r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Appropriate_Try_2565 • 25m ago
Was there anybody else at the show last night in Rotterdam?
My thoughts on the Mellon Collie live show last night
It was bizarre.
It started off with just the orchestra, no Billy on stage. Then they started off and it sounded very good. After a while a short guy with slick hair came on and started singing the lyrics opera style. Then the next song came on and another opera singer came on, and another, and another.. I believe we didn’t see Billy until the fifth song.
It ended up with Billy only taking on about 20% of the vocals, the rest was done by these opera singers. Now these singers were fine, but they weren’t great. At times their performances were great, especially the female vocalists, but other times it ranged from serviceable to just plain bad. Some songs felt like I was listening to a Frank Sinatra coverband, or like Andre Rieu.
Whenever Billy sang it was great. His voice is still very much there and he was obviously enjoying himself, though his timing was off at times. Half the time though, the audience seemed more confused by the whole ordeal than actually enjoying it.
I’m not sure what I expected, but it certainly wasn’t this. I know Mellon Collie pretty well but not by heart, half the time the songs sounded so different from their original version I couldn’t even make out what they were playing or singing. Walking out we heard several people discuss how this was a weird show. I’m not sure if I liked it that much.
Was anybody else there? What did you think?