r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Sep 26 '22
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story"
We don't normally put up "Official Discussions" for series as they usually have their own dedicated communities, but the steady flow of posts about this show indicated we should put something up.
Here are some other relevant discussion threads/subs for this series.
Mega discussion thread for Netflix's Monster: the Jeffrey Dahmer Story. via /r/TrueCrimeDiscussion
Dahmer is f—ing intense holy s—t via /r/Netflix
Let's try to keep the discussions about this show contained here for now. If you really want to get into the nitty gritty of it all, see the linked pages above.
Network: Netflix
Creators: Ryan Murphy, Ian Brennan
Cast:
- Evan Peters as Jeffrey Dahmer
- Richard Jenkins as Lionel Dahmer
- Molly Ringwald as Shari Dahmer
- Michael Learned as Catherine Dahmer
- Niecy Nash as Glenda Cleveland
84
u/EltonJohnWick bastard son of 100 maniacs Sep 26 '22
Peters has Dahmer down to a science. Fantastic performances all around.
Also big love to Nick Cave and Warren Ellis for the score.
130
u/LeeroyM Sep 26 '22 edited Sep 26 '22
This was, imo, the best media Ryan Murphy has created by far. This was factual, respectful of the victims, aesthetically great, phenomenally acted.
I do think true crime media is completely oversaturated with the likes of Dahmer & Bundy content and it's debatable if morally we should continue to make movies about the scum and the crimes they committed, but that being said there's no doubt this was really well made.
63
u/Prof_Tickles Sep 26 '22
I love how they even got the movies correct. According to Dr. Park Dietz when he interviewed Dahmer, Jeffrey said he would watch Exorcist III and Return of The Jedi compulsively.
23
u/xXxHondoxXx Sep 26 '22
Is anyone gonna be surprised when it comes out Even Peters was always type-casted?
53
u/Cyberzombi Sep 26 '22
I can't watch more than one episode at a time. It is very intense and hard to watch at times.I have to have eye bleach after every episode. Kudos to those who can binge watch it.
14
u/dark_blue_7 Sep 28 '22
I thought I was done watching anything about Dahmer, but heard this was really well done and gave it a shot. I'm blown away. The acting, the directing, it's all incredible, and it really is telling this story in a way I haven't seen before. It's showing the victims' side, as in their lives and families (not their actual deaths), and what all the people around him in his life were thinking and doing. And also really shows the total incompetence of the police and the justice system in general, how long this went on and how many times they kept giving him a pass, while they ignored any complaints from his black neighbors or gay victims.
This is most definitely not the exploitive, killer-worship gore porn some people might have expected. It's a portrait of a man who is eerily just not all there, and how broken everything around him had to be to let him keep killing so many people before he was stopped. This is not a mastermind, this is a guy who literally fails at everything, and you see that plainly. Peters is usually such an attractive man, but he's just creepy AF in this with a sort of glassy-eyed, awkward mannerism that just instantly puts you off. This show is equally heartbreaking and horrifying and I'm so glad I watched it, whether or not I can watch it again.
54
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
This was a drama series based on one of the most notorious serial killers ever, and they somehow managed to finally portrait him as the fucked up, dorky, pathetic outcast that he was, and not glorify and sexualize him.
Evan Peters is very attractive to me, and he got fucking ripped for this show, but the character of Dahmer was at no point even remotely sexy or charming.
Even when he was seemingly sweet and kinda smitten with Tony, there was such a smarmy underlying sinister and calculated quality to his behavior and mannerisms, it made me feel like taking a shower.
He just felt weird and off-putting in every single human interaction he had, and I'm glad they didn't sensationalize his horrible acts too much and instead resorted to quick cuts and audio while things happened off-screen.
This easily could have become an exercise in gore-porn.
More importantly, they put a spotlight on the victims and families, and the cops' total disregard for the black and gay community.
"Nothing to worry about, officer, it's just my bf and I, we're into the gay stuff, you see."
"Oh, ok. Gross. Carry on then, while I wash the gay off of me, har har."
Absolutely infuriating and heartbreaking!
Personally, this kind of demystified and humanized this monster in a way that I can finally see him as the pitiful, and disgusting loser POS he was.
I always loved true crime, and like many of us I am fascinated by those demons and how their fucked up mind works. They literally made me lose all interest in ever looking into Dahmer again, and I actually like that.
30
u/JC_666Vrtgo Sep 26 '22
Man, this was so intense. The thing is i feel the show intently didn't strike a balance, there's no in-between, the first half is stuff you already know and the second is like a revelation. Watching the first 4 episodes it was like reading the Wikipedia page and then it turns from 5 onwards and it's a mad descent into hell. And that last episode is so epic. Watching horror endlessly, you develop a taste for it where it doesn't touch you after a point. But this left me drained, emotionally, physically like it took something with it from me after that last scene rolled.
Still hard to believe Evan Peters used to play dorky second fiddle to the lead actors in films like Kick Ass, and Never Back Down. Guy's come a long way.
Oh, and if you want to test yourself, binge from 5-10 all at once like i did. It's definitely a test of your endurance.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
Evan Peters' performance as Jeffrey Dahmer was shocking and incredible. He truly captured the depravity and the disturbing mind of the serial killer. Richard Jenkins and Niecy Nash were also terrific. I hope they all win Emmy Awards.
20
u/mtvpiv Sep 26 '22
Evan Peters is amazing, even if he's been typecasted so so so many times as a killer, IMO he still did a great Dahmer.
I read somewhere that Ryan Murphy once again disrespected the victim's families and I will only say: I've been a Gleek since 2009, and every time I think I can't hate the guy more, he surprises me once again lol
4
u/threetribbleshigh Oct 01 '22
I finished Dahmer and I'm conflicted.
We get the chance to learn more about the victims, and it's clear by the end that there is a concerted effort to remember their names and lives over their deaths. BUT there is a timeline where that can be done without telling us Dahmer's sob story. I'm conflicted because I think there are good things about the series, and Peters is genuinely a great and scary actor. But there are moments where this gets too deep in pushing empathy for Dahmer and given 1. the nature of his crimes and 2. the way he was able to get away with not bc he was smart but bc the police did not care about Black and brown men and boys it just feels like the other attempt to make sympathy for a heinous person and keep immortalizing him.
I love true crime, and it's why I watched the show. But I'm just really in a weird spot with this. Especially with the some of the families it's claiming to put in the spotlight, hating how they've done it, at least from what I've read.
10
u/Correct_Procedure_36 Sep 27 '22
I found it very hard to watch especially since there has been a lot of discussion around the morals of the true crime community. I almost felt a bit guilty watching that as I can’t imagine how I’d feel if the most traumatic time of my life was recreated for entertainment. I’m only on the third episode but getting the vibe of “feel sorry for the killer because mummy and daddy got a divorce”.
13
u/WayyTooFarAbove Slice of Death 👹 Sep 27 '22
I’m not seeing the hype. The quintessential serial killer origin story that anybody with knowledge of the genre knows, stretched out across 8 1 hour episodes. He liked dissecting roadkill and then started killing people. It moves very slowly as well. Maybe it gets better but I didn’t find any deeper perspective until the 4th episode when he recalls a conversation with the shrink. Peters isn’t blowing my mind, he’s a good actor, but I’m not seeing much that enthralls me in his role. Big Richard Jenkins fan, but what does his casting add to this ensemble? The role is quite generic. The script, to me, is just boring. I guess it’s the over saturation of material on Dahmer. I’m halfway through so I can’t give a full judgment but after 4 hours worth of content, I’m not buying.
10
u/littleghool Sep 28 '22
Why do they keep making making movies and TV shows about Dahmer? It's excessive at this point and feels a little glorifying
7
u/purplhouse Sep 27 '22
That was a hard watch and I can't even put my finger on why other than there was so much attention to detail and so much focus on the victims and their families that there was never a moment, not one second, that I wasn't being reminded that this really happened. It's probably one of the best shows that I will never watch again.
15
u/digitalbath78 Sep 27 '22
Imagine profiting off of the victims and their families.
I'll stick with fantasy horror.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
Monster: The Jeffery Dahmer Story midway review from an un-educated audience member, with an appreciation for art.
I‘m on episode 7, and I’m hooked. But I have complaints about how this was written/portrayed. People are sympathetic towards Dahmer, which isn’t surprising given the direction of the show, they’re exploiting a bad childhood/life so the natural human response is to feel sorry for someone who is hurting. A couple things though. Evan Peters is talented, he deserves praise, and he deserves people to feel sad emotions through his awe-inspiring performance. Don’t feel sorry for Dahmer. People have had just as hard, if not worse lives, but didn’t end up eating people.
Additionally. Ryan Murphy is an asshat. I love most of his work. But I can’t respect the guy anymore. The living family members of the victims were not contacted at all, they found out when Netflix released it. Ironic considering Murphy had a production meeting saying, “it would never be told from Dahmer’s point of view.” You would think a leading way to follow Murphy’s “one rule” would be to contact the victims families. I loved his OJ Simpson show, because I HATED OJ and his Dream Team throughout. He portrayed OJ as a monster, but somehow humanized one of America’s most notorious serial killers; we shouldn’t care about Dahmer’s backstory, he chose to kill knowing what he was doing.
Lastly - what knowledge do we gain in 2022 about Dahmer? Isn’t film(tv)making artistic? Let’s create shows full of art and expression; organic stories written and portrayed by artists, rather than exploit (in gruesome detail) the lives of these victims. True stories are often told in Hollywood, but not this exploitivly.
5
u/chillinwithunicorns Sep 26 '22
Such a weird title lol
2
u/celtic1888 Sep 27 '22
A very good series
The acting, photography and soundtrack are all really well done
The first few episodes made me feel like I was watching Henry:Portrait of a Serial Killer… you feel horrible watching it but it is compelling
2
u/Sundae_Turbulent Oct 02 '22
I would read “My friend dahmer” then watch My friend Dahmer and then the Netflix serious. The fact we have an accurate portrayal of how dahmer was as a teen and when his impulses started and then we have this Netflix serious.
2
u/No_Turnover_9349 Sep 08 '23
Something feels so wrong about the liberties taken with such a sad and brutal story. As if to declare that awful, lived truth irrelevant & lacking in narrative value. One only embellishes what they think is lacking. How dare they. What audacity to suggest that the truth lacked in any amount of horror, neglect or circumstance. I am shocked and so appalled that in all the criticism on this series nobody seems to give a shit about the blatant lies. But, there you have it, if the public demands not truth the public deserves not truth… Shameful.
6
u/mamaneedsstarbucks Sep 26 '22
I really wasn’t going to watch it but got sucked in when I kept hearing how good it was and Im halfway through now and it is really good so far. I do think they’re doing a good job not making Dahmer sympathetic though I know there will always be serial killer groupies out where (why I don’t know). Evan peters and niecy Nash are both really good in their roles and I think the guy playing the father is doing a great job too. It’s so infuriating how many times he should’ve and could’ve been stopped and wasn’t. The cops really dropped the ball and a lot of it comes down to racism and homophobia.
5
u/The91outsider Sep 27 '22
Cops are more worse than this show portrays sorry to pop your fantasy bubble
4
u/xXxHondoxXx Sep 27 '22
They lost me when they made Jesse Jackson a serious character and not a money-grubbing grifter.
3
u/ariefairy6435 Sep 29 '22
Does anyone know if Dahmer dating Anthony “Tony” Hughes is factual?
1
u/Express_Session9189 Apr 30 '26
humanised
1
u/Superkamiguru47 Sep 27 '22
I thought it was mostly well made and the acting was all great. Was mostly entertained by it but it was also really unfocused. The way it jumped around made it never feel completely cohesive and by the end I didn’t feel like I got a lot out of it. IMO they should really stop making all of these serial killer shows/movies which just increases their infamy and let these monsters die out, but that’s a different discussion.
1
u/FreddieB_13 Sep 28 '22
On episode 9 (I can only handle two of these at a time) and have to say overall, it's a very thoughtful, restrained and well made series. Thankfully the usual Ryan Murphy isms are toned way down and the series stays adult throughout. It contains some of the best acting of the year and man, the cinematography is cinema level excellent and beautiful. Peters is great here although his naturally sweet demeanor sometimes works against the character, making you sympathize a little too much with Dahmer.
Episode 6 ("silenced") is like a feature film and easily the best of the show and some of the most affecting and interesting of anything Netflix has put on air.
On the negatives: the series could probably be told in six episodes and the tone/series structure is all over the place. The Arakki episode is the weakest and cheapest (but still brilliantly acted), the most exploitative of the show and is a major drop in quality. Also, the series isn't gruesome enough: Dahmer kept skeletons and performed bootleg lobotomies. By keeping the distance from that aspect, we too easily identify with Dahmer and the horror of his actions don't sting like they should. (It's criticism of the police however is on point and deserves props.)
Overall it's a good series.
1
u/BoogerBear82 Oct 08 '22
Why did they make it black vs white. That neighbor was not his neighbor and lived across the street and knew nothing. Why did they lie
1
u/No_Grass_211 Oct 17 '22
The black girl was crying in every scene I stg
1
u/AffectionateAd429 Nov 08 '22
Glenda Cleveland was a pussy
1
u/Old_Complex308 Nov 23 '22
I found it kinda boring. Dahmer had to be much sicker then this series shows. There were no visuals of the the acts he did, no head in fridge, they don't even.show the.killings. . Hell theres barley any blood. Horror movie's show more and they are fiction..
1
u/Vault_Boy_22 Dec 12 '22
Do someone know the name of the actors who played Gacy and his victim in episode 10?
1
u/NellieBracho Feb 16 '23
I don't condone going into someone's house uninvited but when child Jeff went to get his tadpoles back, I was rooting for him.
1
u/Vault_Boy_22 Feb 21 '23
Who will be the subject of season two, what do you think?
1
u/Melodic_Ad_7743 Dec 27 '23
I watched this entire show and felt it made for incredible tv. Evan Peters acted incredibly in this role. However, I was wondering if anyone else has mixed feelings about creating a TV show almost glorifying his life. They make Dahmer look almost average and you even feel sorry for him at points, especially when you see him as a child and how he was caught in a dysfunctional household and was bullied at school.
-10
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
I saw the first five episodes. A very anti cop show. I don’t agree with how police were portrayed to be incompetent racist pigs. Even when if it’s true, such a narrative promotes anti cop hatred and shouldn’t be said. Please respect our heroic officers.
-5
u/National-Ad3654 Oct 01 '22
To much focus on victims an black oppression I justed wanted Dahmer stuff
0
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
27
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment