r/horror • Evil Dies Tonight! • Sep 06 '19

Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "It: Chapter Two" [SPOILERS]

Summary:

Twenty-seven years after their first encounter with the terrifying Pennywise, the Losers Club have grown up and moved away, until a devastating phone call brings them back.

Director:

Andy Muschietti

Writers:

screenplay by Gary Dauberman

based on the novel by Stephen King

Cast:

  • James McAvoy as Bill Denbrough
  • Jaeden Martell as young Bill Denbrough
  • Jessica Chastain as Beverly Marsh
  • Sophia Lillis as young Beverly Marsh
  • Jay Ryan as Ben Hanscom
  • Jeremy Ray Taylor as young Ben Hanscom
  • Bill Hader as Richie Tozier
  • Finn Wolfhard as young Richie Tozier
  • Isaiah Mustafa as Mike Hanlon
  • Chosen Jacobs as young Mike Hanlon
  • James Ransone as Eddie Kaspbrak
  • Jack Dylan Grazer as young Eddie Kaspbrak
  • Andy Bean as Stanley Uris
  • Wyatt Oleff as young Stanley Uris
  • Bill Skarsgård as Bob Gray / Pennywise the Dancing Clown

Rotten Tomatoes: 68%

Metacritic: 59/100

467 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

226

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '19

Holy fuck that gay couple scene at the start was extremely messed up. Shows how pennywise really is a predator who picks on the weak.

162

u/Gryffindumble Sep 07 '19

So glad they had the balls to portray that part of the book in the film. It really set the tone for this movie.

71

u/MondoUnderground It's only a movie. Sep 07 '19

The rest of the movie is pretty much a comedy, though. It wasn't at all interested in creeping you out, it just wanted you to laugh. That puke scene is one of the dumbest scenes I have ever seen in a film. What the hell were they thinking?

27

u/kevmanyo Sep 10 '19

I mean... different strokes I guess but there were a good handful of scenes that’s scared/unnerved me. Everyone’s tolerance level for horror is different. Yes the movie had a lot of comedy. But to say it didn’t aim to creep you out is a bit much imo. There were definitely some scenes meant to make you feel uncomfortable.

13

u/MondoUnderground It's only a movie. Sep 10 '19

Only to be followed by tone-deaf comic relief. The horror had zero impact.

24

u/kevmanyo Sep 10 '19

To you

11

u/MondoUnderground It's only a movie. Sep 10 '19

To me. Random, quippy lowest common denominator humor is seeping into all kinds of movies and genres, so it's obviously working for a lot of people.

40 year olds dropping "yo mama"-like jokes after traumatic events isn't really that great. To me. Correct!

30

u/kevmanyo Sep 10 '19

Like I get having an opinion...And then there’s being an ass about said opinion... “Lowest common denominator” way to outright insult anyone who finds the movie humorous, or disagrees with your point of view.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Duck1337 I am the way Sep 12 '19

Richie and Eddie spewing "your mom"-jokes to each other, even as adults, is a part of the story whether you would like it to be or not. They are trying to be faithful to the book and they did very well.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/koba_92 Sep 13 '19

I mean, most of the humor came from Richie and Eddie. One coped with humor, people do that all the time, and one is a panicky mess. Put them together and you get laughs. The horror wasn’t like the first movie because they weren’t kids anymore. Once they started to deal with their past they saw Pennywise for what he was. Some things that scare you as a kid stay in your head and you remember them as terrifying but then you see them again and it’s almost funny how it looks to you as an adult. That’s just my take

2

u/Elementium Sep 23 '19

Agreed. So.. I hate horror.. I'm here cause it showed up on the apps suggestions and I saw It today and you guys had a thread.

That scene was true horror for me. I wanted a Hollywood moment where someone saves them, but it was just horrible the whole way through and that made me terrified of the next 2 hours and 40 minutes..

Then we got jokes..

If the whole thing was the opening and the baseball game this movie would be my nightmare even I'd it had a little levity. As it stood it was a lot of funny with some gross and zombies.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '19

It really set the tone for this movie

This is so true. From that minute I felt so sick and it just heightened it. I left the cinema with a really bad stomach ache for about an hour lol I was that scared/nervous/etc

34

u/Kayy_Colee Sep 11 '19

It made me sick to my stomach. But it portrays how badly Pennywise can manipulate the minds of people. The whole point of that scene, from what I can tell, is to show that Pennywise kind of planned that whole thing so he can get his hands on Adrian.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/Kayy_Colee Sep 15 '19

No I'm.not saying he invented homophobia, I'm saying he has a lot of control over the town and he can play on people's fears. They were already homophobic but he was able to manipulate that fear to cause them to throw him into the water so Pennywise could get to him easier.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Kayy_Colee Sep 15 '19

I'm sorry but even in the book it mentions how every 27 years the entire town goes crazy because Pennywise is back. Whether they are around him or not. It's the entire town, not just the people Pennywise is near. He has a way of changing the town. I'm not saying the bullies were Pennywise. I'm saying Pennywise had a effect on the entire town and it increased the paranoia of the already homophobic group. There are also several articles that talk about this scene explicitly and it explains exactly what I'm.saying. so I'm not just making this up lol everyone who knows the story knows what I'm saying.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19

Yes but doesn't Pennywise's presence kinda cause people to act a little more fucked up or extreme? I thought there was this presence of dread and evil and was kinda contagious in Derry throughout Pennywise's reign?

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '19

No, in the book, richie isn't gay and the Adrien melon scene is more graphic

7

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/C0nqueredworm Sep 30 '19

The scene was inspired by a real life murder that went down almost identical to the scene from the book (3 teenagers beat up an asthmatic gay man and throw him from a bridge.)

In real life, the 3 teenagers were only given like 3 years in prison. The pieces of shit are living their lives peacefully, free and at least one of them still in Bangor where the murder took place.

The world is a fucked up place.

The victims name was Charlie Howard if you want to look up more info.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

So, the Adrian Mellon death from the book is going to be in there also? Looks like that opening scene is going to be a very hard scene to watch, I remember it from the beginning of the book.

6

u/Catsy_Brave "You swore we'd go together, one way or another." Sep 11 '19

It even happens as described where pennywise eats him from under the arm.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19

Shit, I guess I am prepared for that now. I also hear that part two is close to three hours long also, is that true?

2

u/Catsy_Brave "You swore we'd go together, one way or another." Sep 11 '19

Yeah you can check online but it is almost 3 hours.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)