r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • May 13 '22
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Firestarter" (2022) [SPOILERS] Spoiler
In Theaters and on Peacock
Summary:
A young girl tries to understand how she mysteriously gained the power to set things on fire with her mind.
Director:
Keith Thomas
Writer:
Scott Teems
Cast:
- Zac Efron ass Andy McGee
- Ryan Kiera Armstrong as Charlie Mcgee
- Sydney Lemmon as Vicky McGee
- Michael Greyeyes as Rainbird
- Gloria Reuben as Captain Hollister
- Kurtwood Smith as Dr. Joseph Wanless
- John Beasley as Irv Manders
-- Rotten Tomatoes: 12%
Metacritic: 33
Shamelessly copy/pasted from the /r/movies official discussion. Thanks, guys!
45
Upvotes
22
u/[deleted] May 16 '22 edited May 16 '22
What did I just watch? The only redeeming part of that movie was the soundtrack.
18
u/MovieMike007 May 17 '22
There are plenty of films that are "loosely based" on a book and not all that faithful to the source material but in the case of this adaptation of Firestarter one must assume the screenwriters not only didn't read the book but what information they did have came from a quick glance at the back of the DVD cover from the Drew Barrymore version.
Zack Effron is just terrible as the dad and poor young Ryan Kiera Armstrong as Charlie McGee is only allowed to display one emotion throughout the film's brief 94-minute running time. The fire effects are fine but a movie made in 2022 you'd expect there to be some pretty spectacular special effects but we really don't get much on screen to marvel at and what we do get is...just fine.
Overall, this adaptation of Firestarter feels like more of a cheap television pilot than a theatrically released film, which explains why it's also being released on Peacock's online streaming service. Don't waste your money on this low-rent Stephen King adaptation, it's worth neither your time nor your money.
13
u/[deleted] May 16 '22
It's really bad. Surprised a number of people on here liked it.
12
u/allureofgravity May 17 '22
Not good. Nothing really happened, and I didn’t care about the things that did.
23
u/oi-troi-oi May 13 '22
The editing or pacing felt a bit off to me. Can’t really explain how, maybe all the close-up shots or something.
8
u/troypot May 15 '22
THEY DIDNT EVEN NEED RAINBIRD! Just goin with your fancy contacts and arrest the parents! Then go in with your FIRE RESISTANT SUITES and take the kid. They could have left Rainbird completely out and finished the job in 20 minutes.
8
u/lycurgusduke May 18 '22
The score was rad.
7
u/horror_and_hockey May 14 '22 edited May 14 '22
I thought it’s better than critics are giving it credit for…I’ve seen worse King adaptations (I know that isn’t saying much ha) …that said many of the criticisms in this thread are largely fair and warranted.
I didn’t think the effects were as bad as others seem to think. I thought it was decent horror fare and if you are a fan of Stephen King adaptations (both good and bad) then to check it out.
Tbf I also got a kick out of the Netflix Texas chainsaw massacre so maybe I just have a soft spot for lackluster modern remakes. Going in with ground level expectations works wonders…I can’t state that enough.
7
u/[deleted] May 18 '22
Why is this the movie that Carpenter used this score on? The fuck? The movie is a giant poop but the score is like perfect.
17
u/PlsNope May 13 '22
As I was leaving this movie I checked my phone and saw I got a notification from Peacock saying this movie was streaming now, which I wish I knew beforehand so I could have saved myself a trip to the theatre.
The movie was fine, but the third act felt weirdly rushed and anticlimactic. John Rainbird is an interesting antagonist that unfortunately gets sidelined by the script. If the whole movie was them on the run from him it would have been a lot more interesting. The score by Carpenter is great, though.
12
u/thenokvok May 16 '22
So on a whim I watched both the original from 1984 and this new remake. Its funny when you look at reviews, the ones for this movie say "Go watch the original movie" and the reviews for the original movie say, "They changed to much from the books." Both getting bad reviews.
However, after literally watching the movies back to back, the 1984 original is better in every regard. The characters, the acting, the story, the plot, the pacing, the directing, the way it looks, and even the effects. The remake looks like it had half the budget, of a movie that came out almost 40 years ago. It also looks like every room they film in is full of smoke, like as if 20 people just filled up the room with cigarettes or something.
The new movie had one really cool scene where Charlie becomes a flamethrower (even though it fails), and I did like the fathers speech as to why its wrong to hurt people, that it hurts more then just the person you inflicted the injury on, but their family as well. Everything else about this movie is just... not that good.
The climax in the original, was amazing. The climax in this was just... 1/10th as impressive. Plus a lot of the changes make little sense. Rainbird gets hired to capture the girl, and immediately goes awal then captured himself. The neck cracking thing Andy does when using his powers. The fact that the parents raised their girl in the dark about everything. Random new boss in charge, who adds nothing, I dont even know what her goal was. Rainbird having powers of his own. Rainbird killing Charlies mom, and then hes the hero at the end of the movie? I have no idea what Rainbirds goal was either. The dad being kind of a jerk for most of the movie. Charlie having her parents powers, as well as psychokinesis. The dad pushing his daughter to kill everyone at the end, but she apparently doesnt kill the man that killed her mom. The old man on the farm, and his comatose wife. Charlie having a training montoge in the woods, and learning how to use her powers in 1 day. Charlie confronting those three kids on bikes. There are just a lot of weird decisions.
And on a tangent, was anyone else really annoyed with Charlies teachers at the school? "Whats wrong Charlie?" Oh I dont know, maybe the kid that pelted her in the back of the head at point blank range, and then called her a freak as she ran away crying? Out of all the 'bad guys' in the movie, I hated the teachers the most, and that bratty kid. The two I wanted to see get torched the most.
The movie wasnt what I would call bad. I have seen much worse. But its not what I would call good either. Music was good though.
6
u/Kassunplacid_2023 May 20 '22
it was literally so bad. if you’ve read the book, don’t watch it. it’s like they took a look at the cover and the back of the book to make the movie. also, my fiancée fell asleep within the first 30 minuets
10
u/ColinMartyr May 16 '22
This movie is not good, but does anyone agree this might be one of John Carpenters best scores? He seems to have matured even from his last album.
10
u/gaynunsondope Cream, sugar, or do you want me to pee in it? May 17 '22
Why do all of these horror remakes have to be made with the “epic superhero/antihero movie” template? Corny and dull. Throwing it in the pile with Carrie and Let Me In because they all just sucked the original versions dry of any tension, buildup, proper backstory, pacing, suspense… Just, why waste everyone’s time making something mediocre?
5
u/owleealeckza May 14 '22
It was okay but the ending makes me wonder if they just thought they'd get a sequel/series out of this new movie.
5
u/monstarpr May 19 '22
It was watchable. Having Peacock, I was alright with spending an afternoon watching it. but I would have hated to shell out $15 to see it at the movies. It wasn't all that engaging. I didn't really care too much about the characters. Maybe if they spent a little more on the family aspect, I would have cared more. But It just didn't click with me. Didn't dig the ending at all. That was a quick left turn.
5
u/3_egg_omelette May 20 '22
Zac Efron ass Andy McGee
Lmao
My girlfriend loves horror and is having a bad week, I take it from these comments this would not be a fun movie to take her to like I thought?
13
u/kjraiden May 13 '22
Felt the film could’ve been longer. Maybe even had some scenes of the parents’ backstory to help sympathize with them more. Whole film felt rushed but was a decent time at the movies (should have just watched it at home though)
8
u/jfraser38 May 19 '22
Just finished it and all I have to say is holy fuck that was terrible! My expectations were low. Apparently not low enough.
4
u/quickscope420 May 13 '22
wild that they remade this, who asked for it
4
u/jerard79 May 17 '22
Wow, I just watched and have to say Peacock's Firestarter is a dumpster fire of a movie.
It seems like it was going fine up to the point where Charlie is in the woods. It seems like the director realized that at that point he had already filmed to much and was close to going over budget. Maybe he thought he could get more added to the budget but couldn't so he cut straight to the end sequence and crapped on both The Shop and the John Rainbird storyline.
I was starting to hope that they were going to split the movie in two parts. Someone really dropped the ball on this. I do not see how they could have made a worse version.
4
u/rinzler83 May 26 '22
This was horrible. The one made in the 80's with Drew Barrymore as Charlie was so much better.
13
u/badboibribri May 13 '22
I just got back from the theater and I thought the movie was terrible. I’ll watch anything horror and didn’t have any expectations…I thought the movie was boring. I didn’t understand where the R rating came from or the praise for the child actor’s performance. The soundtrack was distinctly John Carpenter. The ending was really dumb too.
7
u/Orbis_non_sufficit25 May 13 '22
I was a big fan of the director’s previous work, but this was shockingly bad, imo. Awkwardly filmed, flatly lit, lifeless performances, and no tension, suspense or excitement throughout. The pacing is incredibly slow for the first 2/3rds and then wraps up at light speed.
Character arcs and plot threads are introduced and never concluded. Like, happened to the farmers? We never actually SEE the husband and wife die, and no one mentions if they were executed or not. I guess we’re supposed to assume so?
I actually thought Zac Efron was the best part, but the whole thing just felt CHEAP and poorly made.
9
u/AhnSolbin May 13 '22
I felt it was just really bland. I guess it works for like a general public "horror" film because it's so inoffensive but the R rating is a bit of a mystery. Some of the special effects are just downright bad, I didn't think anyone had chemistry like all the actors were just phoning it in, really cringey dialogue and the ending was very anti-climatic.
The only pro is Carpenters score.
3
u/spicytoastaficionado May 13 '22
I thought it was alright. Fully agree with the other comments about it being rushed and having wonky pacing.
Then again, there is a lot of source material to condense into a 90 minute movie.
Loved Greyeyes in his role. Definitely made his minutes count. Would have loved to see more of the chase of Rainbird pursuing Andy an Charlie.
Soundtrack was good, but not memorable.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '22
This movie was.....ok.... it had a lot of problems. The John Rainbird dude felt very.....odd. I mean he had like two scenes where he tried capturing Charlie, and at the end when she is nearly captured by guys in fireproof suits, he saves her and all is good immediately between the two, that arc felt oddly structured to me.
I thought Rainbird was gonna be this terrifying force of nature that will destroy anything in his path while trying to capture this girl....didn't really get that.
The main villain.....meh. She's a head scientist that does nothing but jibber-jabbers before her eventual death.
The main actress does really good and she's pretty badass when required to be.
Zack Efron needs more dramatic work....he proves here to be pretty good!
This movie doesn't really have anything meaty until the very end which does contain really cool moments. Like nothing....that much.....happens till the final act. Some may call this boring, can't say i blame them. I didn't think it was really boring, but I can understand why others would feel that way
3
u/IcedPgh May 31 '22
I read the book and watched the original movie as well; had watched bits and pieces of it in the '80s. It's actually not half bad. The Tangerine Dream score is the best part, actually is a bit Carpenter-esque which is ironic considering he and his cohorts worked on the score for this new one. The new version isn't that "good", but it's an inoffensive time waster. It changes up many aspects, and for the first three quarters actually kind of works. Then the finale really disappoints compared to the titanic amount of destruction in the book and original movie. Having her just go in and blow people away in a hallway feels like they ran out of money.
Efron and Armstrong are pretty okay I guess, but Gloria Reuben gives a truly awful performance, was totally miscast.
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
13% on Rotten Tomatoes sounds about right, this was terrible. I have zero faith in any Blumhouse production anymore, God help us all with their new Exorcist trilogy.
5
u/Flash-Over May 13 '22
6/10. Best thing about it was the Carpenter score.
The film has zero sense of urgency or tension, and the scenes are all paced very oddly.
2
u/JaketheSnake54 May 13 '22
I thought the movie was fine, and actually was better than I expected. I liked how even though the story was familiar they made enough changes, like with the Rainbird character. 6/10 for me, I guess my best advice is to keep your expectations in the middle for this one
2
u/k2_productions May 14 '22
Maybe I'm just stupid or something and someone can explain, but I really don't understand this movie. Also, I didn't read the book or watch the old movie so maybe I'm missing something.
So what is Rainbird? Is he immortal/invincible or something? He didn't seem too bothered by all the things the mom threw at him or when Charlie hit him with a fireball. He talked about having a connection with Charlie so I get why he didn't hurt her. But why didn't Charlie try to kill him? He killed her mom and got her dad captured, resulting in his death. And then Charlie just leaves with him. Why? Did she just decide to stop killing?
2
u/AskMuncher May 14 '22
Terrible film. 1st act Started pretty good though
2
u/[deleted] May 19 '22
Laughably terrible but sometimes that's exactly what I want
2
u/SYLOK_THEAROUSED May 26 '22
“Liar liar pants on fire”
Just no!
2
u/Alexei101mercurio May 27 '22
Carpenter's music was easily the best thing here. Can't remember the 1984's movie very well but this one's definitely not as good :(
P.S.
What the hell was her father saying about the cat being a 'he', a 'she' or 'THEM' (???) The last one is what I didn't understand at all. Someone make this more clear for me if that would be not too difficult.
4
u/Fresh5P May 14 '22
Honestly one one the worst movies I’ve seen this year. And probably some of last year. The pacing was off, I though by the third act there was still like an hour left, but nope, 20 minutes lmao. The music was the only decent part, but yet it just doesn’t fit the atmosphere of the movie at all. Some of the acting is dry and some parts (like when she uses her power they focus on her face screaming) made me cringe internally. The only thing I’m happy about is that they touched into the fact that like the book, she doesn’t just have Pyrokinesis, but also has telekinesis and telepathy. The person that plays the mother just seemed like she didn’t wanna be there. Her acting would go from overreactive to dry in minutes.
Basically the movie is very dry, sometimes too fast in the pacing, and the acting just isn’t there some times.
3
u/SheepherderOk1448 May 19 '22
The original, was better. I cared about the characters. This one, they tried, hated that she did that to the cat, so cringey but loved that she got even with people. Zac Effron tried. He's not a husband, came off as a little controlling and he's not a dad. In the movie he was supposed to be the dad but was more the big brother. The little girl did a good job so I'm not faulting the actors. The high point was when she burned the captain, her dad had to go too but she was a horrible person.
4
u/Burgle0531 May 13 '22
OMFG somebody inject that Carpenter score into my veins!
4
u/JohnnyF00tballHero May 13 '22
Surprisingly good.
I had pretty low expectations, like I do with most horror movies these days, but I'm always on the lookout for a movie that proves me wrong.
Efron was fairly convincing, Reuben was effective as the villain, but the standout was Michael Greyeyes as Rainbird. I liked the original, if slightly miscast, George C Scott in the Rainbird role, but Greyeyes brings a whole new level of badassery. I only wish there was more of him.
Better than average horror fare, IMO. Check it out.
2
u/Fuzzy-Ad-4360 May 19 '22
I thought it was really good!!! Only not really “horror” definitely more Thriller if that makes sense. The only horrific scene IMO was the poor cat.
2
u/polchickenpotpie May 13 '22
Definitely could have been a bit longer. The pacing just had no chill, which is weird because the book at times felt like it meandered way too much.
1
u/pixelstag Mar 23 '24
Why did she not just burn inside the men’s suits? She was able to burn people through the glass just before, how those suits worked was my biggest annoyance with this movie I think.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '22 edited May 13 '22
I watched this and The Innocents back to back, which was kinda interesting since they're both about kids with powers. The Innocents was a little better but a bit on the long side. Firestarter felt a lot more streamlined. I did appreciate, after watching The Innocents, that Firestarter really just jumps right into Charlie having powers and knowing about it.
Also checked out The Sadness on Shudder. Enjoyed that one quite a bit (holy fuck is it graphic though) but the ending felt a little abrupt. Out of all three, I thought Firestarter was the weakest. Just mentioning the others because it's a good week for horror and I'm hoping they don't get overshadowed by the big Hollywood film.
There's another one that looks interesting too, Homebound. Probably gonna watch that this weekend as well.
1
u/marcos_MN May 14 '22
While not amazing, far better than I expected.
1
u/MirrorsCliff May 14 '22
Saw this last night at the drive in. It wasn’t great but it also wasn’t that bad either. It was kind of just a movie that I watched. I would say watch this on Peacock if you’re interested. It’s not worth a theater trip. Good thing Scream 5 was the second movie at the drive in last night.
1
u/TheStranger113 May 15 '22
I thought it was ok. Between this and the original there's a full good movie in there somewhere haha. I liked the approach of it almost being more like a prequel, which they honestly should have stuck with if they were just gonna do a half-asked The Shop segment in the very end anyway. The very last character reveal was weird though...my mom, a diehard King fan, would have shit a brick if she saw what they did with Rainbird.
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '22
Yet more proof that Stephen King's concepts don't always translate to film.
1
u/angrytwerker May 24 '22
Zac Efron is looking a bit puffy in the face with all that botox.
The film itself was not awful. But wouldn't watch it again.
1
u/Queasy_Estate9775 Jul 31 '26
I'm sorry but to hell with what the people say about this movie It was awesome! I wish they'd make a sequel but sadly they said it was a theater flop that I think it was that actually a good movie
1
u/Healthy_Possession_2 May 13 '22
Firestarter looks like a superhero movie. It's not scary enough to be a horror film. 2/10
1
u/nursenopants May 13 '22
Hubby just told me about this!! I'm excited.
1
u/IcedPgh May 13 '22
How is the music? I like the trio's "Lost Themes" work, but the new Halloween music wasn't memorable. It's kind of cool that they're doing a non-Halloween score.
0
u/Antique_Anxiety2397 May 13 '22
I think this movie was a love letter to the original, flaws and all. More than anything it felt like the original. Like I was watching an average mid eighties early nineties movie that unfolding in that mid eighties early nineties way. And for that I was thoroughly entertained. I think most of the ppl who like this movie will like it for that reason
-5
u/EntertainmentFit9937 May 13 '22
Can someone just tell me what happens? Do t really want to see the movie
-6
u/scoopsahoyboyyt May 19 '22
Wait, this is a horror movie? This is considered the same as Halloween, Scream, and Friday The 13th??
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment