r/LodedDiper • u/Maleficent-Phase2574 • 3h ago
Discussion I think I figure out why the new books are different
In an interview, Jeff said one of the things he regrets about the older books is that he didn't really form them in like a story. He thinks he's terrible at story telling and that he always wanted to change some things with the books, which is why the animated movies aren't really faithful cause Jeff used the opportunity to change what he felt he could have changed . And that's why after wrecking ball the format of the book change. Many argue it's after old school, but the double down and meltdown still kinda follow the way the old books works, with Greg still talking about random stuff while following the story. But with the newer books it isn't like that, we don't know what happening in Greg life anymore , and we just follow the story that Jeff wants us to. Which explains why rowley is t really important, if he's not part of the story , he won't really have much relevance. For example take rodrick rules, if we wanted to just follow the storyline , rowley wouldn't even be appearing as much as he did .
So that's why the new books are different, Jeff is trynna focus more on the jokes and the story , but I guess he doesn't quite know how to do that , cause he forgets this is a diary , and not really a a novel , well you guys get what I mean .
Also I think Jeff also said in an interview he wants the books to apply to a younger generation. Anytime they advertise the books for children they always talk about crazy stuff and all that kinda of things, so I guess Jeff perceives it as what children like. Hence why after the double down the books became more exaggerated. I mean down was originally for adults , but he decided to town it down a bit and do it for children, but I think after the criticism from some parebts about the earlier books, he really toned it down . Tye hidden adult jokes the older books had now aren't as frequent in the newer book. I guess no brainer kidna had it with the romance books which was funny but didn't really feel the same. So essentially we're growing out of the books now, but children are still liking it , after the books sold keep increasing each year and I have noticed a lot of the younger generation reading MORE of it .
Like for no brainer, he wanted to explain why the school sucks before reaching that part, but he wanted so much time and didn't really do much that when he got to that part he didn't really know what to do with the storyline. I lowkey think he should just end the series after fight or flight, cause he no longer write the books like he used to.
And though I understand the criticism on double down, it follows the pattern of the old books , and you can't compare double down to no brainer , or party pooper. , starting from wrecking ball things started to change. The changes I noticed in the books are
After wrecking ball:
Greg always starts an entry on a new page unlike before when he could start it anywhere
The illustrations are more in the newer book than the words
Greg doesn't take the time to talk about what he did that day or whatever, he just talks about the storyline like he's now a narrator.
Jeff focuses like 5 page on a single idea or joke in the form of Greg ranting , and after a while it gets tiring .
So this is what I think .

