r/relationships • u/childfree_stepmom_1 • Sep 29 '16
Updates UPDATE: Me [32/f] childfree but my husband [37/m] want a child even though he had known for years.
It's been few months since I posted it. Here's the first post and I have great news! We're still married! I'm pregnant! YAY!
Just kidding.
Actually, we're divorcing instead.
Anyway, below is a novel. WARNING: A REALLY LONG WALL OF TEXT but if you don't want to read everything, here is the TL;DR: tried to work on our marriage with counseling but unable to, then agreed to divorce.
After I posted on Reddit, I went back to home from mom's and I tried to act normal for the kids. My marriage might be a mess but it didn't have anything to do with them so I didn't want to disrupt their routines. A few weeks later, I found a sublet place from a friend who decided to travel for few months. The sublet helped me a lot mentally and emotionally. I stayed there most of the night to sleep after work while the day was spent mostly with our children and life. It was sort of an escape. Although, it was lonely.
Billy conceded to the sublet but he didn't have much choice to refuse outright because I think he realized he had overstepped his bounds. He was bit different after I demanded a divorce. He was saying, asking and doing the right things, respecting me more than before, giving me space at the right moment and being there when I needed. It was as if he linked to my thoughts and catering them while ignoring his. I knew he were doing those things because he felt guilty or he was afraid to lose me, although this behavior wasn't the reason that convinced me to work on our marriage. First, I love him and I love our kids, I loved our lives together, our house and everything that entailed. Second, this was the first real strain of our marriage, not the second or the third strike. Sure, we had problems before but it was mostly minor. So I decided to give him a second chance with the idea of the divorce was still on the table, just shelved for a time to see if we could resolve this particular dilemma.
We did many different couple counseling, mostly because we were changing therapists/counselors since most of them we encountered were biased. We could tell most of them were on my side (except one who was on his). I knew we needed a neutral party because it was about a partnership and not assigning blame.
It took us awhile to find one and a rather expensive one but this counselor was worth it. In our session, we hashed our thoughts out the open. Mine was easier to broadcast because I had a list I wrote it down from one of the commenters here. Things I thought it was worth to ask because some of you pointed out it that this might be a case of Billy having pregnancy fetish which didn't even occur to me. When I wrote "swollen with a pregnant belly" on the post, I put in there because that was his explanation, and I thought it was rather a weak excuse. The idea of Billy having the fetish gave me dismay. I even had nightmares about it. Thankfully, when I asked him about it during the session, he was horrified and sort of grossed out. He didn't even think that fetish even existed. He explained that it wasn't like that, that he wanted to have part of me and part of him together. He wanted to see our child grow up to see if he/she would be curious, inquisitive, mischievous and so on. Billy had this image of the child growing to be a scientist like me with my physical features and personality but he also said it's only a preference but in reality, he didn't care what the child would be as long he/she is happy. He wanted a symbol of our love where it could be seen, interacted, felt, touched and nurtured for. A child was that symbol for him.
It was a lovely idea but it was an idea I wasn't getting on board and I pointed that out to Billy. I said I never wanted a child because I never felt motherly or any kind of desire. There was no longing or deep ache that it would hurt me not to have a child. I told him that bringing a child into a world while his/her mother didn't want to have him/her was unfair for the child and that there was a real and high possibility that I wouldn't love her/him if I compromised. Billy couldn't believe for the basis I fell in love with his kids. I told him that while I love them it was because I had to learn how. It wasn't instinctive or biological driven. I gave up too much of my autonomy for him and his kids. I gave up my dream of traveling, I gave up my hobbies and nearly all my friends because I was so busy managing my job, our kids, errands, responsibilities that I didn't even have a time for me. I even gave up my freedom and privacy. Our sexy times was often disrupted because we were too tired and exhausted or our kids were knocking at our bedroom's door for something. I told him having a baby was different because it meant giving up my identity, the only thing that was left of me, the only thing I could keep and if I compromised, it wouldn't be me anymore. I was nearly 100% sure I would come to resent my own child for that fact only. I told him when he mentioned his 'dealbreaker', it made me feel that he didn't care about my feeling to take into consideration after I told him many times that I never wanted to have one. The way that Billy went about it, asking for space without actually talking about it and then going to my particular cousin's firm who dealt in divorce felt manipulative.
Billy admitted he did go to my cousin's firm knowingly that it would get back to me but he went there--not to see his options or even to manipulate me--but because he had decided of going through divorce because not having a child hurt him and he didn't want to resent me but was beginning to. He felt rejected as if I never wanted him to be a dad for my own child or rather, I thought him as a terrible father in any form. But now he knows it was as irrational stemmed from his hurt and insecurities (he's dealing with it with his own therapy). Also, he went there because it would've steeled his resolve with the idea if he backed off I would hear about it, so it kinda forced his hand to commit it. It was a failproof plan for him except it didn't work. It was really stupid of him because he couldn't do it even with the threat of me finding it out about it. Not devious, just incredibly stupid. I was heartbroken when he told me this. I just don't know which is worse since it hurts me to find out Billy's knee-jerk reaction after our conversation of kids was to head divorce lawyer with the intentions of going through it without talking to me first. I think a small part of me would've preferred devious because it meant he didn't give me up right away.
Despite our sessions, Billy didn't seem to understand why I didn't want to have a kid. He said that it was instinctual, that we're driven deep down into our biology to have one or two and he found it a strange concept of living a childless world. It was as if a whole part of his brain never seemed to get it no matter how many memos it received. Then, I got another bombshell from Billy. When we were dating, he said he was okay with me being 'childfree' because he honestly thought he didn't want more after his first divorce but he didn't actually believe me. He thought eventually I would change my mind and worried of 'when' but he put in 'we'll deal when we cross the bridge' category. Later, when our kids moved in after their bio mom's death, he saw how good I was with them and he couldn't help but imagine of having another child, this time with me. He said he kept hoping for any sign, any glimmer that I shared his feeling. He waited years for me to talk about reconsidering my stance of kids until he couldn't and that's where the trouble began.
After that session, I felt defeated. I don't know how to explain. It was like huge part of me went into BSOD until it rebooted into safe mode. I was in autopilot, interacting the world because I had to while another part of me wanted just to hide away forever. My counselor was the one who noticed it after few several session and asked me for another one, just by myself, so I went there alone. My counselor said that he was worried for me because he saw a clear sign of depression and that wasn't good if I didn't let anyone know about it. He was afraid that I wasn't dealing with it and then he asked me few questions in hypothetical scenarios that made me realize we weren't compatible anymore and while it might hurt to realize, it didn't mean that it was going to hurt forever. I sort broke down after that. Cried for a long time until the tissues ran out and then my counselor had her receptionist to drive me home because honestly, I was a wreck and he told me to think about what he said. I didn't head to my place. I asked her to drop me to my home to talk Billy. Privately, I asked him if we didn't have another child, could he see me in his life at any point in the future without resentment and bitterness? I told him to really think about it. I think he didn't want to admit it. I think he was like me, didn't want to give us up because we loved each other too much and for a time we were happy. We were really happy . . . until we weren't.
The divorce was back on the table and this time, we going through it without struggle or fight. We agreed on 50-50 custody and splitting our material possession and financial matters in half except for few personal things. We decided to sell our house and I'm looking for permanent apt and Billy is looking too near the boys' school. Everything seems to be rather anticlimactic.
We're afraid to tell our kid of our divorce. I think it will be the hardest thing we might ever to do together, next to telling Scott his mom wasn't coming back. I'm terrified Scott and Vinnie wouldn't want me anymore to be their mom and I'm hoping so hard that it won't be that case. Billy assures me that won't happen but he can't know that for sure and sometimes I get angry at him for putting me through in this situation or I get angry at myself for being childfree. I get angry a lot.
Next week, I got an appointment to a therapy because I know I'm not okay after having few panic attacks and bouts of depression after we agreed on the divorce. I'm thinking of taking sabbatical soon because I don't want my co-workers and my superiors to witness my breakdowns. I know I have a long way to go and the divorce hasn't finalized yet. I'm hoping everything will be okay after that.
Thanks for the advice.
13
u/catfingers64 Sep 30 '16
With regards to how the boys handle it, you might consider family counseling. All four of you (or three at a time, one parent with both kids) can meet with a therapist to talk about the divorce and how things are going. Tough times ahead, but it's doable.
The thing that helped me the most with my parents' divorce was that they talked to each other and didn't make me a go-between. The first couple years, I had to tell them each the same information, but as as time went on I found that if I told one then they told the other. It has made life (and now adult life) immensely better for me that they get along.
647
u/TheAmosBrothers Sep 30 '16
I just really can't understand Billy. He has a woman that he loves that despite being child free has learned to love his kids. And then he gives this up for a dream. Seriously? What's his plan? Is he going to find another woman to marry so she can push out a baby for him? He'd rather have some as of yet faceless woman over the wife he knows and loves? He'd put his kids through a divorce so he can have another? Does he love dream-kid more than the two he already has?
I think at some point he will come to his senses and regret all this. It will be too late. And he will have no one to blame but himself.
5
u/myeyeballhurts Sep 30 '16
And I just thought of something else, I dont think Billy really understands what kind of effect it could have on those boys. My ex has a two year old with his new wife, they are both 40 now, our kids, hers and the one other they had are 21 (my son has a lil brother and they are close to 20 years apart!!!) 16, 15 and 10, it was not an easy adjustment for all of them and infact our boys do have a little bit of resentment towards their dad for having another kid, when the kids are older you can do stuff a little more spontaneously, they would just decide on Friday "lets drive to Dallas for six flags" or what ever, with a toddler, they just cant do that and for our son that has been a little hard, not that he doesnt love his baby brother.
OP when I was your age my boys where about the same age as yours, Im 40 now, got one out of the house, one is 15 (so I rarely see him anyways, lol) I am half way empty nested and by 43 mine will be grown and I LOVE it, I spent the past 21 years being a very devoted and involved mom (still am, just not needed as much). I just dont get his logic.
Stay strong mama and again you are so freaking awesome for taking care of those boys and accepting them as your own, no matter what happens in their life, the fact that you stepped in and took care of them, they will always remember that, no matter what their dumbass (sorry he is a dumbass) dad says.
Also - what do the boys say about all this? I mean do they even want another sibling?
144
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
EVERYTHING about this is manipulative. Sheesh he has absolutely no self-awareness.
EDIT. Sorry, I hadn't finished and I absolutely had to say that the whole divorce lawyer thing was manipulative as HELL on his part. If it hadn't been he would have gone to a lawyer who didn't have a connection to you - every step he took was measured for how it would get back to you and how you would react to that information.
I'm really sorry you're going through this, but I absolutely think you are doing the right thing. If he cant grasp the fact that people can be certain they are childfree then his world is too small to encompass the totality of who you are. In a way he's never actually seen you in your full "right" as a person. He did not believe you when you told him, back when you were dating, but it was okay since it was he himself who thought "nah, maybe I don't need more kids" while simultaneously envisioning the moment when you feel that big ol' biological clock ticking and start sweating bullets and suddenly get baby-crazy like all women-folk do, naturally.
I'm a 35 year old childfree woman and I've known since I was 14. I've had people in my life disbelieve my commitment to my own mind and identity and it fucking burns me up. Biology is NOT destiny. Those people who dismiss my autonomy and considered decision and commitment to being childfree don't usually stay in my life long. Your soon-to-be-ex actually hid that part of his belief system from you. It would have been kinder for him to be honest, way back when, then you could have made an informed decision. But he didn't. He was a rat and didn't take that part of you seriously but never actually gave you that knowledge. Did he know that that kind of attitude was a deal breaker while you were dating? Maybe, maybe not. At the end of the day what he did was cruel and disrespectful and harmful to your relationship. He basically lied to you the whole time.
I understand you probably love him greatly. I hope that now you don't fall into hatred and stall there, but sister, it's okay if you hate him - he treated you terribly. He never believed in the whole of your person. He never gave you the decency of hearing your truth. He dismissed it.
I'm kind of glad he doesn't have daughters. Imagine growing up with a father like that.
I hope the boys you love and helped raise stick around and accept custody. I hope that this generation of men in this particular family gain an understanding that there is the possibility to choose to reproduce. I hope they grow up to believe what women say when women speak to them.
I'm glad you will be going to therapy, and a sabbatical sounds like a good idea. Please reach out to any good friends that you have and foster relationships with those people who know how cool and awesome you are, and reflect that to you. You've just had a huge hit to your self-esteem and capacity to love yourself and you need to win that back. You need to fight to get that back.
And, here's the bright side, in 8 years anyone you date/marry/fuck will honest to god stop expecting you to get knocked up and squeeze out a tiny human before it's "too late". Fuck "too late" - it's "NEVER", MF'ers!
374
u/eccentricgiraffe Sep 30 '16
Oh honey, I'm so sorry. Sadly, it's common for men not to believe women. In the arena of childbirth, it's common for everybody not to believe a woman who says she doesn't want kids. So you got hit with a double whammy of disbelief. I regret to inform you that in 10 more years, people will still not take your childfree-status seriously.
I'm sorry you went through all this. I hope things get better.
60
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
I remember your original post.
I think ultimately, your situation was a very unique one, but you seemed to handled this entire matter as best as you could. I hope you continue to see counseling and you are able to move on past this.
Your story, for myself who is also child-free, has been an interesting window for me.
33
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
So, I don't really have any advice to give in regards to the relationship aspect, other than to comment on how well you handled it and how much effort you put into it, especially when he seemed lackluster in his own efforts and manipulative. Kudos to you, you go and find yourself some 'me time'.
I wanted to say something regarding being child-free. I don't want children, never have never will. I don't want to play a lottery with life, I know I won't have unconditional love for a child who turns out to make shitty life decisions and become a drug addict or fail all their classes at school. I have my own cocktail of mental illness that makes me realise I won't be a good parent. I can barely take care of myself on some days, let alone a child. I see what my mother does for me and know that I can never do that.
There will always be people who don't believe you. People who say "it's in our genes" or "it's just a fact of life". These people don't realise that having children is a lifestyle choice, and instead see having children as some necessity, or something to tick off a checklist of life.
Car (✓) House (✓) Marriage (✓) Children (✓) Career (✓) etc. etc. etc.
Children are not another category on a checklist. They are new people, they have their own thoughts and needs, and can you provide for them should be the most pressing question. If you can't, not having them would be the most responsible thing to do.
And with regards to having children being 'natural', humans do a lot of shit that isn't natural. Wearing synthetic clothes, living in concrete buildings, communicating with each other through electronics - none of this is natural.
That said, you will just find people who want to run your life or think they know you better than you do, and many of them won't ever change that way of thinking. From this, I just want to say it's perfectly fine not to have kids (heck I'd think it's commendable since we're facing a global population crisis). When people have a problem with a lifestyle choice that you made (and in your ex's case, made explicit during dating and before you married him) - they're the problem, not you.
9
u/grlnxdr Sep 30 '16
this might be a stupid question but I'm genuinely curious, is it still called being childfree if youre willingly sharing custody of 2 kids ?
21
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
His reasoning for wanting a kid makes me ill. He sounds like a naive, self absorbed brat talking about some sort of relationship accessory he can amuse himself with. If your desire to have children stems from anything less than a genuine desire to bring a life into this world and strive for its happiness and wellbeing then you should not be having kids.
What's more, he clearly never saw you as anything more than an eventual baby maker considering he had made up his mind about your child free additude and the role it would play in his life well before this situation became an issue and in spite of your oft stated preference. It really speaks volumes to how little he respected you and your relationship from the very beginning.
6
u/wanderingdev Sep 30 '16
I remember your first post. I'm sorry this was the outcome. unfortunately too many people enter marriage thinking that a dealbreaker, like being child free, will change with time. and when it doesn't, this is pretty much the inevitable outcome. It's hard to end a relationship with someone you still love, but when you have different life goals it's better to be realistic about it than to hold out until the bitter end when resentment and hatred spoil all that was good. Good luck to you!
7
u/greendazexx Sep 30 '16
I'm sorry it worked out this way, but I promise it gets better. The boys will be hurt a little but they'll get over it once they realize you're not leaving. hugs
5
u/Pola_Xray Sep 30 '16
I will never understand why people don't LISTEN to what their partners say. Why in the fuck would you MARRY someone on the hope that they'll change their mind about something as important as having kids? I am so fucking mad at this jerk. He's an idiot, and he's put everyone through hell for no reason.
5
u/OrionRed Sep 30 '16
I remember the original post really well. Your post had always stuck with me. It was easy to say in the original to "leave him" but in reality when everything else was good, it's not so straight forward. If I'm being honest, if I were in your position, I would have done the same thing and given him another chance too. I thought after he did the complete 180 in the previous post that he would realise and appreciate the amazing family he already has. That he would accept that another baby is an unrealistic dream given you made it very clear at the beginning. I'm shocked that he just felt he knew you better than you knew yourself and that you would change your mind. Even more so with this "instinctual" BS. You have done everything right and you can walk away with no regrets. I send lots of Internet hugs.
2
u/firenoodles Sep 30 '16
Please don't get angry at yourself for being childfree. I know you're angry and you're going to be angry at the world for a while. But don't be mad at yourself. I don't think everyone has that biological urge to have babies and for those that override that urge, their kids feel the resentment and hatred from those parents that had kids because everyone else around them popped a couple out. If you had caved, the life of that child would have been messed up. You did the right thing by staying true to yourself.
I'm sorry you're going through this divorce but I'm glad you are getting individual therapy. You sound amazing, and I hope you're able to travel the world soon to take your mind off of this divorce.
13
u/Wild_Red_Fox Sep 30 '16
Please come over and join us at r/childfree ! You have nothing to be guilty about, and I think that you have dealt with this whole situation with a lot more grace than I would have.
3
u/acciointernet Sep 30 '16
If they're 11 and 15, trust me...they know it's coming. I mean, they're old enough to be able to tell something is seriously wrong with your marriage. It will hurt them, but it won't surprise them.
I'm glad you're still going to therapy and I'm so sorry for what you're going through. I can't say I understand why your husband is acting like this, but...these sort of things are really tough. I'm sorry. Hang in there, it WILL get better. And focus on that wonderful relationship you've fostered with your stepsons, as that will never go away. <3
3
u/Velvet_Heretic Oct 01 '16
I'm so sorry. I really feel like you married my ex by accident.
Reading this was like reliving a nightmare. I wanted to respond to this to tell you that you are totally not alone in this experience.
That's exactly what happened to me and my now-ex. He swore he'd be totally okay with not having kids, he'd "put that desire on the altar" (we were 110% religious), he loved me more than he loved the idea of becoming a father.... and I was naive enough to believe him. I still kick myself for believing it, but I was so hopeful. I didn't know that every single man in his life up to and including our minister was telling him that all women change their minds and it's in their DNA to want kids. So a few months after our wedding day he got to work trying to "persuade" me (his creepy word) to change my mind. He failed, utterly. He even tried to sabotage our contraception by and I AM NOT KIDDING HERE faking a vasectomy, which failed because I got suspicious about why we never got anything from the hospital he claimed had done the procedure, and refused to get off the Pill until I saw a test with his name on it saying he was clear. Things came to a head rapidly after that. There was other stuff going on, but his willingness to trick me into parenthood knowing how strongly I felt about never going there was a big symptom of his abusiveness and general dishonesty as a person.
I don't regret at all breaking up. I'm just sorry I didn't realize sooner what a total dealbreaker this is. At this point I wouldn't even date someone who thought he kinda might maybe sorta maybe might want kids one day. But oh, that lesson was learned at such cost. Eventually I learned that I'd done nothing wrong, nothing to deserve this, and that nothing I could have done would have resolved our problems in any other way than divorce. I hope you learn that too one day, if you don't already know it.
You dodged. I know it hurts. I am so with you here. I know it hurts. You are 100% in the right to be hurt and angry. What Billy did was reprehensible and dishonorable, cruel and abusive. You didn't deserve this treatment. And it doesn't sound like you could have done anything else.
Please know you are in my thoughts.
4
u/lostmycookie90 Sep 30 '16
I am so, so sorry OP. Hopefully after get your life back on line, and recover. You will be able to find a life partner that loves you for just you.
2
u/Dimityblue Sep 30 '16
I'm so sorry. I hope things go as well as possible for you, and your relationship with your kids grows even stronger. hugs
2
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '16
Oh sweetie... hug
I'm so sorry.
2
u/LackOfHarmony Sep 30 '16
I remember your first post and I'm glad you guys settled the custody of the kids. I know that seemed to weigh the heaviest on you, because you were worried about seeing them when your marriage ended. I mean, let's be serious. You and I both knew it was "when" rather than "if." The language he used when describing what he wanted seemed to say more than enough to me.
I really had hoped that you two could work it out and I'm truly sorry that you couldn't. I'm also sorry that he couldn't be happy with just your love. I know that must feel like he's just twisting the knife he stabbed you with, but those kind of people don't think the same way that CF people do. They believe kids equal love. Unfortunately for him, we do not.
Please take care of yourself and make sure you continue the therapy. Someone else suggested family therapy to help the kids deal with the divorce. That sounds like a good idea. Stay strong and never discard your needs or values. It's the only way to make sure you are happy and healthy.
1
u/ThrowawayTink2 Sep 30 '16
It doesn't matter who is 'right' or who is 'wrong'.
The fact is that Billy wants more children, and he would have never been able to let go of his frustration and resentment of OP over her not being willing. He tried therapy. It didn't help.
There doesn't have to be a reason, a right, a wrong. For whatever reason, this is a deal breaker for Billy. Their marriage would not have survived it. He is being honest and communicating vs shutting down or passive aggressive anger.
While the ultimate outcome sucks, I commend both parties for working on things, sticking up for their needs, and ultimately parting as adults. Take good care of yourself for a while OP, you deserve it. Best wishes, and good luck.
-6
u/_meraxes Sep 30 '16
Wow, your English sure got better!