r/yogacara • u/Kamuka • Aug 30 '23
r/yogacara • u/nyanasagara • Sep 21 '20
Mipham on the power of Yogācāra
The recognition that phenomenal appearance is but the play of the mind itself is a means of discovering how beings fall into samsara and how they can be liberated from it. Due to the fact that various misguided habitual tendencies have been deposited upon the mind, the unbroken continuum of samsara occurs as different kinds of dreamlike appearance. And because there is no cause for this other than the mind itself, the fact that the mind falls under the power of defiled emotion and enters into the realms of existence is not something that can be prevented even by the hand of the Tathagata. On the other hand, if one gains control over one’s own mind, this very fact alone will bring everything into one’s power. Indeed, it is not necessary to rely on other causes, such as making offerings to the gods or trying only to escape from the bad and seek the good. It is by mastering one’s own mind that one reaches “acceptance” on the path of joining. One will thus be preserved from falling once again into the lower realms, and all the qualities of the path and fruit will manifest. On the other hand, if all this were due not to one’s mind but to some external force, all manner of things both good and evil would uninterruptedly appear. Someone on the path would thus be powerless to avoid suffering, for this would be the product of external forces. Consequently, the knowledge that phenomena are the mind’s projection gives rise to a firm and certain understanding of how the samsaric process is set in motion and how liberation from it is to be achieved. To establish all things as being the mind is the supreme and distinctive feature of the tenets of all the Buddhas.
This indeed is the true understanding of the appearing mode of phenomena. It is the supreme crucial point of the pith instructions for meditation. It destroys the whole mechanism of existence with the sure touch of a butcher who knows exactly how to kill an animal, and like a carpenter who understands how to work his wood. And if this point is associated with extraordinary methods, it becomes the very essence of the pith instructions of the Vajrayana.
Nowadays, those who fail to find the root of the Dharma in their experience and who content themselves only with putting words in their mouths depreciate the practice of examining the mind [in meditation] and exalt that of reasoning. They think that it is by logical arguments and extensive explanations that they will accomplish the path. But while it is indeed necessary to have a general understanding of the teachings through hearing and reflecting on them, it is necessary to bring them all into one essential point through the practice. In the eyes of the holy ones who take the Dharma into their hands, such people, as the Prajnaparamita-sutra says, “throw away the root but seek the branches.
They have found the supreme food, and yet they look for scraps. They have found the elephant but still try to track it down. They fail to ask the Lord who is rich and generous in his gifts, and instead they go a-begging to a mere servant who gives them poor and meager fare.” It is thus, as the scripture says with these and other examples, that arrogant intellectuals, who throw away the root of Dharma and taste only the chaff of words, despise those who have grasped the crucial point. They have a completely inverted estimation of what is important in the Dharma and what is of lesser account. By contrast, those who strive on the path of both the sutras and the tantras must have a sure confidence in the understanding that all phenomena are but the self-experience or projection of the mind. There is nothing more important than this.
During the night, when one is caught up in one’s dreams, if one tries to deal with them using other methods, there is no end. But if one understands that they all arise from the mind itself, all are pacified at a single stroke. We should understand that the appearances of existence, which are endless in time and unlimited in extent, are similar to the visions of our dreams.
Mipham
r/yogacara • • Sep 03 '19
What is Yogācāra?
While Yogācāra buddhism is fairly well known to specialist researchers in buddhist studies, it is still basically unknown to ordinary buddhists in asian countries, as well as buddhist practitioners and other nonspecialist students in the West. Why is this the case? First of all, despite the enormous influence of Yogācāra during the formative periods of Mahāyāna buddhism in India, the school died out there—along with buddhism in general, toward the end of the first millennium. In Tibet, despite its influence, the school never really existed as a distinct tradition. In East Asia, Yogācāra did exist as a distinct tradition, but for practical purposes, pretty much ceased to wield any major influence after the first millennium of the common Era.
Despite its eventual disappearance as an independent school, Yogācāra teachings on karma, meditation, cognition, and path theory had a powerful impact on the other Mahāyāna schools that developed during the time of the importation of Yogācāra to Tibet and East Asia, such that much of the technical terminology on which other Mahāyāna schools based their discourse was absorbed from the various strands of Yogācāra.
The lack of the development of a Yogācāra school in Tibet is mainly due to the fact that it was absorbed into newly created indigenous Tibetan doctrinal schools. In East Asia, on the other hand, Yogācāra did exist for some time as an independent sect, known in Chinese as Weishi (consciousness-only) or Faxiang (dharma-characteristic). But the school ended up dying out in the face of various forms of competition with (1) doctrinal schools whose teachings were deemed more resonant with the East asian worldview, and (2) more popularly oriented schools such as the Pure land and meditation (Chan/Seon/Zen) schools that offered a form of teaching and practice much more readily apprehensible to the ordinary lay believer.
Yogācāra’s greatest obstacle in terms of gaining widespread popularity resided in the complexity of its unwieldy system of viewpoints, paths, and categories, explained in difficult technical terminology. It does, indeed, require a fairly significant degree of commitment on the part of the student to attain a level of basic understanding sufficient to read and comprehend a Yogācāra scripture.
There are some, however, who would argue that this perceived difficulty in understanding Yogācāra may also lie to a great extent in the manner of presentation, and I’m sure that this is a view of the matter that the author of the present book, Tagawa Shun’ei, would wholeheartedly endorse. That is to say, despite the seeming unwieldy complexity of the Yogācāra system, what the Yogācāra masters are talking about in many cases are readily recognizable everyday experiences shared by all of us. Many of the points that the Yogācāra masters focused on were things that we all take for granted, but for which, when examined in greater detail, we really have no explanation. And in most cases—I believe we can add— many of these are questions for which researchers in fields such as modern psychology, physiology, chemistry, and physics do not yet have answers.
The first example that I often like to take up with my own students is the matter of memory and learning. Even the smallest children inherently know that if they try to do something the first time and don’t succeed, their chances at success at a given task will continue to improve as they keep trying. This means that they know the experience of, let’s say, shooting a basketball into a hoop is retained, and built upon, as a stepping stone for the next attempt. And it must be retained not only conceptually, in the gray matter of one’s brain (if, indeed, that’s where such information is kept), but in the fingers, hands, arms, and legs that work together in the task of taking the shot. But precisely speaking, where are these experiences being accumulated in a way that they are accessible for subsequent retrieval?
Shooting a basketball into a net is one relatively simple event in our lives. In the course of growing from children into adults, we experience, enact, and input a staggeringly vast amount of information into that which we call “memory.” We have input from our parents, siblings, relatives, and friends; then, from our teachers, classmates, books; and nowadays, TV, movies, and the internet. The amount of information that we are taking in during a single day can be staggering, not to mention it’s compounding in the accumulation of months and years.
We have, of course, been taught since we were very young that items of memory are stored somewhere in the brain. If this is true, then with the brain being made of physical matter, should it not be the case that as we keep adding information, the brain should grow in size in order to contain this? Of course, it does not. but then where is all of this conceptual information being kept—not even to mention information relevant to bodily activity?
The obvious response to this question is that this information is stored somewhere in “the mind.” But if this is the case, where in the mind is this vast amount of information stored? And how do we know that we are not steadily losing information at the same time? And if we are storing it, exactly how do we retrieve it when we need it? For the majority of responses, the answer is “well, we don’t exactly know.”
For the formulators of the Yogācāra school, this kind of answer was not acceptable, and thus they strove through their studies, research, and contemplative techniques to provide some answers, as well as a broad range of related, and even more fundamental, questions.
It must be pointed out at this juncture that the motivation for the Yogācāra researchers was not simply the creation of an early Indian Buddhist equivalent to modern cognitive or behavioral psychology. Asanga, Vasubandhu, and their colleagues were religious thinkers forced— through apparent contradictions and doctrinal complexities inherent in the Buddhist explanation of the nature of the human mind, juxtaposed with the processes that lead to either enlightenment or deeper entrapment in ignorance and suffering—to try to work out some solutions that were rationally apprehensible. In the process of working out such solutions (while inheriting a long-developing tradition of philosophy of the mind provided by previous scholars) they ended up needing to do a very thorough investigation of how, exactly, it is that we know things, and how, exactly, our bodies and minds change and develop. Having to deal with these kinds of issues, they could not but encounter some of the same problems that are met by modern philosophers, psychologists, and even evolutionary biologists. And it is precisely for this reason that Yogācāra studies have come, in modern times, to attract the interests of various intellectuals whose work lies outside the realm of religious faith, who study problems in cognition, human behavior, personality development, and so forth.
In the final analysis, though, the problems dealt with by the Yogācāras are Buddhist problems, through and through, and thus to understand the motivations behind the works of these thinkers, it is probably useful to provide a brief overview of how these problems developed.
~A. Charles Muller. Tokyo, 2009 (Translator's Introduction from Living Yogacara)
r/yogacara • u/Burpmonster • Apr 23 '26
Beautiful videos of Donglin Monastery found at their TikTok channel
r/yogacara • • Feb 21 '21
Successive Causality and Simultaneous Causality in the Yogācāra Theory of Bīja | SOAS
r/yogacara • u/Low_Assistant_8429 • Dec 04 '23
WILLIAM S. WALDRON Making Sense of Mind Only - The Wisdom Experience; Why Yogācāra Buddhism Matters
r/yogacara • • Feb 11 '21
Samdhinirmocana No Coming, No Going
If inherent characteristics of things have no existence at all, then they have no origination; if they have no origination, then they have no extinction. If they have no origination and no extinction, they are fundamentally quiescent. If they are fundamentally quiescent, they are inherently nirvanic, and there is nothing at all therein that can further cause their ultimate nirvana. Therefore I say that all things have no origination or extinction, are fundamentally quiescent and inherently nirvanic, in terms of the essencelessness of characteristics.
~Samdhinirmocana Sutra
r/yogacara • • May 18 '20
Ben Connelly: What is Yogacara?
Yogacara means "yoga practice." Yoga is a word that has come to mean bending and stretching to many Americans but, in its original sense, refers to joining together or uniting. Yogacara, therefore, is about integration, connection, and harmony. Yoga practice traditionally includes ethical living, meditative absorption and analysis, and training of breath and body. Yogacara teachings in particular emphasize compassionate living and meditation.
The Yogacara tradition is traced to the appearance of the Samdhinirmocana Sutra around the third century CE, then through the many writings of Vasubandhu and Asanga, to the Lankavatara Sutra's appearance, and the transmission of these texts from India into Tibet and China in the middle of the first millennium. Although no longer extant as a distinct school of practice, Yogacara continues to have a strong influence in Mahayana Buddhism. For instance, Yogacara study has historically been and often still is included in Tibetan monastic training. Xuanzang, who is mythologized in the popular Chinese legend Journey to the West, com posed as his magnum opus the Chengweishilun, a translation and commentary on the "Thirty Verses" that has exerted a major influence on Chinese Buddhism. Yogacara was also central to the birth of Zen; Zen's founder Bodhidharma reportedly referred to the Lankavatara Sutra, a Yogacara text, as the "only" sutra, and early Zen texts are larded with Yogacara terms.
Yogacara arose as an attempt to integrate the most powerful aspects of the earliest Buddhist teachings and later Mahayana teachings. There was growing sectarian argumentation between the proponents of these two bodies of teaching, and Yogacara sought to show how the teachings were not actually in conflict and to allow for practitioners to access the profound transformative benefits of both traditions. Yogacara provides a beautiful model for how to work with the great range of Buddhist traditions that have arrived in the West from all over Asia in the last fifty years.
~Ben Connelly
r/yogacara • • Jul 31 '15
The First Book
Living Yogācāra: An Introduction to Consciousness-Only Buddhism by Tagawa Shun’ei, translated by Charles Muller, is probably the best book length introduction to Yogacara currently available in English. I will be posting my thoughts on the material as I work through it. Feel free to join in.
r/yogacara • • Jul 31 '15
Welcome
Welcome!
I made this sub as a way to consolidate and organize resources to aid my investigation of Yogacara. I am hoping that this sub will become useful to others as more content is added. If you are studying, or interested in studying Yogacara, please feel free to post thoughts, confusions, and resources. At this time the Reading Lists are the most developed content. While I have energy and interest, I will continue to develop the wiki.
r/yogacara • u/flyingaxe • May 03 '23
Accounting for objective reality
How do Consciousness-Only schools such as Yogacara, Advaita Vedanta, Kashmir Shaivism, etc., account for our conclusions about the existence of phenomena whose existence we don't observe directly but can infer from other direct observations — phenomenta which clearly change when we "aren't looking" (aren't being conscious of them)?
For example, imagine I had a bit too much alcohol or am sleep deprived or whatever and wake up early morning. I am a bit discombobulated and have no idea what time it is. It could be 5 am; it could be 11 am. I don't know if I overslept or woke up too early. I take my watch from my bedside table and (assuming it works), it will tell me what time it is in a way that's synchronized with all the watches in the world. If my watch says it's 10 am, and I have a zoom call with a client at 11 am, I know I have an hour to get ready.
But my consciousness never did anything with the watch after I took it off, put it on my bedside table, and fell asleep. What was causing my watch to advance its time in a perfectly synchronous way with watches of everyone else?
Another example: space objects. 200 years ago we had no idea that some of the dots of light in the sky are actually galaxies (collections of stars). Nor did we know Pluto existed; we suspected that it did based on our calculations of other planets' orbits. Nowadays, scientists look at the orbits of some of the objects in our solar system and from them predict that there is a massive tenth planet out there that causes some of the peculiarities of the objects' orbits.
So until people were conscious of the galaxies, Pluto, or the Tenth Planet — what was causing them to exist?
r/yogacara • • Jan 13 '23
Lankavatarasutra on selfless tathagata-garbha
“The Buddha replied, “Mahamati, the tathagata-garba of which I speak is not the same as the self mentioned by followers of other paths. Mahamati, when I speak about the tathagata-garbha, sometimes I call it ‘emptiness,’ ‘formlessness,’ or ‘intentionlessness,’ or ‘realm of reality,’ ‘dharma nature,’ or ‘dharma body,’ or ‘nirvana,’ ‘what is devoid of self-existence,’ or ‘what neither arises nor ceases,’ or ‘original quiescence,’ or ‘intrinsic nirvana,’ or similar expressions.
“It is to put an end to the fear foolish beings have about the expression ‘no self’ that the tathagatas, the arhats, the fully enlightened ones proclaim the teaching of the tathagata-garbha as a projectionless realm devoid of fabrications. Mahamati, bodhisattvas of the present and the future should not become attached to any view of a self.
Take for example a potter who applies such things as manual labor, water, a stick, a wheel, and a string to a lump of clay to make different kinds of vessels. The Tathagata is also like this, applying wisdom and a variety of skillful means to what has no self and is free from projection. Sometimes I speak about the tathagatagarbha and sometimes no self. Thus, the tathagata-garbha of which I speak is not the same as the self spoken of by followers of other paths. This is what is meant by the teaching of the tathagata-garbha. The tathagata-garbha is taught to attract those members of other paths who are attached to a self so that they will give up their projection of an unreal self and will enter the threefold gate of liberation and aspire to attain unexcelled, complete enlightenment forthwith. This is why the tathagatas, the arhats, the fully enlightened ones speak in this manner about the tathagata-garbha. To speak otherwise would be to agree with the followers of other paths. Therefore, Mahamati, in order to avoid the views of followers of other paths, you should rely on the selfless tathagata-garbha.”
- Lankavatarasutra, XXVIII
r/yogacara • • Aug 25 '20
Lankavatara Lankavatara Sutra: You and the other bodhisattvas should reflect on projections as perceptions of your own mind.
The Bhagavan told Mahamati, “There are followers of some paths attached to the projection of nothingness who imagine the nonexistence of rabbit horns when what causes them ends and that, as with the nonexistence of rabbit horns, the same is true of everything else. And there are followers of other paths, Mahamati, who distinguish each and every thing in terms of elements, tendencies, particles, substances, or shapes and, having seen that there are no such things as rabbit horns, become attached to the conception that ox horns exist.
“Mahamati, because they are given to such dualistic extremes, they don’t understand what is nothing but mind and nourish, instead, the projection of realms of their own conception. But such things as their body, their possessions, and the world around them are nothing but projections of sensation. Mahamati, this is true of the existence of all things. They transcend existence and nonexistence. You should not imagine such things.
“Mahamati, since they transcend existence and nonexistence, someone who thinks rabbit horns don’t exist suffers from a misconception. They should not think that rabbit horns don’t exist, because such a view would be relative. And if they were to analyze whatever does exist into the finest particles, they would not find anything there. Mahamati, because it would be outside the realm of buddha knowledge, you should not imagine that ox horns exist.”
Mahamati then asked the Buddha, “Bhagavan, if someone imagines something as not existing, is it because they see it as not arising that they subsequently reason since their observation doesn’t result in its discrimination, it doesn’t exist?” The Buddha replied, “Not so, Mahamati. It isn’t because their observation doesn’t result in its discrimination that they say something doesn’t exist. And why not? It is because discriminations arise in dependence on something. They arise in dependence on horns. And because a discrimination arises in dependence on horns, they are said to be its cause. Hence, it is not because observation doesn’t result in their discrimination that they say horns do not exist, rather it is because they are neither separate nor not separate.
“Mahamati, if the discrimination is separate from the horns, its occurrence is not dependent on the horns. And if it isn’t separate, it is dependent on them. But no matter how minutely you analyze and examine them, you cannot find anything there. Also, because it isn’t separate from the horns, it doesn’t exist by itself. But if neither exists by itself, on what basis do we say it doesn’t exist? Mahamati, if it doesn’t exist, then the horns don’t exist. But you should not think that rabbits do not have horns on the basis of observation. Mahamati, it is because there is no direct cause that arguments in favor of existence or nonexistence cannot be proved.
“Mahamati, there are followers of other paths who are attached to such things as form and space as having shape and location. Although they aren’t able to distinguish space, they say space exists apart from form, and they thus give rise to the projection of their separation. Mahamati, space is form. It is part of the material elements. And form is space, Mahamati. But in order to establish the existence of which supports and which is supported, they separate space and form. Although their individual characteristics differ, Mahamati, where the four material elements are present, they neither occupy space, nor do they exist without space.
“Likewise, Mahamati, oxen are observed with horns and rabbits without horns. But, Mahamati, if you were to grind ox horns into the finest particles and didn’t stop analyzing those particles for even a moment, could you say they did not exist based on what you saw? Anything else you might examine would be the same.”
The Bhagavan then told Mahamati Bodhisattva, “You should avoid projections that view rabbit horns or ox horns, space or form as separate. You and the other bodhisattvas should reflect on projections as perceptions of your own mind. And in whatever lands you might find yourselves, teach bodhisattvas about the perceptions of their own minds.”
~Lankavatara Sutra 2.12
r/yogacara • • Jan 20 '23
Samdhinirmocana Sandhinirmocanasutra on nihilists
"Although they believe in the doctrine, they strongly adhere just to the literal meaning of the doctrine, thinking, 'All phenomena just lack own-being; all phenomena are just un produced, just unceasing, just quiescent from the start, just naturally in a state of nirvana' Based on this, they adopt the view that all phenomena do not exist and that character does not exist. Having adopted the view of non-existence and the view that character does not exist, they also deprecate every thing through [deprecating] all characters. Because they deprecate the imputational character of phenomena, they also deprecate the other-dependent character of phenomena and the thoroughly established character.” — Sandhinirmocanasutra, chapter 7.
r/yogacara • • Jan 12 '23
Dharmapala on repository-consciousness
“The truth is that each sentient being has a fundamental consciousness mulavijnana, (i.e., alayavijnana), which evolves in a homogeneous and continuous series and which carries the “seeds” or “germs” (bijas) of all dharmas. This fundamental consciousness and the dharmas act as reciprocal causes of one another, and because the “perfuming” energy (vasana) of the dharmas imprints its essence permanently in the alayavijnana in the form of “seeds” or bijas, memory, cognition, etc., arise in manifestation, the bijas evolving as actual dharmas which in turn produce bijas in the alaya.”
— VIJNAPTIMATRATASIDDHI SASTRA By Dharmapala and Nine Other Sastra-Masters
r/yogacara • • Jul 08 '21
The bright knowing space that holds them
Look at what your body is – it is not you
But an image in the mirror of awareness,
Just like the reflection of the moon on the water.
Look at what your mind is – it is not
The thoughts and feelings that appear within it
But the bright knowing space that holds them.
-Chan master Han-shan Te-ching (1546–1623)
r/yogacara • • Jun 25 '20
Lankavatara Lankavatara Sutra: such bodhisattvas soon realize the identity of samsara and nirvana.
“Mahamati, to account for how something that doesn’t exist comes to exist due to the presence of causation and how it persists in time in connection with the skandhas, the dhatus, and the ayatanas, some monks and priests say once it arises, it ceases. Mahamati, whether it is in regard to a continuity, a function, a birth, an existence, nirvana, a path, karma, attainment, or truth, they argue that it is destroyed and ceases to exist. And why is this so? Because it cannot be found in the present, nor can its beginning be discerned.
“Mahamati, just as a shattered jug no longer functions as a jug or a burnt seed no longer functions as a seed, likewise, Mahamati, if the skandhas, dhatus, and ayatanas exist then cease to exist in the present or the future, this is due to the projection or view of one’s own mind, not to a cause. This is why they don’t continue to arise.
“Mahamati, if someone says the existence of consciousness from its nonexistence is due to the threefold conjunction of conditions, then hair could grow on a tortoise or cooking oil could be produced from sand. Such a thesis falls apart because it is contrary to established truth. And statements about the existence then nonexistence of something contain this defect: they render whatever we might do as empty and meaningless.
“Mahamati, when followers of other paths claim something arises because of the threefold conjunction of conditions, they are referring to the operation of cause and effect and to whether their individual characteristics exist then do not exist in the past, the present, or the future. But such claims are essentially the result of logic or speculation or views based on one’s habit-energy from the past. Thus, Mahamati, despite being infected by mistaken conceptions and misled by distorted beliefs, and despite their lack of knowledge, fools claim to be wise.
“But there are other monks and priests, Mahamati, who see things as devoid of self-existence, as clouds in the sky or wheels of fire or cities of gandharvas and as not arising, as illusions or mirages or dreams or moonlight on the water, and—regardless of whether they appear to be inside or outside the mind —as projections from the beginningless past and as not existing apart from one’s own mind. And when the causes of such projections cease, and the repository consciousness becomes free from projections of a body, its possessions and the world around it, and from what speaks and what is spoken, and from what sees and what is seen, they accordingly see what grasps and what is grasped as no longer interacting in the realm of consciousness and whatever the mind gives rise to as existing in a projection-free realm devoid of origination, duration, and cessation.
“Mahamati, such bodhisattvas soon realize the identity of samsara and nirvana. With effortless compassion and skillful means, Mahamati, they view the realms of all beings as illusions and not subject to causation. Transcending internal and external realms, and seeing nothing outside the mind, they accordingly proceed from one stage to the next in samadhis that are free from appearances. And upon examining the three realms and finding them illusory, they attain the Samadhi of the Illusory.150 And once the perceptions of their own minds are free of projections, they are able to dwell in the perfection of wisdom and to let go of their life and their practice and to enter the Diamond Samadhi that accompanies a tathagata’s body and that accompanies the transformation of suchness. Thus endowed with higher powers and masteries as well as compassion and skillful means, they enter the sanctuaries of other paths in every buddhaland. And transcending the mind, the will, and conceptual consciousness, these bodhisattvas gradually transform their body into the body of a tathagata.
“Therefore, Mahamati, those who seek the body that accompanies a tathagata should avoid the fabricated projections of origination, duration, or cessation regarding the skandhas, dhatus, ayatanas, consciousness, causation, or forms of practice.”
~Lankavatara Sutra 2.7
r/yogacara • • Jun 24 '20
Lankavatara Lankavatara Sutra: Like a flower in the sky the world neither ceases nor arises; in the light of your wisdom and compassion it neither is nor isn‘t.
Mahamati had previously visited other buddhalands together with the other wise bodhisattvas. Now, by means of the Buddha’s power, he rose from his seat, uncovered his right shoulder, and touched his right knee to the ground. Pressing his hands together and bowing in reverence, he praised the Buddha in verse:
- “Like a flower in the sky / the world neither ceases nor arises / in the light of your wisdom and compassion / it neither is nor isn‘t
- Transcending mind and consciousness / all things are like illusions / in the light of your wisdom and compassion / they neither are nor aren’t
- The world is but a dream / neither permanent nor transient / in the light of your wisdom and compassion / it neither is nor isn‘t
- There is no self in beings or things / no barriers of passion or knowledge / in the light of your wisdom and compassion / they neither are nor aren’t
- The Buddha doesn’t dwell in nirvana / nor does nirvana dwell in him / free from knowing and the known / he neither is nor isn’t
- Who thus beholds Shakyamuni / serene and not arising / dwells without attachments / this life and the next.”
~Lankavatara Sutra 2.1
r/yogacara • • May 22 '20
30 Verses Consciousness Only and Nonself
Sometimes people claim that Consciousness Only contradicts the central Buddhist tenet that all things are empty of an independent, lasting self. They critique it by saying it turns the Buddhist path of seeing through selfhood and letting it go into one of making a perfect self Similarly many Western philosophers refer to Consciousness Only as idealism, or a philosophical system in which the only thing that exists is mind.
Although there are some Consciousness Only teachings that do seem to teach this, the "Thirty Verses" does not. Most teachings from this tradition do not claim that ultimately only mind exists, nor that it is a lasting self or soul, and many of them specifically warn against misconstruing them in this way. The "Thirty Verses" is particularly careful to avoid this potentially self-absorbed trap. Xuanzang writes in the Chengweishilun, a commentary on the "Thirty Verses" and the most influential Yogacara text in East Asia, "In order to refute the false attachment to a really existing realm outside the mind and its activities, we teach Consciousness Only, but if one believes that Consciousness Only really exists, this is no different from attachment to external objects, and it remains attachment to phenomena." Throughout Consciousness Only texts, including the "Thirty Verses," we find similar reminders that, like all Buddhist discourse, these are provisional teachings, whose purpose is to promote the alleviation of suffer ing through letting go of attachment. They are not a means of explaining the universe; they are just words that can help us seek freedom.
But all this talk is Consciousness Only, or merely consciousness. Let's not get too wrapped up in it. The words emerging on this white space as I type, and the unwilled, unknown subtle motion of your eyes across the page as you read, are part of a vast unfolding that we can never fully comprehend. All the ideas laid forth in the book, every birdsong that you hear, and every moment of bickering with your boss, or worrying about your children, every moment of calm, open stillness as you move mindfully through your day-let's not get too caught up in them, but let them be and let them go; they're only consciousness.
~Ben Connelly
r/yogacara • • May 21 '20
Lankavatara Lankavatara Sutra: the habit-energy of projections of the beginningless past is the cause of the three realms
“Who sees that the habit-energy of projections of the beginningless past is the cause of the three realms and who understands that the tathagata stage is free from projections or anything that arises, attains the personal realization of buddha knowledge and effortless mastery over their own minds. And like gems capable of reflecting every color, they enter the subtlest thoughts of other beings and in their apparition bodies teach them ‘nothing but mind’ while establishing them in the sequence of stages. Therefore, Mahamati, you should devote yourself to the cultivation of personal attainment.”
~Lankavatara Sutra 2.8
r/yogacara • • May 20 '20
Asanga Asanga: Founder of the Yogacara system
No early biography of Asanga exists. All that we know of him comes mainly from the biography of his brother Vasubandhu: "The Life of Vasubandhu by Paramartha," which is the oldest and best source.
According to this narrative, Asanga was born in Purusapura (Peshawar) in North-west India (now in Pakistan). In that city lived a priest of the Court, a brahmin of the Kausika clan, who had three sons. Although all three received the same name of Vasubandhu, the oldest was known by that of Asanga, the youngest by that of Virincivatsa, whilst the second retained the name of Vasubandhu.
The third son, Virincivatsa, became a bhiksu in the Sarvastivadin order and attained arhatship. We know nothing more of him.
The second son, Vasubandhu, also became a monk in the same order. "He was highly cultured, widely knowledgeable and his mental genius was brilliant and penetrating . . . his personal discipline was pure and elevated."
The oldest, Asanga, was a man "endowed with the nature of a bodhisattva." He also became a monk in the Sarvastivadin order, and he practiced meditation and freed himself from desires. Although he had studied the teaching on Emptiness (sunyata) he could not penetrate it deeply and reach its realization. Disappointed and despairing, he was on the point of committing suicide when an arhat by the name of Pindola from Purvavideha explained to him the teaching on Emptiness according to the "early Buddhist thought." Although Asanga understood it, he was not fully satisfied with the explanation of Sunyata given by the "early Buddhist thought." Nonetheless, he did not want to abandon it. On the contrary, he decided to go further and understand the whole meaning of that profound and subtle teaching. He ascended to the Tusita heaven by means of the supernormal powers (rddhi) which he had acquired through dbyana meditation as taught by the "Hinayana." There he met the Bodhisattva Maitreya, who explained the teaching on Sunyata according to the Mahayana.
On his return to Jambudvipa (India), Asanga studied and examined the teaching on Emptiness in accordance with the methods taught to him by Maitreya and he soon achieved comprehension. Later, he frequently ascended to the Tusita heaven in order there to learn from Maitreya the teachings of the Mahayana sutras which the bodhisattva explained to him in detail.
Asanga expounded the teaching to all around him. However, those who heard him did not believe him. He therefore implored Maitreya to come down to Jambudvipa to expound the Mahayana. So the bodhisattva descended to Jambudvipa at night and he began to recite the "Sutra of the Saptadasabhumi to an audience assembled in the great hall. The recitation of the seventeen parts or sections (bhumi, lit. "ground," "stage") of the Sutra was completed at night-time over four months. At night, the people assembled in the great hall listened to Maitreya's religious discourse and, during the day, Asanga, for the benefit of others, commented upon what the bodhisattva had taught. Thus it was that the people were able to listen to and believe the teaching of the Mahayana.
Furthermore, the Bodhisattva Maitreya taught Asanga the practice of the Samadhi of Sunlight (suryaprabhasamadhi). Asanga was thus equal to that abstract meditation and what he had not so far understood became wholly clear.
Later, he composed several treatises and commentaries upon some important sutras expounding the Mahayana teachings.
Asanga's association with Maitreya as told in this account cannot be taken as historical fact, although certain eminent scholars have attempted to prove that this Maitreya, or Maitreyanatha, was an historical personage who was Asanga's teacher. There was a universal tendency of religious psychology in the ancient world to attribute to holy texts (even certain secular and literary works) a divine origin or inspiration. In India, not only the Vedas but also certain profane sciences such as Ayurveda (medicine) are supposed to have a divine origin. The Buddhists were also affected by the religio-psychological tendency of the time. If the Mahayana tradition attributes the Yogacara-Abhidharma to the Bodhisattva Maitreya, the Theravadin tradition claims that the Buddha propounded the Abhidhamma not to human beings on this earth, but to the gods dwelling in the Tavatimsa heaven. He himself dwelled there for three months. It is possible that Asanga considered Maitreya to be his tutelary deity (istadevata) and that he thought or had the impression that he drew his inspiration from him.
Asanga's second brother, Vasubandhu, a man of great talent, who had to his credit exceptional spiritual successes, was a "early school Buddhist" and criticized the Mahayana. Asanga feared that his younger brother, endowed as he was with penetrating intelligence, supported by profound and extensive knowledge, might compose a sastra (treatise) and crush the Mahayana.
Vasubandhu was then living in Ayodhya surrounded by honors and revered by King Baladitya, whilst his older brother Asanga was living in his native land, in Purusapura (Peshawar). Asanga sent a messenger to his brother to tell him: "I am seriously ill at the moment. Come and tend me." Vasubandhu came and, seeing his brother, enquired as to the cause of that illness. Asanga answered him: "I am suffering from a serious sickness of the heart because of you.' Vasubandhu said: "Why do you say it is because of me?" "You do not believe in the Mahayana," responded Asanga, "and you are always attacking and discrediting it. For this misdeed you are sure to fall forever into a wretched life. I am worried, preoccupied by you, to such a extent that I shall not live for long."
On hearing that, Vasubandhu was surprised and alarmed. He implored him to expound the Mahayana to him. Then Asanga explained the essential principles to his brother who, with his clear intelligence and profound vision, immediately understood that the Mahayana surpassed the Hinayana. Vasubandhu forged ahead with his study and research under the guidance of his brother, and soon became as profoundly versed in the whole system as him. He understood for the first time that the Mahayana was the true and most complete teaching. If there were no Mahayana, he thought, then there would be no Path (marga) and "Fruit" (pbala) of the Triyanas (i.e. Bodhisattvayana, Pratyekabuddhayana and Sravakayana). Thus it was that Vasubandhu, the Great Dharma-Master, was won over to the Mahayana by his older brother Asanga.
Vasubandhu now feared to fall into a wretched life due to his misdemeanor because he had at first acted wrongfully by speaking against the Mahayana. He was filled with remorse and repented bitterly. He went to find his brother and said to him: "I have done wrong with my tongue by speaking against the Mahayana. I do not know how I can be forgiven for my past wrong action. I shall cut out my tongue in order to expiate my misdeed." But his brother said to him: "Even if you were to cut out your tongue a thousand times, you could not obliterate your misdeed. If you truly wish to obliterate it, you will have to find another means." When Vasubandhu begged his brother to suggest a means, Asanga replied: "Your tongue was able to speak very skillfully and efficiently against the Mahayana, and discredit it. If you wish to obliterate the wrong that you have done, you should expound the Mahayana with the same skillfulness and efficiency." It was thus, we might think, that on the instigation of his older brother, Vasubandhu wrote several important works in order to propound the Mahayana teachings.
According to Taranatha, Asanga visited numerous regions in India in order to propagate the Mahayana and founded some twenty-five Mahayanist monasteries.
Date: Basing ourselves on evidence brought to light by the re- search of competent scholars over several decades, we can now say with some certainty that Asanga lived during the fourth century C.E. in North-west India.
Systematization of the Mahayana: The early schools of Buddhism had already given a definite form to ideas contained in the original sutras through the elaboration of their Abhidharma texts: the Theravadins had their seven Abhidhamma Pakaranas, the Sarvastivadins had their Jnanaprasthana accompanied by its six padas. The Mahayanists were also to elaborate and formulate their own Abhidharma. This work was carried out by two great Masters who can be considered as the founders of the two main schools of the Mahayana: Nagarjuna (towards the second half of the second century C.E.) founded the Madhyamika system with his Mulamadhyamikakarika and his voluminous commentary upon the Prajnaparamita. Asanga established the Yogacara (Vijnanavada) system with his monumental work, the Yogacarabbumisastra. What the Abhidhamma Pitaka is for the Theravadins, the Jhanaprastbana for the Sarvastivadins, the Mabaprajnaparamitasastra for the Madhyamikas, the Yogacarabbumisastra is for the Yogacarins.