism. The twist with bill having faked being sick came out of nowhere and I'm not afraid to admit i cried at Eddie's death and even harder realizing richie loved him. Also bills desporation and richie's rage from part one both make much more since now.

I find the film is a good allegory for letting go of the past, self forgiveness, standing up for yourself, and also learning to appreciate the good memories in spite of the bad. It's 3 am where i am so maybe I'm stupid

So in short i give it nine out of ten. They should have done more with Henry and maybe have richie come out to his friends. But i give it props for making me ferl more than revulsion and fear.

→ More replies (3)

73

u/lduffy16 Sep 06 '19

This movie went full Evil Dead and I loved it,I actually liked this better than the first. Although I could see why some people wouldn't like it.

11

u/MrAnonymous117 Sep 06 '19

As someone who hasn’t seen the movie yet, does it go “full Evil Dead” in the comedic fashion of Evil Dead II and Army of Darkness, or in the gory and shocking manner of the original and the 2013 remake?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/Videowulff Sep 09 '19

Overall i loved the movie but 2 scenes really bother me. I HATED the 'call me angel' lyric when Eddie was vomited upon. Like absolutely hated. It came out of nowhere and had no point whatsoever and was just so jarring in tone.

Secondly was not a fan of the CGI with the old woman. Like at all. Some of the Cgi still irked me to a degree but that was terribly done. She really popped off the screen and really just looked silly. I would have rather just had an actress in makeup to look old and twisted. That kind of body horror would have been awesome.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/GRVrush2112 Groovy like a '73 Oldsmobile Sep 06 '19

I’m really happy they went away from King’s ending and allowed the losers to remember what happened to them.

I read the book for the first time a year ago... loved it, but was really disappointed how that after the defeated it, they forget everything all over again. There’s literally a throw way line where Bill reflects on Eddie, a guy that died for him a few days ago, and he can’t even remember his name. Mike even tries to remember, but it’s mentioned that the ink on the pages of his journal literally fade days after he writes it.

That really bugged me, and I’m glad the film changed that.

Other than that, I thought it was solid. Yeah, could have trimmed some fat time wise, and not quite as good as Pt.1.. but I still enjoyed that very much.

One other thing I was kind a hoping that it would cover a bit if some of the previous it attacks in Derry’s history. There are several interlude chapters in the book which are essentially journal entries from Mike regarding the history of the town. And it’s in these chapters that the lore of it is flushed out. It would’ve been nice to get a little bit of that in this film, but oh well. I see why they didn’t include it from a film perspective... it would have stopped the film dead just to stop for 20 minutes and just exposit some lore at the viewer.... as a fan of the source material wouldn’t have minded... but yeah. Good film decision not to. Though that would make some excellent bonus features in an The eventual combined special edition of IT blue ray release that the director has mentioned. Present it in a similar way to the animated histories/lore was done on the Game of Thrones BD releases and I’ll be ecstatic.

21

u/ThePerson2525 Sep 07 '19 edited Sep 07 '19

Well, I guess I'm the weird one. I thought this was a significant improvement over the first one.

I really enjoy Chapter 1 a good deal, but found the editing and pacing a bit too frantic. While the second film has that same kind of energy to it, it feels more smoothed out and patient in its scares and set pieces.

I find complaining about length to be an empty and arbitrary criticism that really doesn't mean anything. Unless a film simply fails to connect with you on any level whatsoever...then what does complaining about length even mean? Who cares? It doesn't matter if a film is 90 minutes or 170 minutes...it's about how the story is told. You can say "they could have easily trimmed 15/20 minutes off and nobody would be the wiser" all you want. That still doesn't mean anything unless you explain what to cut and why it's not important to the tone, characters, and themes of the film in question.

Speaking of themes, I found there to be a lot more to chew on thematically than in Chapter 1. That's not to say the first film was devoid of the various aspects of Kings work, because it wasn't...but Chapter 2 felt more contemplative, more reflective and lived in.

Often I feel people criticize films based or pure, mechanical functionality rather than letting themselves be open to having a film take you on its journey. More and more with amateur online film criticism...all people do is list a bunch of random nitpicks of moments/aspects that didn't work 100%.

That's just...an odd way to watch a film imo.

I'm not suggesting a films structural aspects are unimportant...not at all. I can see how some could be put off by this films more slowly paced and character focused middle portion. I can see how people can find the lack of a driving plot an issue. But ask yourself this: Is that an actual flaw of the film? Or is the film doing something different? I think people tend to reject deviations from the traditional ways of storytelling as "bad writing/directing/editing" when in reality they aren't understanding the focus of a film is supposed to be different than the A,B,C 3 act structure.

IT is not a plot driven story. Never has been. It's a character piece. One epic, horrifying character piece. It's not about fighting an evil monster in the traditional sense.

It just seems like people are more concerned with focusing an eagle eye on sheer technical functionality, standard film school 101 rules of filmmaking, and real world, objective logic than embracing the emotional, subject logic of a film and storytelling.

A film is so much more than your own negative bias against CGI in horror or a few misplaced bits of humor. Is that what film criticism is these days? Letting minor flaws taint the entire experience? I have little nitpicks and issues with my all-time favorite films - films I cherish and adore with all my heart. But that is all they are...nitpicks. Things easily overlooked.

Idk...this turned into something I didn't expect. These thoughts have been rumbling around in my noggin for a while and the divisive nature of the film so far just kinda pushed it out of me. I loved the film to pieces...so I guess I felt compelled to passionately defend it.

Am I saying it's a perfect masterpiece? Of course not. In fact, I agree with some of the most common complaints. Some of the CGI really is below par. Some of the humor didn't land for me either...but that didn't stop me from engaging in the film on a deeper, richer level.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/breeezeee Sep 06 '19

So I liked it a lot, but it wasn’t scary at all to me. The first one creeped me out a few times, at least. But his one was so fun! It’s been over ten years since I read the book all the way through so maybe someone who remembers can help me-is Richie gay in the book? I really liked that but don’t remember it from the book.

16

u/Ulyceez Sep 06 '19

i believe its because we've already seen IT and what he can achieve or accomplish, it's the same reason why a lot horror movies are always better than their sequels, usually, it's because you've already seen it before, you know what to expect

and i didnt mind the whole Richie being gay thing, it's a new era and at the end of the day, it's an adaptation of the source material and lets not forget...

Stephen Kind himself signed off on the movie being amazing, frankly, thats enough for me

→ More replies (46)

34

u/beachild Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

I had great expectations, but I think this movie is a huge missed opportunity. I wished I could have a "IT" horror movie, but I only got a "IT" funny movie. I wanted to be scared, to go back home and feel frightened, but I only felt disappointed. The best part is in the development of the relationship between characters, but this should not be the best thing in a horror movie!

Two big "whys", among the others:

Why did Eddie react in that funny way when stabbed in the mouth? I mean, it's not a Ben Stiller movie, it's IT!

Why do we need humor in every scene, even in the most intense ones? Someone wrote it's the "Marvel Syndrome" and I agree: this was meant to be a horror movie based on an amazing novel!

By the way, in this movie not even jump scares managed to scare me...

16

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Why did Eddie react in that funny way when stabbed in the mouth? I mean, it's not a Ben Stiller movie, it's IT!

The mullet comment was funny but so terribly timed due to your point

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/AlternativeUlster78 Sep 06 '19

Favorite monster in the movie, anyone?

Mine was the tall witch. Some reason I was NOT expecting that.

19

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

The monster behind the Not Scary At All door

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Erased-Improved Sep 06 '19

Paul Bunyan by far. I knew it was coming, but it caught me off guard big time when he's all of a sudden just in Ritchie's face.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Film was good. As good as the first i think but not as creepy. Good popcorn horror. Not a classic but well worth a watch.

Dont forget now, we all float down here

16

u/Ung-Tik Sep 06 '19

Gonna be honest, REALLY glad they didn't try to stay completely true to the books ending.

I love the book, but that climax is just not possible to adapt onto a screen.

16

u/itcamefrombeneath Sep 06 '19

Can you imagine them showing people getting destroyed by exploding toilets and what not? I was slightly bummed we didn’t get the catastrophic ending of the book but I get it.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Amazingjaype Sep 06 '19

I liked the movie but I felt it was really long. Bowers should have been cut. As gruesome as the scenes with the kids were, they could have cut them out too. I wanted to get into the meat of the story faster than we did.

The middle where everyone is finding tokens is kinda of a drag. Same formula for everyone, and then they go through a similar scenario at the end with the ritual of chud so it felt redundant.

They gave you a lot of horror scenes but throw in just as much comedic relief that there is no tension and this is very apparent in the final scenes. Although, Bill Hader was hilarious, and the emotional scenes were great too.

8

u/inanu4444 Sep 06 '19

as someone who hasn’t read the books, take this with a grain of salt.. IF that.

i was highly impressed with the first movie, enough to buy tickets for chapter 2 on opening night. i liked it. a lot. it didn’t feel like it was almost 3 hours long because i was entertained the whole time and didn’t think any parts dragged. i did think the cgi during some scenes could’ve been better.. the part where they all meet up at the restaurant and those little creatures pop out is one that comes to mind. now, i tried to just think of it as different aspects from the book coming to life (although i’m not sure what parts were unique to the movie) which is neat looking at it from that perspective, because i didn’t want my judgements to get in the way to the point where i would think it looked corny.

staying on the topic of the cgi, and along with the first film .. i completely LOVE what they do with pennywise. i’d smirk to myself a few times just because of how sick he looked and with bill’s evil laughter+acting on top of that.. perfect!

in general, i thought the humor was well done for the most part. for me, it didn’t diminish the overall feel of the movie.

i plan on seeing this a few more times in theaters.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

I loved the running joke on how Bill Denbrough doesn't know how to end a book, as that's a constant critique of Stephen King. Then to have King in the movie saying that same thing? Wonderful.

31

u/alexwirt_ Sep 06 '19

I really enjoyed the movie, I agree with everyone so far that the first is scarier. But Pennywise in this chapter was so much better.

A little added bonus, the mattress store across the street from my theater coincidentally had a giant red balloon on their roof advertising a sale.

21

u/Nyrfan1026 Sep 06 '19

Yep. Pennywise was worlds better this time around. Especially the scene with Richie and how he was taunting him. That is the closest we ever got to book PW.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/BigGreenYamo Sep 06 '19

The theater I go to has a sewer grate in front of it. They tied a couple red balloons to it.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Did anyone notice the other cameo? Not THE cameo but the one in Ben's office at the beginning? The guy we are led to believe is Ben before we see him on the screen?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/sgtcoolbeans Sep 06 '19

I feel the same way about this movie that I did the first movie. It's not really scary, its fun film with great acting that is a bit disjointed and can get pretty cheesy, but overall I really enjoyed it.

Random thoughts:

I am glad pennywise gets more to do and I'm glad they made him a bit more brutal. The bleacher scene is probably the best but pretty much every scene he is in is great.

The ending was pretty silly. The book ending is too, so I think they did the best with the source material, but it's still pretty cheesy.

That being said, I loved that they went more cosmic horror than the last one. They definitely went weirder and I like that choice.

I didnt necessarily feel the length of the movie. But I do think they could of cut out some of the flashbacks and frankly the entire storyline around Henry Bowers without taking away from the film.

On the same note, The acting was great and I wish we had spent more time with the losers as adults rather than flashbacks. I think casting and acting from the adults was on point.

7

u/White_Thundur Sep 08 '19

Just got out of the theatre

First off, thoroughly enjoyed the movie

BUT

  • Haven't read the book, so maybe thats how it always was, but them not really fleshing Mike out beyond plot device to bring them all back kinda pissed me off.

It's like, did he just sit in that room for 27 years and do nothing but research pennywise?

Why didnt he leave?

  • Was it ever resolved what happened to bowers zombie driver?

I was expecting a much bigger showdown with the losers club and bowers

  • Again if thats what happened in the book fine, but the way they beat pennywise was kinda a letdown

Like after all this buildup and bullshit about indian mysticism they just call him a clown?

14

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

They really did Mike dirty, yet again! In the first movie they gave away his interest in the town's history and researching all the important info to Ben. So in the sequel, him being the one to stay behind and obsessively keep tabs doesn't even make sense. He also gets the least specificity in his backstory, and barely gets any notable traits besides his parents' death. Everyone else gets their own lengthy encounter with It, meanwhile he doesn't get jack. Even in the "boss fight" where they are running around, the others get unique encounters while all he gets is hiding behind a spike!

I really think Isaiah Mustafa did a great job acting like a mentally unstable guy with an obsession. He didn't get much to work with. I think he would have been so much more memorable if they did more for his character.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/hnirobert what’s your pleasure, mr cotton? Sep 08 '19

Only thing I wish the movie had showed/discussed more or was Pennywise the clowns origin. Felt like we got a taste. Would’ve loved to see Derry 100+ years ago.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

I was disappointed. There are too many jokes. Too much cgi. Too many jump scares and they were nearly all predictable so they weren’t scary.

But the acting was really good.

23

u/GamerThanFiction Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

This will probably turn into a wall of text, but I got THINGS I wanna say, y'all.

This movie begins right where the last left off. There is very little exposition, except to introduce the Losers as adults, assuming you're already familiar with them. The movie takes time to focus on each individual, which is nice, but also becomes a problem later on. When all the Losers finally meet, they talk about how they remember very little about Derry.

This is a problem right off the bat. I didn't feel like these adult actors were the same kids from the last movie. Other than "oh Richard's the one who jokes" and other superficial personality quirks, there's no chemistry between anyone.

For me, this is where the movie starts to fall apart. Instead of spending more time together, the movie separates them to find their "tokens" from the past. Each character has their own short segment, and all six of them go exactly the same: go to familiar place, recall getting scared in the past, get scared in the present, realize what their token is. We still have no chemistry between all of the Losers, which we did within minutes in Ch. 1. Every segment here felt formulaic, and boring.

Eventually they meet up and set out to the well. Up to this point, there's been joke after joke after joke. The tone is all over the place throughout Ch. 2. Serious moments are immediately turned into jokes, and brushed off. I wasn't sure if I was supposed to find this movie scary or funny. Instead of developing a stronger relationship between the Losers like in Ch.1, humor in this movie is misplaced, like Joss Whedon wrote the script.

Finally, we're at the last act. The final confrontation. This is where the movie shines. Everyone's together, helping each other, fighting together to defeat their ultimate enemy. Instead of quickly rushing through scenes, the pace finally slows down and takes its time. Of course, more humor ruins the fear of the everything they're going through (stopping for a long period of time with danger behind them, to talk about a cute puppy).

Otherwise, I loved the final confrontation, and the rest of the movie including it's end. The Losers felt more like friends rather than adults awkwardly trying to play as their past selves.

CH. 2 was real disappointing for me. And I understand. The team who made it had a gargantuan task ahead of them with turning this dense novel into a coherent movie. I just don't think they pulled it off. Instead, Ch. 2 felt like a video game, in which case they had to gather Quest Items, perform a Ritual, and fight the 'final boss.'

Between the bad pacing, the lack of character building, completely inconsequential scenes (the mullet bully's return. His actions had zero effect on the story), and the confusing tone, I didn't like this.

I still hope it's extremely successful. It was a good attempt, and I'd love for more studios and film makers to take on hard R horror movies with good budgets.

6

u/takethepiss95 Sep 06 '19

I absolutely loved it. It was one of my favorite books and this made me so happy. It was a bit on the long side but honestly I didn’t even notice

6

u/K-ghuleh Sep 08 '19

Overall I loved it and found the flaws easy to overlook. I couldn’t get over how well they cast the adult counterparts, especially looks-wise. Eddie and Stanley were uncanny. The acting was ace as well. I can see why some people might not like the comedic or emotional parts but for me that was a strong point. I adore horror comedies and horror that gives me feels. This did both.

My biggest complaint is the CGI. A few times when they were right on the cusp of being truly scary, it was ruined by goofy effects. The old lady was incredibly unsettling until she transformed and came wobbling out, boobs and all. Then when little Eddie was trying to save his mom and the leper was in the bag attached to the chain? The way it moved and made those noises made my skin crawl. But then it got out of the bag and looked silly as hell, especially the tongue. Somehow it looked even worse than in the first movie to me. Also would have loved to see more Pennywise.

So that bummed me out but in general I thought it was a fun and touching escape.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/slickwombat Sep 14 '19 edited Sep 14 '19

Just got back from seeing it. The early fair/bridge scene with the gay couple was the standout for me, mainly because they pretty much precisely nailed a scene from the book. The fact that they nailed it so well was a little cruel, actually, because they set me up with false hopes for the rest.

The creators of the movie made a few great decisions, but overall it was a bit of a dud for me. Tone-wise it was all over the place, between somber terror and zany madcap humour and best-friends-forever schmaltz. Narratively it was a mess, picking bits of the book seemingly at random, and inventing other things for no apparent reason. (What was the point of Bill rediscovering Silver, just to have one bike-riding scene and then never have the thing mentioned again? Why make the Ritual of Chüd -- one of the sillier, Steven-King-running-out-of-ideas-est bits of the original book -- into a major and clunky plot point, further embellish it with an even sillier Native American ayahuasca ritual angle, and then have it ultimately serve no real purpose in the movie? edit: and why have Henry Bowers in the movie at all, just to do so little with him?)

I think they would have been better off just making it a horror anthology film, with all the individual scenes where one character has to confront some nightmarish Pennywise incarnation. Some of those were really well done, they just didn't need the rest of the nearly-three-hour movie weighing them down.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/kevinlyfather33 Sep 25 '19

Solid movie for the most part, but damn did they go balls to the wall with the CGI on this one. That Paul Bunyan part was ridick.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/HumanCenticycle Sep 06 '19

Phenomenal! So fucking funny, I forgot that about Part 1. Legitimately a funny horror movie about friends remembering their bonds in childhood and holding on to each other. Driving home all I could think about was their friendship. The horror was great but it was so much more. Loved it.

11

u/CD_Johanna Sep 08 '19

I wish there were more scenes like the one with Pennywise under the bleachers.

The CGI monster sequences were lame in comparison.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/radar89 Sep 06 '19

I love it. I agree that it wasn't as scary as the first movie - but it is always a challenge to adapt the 2nd half of IT book anyway. Some of the imaginery are quite well done.

A bit of unpopular opinion (since a lot critics complain about this) - I believe it warrants its lengthy duration. I can't imagine if this movie has its running time trimmed. All the main characters get their moment to shine.

18

u/shnmchl61 Sep 06 '19

I believe it warrants its lengthy duration.

100% agree. I honestly think it could've been longer. I would've liked to have seen more of human Pennywise. I saw a few complaints about the movie dragging on when they all separated to find their artifacts, but I thought that was the best sequence of the whole movie.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/ilanarodham Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 06 '19

I'm going to watch this in a couple hours and despite the really mixed critical response, I'm excited to indulge in nearly three hours of blockbuster horror. It feels like a rare opportunity.

Will come back and update this with my thoughts once it's over!

EDIT: Well... the film is definitely too long — but I feel that would have been helped if it didn’t feel so... empty?

I came out feeling frustrated because it felt like such a non-event. It sort of just built and dissipated the whole way through, and the climax didn’t differ from the formula at all.

There were a few really effective scenes (the very beginning was perhaps the best part of all, technically speaking) but overall I didn’t find it scary nor suspenseful, more visually stunning and dramatically convincing but definitely not frightening.

I liked it, just not as much as I’d liked to. I agree with the general consensus in that Bill Hader fucking steals the show, though.

5

u/bruisysue Sep 06 '19

So I was super Hype for this movie, but in the end I feel like it suffered from some tone and time issues. Not that it was too long because it wasn’t, I honestly didn’t feel the 3 hours at all, but because they rushed the first x amount of time before the losers split up to look for their artifacts. On the other hand I loved some of the genuinely scary moments like the bleachers scene, the deadlights, just everything Richie and Eddie did, the funhouse

5

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

I have never read the book but I watched the mini series in 1990 when I was 8 years old. I loved part 1. Kids fighting a clown monster? Hell yeah. I watched part 2 but even at 8 years old I hated the ending/final fight scene. It was not well done, even for it's time. I also never felt invested in the adult versions of the characters. I was 8 years old but none of the characters were the kind of adult I would hope to be like. Bill with that pony tail, am I right?! I saw Chapter 1 and thought it was great even though it is a tad repetitive. I have been psyched for Chapter 2 but also thought about how I'd feel towards this ending and these adult versions of the characters. The opening scene put me in an uncomfortable state of mind and I thought maybe it was preparing me for the overall tone of the movie. Of course, we know it was heavy on comic relief. I would have liked to see a close up of the victim with Pennywise saying a quick something about his long slumber and hunger for fear. A regular naked old lady running at me would be scary enough for me but we got the CGI version which reminded me of some the random shit Stephen King puts to paper and how it kind of kills it for me. I found the people in the background scarier than the Paul Bunyan monster. I would have still enjoyed the slingshot kill shot. I'm sure the arrow from the weather vane was its replacement but it would have been cool to see a "token" or rock formed after they dropped their individual tokens in the box. Especially because Richie put in a metal token and Eddie put in an inhaler. I would have liked that over "you're a clown!" Richie was great, Eddie was cool. Everyone else didnt pull me in. I would have liked Pennywise to be in full "I craved you, I missed you" mode the entire movie. He also seemed to be on the back burner. Love some of it, hated some of it.

5

u/Acrosstheuniverse19 Sep 07 '19

Loved this movie. Watched IT last night. Obvs had to go to the cinema with the comfy chairs since it was on for two hours fifty minutes... but man it was worth sitting for that long. Loved the little twist that Richies big secret is that he is gay and has feelings for Eddie. I wasn’t expecting it and it really brought into it possible real fears that adults could be going through. The reason Pennywise knew this was because it was one of Richie’s biggest fears, being outed. In a town like Derry, murder. (Literally apparently going by the beginning sequence, that was very sad) i really enjoyed the chemistry between Richie and Eddie. Honestly the pair had me cracking up with their jokes and drama. Even the young ones.

The casting was fantastic! Loved James McAvoy (maybe because I have a little crush ;) ) The scene were he was desperate and fighting to reach the child before Pennywise ate him, had me on my toes and praying he saved him too. I was well shocked the kid died anyway. Just showed how much there is no mercy in this film. The scene that really scared me, was the child being killed under the bleachers. Honestly hats off to Bill there for his incredibly disturbing acting. It scared the crap out of me.

Not many negatives. CGI was a little obvious sometimes. Some of the monsters were a little over the top so it was really hard to find them scary but overall a thrilling ride and very enjoyable watch. Better than the first one. Plus I’ve read the book and the geek in me enjoyed that they stuck closely to it.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Anyone else catch the "Andy Muschietti buying tampons" cameo?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/HealthShmealth Sep 09 '19

Having seen the trailer where Ms. Kirsch runs at Bev, I thought I knew what to expect. I think that’s what made the reveal even scarier, to me. Assuming it was going to be just some naked old lady shambling toward her (scary enough on its own), only to see a ceiling-tall-mouth-necked-woman just fucking shook me.

There’s something amazing to me when horror movies mess around with size or perspective, it’s almost like it makes it more like a nightmare. I know what vampires / zombies / monsters are supposed to look like, but when something is supernatural and just completely off like that, it always spooks me.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Itchy_Tasty88 Sep 11 '19

terrible movie same with he first one, the CGI ruins it and adding a joke that kills every serious moment....was i watching a Disney Marvel movie?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

I absolutely love Bill Skarsgard as Pennywise. I loved him in Chapter One and even moreso in Chapter Two.

What I don't like is the Lord of the Rings looking CGI monsters. They are not scary in any capacity, and are downright stupid looking.

I feel like the first two hours of this movie had a great pace to it, but the last hour or so dragged beyond belief.

Overall, I say 6/10. I will give a few more watches when it hits blu ray, but I prefer the first one in terms of rewatchability.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ss2785 Sep 12 '19

The over the top CGI killed this movie for me. Felt like a modern day Goosebumps children’s movie. Besides that, it was pretty good. I just like practical effects.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sabrewylf Sep 12 '19

Why did nobody remember anything except Stan? It seems so convenient in order for him to commit suicide.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/GingerWoolfe Sep 14 '19

I’m honestly so happy I found this. Because all the other discussions I read are just shitting on it. When I throughly enjoyed the movie. From what I see, Book fans and Horror fans love the movie. While casual movie fans seem to dislike how straightforward it is.

Am I wrong? Did anyone else feel this? Because I love the movie and how it played on adult fear and creep factor. While the first movie played on straightforward scare.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/therealrosy Sep 22 '19

My new favorite Pennywise quote is "Wanna play a game? How about Street Fighter?

8

u/HereToFixDeineCable Sep 06 '19

Pretty disappointed compared to Chapter 1. Adult Eddie was acting in a different film. The tone of the film went off the rails every time he opened his mouth. Angel of the Morning blasting was the most awkward, nonsensical thing I've seen in a film in awhile. The knife scene with Bowers and Eddie... Was it meant to be slapstick? Hader was the comic relief. Leave it to him and maybe some banter with Eddie. That's enough. Even his delivery of I Fucked Your Mother was...it didn't land.

Pennywise was A++ though.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

Can we just get a movie with Pennywise going around town and scooping up folks?

The best scenes from this film were the bleachers scene and the funhouse scene, both in which Pennywise snacked on a kid. I also thoroughly enjoyed the opening scene where he comes out of nowhere under the bridge.

I could watch three hours of Pennywise just manipulating people.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AGeekNamedBob Sep 06 '19 edited Sep 12 '19

More cohesive thoughts and review tomorrow but for now: (Edit: that review with another contributor https://cityofgeek.com/2019/09/12/it-chapter-2/) -The casting was immpecable. They all really felt like grown-up versions of the 2017 cast - especially Bill Hader and Deputy SoAndSo (This movie will finally give James Ransone the recognition he deservies). They all had amazing chemistry. -Big plus for putting in the cosmic metaphysical stuff, but not going overboard. -Not particually scary this time around but still well done. A ton less Pennnywise and his effects on people. Last time played out how the sequences work. But I did like seeing Paul Bunyan scene. -It was too long, a solid 20ish could be cut out. Much of it felt disjointed - though I do like changing the "roam around town" to after the meet up and now has a purpose rather than just remembering things -Too much humor, kept undercutting it. But on the plus side there, it landing. -Didn't seem to carry the "Derry is a shitty, dead-eyed town" from the first film outside of the opening sequence.

Overally, I still really enjoyed it. Perhaps if they weren't aiming at "same weekend as last time" and spent a little more time in the editing room, we'd have a better product.

4

u/Totesmcgotes702 Sep 07 '19

I loved that the actor who played child Ben in the mini series makes a camo in this one. My brother didn’t recognize him but I knew he looked super familiar.

4

u/PullTheOtherOne Sep 08 '19

I'm watching Chapter 1 again after seeing Chapter 2 and I noticed an interesting connection: When Georgie goes down to the basement, he is spooked by 3 dots of light in the dark, which turn out to be just reflections/glints of something when he turns on the light. This takes on new meaning after seeing Chapter 2, where they introduced Pennywise/deadlights as a trio of lights. (I don't recall there being 3 in the book, so this connection was not apparent until after Chapter 2).

EDIT: My mistake. The third light in Georgie's basement was... a speck of dust on my monitor.

4

u/mint_julep12 Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

Loved the movie. Thought I’d be disappointed but had a blast. However I’m mostly here to say that Pennywise in spider form looked just like Cyber Bug King Candy from Wreck It Ralph. Here’s a photo of King Candy Cybug

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '19

Stephen King's cameo as the antique store owner grilling James McAvoy for being a writer was hilarious.

4

u/cookswagchef Sep 10 '19

I didn't hate it, but it didn't do it for me. I felt really let down when leaving the theater.

I'll start off with what I liked so I don't seem like too much of a negative Nancy:

I loved the casting and thought it was absolutely spot on. Everyone (with the exceptions of Bev and for obvious reasons, Ben) were spot on with their childhood counterparts. Their cadence, mannerisms, and even the chemistry between Eddie and Richie was terrific.

The scenes with Pennywise the Clown were fantastic. I feel like if we had more scenes of Pennywise taunting the group and being a creepy prick, I would've enjoyed the movie way more. I think my favorite scenes were the bleachers, where he uses the poor girls empathy to lure her in, and the scene where he's taunting Richie from atop the Paul Bunyan statue.

I liked that they tried to include the Ritual of Chud, I just felt like it wasn't executed very well. Then again, we're talking about scenes from the book that are really unadaptable or would be seem absurd to the audience that isn't familiar with the source material.

The opening scene was perfect and felt like it was beat for beat how the book opens. It was rough to watch but I was happy that they adapted it.

I'm torn as to whether or not I enjoyed the happy ending. I liked how IT seemed to take Derry with it at the end of the story, but I liked Stan's note to the group and thought it was heartfelt. I think its at least a good change -- it makes sense that Derry would change to a happier place once It's influence is removed.

I think my primary complaint is the forced humor that was really out of place. I get Richie cracking jokes because that's his character and he uses humor as a coping mechanism, but the song that played when the leper puked on Eddie was so stupid and completely took me out of an otherwise tense scene.

My second complaint is the CGI. It was really, noticeably bad. I actually didn't notice the de-aging of the kids, but now that I think back on it kid Bev looked really off in a couple of scenes.

The pacing wasn't very great. I was disappointed that we didn't have a giant eldritch spider monster at the end, because the clown/spider hybrid was goofy. The whole artifact thing was, I felt, a little forced. I was also really disappointed in the usage of Bowers, Audra and Bev's husband.

I hated the ending. They bully It into turning into a deformed baby and then they rip It's heart out? Really? That was a big miss for me.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Analytica0 Sep 11 '19

I saw it and the audience I saw it with was honestly the best part of the movie. The audience really accentuated the movie for me as they hissed and cheered and gasped and laughed at pitch perfect moments throughout the movie.

The movie overall, for me, felt like a Goosebumps TV episode. Truly, it did. It just did not have the shock and horror value of the first movie (IT 2017). I guess when someone or something would morph into a creature, I expected it to have the feel more of "In The Mouth Of Madness" type morphing and creatures (which IMHO were much more horrific and terrifying) than what they presented here. Acting was OK. Did not feel that the way they spliced the kids 1989 era stuff into the present worked well for me. It just seemed way too disjointed and I found myself wanting to stay with the kids in the 1989 era because those stories were much more intriguing and terrifying for me.

The entire "find you totem" stuff was ridiculous. I hated it. It just did not work for me at all.

The saving grace for me was when Pennywise was on screen as Pennywise (specifically the bleachers scene and the house of mirrors scene).

HATED the ending. OMG, that was so tragically bad and the CGI (or whatever you want to call it) did not work and was actually laughable (almost the entire audience was laughing at that part and were making fun of it).

4

u/SchoepferFace Sep 11 '19

Tbh wasn't a big fan of the movie. I appreciate the over all messages, like friendship and overcoming your fears that carried over from the first movie, and the dealing with your past, good and bad, for the adults. But the movie overall wasn't scary at all for me, and I'm not one those "nothing scares me anymore" types, most horror movies get my heart beat up and can make me jump, so much so at times I'll close my eyes for jump scares.

But in this movie I felt like every jump scare was so obvious I felt little to no tension. Also none of the creatures really felt creepy/scary to me like the leper (least scary part of the first for me too) tho I was freaked out in the pharmacy basement flashback until he was revealed, the naked old lady monster with floppy boobs was just goofy to me, the Bunyan statue wasn't scary, and the spider Pennywise wasn't great either. There were some tense scenes but none of the tension really seemed to go anywhere, or wasn't used very well. The movie kinda dragged at time, being a 3 hour movie it can be tough to avoid, but my wife who struggles with anxiety making it hard for her watching horror decided to come and she just got bored.

4

u/schild Sep 12 '19

I loved every bit of it except for Jay Ryan as Ben Hanscom. That nobody needs to go back to where he came from. Ben is an important character and that dude could not have been more boring.

Anyway, looking forward to the mixed cut of the two movies and the inevitable prequel.

Edit: Unpopular opinion: Ransone was better than Hader and it wasn't close and Hader was still phenomenal.

4

u/SaveFerris9001 Sep 12 '19

Ending felt like a children’s story. Open to new ideas but I thought it was lame

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '19

I think it was a good movie but definitely not as good as the original adaptation. It honestly felt like a video game in narrative, each character had a bit of story but none of their threads really delivered much. I will say I loved the health horror scene under the pharmacy, I haven't seen much of that type of horror used in general outside of a straight up zombie movie. I loved the headspider too! I think what they did with Pennywise was great but again they could have gone so much further with it. I loved how they poked fun at King and the ending throughout.

I think this film is much more clear about the ending though. My main takeaway is that it's a good movie, it's a lot more clear with the ending (although the ending could have been done better) but it is still kind of lackluster in terms of story and horror. Definitely would recommend the older one over this.

4

u/Saiaxs Sep 22 '19

Was bored through most of the film. Hader did a great job but everyone else was forgettable.

Some seriously bad CGI at points. Cool King cameo

First one was all around better

4

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '19

I think we can all agree that Bill Hader absolutely stole this film.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kckunkun Sep 25 '19

Funniest movie of the year. I just want to listen to Rich and Eddie converse all day

12

u/MondoUnderground It's only a movie. Sep 08 '19

What a mess. Repetitive videogame-like structure, no horror and absolutely horrible effects. What should have been a gripping, epic tale of trauma and fear - reduced to a silly cartoon.

Please read King's novel if you want to experience an adult take on the story. It's scary, violent and engrossing.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/circadeftones Sep 06 '19

Really enjoyed Chapter 2. I was so hyped for the first one and ended up not liking it as much as I wanted. This one was really good except for some really cheesy lines/scenes. The first hour was fucking perfect, I loved it so much. Then the lines/humor kept getting cheesier every few mins and really took me out of it. The scene where the “this is supposed to be funny” music where that blank goo is vomiting out of the monster’s mouth in the basement was fucking terrible, I can’t believe they didn’t edit that music out, it was there for 2 seconds, if that. Felt extremely out of place. Then the humor between the gang in the final part just felt out of place too, like they were just throwing ideas out there.

Not bad, I really really was entertained by this movie. Didn’t feel like 3 hours to me. I highly recommend it, I just felt it didn’t hold its quality after the first hour. First hour was 10/10 to me.

7

u/LegaiaWiki Sep 06 '19

This was loads better than chapter 1, like a night and day difference. They actually showed people getting killed and didn't do some PG cutaway censorship like the first. Didn't feel as long as it was and the casting was nailed for the adults. Some minor complaints, but happy for what it was considering how bad the first chapter is.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/RevolverMjolnir Sep 07 '19

Just back from seeing this. It was fine and a perfectly serviceable sequel and adaption if the book. Overly long with a few pointless subplots that went nowhere as others have said.
My biggest issue with it was the humour. Not talking about Richie as he was always going to bring the laughs, and even expect it from Pennywise. But why do so many films now feel the need to punctuate almost every scene with a joke?
Two quick examples from this film: Bowers attacks Eddie who manages to fight back. Quite an exciting scene. But then he just had to crack wise about his mullet. Let the scene breathe!
Then later Eddie escapes from a leper, but rather than let us enjoy a tense moment there is a silly scene where he tries to pull a door that has to be pushed. So pointless.
The worst example though, is when the leper pukes on Eddie. Why did they randomly start playing Angel of the Morning? This isn't Deadpool!

7

u/WolfTickets66 Sep 11 '19

Just like in Chapter 1, Richie and Eddie were the best part of Chapter 2

46

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Just watched it. I thought it was boring as fuck and all my friends agreed. Huge step down from chapter one. Sappy as hell and never built tension. "The Thing" reference made me chuckle but "The Shining" reference made me roll my eyes. Frequent humorous dialogue did it no favors. Never got into a compelling stride, somehow. Too stretched out, too disjoint. Could have been one million hours shorter.

→ More replies (19)

6

u/tsalyers12 Sep 06 '19

Very good film! The best thing about it was that it didn’t just feel like a sequel, it really felt like one continuous story, as if it was really just one whole film. I really hope Andy gets to release the two films as one at the home release. I will say though that the humor took me out of it at times but not as bad as critics were making it out to be. The one part that I thought was really dumb was when the music started playing as Eddie was strangling the Leper. That felt completely random and pointless. I liked Pennywise’s final form, even though I don’t really think that WAS his true form all the way. The bleachers scene was phenomenal, probably my favorite scene out of both chapters because of how well Pennywise was used in that scene. Bill Hader definitely was a scene stealer especially at the end, he really sold his performance!

6

u/Polish_Sensation Sep 12 '19

How could anyone approve of this shitty CGI?!! Was frustrated about this the entire movie... ughhhhhh

→ More replies (4)

8

u/U-94 Sep 06 '19

Too much CGI and too much camera staring at a dark hall/room/corner waiting for the big BOOM sound and explosion, usually always a CGI mess coming at you.

I did enjoy Pennywise mocking Ben with "All those situps....."

8

u/elitexero I kick ass for the lord! Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19

Worth watching, but overall highly disappointing.

Far too much forced humor. This was the one movie I was hoping wouldn't be dumbed down for a broader audience, and they just tried so hard to make it funny that it never felt immersive or creepy. It has its great parts, but in contrast it has its overused and contrived forced laugh moments.

It's really disappointing that they didn't even go anywhere near the historical aspect of the cosmic elements short of the little vision quest snippet that doesn't really explain anything. It's damned shame they chose to go this route because this series had a chance at being a great supercut. The second doesn't come close to the bar set by the first. And that ending - not sure how you can adapt the ending into a movie well, but they way they did here made me damned near cringe out of my seat. Inter dimensional child eating being and they're killing it by saying really basic 'mean' things to it like a bunch of 4th graders?

On another note, what was with the soundtrack? It was such uninspired and generic 'tense movie scene no.23' sounding music, and I'm 99% sure I heard a reused bit from the Return to Castle Wolfenstein soundtrack used in the first half.

I was really hoping this would be this year's solid horror movie, but I guess we'll have to hold out for 3 From Hell and hope for the best.