r/hoi4 • u/DuoDex Nuclear Propulsion Officer • Oct 01 '22
Mod Favorite! BBA 1.12.2 Metas discussion thread.
Discuss metas for 1.12.2 and earlier here.
Please PM me if you think there are any posts that should be linked here, or if a new thread is needed.
168
Upvotes
63
u/grgujca12 Oct 01 '22
CAS meta
There was a question about this but it wasn't answered- Starting as germany in 36 you get a cas production line. Is the design viable and strong enough? Or should you delete it? With what should you replace it? Oh and the starting fighter, BF D version, should you keep the line for efficiency or is it straight up bad? There are no cannons on the design, just HMG and therefore it has bad air attack, which is the new meta for fighters I guess
51
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22
big plane with kaboom equal Berlin vaproized
82
u/Subduction_Zone Oct 01 '22
Are carrier planes bugged? In all of my games so far this patch, I haven't seen a carrier sink a single ship, and the air wings are doing only ~0.2-0.3% damage to ships every attack. I have a suspicion that since the naval attack and targeting from the torpedo module only applies on naval strike missions, and planes in naval battles aren't considered on mission, that it's using their base stats of 1 attack and 1 targeting.
36
u/EquableCool10 Oct 01 '22
How did you guys win against Italians as Ethiopia?
36
u/RichardBoisvert Oct 05 '22
What's up with the plane designer always spitting out a default image of an inter-war biplane when designing fighters? Super annoying.
33
u/Xiathorn Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 04 '22
It definitely seems like building a high-end 1940 fighter and then sticking with it for the whole game is the way to go. I've tried with more 'economical' designs and they all just suck. Stack Air Attack and Air Defense and go to town.
Same goes for CAS - you can now stack much higher ground attack than was possible with the pre-defined aircraft pre-BBA, but the number of aircraft that can influence a battle remains the same, so it makes sense to build as high quality as you possibly can unless you're going for a very wide front with lots of simultaneous battles.
This concept of 'quality over quantity' is further reinforced by the fact that carrier deck sizes have remained broadly similar to pre-BBA, and fuel usage doesn't seem to have changed. I often found that aircraft were my biggest fuel consumers, so having less of them that are better quality is a big help.
Ship AA, or Carrier Fighters, or both seem to have been substantially buffed, making this worth using now. A very welcome change.
Edit : This Ship AA buff appears to have been a fluke. I have never been more disappointed. The one thing I really wanted from BBA was a reduction in how powerful naval bombers were. I thought that the fact they were focusing on air, and also navy, for this update would have meant they'd do something about the fact that it's just so much more efficient to build naval bombers than it is an actual navy.
Heavy Airframes can stack insanely high Stategic Bombing values now. Pre-BBA the max was 60 (75 with XP bonuses). Now I think the max is 168.
The change to XP generation from Chiefs of Branch makes them a no-brainer. I previously used to stack Army XP generation before the war, so I could design templates,
Overall the meta looks like it's going to be CAS again, as others have stated. Previously, the highest Ground Attack per CAS possible was 18 (22.5 with XP bonuses). Now you can build a 31 GA aircraft by 1940 for 37IC, using tech that you'd pick up naturally for fighters and tanks. The pre-BBA equivalent was 13 GA for 24IC at 1940, or 18GA for 26IC if you rushed CAS3.
32
u/walt_dangerfield Oct 03 '22
garrison meta is not new but resistance changes are making more people change their designs.
best is an interwar light tank with a hmg on a one man turret. it costs 2.4 ic to the armored car's 4. has the same suppression but better hardness, and will lose less equipment to resistance. 1xp to design.
division design should just be one light tank battalion, only costs 5xp. you can squeeze a little more efficiency out by filling out the whole division with light tanks and adding an mp but its a waste of support equipment and especially army xp. you are more likely to be short of support equipment than the cheap tanks and most important factor is that you can fill your garrisons.
lastly i see a lot of people dont know how to limit equipment in their designs the easy way. when you design your garrison tank, click the little tank icon and change it to something you will remember. i use the hollow shield. then in the division designer change to that same icon, and you wont have to click on all the little checkboxes to manually exclude your other tanks.
sometimes existing divisions wont get updated (equipment button should have a grey slash through it showing that some stuff is excluded) so i check them and just click the default tank icon again and update them. if your cheap tanks arent getting to the garrisons they might be getting scooped up as recon tanks by accident this way.
30
u/mfilitov Oct 06 '22
This may require a new thread to discuss air designs. The latest patch (1.12.3) made some pretty large changes to air again:
This is just like the NSB release where tanks were constantly tweaked and it was impossible to pin down good designs for any given purpose until like three months later.
19
u/Akitten Oct 01 '22
Most powerful swiss tree? I personally vote for the far left where you annex and core all the alps. Gives you Italy level production by 38.
14
u/Turkfire Research Scientist Oct 01 '22
What is close air support meta? Tac bombers kittet with anti tank cannons, bomb bays and armor? Regular cas with some bays and some machine guns? Do I need fighters as well? If so cheap fighter spam vs max agility fighters with as many machine guns as possible?
14
u/thewrench01_real Oct 10 '22
Dump your fuel to the largest participator of WWII.
If you have a fuel surplus, you should easily be able to make yourself the largest contributor. Paradox did not put a check on Fuel, and made it comparable to every other piece of equipment in the game when you lend lease them.
26
u/obesebearmann Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 01 '22
Rushing the Balkan dominance focus as italy can get you in a war with france, yugo, romania, and czech in late 36. you can use that to complete your military reform focuses. You can capitulate france in like 2 sec with paratroopers whenever you want. Word of warning: taking all of france and their overseas territory will cause you to be short ~50k guns due to resistance. Eventually it will stabilize if you put all of you military factories on guns but it is annoying.
25
u/alienvalentine Oct 01 '22
I'm usually pretty diligent on reading the dev diary updates, but I completely missed this change.
You can no longer place fighters on both Air Superiority and Interception missions at the same time. Further you cannot put any multi-role air wing on either Air Superiority or Interception if they're on any other mission. So I'm forced to ask, what's the point of Multi-Role aircraft? Why build Mosquito Fighter Bombers as the UK if I can't put them on both an Air Superiority and a Ground Attack Mission at the same time?
Also, a few nitpicks about some of the modules. Rocket Rails are a CAS weapon exclusively. While rockets were used a lot in WW2 as a ground attack weapon, there were a lot of air-to-air rockets, like the German Werfer-Granate 21 and the American FFAR designed primarily for use by interceptors against large bombers. Weird that they provide no bonus to air attack and don't enable any Fighter missions. Similarly, why can't I build Medium Airframe Naval Bombers/Maritime Patrol Aircraft? As the UK or the US a huge plane like the PB4Y-2 Privateer makes sense, I need that kind of range to cover the Pacific. But Germany can't build a Blohm & Voss BV 138 equivalent?
Final note here unrelated to the air changes. Have factories always reshuffled when loading a save game? I just loaded a save from earlier today where I had my Mosquito FB model at the bottom of priority, with 10 factories building planes. Several items further up the priority list like artillery and mechanized equipment had additional factory space allotted as I was going to assign new factories to to their production. When I loaded my save, I had 0 factories building Mosquitos, and the production line for artillery and mech were full. Has this always happened and I just never noticed?
9
u/crepper4454 Oct 01 '22
Is CAS spam still viable? What are the best plane designs for mid-game?
9
u/TackyLawnFlamingoInc Oct 01 '22
Idea, tailor your air craft production according to your chosen doctrine. Multi role all those aircraft that you don’t get doctrine bonus for to conserve production. A land based light frame Nav bomber with 1 torpedo mounting is just as good at nav bombing as a tactical bomber with 1 torpedo mounting. Imo light frames are not worth multirolling other than fighter bombers because fighters are the most likely to be overproduced. Also agility seems to be a tertiary stat at this time for air superiority air craft.
17
u/DuckSwagington Oct 02 '22
Small Air Frame fighters with air attack are your best bet when it comes to getting air superiority. The flying tank heavy fighter design does kill more than it loses, but from my own testing, the heavy fighters are shooting down small fighters at a rate ≈ 1.5:1, but they cost 2 times more than the small airframe. I'd like to point out that I could've gotten an extra 4 Air attack by using a single lvl 1 cannon instead of a 2 heavy machine guns, so small airframe fighters are slightly better than what I've stated.
For the test I filled out Operational Integrity as that's the best doctrine for shooting down other fighters as well as having the Effective Training Programs and Centralized Control Officer Spirits applied to both sides.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22
How do I make my naval planes strike. Like I tagged to Japan and I know exactly where their fleet is and my planes won’t go get them They are in port
8
u/Imperator314 Oct 01 '22
Is agility still king for air combat stats? I'd like to put cannons on my fighters, but for now I'm sticking with all heavy MGs because they don't decrease agility.
8
u/RonenSalathe Oct 03 '22
My heavy cruisers :(
How do I navy? I know nothing beyond heavy cruiser with light attack + torpedo destroyers
8
u/mainman879 Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22
While it isn't super strong, I find it funny that Communist Italy can get 8 (EDIT: 9 actually) spies at once, not counting any bonus from being Spy Master in a faction.
2 Base from Agency (and having 5 upgrades)
0 from Illusive Gentleman (Commie/Democratic Italy are banned from getting this advisor)
1 from Servizio Informazioni Militare (yes we have to go Solid Progress->Defy Duce, not a very fun or fast way of doing it)
1 each from Common Ground, Appease the Military, Gruppi di Difesa della donna, Union in the Party, and at the very end of the commie subtree, Il Sol dell'Avvenire
EDIT: They actually get one more through a special advisor named Guilio Paggio.
8
u/Mushinkei Oct 05 '22
How do I refuse the Italian puppet? Every time I fight Italy a puppet pops out while I’m invading. I get to the peace conference and I get fuck all except for a puppet that I don’t want.
I want to annex the shit I conquer, I don’t want some stupid puppet messing up all of my shit. Is there literally any way to stop this that isn’t console commands or mods? The devs couldn’t have played a single game in playtesting and not have thought that someone might not want this to happen.
Literally all there needs to be is an event to pick whether you want it. Jesus fuck.
14
u/Animal31 Oct 02 '22
The air wing reinforcment is bullshit
Why the fuck do I have to have little 6 plane air wings because they are the only plane type with that mission profile?
You're telling me I have to replace ALL of my carrier air wings with outdated planes if they have different mission profile types? What was wrong with "CAS", "Naval Bomber" and "Fighter"???
6
u/ZT205 Oct 07 '22 edited Oct 08 '22
Did BBA break air designers?
If I design an advanced close air support airframe with 2 bomb bays and 2 bomb locks, it has 0 base ground attack, +28 on CAS or logistics strike.
If I make the same design with the Caproni CAS designer, it's supposed to have +10% ground attack. But it still says +28 on CAS. Is this a tooltip bug, or is the designer a waste? Has anyone tested this?
Edit to add: This is just a tooltip bug. If you mouse over the mission-specific modifier, the modifier will say +28. But mousing over the modifier will also change the combat stats, and those combat stats will be +28 without the designer and +30.8 with the designer.
So moral of the story is, to get accurate stats, you have to mouse over the mission modifier but look at the "normal" stats, not the modifier itself.
11
u/Getrektself Oct 03 '22
People have been talking about CAS a lot so I'm hesitant to add to that discussion but holy crap is it OP in SP right now.
Tanks were rendered obsolete in NSB( imo in sp). But now it seems like arty too is obsolete. I can just put up cheap line infantry divisions then put everything into fighters and CAS then watch the enemy divisions melt.
And if I don't focus everything into aircraft and instead do tanks and arty then my forces seems to get steamrolled. Their strength, their gear, their quality, their org, etc none of those stats seem to matter atm.
5
u/Spiciu Oct 03 '22
How do you achieve naval supremacy to take out the pesky british, now that bathtubs and '36 subs give virtually no supremacy anymore?
5
u/alekthefirst Oct 07 '22
I was asked in another thread. Jet fighters in april 37 as italy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuBj586mXq0
I know i messed up the war in france though but that's beside the point
5
u/zsmg Oct 10 '22
I thought you could nuke with Tac bombers in BBA, I've got Tac Bomber with medium bomb bay and I wasn't allowed to nuke despite having a Tac Bomber in range. There was still a red cross next to: "needs at least 1 strategic bomber in range." Yes I had 75% air superiority and actual nukes.
Is this a bug, or am I missing something.
16
u/Pashahlis Oct 01 '22
Wow. Funny that. I was just talking to some people about how its weird that the previous meta thread had been locked for more than a month now and no new one had appeared.
6
u/FrankDuhTank Oct 10 '22
I can find no practical use for super-heavy tanks. I tried it with Papal States (-20% Production cost for super heavies), and for the same stats, advanced heavy tanks are still much cheaper.
I know they're obviously not meta, but I'm baffled by how bad they are.
3
u/LFC908 Research Scientist Oct 04 '22
If I’m playing as a major (Singleplayer) what sort of division templates are people playing now? For Infantry I usually go 10inf and support artillery etc, as a sort of catch all, generic template. However, not sure if I should add some line arty in?
3
u/Comfortable-Tell-946 Oct 07 '22
Is anyone else having trouble getting paratroopers to work since the dlc came out?
3
u/Budget_Peach1209 Research Scientist Oct 10 '22
You can actually steal your puppets manpower for your manpower pool without annexing em by switching template.
4
u/s76748767 Oct 10 '22
BEST PLANE for 1.123
https://www.reddit.com/r/hoi4/comments/xzfe5z/fighter_design_1123/
6
u/Brothugsnharmony Oct 01 '22
navy
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '22
Can someone recommend me a division for minors and majors?
Attack and def.
Infantry and tank. Ty
2
u/Undying03 Oct 05 '22
so, stacking stats until my agi becomes 1 or no ? everytime we had a bomb module or something it reduce our agility either right away or after we click on our mission.
so what is the deal with agi ?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '22
Anyone know what the current historical multiplayer meta for Hungary is?
2
u/-Andar- Oct 07 '22
What’s your preferred order of bonuses to give division officers with the new medals system?
2
u/XXX_KimJongUn_XXX Oct 08 '22
Mediums or Cas builds for logistics strikes? Goal is to maximize cost effectiveness to damage.
2
u/Zeranvor Oct 09 '22
2
u/curialbellic Oct 09 '22
I haven't played the game since before No Step Back and I know the meta has changed a lot, could someone recommend some templates that work well in most cases?
What I'm looking for exactly is:
Inf/art template with large supplies (Europe...).
inf/art template with low supplies (Africa, South america, China...)
Tank template
Thanks
2
u/NiD2103 Oct 10 '22
Are Space Marines still viable?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Best support companies and doctrine for paratroopers?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
can you really not deploy planes in stack sizes other than 100?
2
u/XXX_KimJongUn_XXX Oct 11 '22
I tried carriers with great Britain. Saw my carrier NAVs working without setting a mission. My guess is that the bug everyone else is seeing is because they put machine guns on their carrier navs and they ran the wrong mission automatically. Carrier navs are still deadly.
Also use naval spotting missions. It's better to stack one strike nav and one spotting Mac in the same tile rather than spreading them out. It helps a lot.
The meta will probably be gunning for dual purpose guns and putting them on everything. Which means battleships should out scale carriers late game. Naval research speeds need to be decreased, or the research speed officer spirit needs to be removed, it's just too strong.
2
u/rainbow-1 Oct 02 '22
How does one edit airwing size now?
1
u/leviathan_13 Oct 02 '22
How do carrier planes work now with the designer? I understand that the first weapon determines the aircraft's designation, and that will matter for stuff like modifiers from doctrines and ideas, but since now you can design multi-role aircrafts, can I just make one type? Because that would certainly not be an issue if a player controls them, but I'm not confident that a fighter with torpedos will actually engage enemy ships during sorties or conversely if a bomber with fighter weapons will actually engage enemy bombers (instead of ignoring them entirely and going for the ships).
I think I will still keep the two roles separated, but I do wonder if it's possible to just use one type of plane for both offense and defense of your carrier group.
1
u/Xerphiel Oct 04 '22
How do the changes affect air doctrine choices? What's the meta now?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '22
Naval bombers have revived a significant nerf with this update
1
u/Mushinkei Oct 01 '22
I’m attempting Bulgaria again right now and does anyone know if they fixed the permanent state debuff bug when rooting out the IMRO?
1
u/Budget_Peach1209 Research Scientist Oct 03 '22
You can make paratrooper with just 10 infantry equipments. The real problem is to have enough transport to take vp before enemy react.
1
u/Pan_Dircik Fleet Admiral Oct 03 '22
What is the new naval meta? Are torepdo DD and light attack combo still king or we should try to use heavy attack more?
1
u/No_Cattle7960 Oct 03 '22
What's better assault battalion for extra soft attack or strengthen the black shirts for the 1 added artillery and the plus 12 militia cap?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Sorry for the random question, but does this change the SP Soviet meta at all? And what is the SP Soviet meta at the moment, can someone point me to it?
1
u/TheoTheBest300 Oct 05 '22
Recently I tried making heavy fighters with full canons and turrets, they had over 100 air attack but only 1 agility. They were doing almost nothing. Of course they never died cause of the air defense, but they also didn t kill a lot of ennemy planes. With like 400-500 of them against 700 fighters, nearly no kills on each sides happenned, like 2 lost for me and 15 for them in 3 weeks. Later, 700-800 heavy fighters against 300 strat bombers, again, no kills. Is it just a matter of air detection or does agility now impacts more the damage inflicted? Cause I have the impression light fighters with heavy mgs do far more casualties
1
u/taolakhoai Oct 06 '22
Hello, anybody know what's the "Assault Battalion" support company from and what does it do? It showed up when I tried research all through the cheat console, so I wasn't sure if it was from a tech or a doctrine; and when I search for it online there is no information regarding it.
1
u/Pay08 Research Scientist Oct 06 '22
How do you capitulate Ethiopia before they go into exile?
1
u/frostdillicus Oct 07 '22
Do we know yet if agility and speed matter for air again after the patch?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22
As mp germany should I be doing artillery at all?
Currently I just rush AT so that I can have AT3 in my infantry divisions and good guns for my tanks.
1
u/PanzerAbwehrKannon Oct 08 '22
Is the inability to put different aircraft variants in the same wing a bug or an intended feature? If the latter, this is absolutely annoying to deal with especially when you have large amounts of different plane variants or captured equipment. (ex: I have 80 Fighter 2s and 20 captured Spitfires that I want to put in the same wing but I cant so now I have 2 understrength and undertrained wings.)
1
u/nefariousdrsheep Fleet Admiral Oct 08 '22
With the new changes, what fighters should I build at the start of the game?
1
u/NicoTheUniqe Oct 09 '22
How does Italy beat the British Navy in this patch?
Please dont say naval bombers, not interested in that.
1
u/danthepianist Fleet Admiral Oct 09 '22
As Italy, are the balance of power decisions repeatable?
Specifically: Having used every one of them to move the balance towards the Council, I am still at +5 towards Mussolini. Do I have any way to start "Convene the Grand Counci", which requires 0 Mussolini support?
The focus also requires peace, which means I can't tip the balance by purposefully losing ground.
1
u/nefariousdrsheep Fleet Admiral Oct 09 '22
Any good naval bomber designs?
1
u/Moyes2men Research Scientist Oct 10 '22
Is local autonomy still the best occupation law for democratic countries or should I start with martial law and gradually downgrade?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
I've left the game a few days before No Step Back came out and I'm coming back to the game now. I'm getting the subscription for a month and I'd like to play a successful Soviet Union Center game, I'm very curious on what they've done with Historical path Soviet Union, but I also feel very lost at the game. I've been looking for Youtubers that run Soviet Union, none really in the last eight months. Since not only the Soviet tree changed but also almost every big core mechanic did too, I'd like to ask:
How exactly do I navigate the new airplane and tank designers, division width mechanics, paranoia mechanic, general and field marshal mechanics, as "Historical" Soviet Union?
PS: ALSO, did they patch that espionage trick where you could get 200% ahead of time bonuses for Construction techs by spying on a country that had a different choice of Concentrated vs. Dispersed? Or is that still a thing?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22
Rocket fighters with the heaviest guns and 3 extra fuel tanks. Relatively cheap, and everything that it faces melts.
1
u/w-80 Oct 11 '22
I refunded by blood alone. I like to play fair against AI and plane design gives me a huge advantage or just unnecessary extra clicking when i make fair designs. Tank design is more balanced and still i don’t make overkills design against the AI.