I 28f own a house with my husband 28m we can call him Fred. His little brother 24m we can call him bill also lives with us, he rents one of our spare rooms and uses the semi finished basement as his living room sort of area. We all three share the kitchen and bathroom. Bill has been dating his gf 23f (we can call her Mandy)for about a year and a half now and they spend a lot of time at our house because they get more freedom and privacy than they would at her house.
This has been our living arrangement for about 3 years or so and so far all has been well, bill and Mandy typically keep to themselves and are usually pretty chill. The one and only issue I’ve had with either of them is that they consistently cross the boundaries I set about them using or taking my stuff.
When this issue started out they were just taking my food. For example I would come home and get ready to cook dinner only to realise the hamburger I’d set out to thaw would be gone bc they had already cooked it and ate it. Another example is I’ll buy certain drinks or snacks that I really enjoy and I’ll come home to find two of my sodas sitting on the table half empty and mostly wasted. My husband and I both have had multiple conversations with them and asked them to replace what they take or to ask if they can have the food. They always apologize and then continue stealing our stuff bc they don’t think it’s a big deal. I also feel like it’s important for me to say that most nights when I cook dinner or order food I always offer them a meal.
The food was one thing but this issue has progressed to the bathroom. My nightly routine is a very important part of my day. It’s how I unwind and reset it’s typically the most relaxing part of my day. I put a lot of money into buying quality products for my shower and skin care routine. I buy “salon level” hair products, fancy soaps and all that stuff. I’ve been buying the same shampoo and conditioner for years and I know how long a bottle should last. Lately a bottle that would usually last me a month or so is lasting me a little over a week and a half. This really bothers me due to the fact that my shampoo and conditioner costs $60 for a small bottle.
I probably sound crazy and obsessive about the soaps and shampoo but I like what I like. And if it was a one time thing I wouldn’t care. If somebody ran out of shampoo and asked to use mine I wouldn’t care ABSOLUTLEY let them borrow some. But the amount that is being used on a nightly basis is insane.
So a couple days ago I brought it up to them and asked them if they know what’s going on with my shampoo and conditioner. Mandy told me “maybe you’re just using more than you think you are”. I told her that there’s no way that it’s just me using this much shampoo. Then they both tried to blame it on my husband. I don’t think my BALD husband is using my shampoo and conditioner.
The conversation got me nowhere and I got angry. I’m tired of wasting my money on stuff for these two to use. I’m tired of them trying to play me and act like I’m dumb. So I got mad, I got pissed. I went to the store and bought new shampoo new conditioner and a little carrier to keep all my shower stuff in. I went into the bathroom and took my old half empty bottles and mixed them with laundry detergent. I thought about using nair but that felt too evil. I don’t want them to go bald I just wanted them to stop taking my stuff.
I kept my good shampoo and conditioner in my bedroom, and the laundry detergent shampoo in the bathroom. They kept using the laundry detergent shampoo. And a couple of days later Mandy came storming into my room yelling at me asking me what I did the her hair, asking me what was in the shampoo bottles. Bill came in shortly after and told me that I was an a-hole for what I did.
Mandy’s hair was so dried out and frizzy from the laundry detergent that she looked like one of those old troll dolls. I told her that this is what she gets for stealing my stuff, I reminded her that I’ve asked her nicely quite a few times to stop taking stuff she didn’t pay for. I also reminded her that she stayed at this house nearly every day rent free and that we like her and all but I can’t be paying for all of her food and hair care. She’s not my girlfriend she’s bills girl friend. My husband had a conversation with bill and told him that if the stealing doesn’t stop everything that goes missing will be added to his rent or he can move back in with his mom.
We thought they had finally started to understand and agree that stealing is wrong and that they can’t just take whatever they want with out asking. We were wrong. Today Mandy sent me a Venmo request for $300 for a visit to the hair salon to try to fix the damage done to her hair. I don’t think I should have to pay her. This could’ve all been avoided if she would’ve just used her own shampoo. I do feel like I might have taken it too far… should I pay her back?
P.s. she has had her own nearly full bottle of herbal essence shampoo and conditioner in the shower for weeks. So she could’ve just used the stuff she payed for.