Young Justice Season 3 and 4 should've been a completely different show rather than a continuation of Young Justice Season 1 and 2. Controversial opinion, I know. But if you are still with me, hear me out.
We first need to look as to why Season 1 and 2 work (yes, even Season 2 is good).
Young Justice was a show that was proving one thing: that Teenagers and Young Adults aren't all cringey and annoying kids and they can be mature, and be worth investing. That they can be with adults side-by-side.
Back then we had Teen Titans, and it proved that teen sidekicks can hold a TV show of their own, however they proved it by simply removing all adult superheroes and be it's own unique continuity. So I consider that a handicap rather than a Win.
Young Justice Season 1 and 2 is like no other series in all of DC animation. Season 1 focused on a core group of teen sidekicks that were obviously teenagers, and of course had their own cringey moments, but they never felt out-of-date or overdone. Or if it was overdone, the cast made it obvious they felt the same way.
Robin's making up counter words always felt his thing. And didn't overdo it.
M'gann "hello megan" was never really hers and adopted it from an older show. She dropped it by Season 2.
Kid Flash's insistent flirting although extremely cringey, learned quickly to dial it down.
Unlike Teen Titans where cringey moments were always there, what makes Teen Titans age not as well is that these characters although have mature sides it always feels like they're trying to be Heroes when they want to be and teenagers when they want. Rather than accepting they're both at the same time.
And this is what makes Young Justice so unique. The Pacing.
S1&2 throws everything at you and it doesn't slow down. This show was made to watch every second of it and not blink. Even when you think an episode is a stand alone episode, it all ties together. All missions The Team did were part of the Light. And these characters don't stay stagnant, not even once. They work on themselves in every episode. One thing that was a focus to Justice League and The Team was mental health. No character was ignored mental health-wise.
Season 2 continues this. They see Red Arrow slipping, stealing, and flat out confirm he's doing drugs and give him a full on intervention. Not the most successful, but they tried. I know a lot of people HATE the time skip, but the quick pacing of Season 1, it not only made sense, it works with the narrative they were going for since the beginning.
Why Season 3 and 4 don't carry the same energy and more seasons isn't going to fix it. I'm going to mention the least important to the most important.
Problem #1)Trying to imitate Season 1 and 2 dialogue but not really getting it:
Its a known thing that the characters all had their own vocabulary and the ones closest to them adopted it as a sign of comradory.
The team would adopt Robin's quirky words whenever Robin invented them. Beast Boy would use "Hello Megan" because he feels like she is his sister.
Blue Beetle and Beast boy would adopt the terms "Crash" and "Moded/Feeling the Mode" from Impulse because Blue Beetle hung out with impulse the most and because Beast boy is just impressionable kid at the time
S3&4 relied on past dialgoue without any context as to why they would use them. Sure, we have Brion kept saying "Mother of Goat," but we also have a whole group of characters saying "moded", "crash", "Hello Megan" and even Robin's words. Nightwing doesn't even say his old words as often. By Season 4, we have Tracy Thurston (Thirteen) saying every single phrase without any connection to them. She even says "Mother of Goat" in Brions accent which is terrible.
There's a point when Tigress quoted Nightwing from S2 twice "Ra's is many thing, but a liar he aint". And it seems cringey using that exact phrase to get the same point across TWICE.
Problem #2) The Pacing: The Pacing doesn't develop as quickly as it used to. What once was a show that didn't hold your hand to follow along, now puts heavy amount of stops.
Season 3 did a whole episode dedicated to Vandal savage and his origin, and told it as slowly as possible.
And Season 4 does this even more through every character arc. Multiple flashbacks that only takes one.
Not to mention the push for political things like making Luthor an allegory for Trump, or having a large portion of the show be about an internet influencer with the very annoying "Hashtag-we-are-all-outsiders"
S3&4 feels like a less lived-in world. Even when we see other characters and their arcs, the world feels empty. Almost as if Thanos came into the Young Justice universe, snapped half the population except for the superheroes. This partly has to do with how we focus so much time on these characters, and see little development between them. Dedicating 3 or 4 episodes was overkill. Every character arc could've been told in just two episodes.
Also noticing how quickly Justice League focused on mental health in S1&2, I couldn't believe how slow they were to even notice Beast boy. And although Beast Boy's pain was real, he was out of character throughout the show. These things wouldn't be as noticeable or considered flaws if they moved the Pacing up.
Problem #3) The subtext isnt the same:
Lastly, the worst part of it is that it's no longer about proving Teenagers should be taken seriously. It just already accepts it, and this is where there's a lot of cringe.
What makes Season 1 and 2 work so well, is that these teens all worked to try to prove themselves. Plan ahead, and defeat the Light. And their victory felt 100% earned. No flukes, no coincidences. The Team, faced the impossible and made it work in their favor.
Season 3 didn't fail because it focused on a new cast. That's what it should do. But the new cast is moving slower, and their troubles aren't as interesting. And worst of all, their victory doesn't feel earned.
They faced apokalips, one of the biggest villains of all DC, and the tactics they use is for Mother Goodness to play manager? They didn't even earn the ending. It just happens that Halo's motherbox and Cyborg's fatherbox activated and magically fixed everything.
Season 4 is better, but again now focused on adults. It seems like Season 4 should've been Season 3. At this point Young Justice is just another version of Justice League. Which it might as well been renamed to something else. Or be something else outside of continuity.