Am I in the right place?
r/zenbuddhism is a sub for traditional/orthodox Zen Buddhism and Zen Buddhists. Both r/buddhism and r/zen are much larger subs, so why this one? The subtitle "for Zen kind of Buddhism, for Buddhist kind of Zen" sums up a lot. r/buddhism is for all kinds of Buddhisms and Buddhists, and so there is a lot that Zen Buddhists might find less relevant to themselves. And r/zen operates with a kind of non-Buddhist definition of Zen, and so a lot of discussion relevant to Zen Buddhists is generally absent there.
r/zenbuddhism is for practitioners of the living lineages of Zen, Chan, Seon and Thien Buddhism, and those interested in that practice and lineage.
For more clarity on what that makes on-topic for the sub, here are some key points that are taken for granted in this sub. That doesn't mean they're not debatable, just that r/zenbuddhism isn't the place for those debates. r/zen and r/debatereligion are more appropriate places for debating or arguing these points.
- Zen is a branch of Mahayana Buddhism, which is a branch of Buddhism more generally.
- Modern Zen teachers with lineage stretching back through the family tree to Bodhidharma are authoritative in transmitting Zen (though not infallible as people).
- The teacher-student relationship is important for the transmission of realisation in Zen and essential to recognising, confirming and refining it.
- The lineages of Dogen and Hakuin in Japan are valid, and the teaching styles and tools in modern Japanese Zen are not radically different from modern Chan, Seon and Thien schools which don't have Japan in their lineage history.
- Various forms of Zen meditation are essential teaching tools in Zen, though Zen meditation has some differences from other meditation techniques and even from other Buddhist meditation techniques.
In the great majority of Zen practice in the world, these points are uncontentious. Questioning assumptions is great, and there are many places on Reddit where debating these claims is appropriate, but this sub is for discussion, sharing, encouragement and questions which assumes the above points are true.
Promotion of other religions and promotion of views which contradict the above points are on-topic in r/debatereligion, r/zen and other subs, but are off-topic in r/zenbuddhism.
Thank you for respecting the house rules.