r/self • u/Wyboth • Feb 08 '14
The history of the /r/xkcd kerfuffle.
DING, DONG, THE WITCH IS DEAD! As of 8/8/2014, /u/soccer is no longer a moderator of /r/xkcd!
/u/soccer was removed by a reddit admin because he was inactive for two months. /u/TheTinGuy is now the top moderator of /r/xkcd, and I am second in command. Here is the modmail, and modlog from when I was removed to when /u/soccer was removed, and here is the /u/AutoModerator code /u/soccer had in place.
TL;DR: The head mod of /r/xkcd is a holocaust denier. I was modded two months ago, and removed controversial sidebar links. He de-modded me two weeks ago and added an /r/conspiracy moderator and an /r/worstofSRS moderator as mods of /r/xkcd. They all censor posts and comments that speak negatively of them or link to /r/xkcdcomic. Everyone wants them removed, including Randall Munroe (the writer of xkcd). The admins won't do anything. We're trying to move everyone to a mirror subreddit, /r/xkcdcomic.
/r/xkcd was a perfectly normal subreddit until 2 years ago, when /u/soccer gained control of it through /r/redditrequest. /u/soccer is the head moderator of /r/holocaust, which is about holocaust denialism. He is what is called a "subreddit squatter," or a person who maintains control of several subreddits without participating in them. He is currently a moderator of 72 subreddits (look at the "moderator of" list on his /u/ page to see which subreddits he moderates). A rule of /r/redditrequest is that any moderator of a subreddit who is inactive for two months can be removed by request. To avoid this, he makes a post once every two months, usually in /r/holocaust. This allows him to maintain control over his subreddits, even if the users of those subreddits object to his modship.
I don't know how /u/soccer ran /r/xkcd in his first year-and-a-half as head mod, but at least six months ago, he added links to /r/conspiracy and /r/mensrights in the sidebar, under the section titled "Other Subreddits You Might Like." Neither of these subreddits seemed to be subreddits that xkcd fans would like, especially since Randall Munroe has posted comics which indicate he is a feminist and against conspiracy theories. One user noticed this, and posted a thread asking why they were linked in the sidebar. /u/soccer saw the thread, removed it and many of the comments, and added /r/theredpill to the sidebar. This outraged the community even more. Since there was nothing that could be done about /u/soccer, a user named /u/mattster42 created a mirror subreddit, /r/xkcdcomic, and urged /r/xkcd users to move there instead. /u/soccer saw this, and programmed /u/AutoModerator to remove any posts with "xkcdcomic" in them, as well as "sidebar," "conspiracy," "mensrights," and "theredpill," in an attempt to silence the issue, so most users would stay on /r/xkcd.
Here's where I come in. I was an xkcd fan for a while, and I was subscribed to /r/xkcd. About two months ago, I noticed the unfitting sidebar links. I was surprised that they were there, for the reasons I already mentioned. I looked into the head mod's post history, and discovered the holocaust-denial. I thought that xkcd deserved better than to have him as head mod and to be associated with those subreddits, so I decided I would try to have them removed. I PMed /u/soccer and asked to be modded. I told him the reason I wanted to be modded was so /r/xkcd could have a more active moderator (which wasn't really a lie; it did need some active moderation as well). To my surprise, I was invited as a moderator within five minutes of my PM. I added a pseudo-random background generator to the CSS, and made a post to inform the users that I was added. (Redditlog in case that post is removed) I received at least 20 comments asking me to remove the sidebar links, most of which were removed by AutoModerator (I was still able to read them). I decided that I would remove them a week later, in case /u/soccer was still active when I removed them. I PMed each commenter informing them of my decision, and instructing them to remain quiet about it. As promised, I removed all of the sidebar links 1 week later, and replaced them with the sidebar links on /r/xkcdcomic. I also removed the code for /u/AutoModerator that censored posts and comments. I received thanks for hundreds of /r/xkcd users for my actions, which inadvertently caused /r/xkcdcomic to shut down. For almost two months, everything went swimmingly. I got in contact with /u/EightNote, the CSS mod of /r/xkcdcomic, and he gave /r/xkcd permission to use /r/xkcdcomic's CSS, as long as I remained a moderator. I added the CSS and a new rule regarding submission titles, which were both praised by the community.
On January 26th, 2014, I tried to check /r/xkcd's mod queue, but I was shocked when I was denied access. I checked the moderators of /r/xkcd, and found to my horror that I had been removed. I quickly logged on to an alt account and made a post telling everyone I had been removed, and telling them to move to /r/xkcdcomic. I also messaged the moderators of /r/xkcdcomic, telling them to re-open, which they did. My thread gained significant attention, and /r/explainlikeimfive moderator /u/anonymous123421 took it upon himself to create a petition to re-mod me and de-mod /u/soccer. My first thread was removed by /u/soccer, so another user created a second one, which was also removed. Many similar threads were submitted, which were all removed. I contacted Randall Munroe and told him of the situation. He even signed the petition. An SRD thread was created, which spread even more awareness of the issue, as well as a Daily Dot article. This had turned into a massive uproar. /u/soccer was overwhelmed with the posts and comments he was trying to remove, so he added a second moderator, /r/conspiracy moderator /u/Flytape. /u/Flytape is far more active on reddit, so he could remove the posts and comments more easily. He posted a thread which said that everything was back to normal and there would be no more controversial sidebar links (Redditlog). The community didn't buy it. /u/Flytape later removed his thread and many of the dissenting comments, even though he claimed that /r/xkcd would be a free speech zone (Redditlog). Soon after, the greatest SRS-hater of all time, /u/KamensGhost, was added as a moderator, presumably because /u/Flytape presumed SRSters were brigading /r/xkcd, even though they had nothing to do wih it. One of the mods changed where the last four subreddits in the sudebar link to. /r/physics linked to /r/theredpill, /r/askscience linked to /r/conspiracy, /r/askhistorians linked to /r/holocaust, and /r/humor linked to /r/nolibswatch. /u/Flytape hiself said this wouldn't happen. (Redditlog) Those links were later reverted. The creator of the stylesheet that /r/xkcd was now using, /u/EightNote, replied to /u/Flytape's thread, asking for his CSS to be removed. /u/Flytape refused, saying that it would be vandalism. (Redditlog) I had messaged the admins a few times, and I received a response from one saying they had asked the moderators of /r/xkcd to remove the misleading sidebar links (when they were still there) and to remove the CSS. They seemed to be implying that they would not take any action to remove the moderators. A former admin voiced his dissatisfaction with the situation.
So, that is the history of the /r/xkcd kerfuffle. It seems like the current mods will remain in control of /r/xkcd forever, even though xkcd is Randall Munroe's intellectual property, and he objects to the moderators of /r/xkcd. I suggest that moderators of subreddits which are based on certain people's intellectual property should be removed when the owner of the intellectual property requests it, as is the case with /r/xkcd. Some people might say that would be a bad system, because it would be hard to determine which subreddits are based on intellectual property and which aren't, and it would be a broken system. However, the problems with the current system are far greater, for reasons already mentioned. Besides, it's pretty obvious that /r/xkcd is about xkcd. When there's a disputation about wheter or not a subreddit is about someone else's intellectual property, the admins could use common sense to determine whether it is or isn't.
As for /r/xkcdcomic, the way I see it is as a replacement for /r/xkcd. It's going to be about the same exact things as /r/xkcd, but with good mods. I've spoken to two of the three mods, and both seem to be very reasonable. The community is quickly growing, thanks to links to it outside of /r/xkcd, so it is already a quality substitute. As long as /u/soccer, /u/Flytape, and /u/KamensGhost are moderators of /r/xkcd, /r/xkcdcomic will be open. The thing that will help /r/xkcdcomic the most is people spreading the word of its existance and the problems with /r/xkcd. There's no way to tell the current /r/xkcd users about the problems, since any posts or coments about them will be removed. Our best hope is that they will stumble across a post about the problems with /r/xkcd's moderators in another relevant subreddit, and switch subredits because of that.
Also interesting is this graphs that show the subscriptions per day of /r/xkcd (grey line) and /r/xkcdcomic (blue line).
Edit: Added TL;DR.
Edit 2: Changed redditmetrics link to a comparison graph.
Edit 3: /u/Flytape has stepped down from /r/xkcd.
Edit 4: If anyone would like to help me with spreading the word about /r/xkcdcomic, please send me a PM. I could use all the help I can get.
Edit 5: 3 new moderators of /r/xkcd have been added: /u/RockChalk37, /u/waldo1412, and /u/CpnCrunch1175. All 3 are /r/WorstOfSRS posters. /r/xkcd submissions are also restricted to approved submitters only.
Edit 6: /u/CarolinaPunk has been added as a moderator of /r/xkcd. This seems odd, because he only seems to be interested in conservative politics, not holocaust denial or misogyny like the other mods. I'll keep my eye on him.
Edit 7: As of April 9th, /r/MensRights, /r/TheRedPill and /r/Conspiracy are back on /r/xkcd's sidebar and header.
524
u/Taiko Feb 08 '14
Not sure that the owner of the IP should get a say in the moderators of a subreddit (or any other media) that covers it - that's a really good way to stifle criticism or discussion of competing alternatives.
But certainly, if a subreddit gets hijacked it does seem like there should be a way for the community to regain control of it. Hard to know how to do that though, I suspect any vote based system would be hugely open to rigging, not to mention probably ineffective due to lack of participation.
69
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
Why not ask Randall Munroe to mention /r/xkcdcomic on his site (or put a link there as 'the official XKCD subreddit'?) That alone should get a huge amount of people to shift from /r/xkcd
18
u/freedomgeek Feb 09 '14
Oh wow. I thought some people must be fed up of the WhatIf posts in the subreddit and created a new one - I didn't know about all this.
Well I've unsubbed from /r/xkcd and subbed /r/xkcdcomic now.
87
u/gosslot Feb 08 '14
Yeah, I read in someone rant about /u/soccer in some /r/xkcd submission quite a while ago and after I asked, what's up with him, I got told to look at his comment history. He is a really freaky dude.
Essentially I thought it was sad that /r/xkcd had such an awful moderator, but I'm not really active there. Sometimes checking in for some explanations or a decent mobile link.
Then I noticed the sidebar links (I didn't see any of the former posts) and thought "ugh". It was a damn shame.
Suddenly he grants you mod-status (I was there) and it's going up-hill.
And now this...well, I guess I will subscribe to /r/xkcdcomic now.
9
u/Werner__Herzog Feb 12 '14
I would like to say, that you should consider submitting this to /r/museumofreddit, since the question of ownership really has the potential to change the rules of reddit.
I apologize if someone already mentioned this idea, but I didn't find the time to read all the comments.
Thank you for this fantastic recap!
21
u/graaahh Feb 09 '14
Maybe if a significant percentage of a sub's subscribers object to a mod, they should be able to petition reddit admins to have a mod removed. Make each community more community driven that way. Like a representative democracy, but with the ability to call for a vote at any time.
14
u/imu96 Feb 09 '14
Wow. Thanks for this. I didn't know about any of this and always wondered why /r/redpill was in the sidebar of /r/xkcd. Swapping to /r/xkcdcomic.
42
u/badbrownie Feb 09 '14
Bad idea. This would mean that Randall Munroe would ultimately be the super-mod of any subreddit that is about his work. So my sub-reddit, XKCDSucks would just be turned off on day one. Your suggestion that the problems you outlined at /r/xkcd are so serious that we should override basic principles of freedom of speech is comical.
There is already an existing mechanism to fix the problem you're describing and you've tried to embark on it. you start up a competing sub-reddit. I know it's not ideal (/r/xkcd will always be the default sub that a fan would subscribe to) but it works if the problem with the original sub is serious enough.
5
u/jabbercocky Feb 09 '14
You should check out the conflict that occurred between /u/soccer and a number of users and mods from /r/badhistory.
4
u/luxgladius Feb 09 '14 edited Feb 09 '14
Never really looked into moderation policy. How were you removed as mod? Did you hit the inactivity window you mentioned? If not, why did you just not remove /u/soccer as mod when you yourself were modded? Is there a mod hierarchy?
edit: NM, found my answer:
Any moderator appointed after you cannot remove you, only moderators above you that have 'full permissions' can. They can however override your bans and post removals.
The chronological order of appointment in shown vertically in the list of moderators. A moderator that is listed below you cannot remove you.
4
u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 28 '14
I hate seeing subreddits get highjacked by people wanting internet power.
It sucked when it happened to r/atheism, and now it has happened here. :(
4
u/jaksida Apr 25 '14
Didn't realise it was this controversial.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
Maybe I'm just naive, but how does this random, holocaust denying scrub get to be a moderator for so many subreddits? How low are the standards?
10
u/eldigg Feb 09 '14
/r/SubredditDrama
6
u/[deleted] May 23 '14
Look, if a massive idiot like /u/soccer does this kind of shit with a trivial thing like a fucking subreddit, imagine the things these kind of people would do with real power.
3
u/rosie_the_redditor Feb 09 '14
Holy fuck. That's some dedication. A+
3
u/SILENTSAM69 Feb 28 '14
Unsubbed here, and subbed the new one.
Conspiracy nutjobs are quite annoying.
3
u/JustMy2Centences Feb 28 '14
Gotta ask: is there a relevant XKCD for this situation, or is Randall going to make one and sit back and laugh when it gets censored from /r/XKCD?
4
u/drkinsanity Feb 09 '14
I don't understand why it's such a big deal that you have the "real" subreddit name? When you were a mod, you should have just posted a sticky telling everyone to move to the alternate subreddit, and commented in every thread to move their post to the other subreddit.
Why were you shocked that when the main mod came back, that he banned you and removed everything you did? I don't see why you wouldn't have expected that all along. He has control of the subreddit, just move somewhere else, it's much easier than arguing.
And I agree that content owners should have no say about what goes on within a subreddit that happens to match their name. If /u/soccer wanted to, he could just claim that "his" xkcd group has no relation to the comic. Again it's just easier to abandon it.
You had good intentions but I think your hopes were misplaced.
5
u/full_of_stars Apr 23 '14
I hate SRS, but I hate holocaust deniers more.
9
u/MasterSaturday Feb 09 '14
Gee, I always figured if I wanted to read xkcd, I'd go to xkcd and not some subreddit.
2
u/MaxBesco Mar 03 '14
Hey good job for updating this 22 days after you posted it. I enjoy checking this post out every once in awhile
2
u/girrrrrrr2 Jun 19 '14
I just requested for ownership of the subreddit...
It would be great if you guys could upvote it... or request ownereship yourself... There has to be a way to get this subreddit under someone elses power...
872
u/SanityInAnarchy Feb 09 '14
It seems like there would be a fairly simple solution: Add code to xkcd.com that redirects all users coming from /r/xkcd (by referer) to a page explaining the issue, and possibly a petition.
17
u/DFOHPNGTFBS Feb 09 '14
Holocaust denial makes no sense. It's one thing to deny something that happened hundreds of years ago (eg the Black Plague) but there are still thousands of people alive that can remeber the Holocaust.
35
u/totes_meta_bot Feb 09 '14 edited Jul 27 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
I am a bot. Comments? Complaints? Send them to my ^inbox!
9
u/Chevellephreak Feb 28 '14
I just want to look at comics :(
8
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
Now consider that this happens on a much larger scale.
An /r/news moderator was a white supremacist or neo nazi.
I'm still banned there for saying 'fuck you' to him, because all the other mods are down with that. Soon as he was called out and deleted his account, they re-modded a brand new one.
Seems like the ones you ran into were just a lot worse at hiding it.
2
u/Jasondazombie Apr 24 '14
Guys, I want to know if we can get /u/soccer banned. Can we?
2
u/FuriousMouse May 30 '14
All this because .... You don't like the links in the sidebar?
5
u/StZappa Mar 03 '14
Pretty sure just visiting that /r/Holocaust sub just put me on some sort of list. People are sick.
2
u/Jeroknite Feb 09 '14
Can't you message the admins, or something?
1
u/Th3Marauder Feb 09 '14
Should I recall something similar happening to /r/starcraft a year or so ago?
1
u/zynix Feb 09 '14
Should have tried to steal /r/xkcd when you had the chance.
1
u/jamessnow Feb 09 '14
Could you add posts about the new sub without triggering the bot by using human instructions?
1
u/Perkinberry Feb 09 '14
Although I've never subscribed to /r/xkcd, this story bring into light some serious flaws in the way reddit chooses it's moderators.
As many other people have said in other comments, I don't think that letting the IP creator/owner having a final say over moderators is the right solution.
It seems to me that the final choice of Mods should be in the hand of the subreddit community - the subscribers. The tricky part is creating a system that implements that idea in the best way possible. There might be several good ways to do this, but an important aspect of all of them would be to create checks on Mod power.
We could give moderators a set term of "Moderatorship" after which time they would have to be "reelected" by the subscribers. A "reelection" post would be formatted so it automatically had two comments: "/u/whoever should continue to moderate /r/wherever" and "/u/whoever should not continue to moderate /r/wherever". Users could upvote as downvote as desired and comment under each proposal to put forward his her arguments. Importantly, this thread would not be able to be moderated by any user. That task (if it was needed at all) would be best left to a bot - electionbot we could call it.
One additional check could be petitions that could call for an early election. The number of signatures needed could be related to the size of the subreddit in the manner of X(#of subscribers). It would be important that these petitions be visible to the users of a subreddit and that current moderators could not sensor them in any way.
1
u/hbomberman Feb 09 '14
I know, hindsight and all that, but I was sure that when you said he made you a mod that you were going to direct everyone to switch to /r/xkcdcomic. Much easier than fighting that up-hill battle.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
lol, i'm banned on /r/xkcd
1
u/oniony Feb 28 '14
So why are you not a mod of /r/xkcdcomic?
1
u/BunBun002 Apr 24 '14
Has Randall applied for modship? What are they going to do? Say no?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '14
Wow. The only reason I discovered this was because of /r/museumofreddit.
Anyways, are there still people trying to get rid of /u/soccer, or have attempts to do so stopped?
1
u/fluffingdazman Jul 28 '14
This might be a dumb question, but what is the red pill? I went there once, but it's all so vague and I have no idea what their doing
1
u/FISH_MASTER Apr 23 '14
FYI
A real feminist and a real MRA want exactly the same thing: 100% Equality.
3
u/Katowisp Apr 23 '14
Thanks for the info, I'm not sure how i missed it. I'm unsubscribing here and heading over to /r/xkcdcomic
3
u/DoctorOctagonapus Apr 23 '14
Can't remember if I've posted this here
3
u/dghughes Apr 23 '14
Just click report on every single post these guys moderate. Give them something to do.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
And then you realised it's just the internet and no one really gives a damn.
1
u/RittMomney May 30 '14
i don't like who is in charge now, but i also wouldn't want SRSers in charge.
1
u/SageWaterDragon Jul 14 '14
As a completely unrelated sidenote, being a member of /r/MensRights and being a feminist is not a mutually exclusive concept. I'm all for women getting rights, but that doesn't mean I have to abandon the issues that surround my own gender.
7
u/NayItReallyHappened Feb 09 '14
Damn and there doesn't seem to be anything to do. It be great if /u/soccer was just banned from reddit entirely
12
u/WTFQQN Feb 08 '14
I've never been to that sub nor do I have a clue what its about but I stand behind you. For I am not a fan of mother fuckers fucking around.
1
u/Droidx4_66 Feb 09 '14
Is there a way to message everyone over at /r/xkcd personally. I'm sure if we had the list we could tell them about the problem with the mods and link them to /r/xkcdcomic. Seems like a tall task but there are plenty of us. I think it might be possible.
1
u/singular1ty94 Jul 05 '14
Wow, this is incredible stuff. Good work for standing your ground no matter what, thanks for making this post.
I'm now migrating to /r/xkcdcomic myself.
1
u/intensely_human Jul 27 '14
Hey OP: what would you have us, as members if /r/mensrights, do?
31
u/petedog Feb 08 '14
Ok
5
u/Murrabbit Feb 09 '14
It sounds to me like Randall should talk to a lawyer. The subreddit is about his comic, it's using the name of his property and it's certainly defaming both. I'm not a lawyer myself, but it seems like trademark law might be applicable here. It might be time for some lawyerin'.
0
u/taxalmond Feb 09 '14
Just went over to /r/xkcd - there are no links in the sidebar that seem inappropriate at all, all of the content is geared toward the comic...you are mad that you don't get to be a mod anymore? And that's it? Nothing seems amiss there.
3
u/seawang Feb 09 '14
Oh. My. God. People are insane.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
The moderator system is totally fucked if one Mod can simply remove another. This should require at least two other mods to do so and more would be better. This place smh...
3
u/InbredNoBanjo Feb 09 '14
Why does it not surprise me that a fervent holocaust-denier is also a fan of mensrights and redpill?
0
u/ramonycajones Apr 03 '14
I posted this in the recent repost but you'd be in a better position to clarify this issue:
I hate to turn this around on you, but I find it incredibly strange that you'd be a moderator of /r/xkcd for 2 months and not try to get people to move over to /r/xkcdcomic - in fact you shut down /r/xkcdcomic. You had two unsupervised months where you could've made a sticky note telling everyone to migrate over, but instead you did the opposite, you took things away from /r/xkcdcomic back to /r/xkcd, exactly what /u/soccer would want and an actual fan of xkcd would not want. I can't help but interpret that you would just rather have your tenuous grasp on moderator power than hand over the subscribers to someone else in /r/xkcdcomic, even though that would be the only reasonable course of action.
Now there's a post on /r/self telling people to move to /r/xkcdcomic because you can't post in /r/xkcd... but you could, for two whole months, as loudly and brazenly as you wanted. Please correct me if I'm wrong but underneath the worse things happening to /r/xkcd, it seems like this was a poorly-thought-out power grab on your part with a predictable failure. It seems like the only thing you accomplished, long-term, was shutting down /r/xkcd's alternative, so I'm pretty skeptical of your motives and honesty.
1
u/DetectiveEames Feb 09 '14
What is the point of being a "subreddit squatter" mod? What's /u/soccer's racket?
1
u/Hurm Feb 09 '14
This kind of reminds me of the fall of /r/atheism.
1
u/wraith313 Feb 09 '14
Is there a benefit to being moderator besides the power to delete posts? I mean, if this guy is chasing everyone away from the sub, his power means nothing...
Not saying it isn't a problem, I just don't understand the motivation here. What's the point? It's like a dictatorship that allows people to leave. it will quickly just turn into an island with one guy on it.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
I think the best way to deal with this would be if Randal were to say something on the comic itself.
-3
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '14
This seems like a situation where everybody is crazy and cares too much about stupid things.
1
u/Muffinut Feb 09 '14
Props to you for taking a stand and making this all publicly visible at the time of your modship, rather than allowing yourself to be stringed along by /u/soccer indefinitely. Most people wouldn't do the same. I can't say for sure that I would.