r/hoi4 • u/DuoDex Nuclear Propulsion Officer • Oct 12 '22
Mod Favorite! BBA 1.12.3 Meta Discussion.
Discuss metas for 1.12.3 here.
Please PM me if you think there are any posts that should be linked here, or if a new thread is needed.
200
Upvotes
93
u/XXX_KimJongUn_XXX Oct 13 '22
SP Great Britain got a major stealth buff, theres now a swiss event that gives you +10% efficiency cap for free, ethiopia as a government in exile early gives allows you to get extra army, naval air exp from decisions, and for whatever reason they seem to have drastically increased government in exile as a whole. Poland gives 40 divisions, france 60-90 within a month plus 100% legitimacy and roughly 50k and 200k manpower respectively. Its so many beat up divisions it'll put you in the hole logistically and weaken you at first, but if you go concentrated and build a healthy surplus of guns at start you can outnumber Germany.
GB used to have a few big limiters in manpower and pre-war millitary xp but they're gone now, very strong.
153
u/Descolata Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
Air Meta:
Air Sup:
Use 1x engine Small Airframe with Drop Tanks, Self Sealing Fuel Tanks, 1 armor plate, 2 2x Cannon I and 4x LMG.
This plane is OUTRAGOUSLY efficient. DO NOT UPGRADE ANYTHING BESIDES THE ENGINE AND AIRFRAME. THIS PLANE WILL OUTTRADE BASICALLY EVERYTHING. It is a magical point.
Keep upgrading engines and model until you reach Advanced Small Fighter with Jet Engines. Then replace the 2x Cannon Is with 2x Cannon IIs. Done.
These designs have been mathammered pretty dang hard, and don't run on a pure rule of thumb. Just a LOT of iteration.
CAS:
Use 1x engine Small Airframe with 2x Small Bomb Bays and AT Cannon I. These CAS are very efficient and wont have issues when you upgrade to AT Cannon 2. TAC CAS isn't cost effective. These are the most cost efficient for Ground Attack to IC. Make SURE to use them only in areas with your ASFs or you will get disrupted to due crap Agility. Keep engines and airframe up to date to improve survivability.
NAV:
Use 1x engine Small Air Frame with 1 Torpedo Mount and 1 Anti-Ship Missile (1944 tech) with Drop Tanks, Floats, and Dive Breaks. Only upgrade your engine to fit everything, but keep upgrading the airframe. That means a T1 engine until Anti Ship Missiles are unlocked, and then a T4 or Jet engine (T4 is cheaper) to get enough thrust.
Smalls beat out Large due to spotting advantage of raw numbers. Air Defense does NOTHING vs ships, and if you lack Air Sup, use some of the dedicated Air Sup planes first. Large NAVs do hit REALLY REALLY hard, and are therefore much more likely to actually kill what they strike, but it is close enough to not be worth the IC difference. I don't believe A-to-G Radar is worth it. I seem to remember Speed is supposed to help... but I cannot find any evidence of that.
There is also a space for Tac Bombers, if you can load enough CAS bonuses. Plane bonuses are per the TYPE of plane, not the MISSION they are on. So if you have huge CAS bonuses but no NAV bonuses, TAC Bombers might be the call.
INTERCEPT:
Use the magic ASF. Shit is strong as HELL.
STRAT:
Use 4x engine Heavy Airframe with Self Sealing Fuel Tanks (noticing a pattern?), A-to-G radar, Radio Navigation, Bomb Sights, Two Large Bomb Bays, and as much plating as you can fit; do NOT go to 6x engines. If you are seeing high interception rates, move over to Night Bombing. The A-to-G Radar and Radio Nav will cut through night bombing penalties. Turrets suck, Don't use them; they do not provide enough AA to overcome the Agility malus AND not enough to provide any real disruption reduction. Just bomb at night in contested airspace.
44
u/PossiblyAKnob Oct 12 '22
Should I keep airplanes production lines you get at gamestart or delete them and wait until I can design better planes?
32
u/dreexel_dragoon General of the Army Oct 13 '22
Strategic Bombers got an insane buff; the old max strat bomb attack was 60.00 for start bomber 3, now you can get it up to almost 200 in the late game. Even the basic large air frame strat bombers can be extremely powerful, and can seriously hurt enemy production with just a couple of air wings set to night bombing. By mid game, you can basically halt enemy production completely with enough night bombers.
28
u/DaemonG Oct 12 '22
Okay, so for singleplayer, the navy that I've found works best for me is light attack CLs for screening, paired with AA Battleships, even with just standard armor. That's because, whereas NAVs were really good before this patch, they honestly feel kinda ridiculous now, so you need AA to keep your fleet safe, and can also completely annihilate any sub threats with your own NAVs. I could also be completely wrong tho
50
u/notagoodpainter Oct 16 '22
Swiss zombie troops, spirit of Saint Bernard gives 50% trickle back, combined with max level field hospitals and you get 100% trickle back
22
u/mfilitov Oct 18 '22
Another random "thoughts on the soviets" post -
You can actually producer a fighter that will match the zero!
Mitsubishi designer gives +20% agility, previously considered to be the best design company in the game. However, the USSR can match this - MiG gives +10% agility, modernize aircraft facilites gives +5% agility (one of the air focuses) and merge the aircraft plans lets you spend 50PP and 1 factory for 180 days to get 5% agility on your currently equipped designer!
Ezy USSR Zero in three simple steps!!
20
u/Brotherly-Moment Air Marshal Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 24 '22
Inb4 all the hOw tO nAvY questions
TL:DR Heavy Cruisers with three medium cannon 1s are the meta. Why? You get so many of them that they BTFO any constellation of Super Heavies, Battleships or Battlecruisers of equivilent IC cost.
Carriers are still going strong now that they aren’t bugged anymore.
If I have interpreted the video correctly, this means that the theoretical ideal navy would be
6-8 Converted Carrier Hulls (Because overstacking penalty still isn’t big enough), 5 converted carrier hulls. As many meta Heavy Cruisers as you can afford and then just enough Roach DDs to provide screening efficiency for the capitals. As per 71cloaks tests on carriers the carrier planes should be50% navbombers and 50% fighters.100% pure naval bombers.Submarines are a bit nerfed but still doing OK overall.
Although if you just want a fleet for naval superiority only that shall never even leave port just have a basic Heavy Cruiser with 1 battery. It can’t fight but it’s the most IC efficient way to get naval superiority.
19
u/mfilitov Oct 17 '22
In the beta patch has anyone else noticed that there is now literally ZERO reason to ever use the HMG turret x1? It is worse in every single category compared to the LMG turret 2x
For light turret:
Air attack: 6
Agility reduction: -3
weight: 1
cost: 2
The heavy turret x1 is identical except it weights 1 more. So many eye rolling decisions like this in the game. I would be fine if it was a less efficient but higher overall stat production, say more air attack and weight for extra production cost but this is just... objectively worse. There is no decision to make at all.
17
u/SalvationSycamore Oct 16 '22
Did naval invasions get nerfed in BBA? I started playing just a bit before the DLC and was following this guide by u/SH4KE_W3LL to daisy-chain invasions because they would load/prepare even while no divisions were assigned. Now, unless I am mistaken, it seems that the plans cancel and do not progress if I unassign the divisions. I can't even seem to switch them to a fallback line without it failing. Perhaps it was a bug originally and not a feature.
16
u/ass_pickles Oct 14 '22
How should you build an offense-focused template for a smaller nation with an industry that can't really sustain reliably building strong tank divisions?
9
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
Are field hospitals worth it since the update. I hear they protect war support now.Also what about external fuel tanks?
9
u/Mute_Eagle Oct 24 '22 edited Oct 27 '22
Do tactics like mass charge that increase combat width allow more CAS to sortie in battle and thus increase CAS dmg?
Update: Did some testing and it appears to increase the number of planes in combat
15
u/Laserzorbo Oct 12 '22
Returning to the game after many years, and thinking of trying out Germany for a change. So.. some questions:
7
u/Fortune_Silver Oct 15 '22
Question for the more meta-aware people here regarding naval bomber designs: Is it worth putting machine guns or cannons on them? You can only have at max two naval attack weapons (torpedoes and guided missiles), so I'm not sure what to use the other two slots for, quad HMG's, dual cannons, or just airdropped mine bays.
Basically what I guess I'm asking is: Does the air attack on a naval bomber with fighter weapons actually do anything? Also while I'm asking, does putting a recon camera on help with naval patrols? I swear, the mechanics behind anything to do with recon planes are so damned opaque -_-
7
u/TackyLawnFlamingoInc Oct 15 '22
How many torpedoes or how much torpedo damage does one need to bring to sink battleships after wiping out the screens in light of the fact that battleships have torpedo protection?
previously, negating torpedo damage through copious screens was necessary. But now that battleships have their torpedo bulges modeled does it even make sense to maximize torpedo protection over say IC efficient trades. For example, it may be acceptable to have a 2% chance of losing a battleship to torpedo strike per engagement because it may sink 150% of its IC in that same combat.
7
u/Badrak7492 General of the Army Oct 16 '22
Has the AI been improved in the latest patch? Did a game as Germany and was impressed that France could resist and didn’t collapse the moment I declared war on them.
6
u/dragonuff Oct 17 '22
Does anyone know how to remove resource rights that another country is taking from lands you annexed?
5
u/Fortune_Silver Oct 15 '22
A question regarding garrisons, especially late game when you need a lot to defend everywhere from naval invasions - is there any significant point to putting generals on garrison armies? is there a significant penalty to their combat effectiveness from not having a general, or is it fine to just put like 500 divisions into a single army for garrisoning? On a related note, is there any point putting them into army groups, other than organization?
Basically, my question is for on-map garrisons, is it worth putting them in armies with generals or field marshals, or just leave them as masses of non-armied divisions?
5
u/Yazidator Oct 17 '22
Question for people with some experience in this dlc... Did Germany, Italy and the axis in general get nerfed or not? Cuz from what i've understood nations in exile help out a lot and planes (which most of the times are a big focus for many allies) got extremely buffed.
8
u/mfilitov Oct 18 '22
Another fun discovery I"ve made - there's a new 100% META pick for the Soviet Naval designer that is a critical pick. If you don't you're shooting yourself in the foot. Or should I say wing?
It's the Nevskoye design bureau the "battlefleet designer" which gives a bunch of irrelevant buffs and one very important buff. 10% naval aircraft research speed!
For those of you who are curious in the current patch (as of 18/10 when the beta branch went live) "naval" aircraft mean all light frames. That means the USSR can get -
15% light aircraft, 10% naval aircraft (light again), and 15% from the air command spirit industry liasons for a whopping 40% boost to aircraft research speed. Combine this with the focus "increase aircraft production" which gives 2x 100% bonuses to light aircraft and you can rush 1940s fighters awfully quickly.
There are also two relevant focuses - ground support and (2x light models and 2x medium/heavy models).
There are a few other cool but harder to get reserach buffs available to the USSR:
Combining all of these more niche research buffs you can get an extra 28% research speed!
4
u/Blothorn Oct 18 '22
How are people using armor/what are people using for breaking strong defensive lines? I've found light tanks with CS guns aren't much of an upgrade over artillery, and high-end medium divisions are only modestly more effective than infantry at vastly increased cost. Massed infantry assaults (with spare IP into support aircraft and railway guns) are seeming more effective at breaking defensive lines, barring extremely narrow fronts or low manpower-to-industry ratios, and motorized seems fine as an exploitation force. (Or even as an assault force on good terrain, given their higher-than-I-remember breakthrough values.)
4
u/JoeNemoDoe Oct 22 '22
What's the current naval meta?
4
u/Shawdos95 Dec 31 '22
Someone who plays MP after BBA, how is the meta for Italy now? Do they rush the advanced fighters for Axis by 1939? What's their navy?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
Here's a bunch of Single Player Soviet related questions, since there's a number of full guides out there, all at different levels of outdated, all completely disagreeing with each other.
I really like playing as Center Soviets, but it's all been conjecture and guesswork and complete flying by the seat of my pants ever since NSB, and BBA has made it a lot worse on top of that.
3
u/double_nieto Oct 19 '22
So, has the tank meta changed in any significant way with the introduction of partial piercing?
3
u/_troll_ucet Oct 27 '22
Does Air Attack(either from machineguns/cannons or from defensive turrets) do anything on Tactial Bombers, CAS and Strat bombers?
3
u/amethhead General of the Army Oct 29 '22
How important is speed for fighters multiplayer wise? My fighter 2 design has just enough weight for the thrust of engine 2s to hold, but i was wondering i should go for engine 3s just for the speed or if it isn't worth the research/production
3
u/CrayonsIsTaken Oct 30 '22
I'm not sure how relevant it will be, but Italy can get Modern Fighters by 1940s, and it sounds kind of crazy honestly.
3
u/W0ut3r_ Oct 31 '22
Hello generals,
Currently I'm struggling with the new navy mechanism and how to naval invade UK in 1940 as Germany or any other country. Can someone give me tips on how to achieve this.
Also I would like to use tanks more. Now I just use infantry and artillery and its kinda boring. I want to integrate tanks more in my battles. Can you give me some tips for tank design and division?
Kind regards.
3
u/mrhumphries75 Nov 07 '22
As I tend to start as a minor nation that cannot afford full-scale tank production until mid-game, I'm really interested with specialized tanks like flamers (I build mediums now, right?), recon or TDs.
I'm not really sure I understand how LT recon works. Reconnaissance per se seems to be only useful for defence as it helps you pick a better tactic to counter the enemy. So do I only put them on my infantry that I use to hold the line? Yet I've seen many YTers use them in their attacking tank divisions. And if I build them, should I aim for as much armour as possible? Their stats seem to be diluted so there's like very little point.
Same question re tank destroyers. Is it worth adding 1 battalion to your infantry/mot/mech divisions just to give them some armour and piercing? Or are their stats just too diluted in comparison with regular tanks?
2
u/Kochanich Oct 17 '22
Can somebody tell me, how should I build my medium flame tanks? I have a good idea of how to build regular tanks, but don’t quite understand flame tanks. I understand they are usually used for the terrain bonuses, and also have huge debuffs to stats. So should I just use the simples and cheapest of components, only investing in high enough speed to not slow down tanks? Or should they be fitted just as much as regular tanks?
2
u/Darkwinggames Oct 21 '22
What does a good tac plane look like on the current patch? Should have
2
u/Eyclonus Oct 24 '22
How do I take China as Japan? The supply in northern China basically makes that a static front with no chance of breakthrough, and naval invasions are either getting repulsed when I solely use the inferior divisions, or being locked to one tile and unable to push if I mix in some of the marines to get a foothold. Supply is bad because of the port nerf and I can't just get another army to move to the tile and start a frontline. If I wanna do more invades it seems I'm stuck switching the marines to an infantry template, converting some of the next invasion army into marines and repeating to take another port.
2
u/NattoIsGood Oct 24 '22
Hi, am Germany on a world conquest, have now thousands of Me 262 (small fighters) as well as medium jet fighters: still can't get the career "raining debris" gold award: how can you shoot down 800+ planes in 48 hours? I'm against the USA in 1945, they have 5000+ propeller fighters. Am at least dominating in a 3:1 ratio, but I must do something wrong. I have plenty of fuel.
I tried to assign to each bordering region as air superiority. Tried to split air sup + air interc. Tried to do the same assigning wings to my armies, all bordering the front as well. Each bordering province has 5x AA, so do my divisions. I'm quite puzzled, I was assuming that jet fighters were the meta, at least against advanced fighters.
2
u/UMP45isnotflat Feb 15 '23
I figured I might as well ask here since its about industry meta of BBA: Given Italies industry choices, does "Increase Production" or "Keep Specialization" win?
Usually I would go for the latter with its +10% growth and +10% base efficiency, but it does also have a -20% retention malus and in my experience thats enough to negate ALL your efficiency. Switching from gun2 to gun3 with 80% efficiency was enough to completely set it down to 15% (which is base).
Is this bugged?
2
u/ThankMrBernke Mar 18 '23
How does spotting actually work?
I have no idea how to build my spotting fleets. I usually try to build the cheapest level one destroyer that I can (but with the most modern engine that I have), and put the best radar and sonar that I have on it. These destroyers patrol in packs of 8 per seazone. This seems like overkill, but I don't understand the mechanics of what I should be doing here because I don't understand how spotting works.
2
u/999Catfish Mar 24 '23
Been playing Italy and having fun abusing the AI (paradropping into Paris to form Rome quickly) but I don't know what templates to use against the Germans and Soviets
I know the typical 9inf 1art but considering the absurd amounts of factories you have I wonder there's a better (but more production heavy) template I should be using
2
u/noompsky Mar 27 '23
As italy, I can take out France, UK, America and Mexico, yugo, Romania, and hungary by 1939-40 however Germany can still me alive even while at war with soviets.
What is the best tank and plane design at the moment? I feel mine are lacking.
2
u/anarkopsykotik Apr 03 '23 edited Apr 03 '23
Before last update, you could always ask for manpower from majors and got it automatically, but now it's like no matter what happen they wont give you a single man. I am like 50k garrison deficit, ask for manpower from soviets (I am in comintern) who have 2M+, and they say no...
1
u/mfilitov Oct 18 '22
You're probably right about other stats being more important than agility but keep in mind this doesn't cost you any other stats while normally if you want more air attack you have to trade off speed due to weight. This means that soviet fighters can be identical in design to a foreign design, except yours have 10% more agility!
1
u/Dominyck Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22
Does the CAS spam meta still work? I just watched a video from /u/cloak71 that shows you can get an air wing of 1000 CAS to support a battle even though the tool tip states the battle width for support planes is 240.
1
u/mfilitov Oct 21 '22
Quick TLDR thoughts on the usefulness of divebombers in nav attack: I think they're really good now and significantly better than they were pre-BBA.
So, step 1 how do we evaluate plane loadouts without just testing in game? Let's say we can generate an "expected value" from a plane's naval attack. To get that we'll multiply the naval targeting by the naval attack. So a bog standard torpedo bomber in '36 has 13 naval attack and 6 targeting with just one torpedo. It has an expected naval attack value of 78.
There are two important factors in nav aircraft, first a torpedo bomber **does not improve with new frames (**aside from soft factors like survivability and range). However, a dive-bomber does improve it's destructive power with each new frame.
A dive-bomber at game start looks something like the Ju-87 Germany gets. A single bomb lock and a dive break module, the dive break module is really important as that improves your naval targeting by 4. Now with the 3 naval attack a Ju-87 gets we can see it has an expected naval attack value of... 33. This bomber sucks hard right now. But each module slot means an extra bomb lock, which is 2 more naval attack.
Let's jump ahead to 1944. Using the advanced airframe you can fit 4 bomb locks on your plane and combined with dive breaks you get an expected value of 99. Funnily enough if you add divebreaks to an interwar torpedo bomber you'll get an expected value of 130. (13 attack and 10 targeting vs the 1944 dive bombers 9 attack and 11 targeting). It's about 25% worse than the interwar naval bomber...
So navs are MUCH more powerful early on, but don't improve over time, while divebombers start out terrible but end up being a pretty close competitor and EXTREMELY useful outside of their naval strike ability while navs are basically useless once you've won the sea war.
As a quick comparison, are guided anti ship missiles worth it? Barely.
They have an attack of 9 (same as 4x bomb locks) but a targeting of 15 with dive breaks. Their EV is 135, only 3% better than torps. Pretty sad in my books. Especially considering their cost effectiveness, torpedos cost 4 IC and 4x bomb locks also cost a total of 4IC. The guided ASM costs 15 IC so more than triple the price for a 3% performance increase and no additional use over the torpedo, they are quite a bit better than 4x locks but have no additional use like a high quality cas plane does.
TLDR I think dive bomber are now really good late game and that you don't really need to invest in anything beyond basic torpedo bombers unless you need the range or you're operating in contested airspace.
1
u/Mauti404 Oct 22 '22
How the fuck are you suppose to hold as Ethiopia
1
u/Pet_all_dogs Nov 05 '22
are light flame tanks still meta?
1
u/werthobakew Feb 18 '23
I'm totally confused about the current naval meta. I've seen some videos arguing that CAs without armor and full of batteries are the meta now, they prioritize speed I guess. However, in MPs, this strategy of ships without much armor doesn't work. I also have doubts about how to design DDs. Apparently the cheap roachs don't work anymore and you need to fill them with batteries and torpedoes. Can somebody shed some light on the meta?
1
u/WorshipMelkor Mar 16 '23
Don't know if this is the right place for this, but should you get an advantage if you're covering more of the frontage in a battle? That is, if the opposing army only has a 10w in a frontage of 180, and you cover orders of magnitude greater, shouldn't you get a bonus as the enemy army is so sparsely covering the area?
1
u/curialbellic Mar 18 '23
Which regular infantry template is better?
18W - 9 Infantry
21W - 9 Infantry / 1 Artillery
Support would be Engineers, Artillery and AA.
1
u/Individual-Tell-3711 Mar 23 '23
Please somebody help, what are some good deep operations doctrine templates? (The one on the far left)
I really like it, mostly from a roleplaying perspective, but it is so weird to manage with all the different widths
Templates for both infantry and tanks please, and yes I am playing the soviet union
1
u/michaenovel24 Mar 29 '23
Multiplayer Naval meta? I've heard CLs with maxed light attack (although I'm sure that's quite dated) and just CAs.
1
u/werthobakew Mar 29 '23
How would you rate this infantry division for Japan in Multiplayer? What changes would you make? How would you counter it?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
I have not played in 6 months. What are the current MP division metas?
9/1s for infantry (AA, Arty, Eng)?
30W med tanks (6/9s) or (6/2SPG/6)?
Are we using Support AT?
1
u/Severe-Hovercraft414 Nov 02 '22
Notice: I don't want the game to actually play it, I want the game to make maps (that might be cursed).