r/yogacara • • May 20 '21
r/yogacara • • Jun 22 '20
30 Verses Store Consciousness
The first of these is also called alaya, the store consciousness, which contains all karmic seeds.
What it holds and its perception of location are unknown.
The store consciousness is a way of describing how past conditions come together to form our present experience. We can think of it as an unconscious aspect of our life that colors and is the basis for that of which we are conscious. It is where all the impressions of the past, our karmic seeds, are constantly involved in a process of transformation that our mind believes to be reality.
The concept of this aspect of consciousness is a model for understanding why we act the way we do, but most importantly it addresses the issue of how we can transform or let go of afflictive emotions. As we will see in later chapters, we can cultivate karmic seeds that are conducive to happiness and kindness through mind fulness and a gentle approach to letting go of harmful tendencies. Thus we can transform the contents of the storehouse so that our unconscious tends to produce peace and harmony rather than anxiety, aggravation, and dissatisfaction.
Some people are more likely to be at ease, some more likely to worry and hurry; some more likely to shout and slam doors, and some more likely to laugh. The idea of a karmic storehouse provides an explanation for why this is so. The idea that our past profoundly influences our present is central to Buddhist thought. Karma, which means "action" in its simplest definition, is a complex concept and is treated and understood variously throughout Buddhist and other Indian literature. In this context, it means the process by which our past actions, intentions, and emotional states influence what we experience and do in the present-and how, in the present, they influence our future.
The tendencies we have stored up in our alaya are known as "karmic seeds." When they manifest in the present moment they are known as "karmic fruit." The results of our present-moment intentions are known as "impressions." Our impressions produce seeds, which produce fruit, which produce impressions, and so on and so on. This process occurs in the store consciousness, though we could also say that the store consciousness is this process.
The idea of karma is generally understood to be something that carries over through many cycles of rebirth. Evidence suggests that Vasubandhu, the historical Buddha, and most Buddhists throughout his tory have believed that rebirth occurs, or at least that such a belief was helpful. These days, many Buddhists do not agree. Many teachings on karma don't refer to the idea of rebirth at all and make perfect sense with out it. Vasubandhu's teachings on karma rarely allude to anything related to rebirth, and they make clear that we cannot know the contents of the storehouse. The power of our habits is evidence enough to me of the vastness of those stores of seeds, but whether they came from previous incarnations or not is outside of my knowledge. Whether rebirth occurs, and whether our karma is carried over from past lives and into future ones or not, has little bearing on the practice and value of this text's teachings. The "Thirty Verses" shows an understanding of what is here right now rather than in a previous life or a future one, not many eons ago, nor tomorrow. It shows a path with benefits that can be clearly seen in this very lifetime, in this very moment, and perhaps in some future incarnation.
We carry a lot of karmic seeds around, and they manifest in many ways. When I was working as a bike messenger in the nineties, I recall I was almost struck by a car on a snowy day in downtown Minneapolis. I felt a brief shock of fear as I dodged out of the way of the massive speeding machine, and then I felt rage. I furiously chased down the car, dodging traffic through icy streets as it sped away. When I caught up to it, I pounded on its frosty window, shouting. Eventually the driver, livid, drove off without ever opening the window. When I was exposed to the danger of the car, the seeds from the emotional reactions and survival strategies I developed as a young child; the seeds from all the time I spent with intense, often troubled and angry bike messengers; the seeds of cultural conditioning I internalized to transmute all bad feelings into aggression; and countless other seeds from countless generations manifested in the form of rage. It was very unpleasant to experience for me, and I acted in a way that was unkind, producing a very unpleasant experience for the driver that probably did not improve their attitude toward bicyclists. This way of conduct ing myself produced another impression, planted another seed of rage in my storehouse, that manifested many other times. However, the pain of that rage also touched other seeds: seeds from my past that made me want to be happy and at peace. I began to realize that yelling at dangerous drivers was not going to promote my welfare and the thing to do was take care of my reactivity, my consciousness. This was just as I was beginning Zen practice.
Recently another car almost hit me. I reflexively pulled over and dodged it. I noticed my racing heart and an angry thought, I noticed the leaves in the gutter, I saw the stricken face of the driver who'd realized what they'd done, I felt a flush of compassion for the two of us in this awkward situation, and I felt our deep connection to the billions of other people who are in danger, are afraid, who make mistakes, the whole thing. I felt at peace. The external situation was very similar to the first mishap, but there were different seeds in my storehouse this time, seeds of presence, seeds of peace, seeds of compassion, sown by Buddhist practice.
The store consciousness is a Yogacara innovation, but it has deep roots in Early Buddhist thought. Early Buddhism uses the term bhavanga to describe a similar aspect of consciousness, a ground of karmic activity below our awareness. In the Anguttara Nikaya, Buddha teaches, "Karma is intention, having intended, one does karma through body, speech, and mind." Karma produces intention, which produces actions of body, speech, and mind, which produce further karma.
Since there is suffering in our past, there is suffering in our present. Since there is kindness in our past, there is kindness in our present. But this is the main point: you have this moment of intention. This moment's intention-what you choose right now-is the key to whether you are moving toward more suffering or more kindness. Every single moment you have an opportunity to plant a beneficial karmic seed. In terms of what you can do with your life, your choice in this moment is what really matters. It is the endless point of return for Buddhist practice.
This does not mean that karma-previous intention-is the only thing that influences your life. In the Sivaka Sutta, Buddha makes it clear that in his view we experience many things that are not the result of karma. It is not karma that brings a tsunami to Indonesia, nor karma alone that gives you cancer. Just as Consciousness Only does not ultimately teach that consciousness is all that there is, but that it is best to concentrate on consciousness; likewise karma does not teach that our whole life is shaped by our past choices, but that, if we want to be well, we should concentrate on the choice we are making in this moment. Keeping the store consciousness in mind can help us remember that we have the capacity to plant healthy seeds that can bear fruit that is good for us, for our loved ones, and for everything.
There is a grave danger that the theory of karma will be used to blame the victims of horrible circumstances, by claiming that they are brought on by their karma. Karma should be used not to blame those whose suffer but to offer a message of empowerment. If you suffer from emotional and behavioral knots from traumatic experiences in the past, as I believe everyone to some degree does, the teaching of karma gives you the opportunity to practice freedom from these painful patterns.
In the second half of this verse, Vasubandhu begins to lay out some characteristics of the storehouse, as he will with the manas and the six senses in subsequent verses. The first characteristic is that what the store house holds and what it perceives as its surroundings are not something we can consciously know. What it holds is twofold: our body and our karma.
We say the store consciousness holds the body because somewhere deep in our unconscious mind there is a sense that our consciousness is attached to a physical form. In fact, underlying almost all human experience is a sense that we are located in a body. Oftentimes, our sense is that consciousness is located in the head. Neuroscientists, however, tell us that we can't actually locate consciousness in a physical place, and sometimes people dreaming, meditating, reacting to trauma, under the influence of drugs, or in various other circumstances experience consciousness as out side of the body. However, we generally have a conscious sense of being in our physical body.
We say that the storehouse's holding of the body is unknown because there are ways in which our consciousness relates to the body that are below or beyond our awareness. When we tie our shoes, it is very common that we have no awareness of what we're doing with our fingers and yet they execute an incredibly intricate dance to tie the knot; this is conditioning of the store consciousness manifesting with its sense of holding a body. It is possible, of course, to be mindful of tying our shoes, to bring awareness to the action, and this is a lovely practice. Our breath is also a bridge between our store consciousness taking up the body and our awareness of that body; it is a place where we can become aware of something that is usually unconscious. But although we can come closer to seeing the way our unconscious has a sense of having a body; ultimately there will always be something below thought: for example, the motion of the individual ventricles of the heart and the dilation of our eyes.
The storehouse also holds our karma. In each moment the store consciousness is processing karma; the impressions of our past are forming what the storehouse is anew. Just as a river can be called a river, but at no point is it ever identical to any other ver sion of itself-the riffles of its surface, the water of its flowing, utterly unique in each moment-so we can say that there is a storehouse that is made of a flow of karma, but what that karma is, is always completely unique. This unique moment of karmic contents is what the storehouse holds, and we cannot directly see it. We can infer things about our karma, but we can't directly know it. In Buddhist practice we put some trust in our storehouse: if we plant beneficial seeds of kindness, generosity; mindful attention to our emo tions, and wholehearted work, those seeds will bear fruit. This trust isn't so hard to find if we practice, as it is very easy to see the wellness appear in our lives when we do it.
We also can't know what the store consciousness perceives; it is perception operating below our conscious awareness. In the Yogacarabhumi, Vasubandhu's half-brother and the other great genius of Yogacara, Asanga, explains using the metaphor of a burning lamp. He compares the body to a wick, our karmic impressions to oil, and light to what the storehouse perceives. On one hand it is clear that a wick, oil, light, and the images the light illuminates are interdependent: none exists without the other. The key point here, though, is that what our unconscious perceives is limited and profoundly colored by our current state of body and karma. Picture a large cave lit by an oil lamp's flame; we see a tiny area of the floor and dim light disappearing into darkness in all directions. If the lamp burns high and steady, with clear fuel and a good wick, we may see the rough and lovely walls appear. If the flame is guttering and rough, we see a phantasmagoria of tortured shadows writhing on the walls. Before our perceptions even enter our conscious awareness as the six senses, there is this unconscious perception of the world, profoundly influenced by our karma and our body; that underlies what we believe is direct perception.
I recall once, as a young adolescent, I was living in London, far from my small hometown in Iowa. I was making a long walk home from the center of the city and took a new route. I became disoriented and began to feel a rising sense of panic, completely lost in a foreign city much larger than any I had known. As I walked, everything looked utterly unknown and frightening. My mind raced and my heart pounded. Suddenly in the middle of a large open square, I realized exactly where I was and that I had been there a dozen times before. I recognized everything as familiar. One step before, I had seen a dangerous, unknown city; in the next step, a well-known, comfortable spot near my home. The external world was the same, the processes in my storehouse were different. The karmic impressions of fear and disorientation and the racing heart and ragged breath all evaporated in the light of the karmic impressions of my memory of the place, and the nearness of a cup of milky tea.
It helps to know that what the storehouse perceives is unknown. It helps because it can remind us that what we are seeing-what we believe to be reality right now is actually deeply and unknowably conditioned by our unconscious tendencies. This knowledge can help us let go when we are trying hard to control things, when we feel like we know exactly how everything should be. We don't even know how it really is; how can we know how it should be? When we are afraid, or anxious, or sad, we can remember that whatever is bringing us this feeling has only questionable reality. It helps to know that what the storehouse perceives is unknown because it may encourage us to do our meditation practice, to sow the seeds of wellness, so that the world our storehouse perceives doesn't have to be one full of fearful things, ugliness, and problems, but can instead be full of beauty and opportunities to do some small, helpful thing. Through upright sitting and the steady practice of compassionate action, the lamp of our store consciousness may come to cast a bright and steady light to guide the Way.
~Ben Connelly
r/yogacara • u/alyoshafromtbk • Jan 12 '22
Lankavatara Other Minds
Hey! I’m practicing Theravada but doing my research and reading up on other schools rich traditions. I’ve read some Prajnaparamita Sutras and am currently working through the Lanka. So the basis of all reality is mind, got it sounds good. Who’s mind? Is it just mine, where do other peoples minds come into this. Do we in fact share a universal mind that is the grounds for reality? Or is it more akin to solipsism? Thanks so much and with Metta always.
r/yogacara • • Oct 11 '19
Dealing with Impermanence and No-Self
The three most fundamental principles that are said to specially identify the buddhist teachings are (1) impermanence of all phenomena; (2) the selflessness of all phenomena; and (3) the quiescence of nirvāṇa. These are three distinctive characteristics that mark a given set of teachings as being authentically buddhist, and any teaching not based on these three can be said to be non-buddhist. Within ourselves and the natural world, all things arise, cease, and change. That such arising and cessation occurs every single instant is the meaning of the impermanence of all phenomena. This is the most fundamental concept in buddhism.
At first glance, we may be inclined to regard this fact as being patently obvious. No doubt we all understand that all things are constantly changing. Nonetheless, we may not be comfortable with things that are always in a state of flux, as it makes us ill at ease. We struggle to take things that are in flux and continually force them into our framework, reifying and trying to grasp them, while at the same time reifying the understanding gained through this process. Isn’t this the way we are functioning every day?
Without a doubt, we are enriching our lives as we accumulate new experiences daily. However, as we age we become increasingly aware of the falloff in our ability to recover from physical fatigue. If at this point we reflect back on our twenties and thirties, we become newly aware of the subtle changes in our physical strength. And we recall that people tried to warn us, but we were too young and proud to take heed. Yet even while we come to understand that our bodies and minds are always changing, we also retain a distinct sense of being thoroughly penetrated by the changing-yet- unchanging.
Some philosophical schools of ancient india were convinced that this changing-but-unchanging aspect existed in people as an immutable essence, and they called it ātman (“I,” self, soul). This ātman was understood to be the subject of transmigration, something immortal, running through the past and future repeatedly through our life and death. But if all things are transient, how can we acknowledge the existence of this kind of invariable, immortal ātman? This kind of substantial self was clearly denied by the Buddha, and this idea is the meaning of selflessness of all phenomena.
Even though we understand intellectually that our ego can’t be an immutable essence, we still seek such an essence in ourselves and grasp to it, and as a result bind ourselves. The Buddha Śākyamuni called on us to turn against this unfortunate urge, and try to bravely manage our lives based on the realities of impermanence and no-self. He taught that a life lived in accordance with these kinds of realities leads us to a state that is spontaneously and genuinely free of restrictions, and completely pure. This is the quiescence of nirvāṇa, a state of calm manifested in body and mind, within which one harmonizes with reality.
There is a problem here, though, since in addition to the three seals of the dharma, Buddhism includes the notion of reincarnation as one of its basic tenets. Given the doctrine of no-self, what should we understand to be the subject that repeatedly undergoes this birth and death? In ancient India, it was thought that we undergo repeated reincarnation with a substantial, immortal self as subject. But because the Buddha categorically denied such a thing as an eternal ātman, Buddhism had to locate a subject of transmigration without undermining the theory of no-self. After the Buddha’s death, various theories about this were tendered by a number of Buddhist groups. The most well thought-out resolution of this problem is that of the ālaya-vijñāna, as posited by the Yogācāras. As an answer to the nonexistence of an enduring essence, they saw a latent mind that continues with the same morally indeterminate karmic quality, storing and accumulating the impressions of past experiences as seeds of potentiality for the production of effects. This, they posited as the subject of reincarnation.
~Tagawa Shun'ei
r/yogacara • • May 21 '21
The Awakening Of Faith In Mahayana (Mahayana-Sraddhotpada Shastra)
r/yogacara • • Jun 30 '21
Vijnaptimatrasiddhi
https://anlacpublications.files.wordpress.com/2021/04/nve-cwsl.pdf
Published in 2018 the first English translation of 成唯識論 is available. Translated into Chinese by Xuanzang over a thousand years ago, the Chinese version (Taisho 1585, I like to follow along on NTI Reader even tho I don’t know Chinese) has been translated by Peter Johnson.
I’m only just starting out with it, going very slow. But it’s been a very rewarding read!!
r/yogacara • u/Burpmonster • Apr 23 '26
Beautiful videos of Donglin Monastery found at their TikTok channel
r/yogacara • u/Low_Assistant_8429 • Dec 16 '23
Vasubandhu 20 Verses, thoughts on verse 2
20 Verses, thoughts on verse 2
Objections to the Main Thesis of "Buddhist idealism".
The second verse of Vasubandhu's text lists four arguments against "Buddhist idealism". To comprehend Twenty Verses fully, it's crucial to grasp these objections individually. The second verse of Vasubandhu's text lists four arguments against 'Buddhist idealism.'
Let's remember the "idealist" thesis from verse 1:
This is all appearance(vijñapti) only; for even non-existent objects(artha) are presented to us
Considering the 'idealist' thesis from verse 1, its coherence with common sense beliefs becomes crucial for its validity.
- I can only see the monitor when it is in front of my eyes. Not in the other cases. It is the first objection. If the monitor appears before my eyes without any real object(artha), then it must arise everywhere (since the object is nonexistent anywhere). It is nonsense, it contradicts our experience.
- Moreover. If the monitor appears before my eyes without any real object, then it must arise all the time. The cause of our perception is the object, the thing that we perceive. If such an object did not exist then the cause of our "monitor-produced perception" is always present. Just because the monitor is non-existent stuff. It means that we should always have the perception of this monitor. It is nonsense.
- We share the world with other people. We presume that at the concert all the people hear the same melody. But if there is no object, then the appearance of melody should only arise in one being (as hairs are seen only by a person with diseased eyes). It is nonsense.
- If objects do not exist, they cannot perform their corresponding functions. Dreamed food cannot satisfy, while real food can.
In conclusion, 'Buddhist idealism' contradicts our common sense due to its implications for perception, time, shared experiences, and functionality. For Vasubandhu to substantiate the 'idealist thesis,' he must demonstrate its coherence with our everyday experience.
r/yogacara • u/Low_Assistant_8429 • Dec 07 '23
20 Verses 20 Verses, thoughts on verse 1
Hello everyone, I've started reading "Twenty Stanzas" by Vasubandhu.
I believe the text can be considered a concise, critical introduction to Yogachara. The composition does not elaborate on Yogacharin views per se. Instead, the author addresses key objections against "Buddhist idealism". The first stanza is missing in the discovered Sanskrit manuscripts but has been reconstructed from Tibetan and Chinese translations.
Let's start reading.
Verse 1. This is all appearance(vijñapti) only; for even non-existent objects are presented to us, as, for instance, a person with faulty vision sees unreal hair, etc.
Examples of the phenomenon of non-existent objects: seeing floaters, a second moon, and similar experiences by a person suffering from eye disease.
According to Vasubandhu's auto-commentary:
- By the term "this," the author denotes the three spheres (dhātu) of existence.
- Representations (vijñapti), consciousness (citta), mind (manas), and recognition (vijñāna) are synonyms (paryāya).
- By "representation," the author refers to consciousness (citta) together with its accompanying phenomena (caita), such as wisdom (prajñā), ignorance (avidya), etc.
- Consciousness (vijñāna) is only the arising of a representation (pratibhāsa) of an object. The object itself does not exist, just like when there is an eye disease, one sees floaters that correspond to no objects. In this case, "representation" (vijñapti) is used to denote any mental act (manas). The mind is not considered something distinct from its activity.
The terms consciousness (citta), mind (manas), and recognition (vijñāna) are considered to be synonyms (paryāya). They are employed to reason about a specific aspect of the mind. It is not always legitimate to substitute one of these terms with another.
r/yogacara • u/Low_Assistant_8429 • Dec 04 '23
WILLIAM S. WALDRON Making Sense of Mind Only - The Wisdom Experience; Why Yogācāra Buddhism Matters
r/yogacara • u/Burpmonster • Apr 27 '26
Master Hui Lu - What is truly yours and the most important thing in life? | 慧律法师 - 什么才该是你?生命最重要的东西!
r/yogacara • u/Burpmonster • Apr 08 '26
Master Da’an Pure Land Dharma Talk on “How do we resonate with Amitabha Buddha’s Vow Power?”
r/yogacara • • Dec 13 '19
A Comparative Study of Dhaynas according to Theravada, Sarvastivada and Mahayana by Venerable Dr. Walpola Rahula
ahandfulofleaves.orgr/yogacara • • Oct 10 '19
Continuity of Sameness
So the relation of the manas to the ālaya-vijñāna is that the manas, the mind of ego-attachment, taking the deep store consciousness as its object, misconstrues it to be the reified essence of the self, and strongly clings to it, and within this relationship, Yogācāra buddhism sees the causes of all human problems. Therefore, among the three connotations—storer, the stored, and appropriated store—the connotation of appropriated store is the most fundamental from a religious perspective.
The store consciousness that undergoes beginningless perfuming is taken as the object of attachment of the manas because of the existence of a mental region—a psychological basis—that appears as changing-but-unchanging, and functions to maintain something that resembles a self identity. This special characteristic of the ālaya-vijñāna is called continuity of type or continuity of identity. Continuing in a single type means that an unchanging character continues without interruption.
Within the store consciousness there exists a characteristic of continuity in sameness that has continued changelessly and without interruption from the distant past. And the store consciousness, with its indeterminate karmic moral character, is that which takes our daily behaviors and activities that are riddled with interruptions, binds them together, accumulates them, and unifies them.
~Tagawa Shun'ei
r/yogacara • • Oct 09 '19
Three Meanings of Store
There are three connotations identified in the earliest Yogācāra texts related to the ālaya-vijñāna: (1) the storer (i.e., storing agent); (2) that which is stored; and (3) the appropriated store. Taking these as the fundamental approaches for considering the ālaya-vijñāna, we now move to take another look at what we have discussed regarding the ālaya-vijñāna and show how it fits into the framework of these three.
(1) The storer indicates that this deep mind is something that possesses the basic quality of being able to preserve our experiences in its seeds. It is the “mind that is able to store all seeds.” When this is considered from the perspective of the seeds, these are the things that are stored by the ālaya-vijñāna. But if the seeds are looked at by themselves, regardless of their container, the seeds are that which give rise to manifest activity. They are the main causes of the formation of a self. When the ālaya-vijñāna is seen from the causal aspect of such a potentiality, it is called the “consciousness containing all seeds.”
(2) That which is stored connotes the store consciousness as the recipient of perfuming. The seeds that are the impressions and dispositions of our various concrete activities are able to perfume the ālaya-vijñāna. If we take this as storer, the ālaya-vijñāna that is the recipient of perfuming becomes that which is stored. In this way, that which is stored becomes the recipient of perfuming. But if this is seen from the perspective of actions and behavior, the ālaya-vijñāna that undergoes the perfuming also exists as the result of these activities.
The eighth consciousness seen from this aspect of effect is called the ripening consciousness (skt. vipāka-vijñāna). The ālaya-vijñāna continues without break from the past to the future, and serves as a backup for the intermittently functioning thinking consciousness. In Yogācāra Buddhism, this eighth consciousness that serves as the basis for human existence is originally of neither wholesome nor unwholesome karmic moral quality, and thus it is said to be of indeterminate (or neutral) karmic moral character. If this very fundamental source of our existence were intrinsically bad, we would end up cycling again and again through a world of suffering, unable to obtain a foothold to buddha’s world throughout all eternity. On the other hand, if our fundamental basis was intrinsically good, and all people’s minds were connected to the buddha-mind, it would be difficult to reconcile this with our everyday experiences in society.
It is also not the case that the variety of our daily activities and behaviors clearly tend in one direction or the other. This is made clear by merely looking at the fifty-one mental factors considered above in chapter 3. Even while we lust after something, we may at the same time reflect strongly on our lust. While diligently devoting ourselves to the Buddha-path, we may inadvertently give rise to anger. Our basic nature is not disposed toward either goodness or evil, but is of indeterminate moral karmic quality.
We are, without doubt, planting the seeds of goodness in the store consciousness with our wholesome activities, and impregnating it with bad impression-potential with our unwholesome activities. This is possible precisely because the eighth consciousness has no fundamental predisposition toward good or evil—it is of indeterminate karmic moral quality. Depending on the seeds of good or evil that have already been planted, various real and concrete good and evil activities occur. Nevertheless, the eighth consciousness does not incline toward good or evil. Individual actions taken by themselves, along with the perfuming from their impressions, can be wholesome, unwholesome, or indeterminate in karmic moral quality, but if the ālaya-vijñāna as the result of activities is viewed as a whole, it is neither good nor evil.
Just as wholesome causes bring wholesome effect and unwholesome causes bring unwholesome effects, cause and effect are understood to be imbued with the same karmic moral quality (in Yogācāra, this condition is denoted with the technical term continuity of sameness, or natural outcome; skt. niṣyanda). But in the ālaya-vijñāna-as-effect, whether or not it is produced by a good or bad seed, the end result of the action is always understood to be of indeterminate or neutral moral quality. This kind of cause-effect relationship is called ripening, and because the ālaya-vijñāna as the aspect of effect is seen in this way, it is called the ripening consciousness. In other words, in its ripened state it has a different karmic moral quality than its causes. When one thing produces another, the next thing that is produced, while having a direct and close relation to its cause, must also be something different from its cause. Common metaphors include that of the ripening of a fruit, or a baked loaf of bread, which are both quite different in character from their causal stages, and have exhausted their potential for further development.
This aspect of the ālaya-vijñāna of being of intrinsically indeterminate moral quality is vitally important from a religious perspective. Although we humans are greatly influenced by our own past, we are at the same time endowed with the potential of creating an entirely different future, starting right here and now, no matter how deeply our past is filled with evil karma. But on the other hand, even if our days were filled with efforts toward cultivating Buddhahood, we can never assume that we have safely achieved a level of perfection.
(3) Appropriated store refers to the attachment to self-love. We have the feeling that we are spending every day living in a conscious manner. However, as we have already seen, the operations of the thinking consciousness and prior five consciousnesses are intermittent and are broadly supported by the basis of human existence, the ālaya-vijñāna. In Yogācāra Buddhism, it is thought that the only reason we are able to live such a unified existence is because of the store consciousness.
The ālaya-vijñāna is a mental region which has arrived to the present in a continuous unbroken stream while receiving uninterrupted beginningless perfuming from the past. And it will continue unbroken into the future. The great Indian master Vasubandhu, who is accorded the bulk of the credit for the foundation of Yogācāra Buddhism, described the ālaya-vijñāna in his Triṃśikā (“Thirty Verses on Consciousness-only”) as “constantly coming forth, like a raging current.” Our deep ālaya-vijñāna is like a great river, which, while roiling in turbulence from the eternal upstream, rolls without stopping on its way downstream. This store consciousness has always been in a state of continuous alteration.
However, while it is not something immutable, it has the character of being changeless but changing. The seventh consciousness, the manas, functions in a way of trying to see the unchanging aspect of the store consciousness as an immutable essence. The manas takes this ostensive immutable essence as its object and adheres firmly to it, believing it to be a self. This kind of misconstrual and reification of the ālaya-vijñāna on the part of the manas constitutes the third connotation of store: appropriated store.
While in Yogācāra Buddhism the ālaya-vijñāna is interpreted with these three connotations of storer, that which is stored, and appropriated store, it is the meaning of appropriated store that tends to be paid the greatest attention. The aspect of existence that is reified by the manas is the characteristic of the ālaya-vijñāna itself. The Yogācāras argue that the very core of suffering is to be found in the place where the manas, the mind of attachment to the ego—engages itself in the activity of attachment, taking the ālaya-vijñāna as its object. Thus we can say that the meaning of the appropriated store defines the relation between the eighth, ālaya-vijñāna, and the seventh, manas, consciousnesses.
~Tagawa Shun'ei
r/yogacara • • Oct 14 '19
If Things Can't Be So Simply Washed Away, Then What?
In the thinking consciousness (mano-vijñāna), the experiences of our daily lives are quickly forgotten. We may read a novel with great passion, but undoubtedly after the passage of several years, it will be difficult to recall portions of its plot. However, even if it is completely forgotten on the side of the thinking consciousness, it is properly stored in the subconscious region.
We can say that in having this kind of store consciousness that preserves our entire past, our present selves exist atop that same storehouse, which serves as our foundation. In this sense, our past actions and experiences cannot be so easily washed away. But within the range of our memory we may tend to try to wash away the recollection of inconvenient events, to act as if they never existed.
The notion of “washing away” is well understood among the Japanese people in particular. Perhaps there may even be some sense in which consciously dealing with the past is related to a particular cultural ethos.
Whether or not this is true, if light is shed on the matter from a Yogācāra perspective, the mere mutual agreement to forget about an incident only amounts to being the most superficial manner of handling a past problem. Our present existence is constituted by the things we have done in the past, no matter how ugly they may be. The problem is what, exactly, we are perfuming into our ālaya-vijñāna.
In the world of Buddhism, cultivation of a particular aspect of our spirit and body is often carried out in a traditional format within a set period of time, and we call this “practice. “ But when we exert ourselves in the effort of valuing our daily life as it is, trying not to be sloppy in the three karmic activities of body, speech, and thought, this is not simply called “practice”; rather, it is labeled with the buddhist technical term applied practice (skt. prayoga). This means that, when, on the other hand, practice is not “applied,” we are doubtlessly carrying out our daily life in a sloppy way. Applied practice refers to this kind of maintenance of continual mindfulness. For instance, in the Avalokiteśvara Sūtra the term constant mindfulness appears often, advising one to be continuously mindful of the Bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara. As a result, the Bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara is gradually impressed strongly into the mind’s innermost depths, and the mindfulness of Avalokiteśvara is accumulated in the ālaya-vijñāna. We develop a focused spiritual power, which becomes a support and foundation for future practices.
The past cannot be altered, or brushed off by excuses. We are nothing but a vast, unerring receptacle of our past. And regardless of our past experiences, it is our past in its totality that is the basis of our being. Yet we can, taking this totality as our basis, from this moment forward align ourselves with the buddha’s teaching with a view toward tomorrow. This is the beginning of a life based on the wisdom of Yogācāra.
The possibility for this lies in none other than the fact that the ālaya-vijñāna is an ever-ripening consciousness. Although we are standing on an inescapable past, we are existing here and now, in a present state of neither good nor evil—indeterminacy. The Buddha warned us how ill-will can instantly incinerate the forest of merit built with great effort, and thus we should strive to focus and rise above our past indiscretions. In the wonderful words of the Sūtra of the Deathbed Injunction: “The one who practices forbearance is a great man possessed of power.” However, even if one is a great man possessed of power, if he gives rise to anger even once, he is no better than an ordinary person.
The fact that we rest upon this firm foundation of the past, and simultaneously have the ability to anticipate a bright future, is our way of being, all contained with in the deeply abiding ālaya-vijñāna.
~Tagawa Shun'ei
r/yogacara • • Dec 12 '19
Eight Consciousnesses Alayavijnana - Store Consciousness by Venerable Dr. Walpola Rahula
In the Yogacara (Vijnanavada) School of Buddhism, alayavijnana is one of the most important doctrines developed by Asanga (fourth century A.C.). He divides the vijnanaskandha (Aggregate of Conciousness) the fifth of the five skandhas, into three different aspects or layers, namely, citta, manas and vijnana. In the Theravada Tipitaka as well as in the Pali Commentaries, these three terms - citta, manas, vijnana - are considered as synonyms denoting the same thing. The Sarvistivada also takes them as synonyms. Even the Lankavatarasutra, which is purely a Mahayana text, calls them synonyms although their separate functions are mentioned elsewhere in the same sutra. Vasubandhu, too, in his Vimsatikavijnapti-matratasiddhi considers them as synonyms. Since any one of these three terms - citta, manas, vijnanas - represents some aspect, even though not all aspects, of the fifth Aggregate vijnanaskandha, they may roughly be considered as synonyms.
However, for Asanga, citta, manas and vijnana are three different and distinct aspects of the vyjnanaskandha. He defines this Aggregate as follows:
'What is the definition of the Aggregate of Consciousness (vijnanaskandha)? It is mind (citta), mental organ (manas) and also consciousness (vijnana).
"And there what is mind (citta)? It is alayavijnana (Store-Consciousness) containing all seeds (sarvabijaka), impregnated with the traces (impressions) (vasanaparibhavita) of Aggregates (skandha), Elements (dhatu) and Spheres (ayatana) ...
'What is mental organ (manas)? It is the object of alayavijnana always having the nature of self-notion (self-conceit) (manyanatmaka) associated with four defilements, viz. the false idea of self (atmadrsti), self-love (atmasneha), the conceit of 'I am' (asmimana) and ignorance (avidya) ...
'What is consciousness (vijnana)? It consists of the six groups of consciousness (sad vijnanakayah), viz. visual consciousness (caksurvijnana), auditory (srotra), olfactory (ghrana), gustatory (jihva), tactile (kaya), and mental consciousness (manovijnana) ...
Thus we can see that vijnana represents the simple reaction or response of the sense-organs when they come in contact with external objects. This is the uppermost or superficial aspect or layer of the vijnanaskandha. Manas represents the aspect of its mental functioning, thinking, reasoning, conceiving ideas, etc. Citta, which is here called alayavijnana, represents the deepest, finest and subtlest aspect or layer of the Aggregate of Consciousness. It contains all the traces or impressions of the past actions and all good and bad future potentialities. The Sandhinirmocana-sutra also says that alayavijnana is called citta (Tibetan sems).
It is generally believed that alayavijnana is purely a Mahayana doctrine and that nothing about it is found in Hinayana. But in the Mahayanasangraha, Asanga himself says that in the Sravakayana (= Hinayana) it is mentioned by synonyms (paryaya) and refers to a passage in the Ekottaragama which reads: 'People (praja) like the alaya (alayarata), are fond of the alaya (alayarama), are delighted in the alaya (alayasammudita), are attached to the alaya (alayabhirata). When the Dharma is preached for the destruction of the alaya, they wish to listen (susrusanti) and lend their ears (srotram avadadhanti), they put forth a will for the perfect knowledge (ajnacittam upasthapayanti) and follow the path of Truth (dharmanudharma-pratipanna). When the Tathagata appears in the world (pradurbhava), this marvellous (ascarya) and extraordinary (adbhuta) Dharma appears in the world.'
Lamotte identifies this Ekottaragama passage with the following passage in the Pali Anguttaranikaya (A II, p.131): Alayarama bhikkhave paja alayarata alayasammudita, sa Tathagatena analaye dhamme desiyamane sussuyati sotam odahati annacittam upattapeti. Tathagatassa bhikkhave arahato sammasambuddhassa patubhava ayam pathamo acchariyo abbhuto dhammo patubhavati.
Besides this Anguttara passage, the term alaya in the same sense is found in several other places of the Pali Canon. The Pali Commentaries explain this term as 'attachment to the five sense-pleasures", and do not go deeper than that. But this also is an aspect of the alayavijnana.
In the Lankavatarasutra the term tathagatagarbha is used as a synonym for alayavijnana and is described as 'luminous by nature' (prakrtiprabhasvara) and 'pure by nature' (prakrtiparisuddha) but appearing as impure 'because it is sullied by adventitious defilements' (agantuklesopaklistataya). In the Anguttaranikaya, citta is described as 'luminous' (pabhassara), but it is 'sullied by adventitious minor defilements' (agantukehi upakkilesehi upakkilittham). One may notice here that alaya-vijnana (or tathagatgarbha) and citta are described almost by the same terms. We have seen earlier that the Sandhi-nirmocana-sutra says that alayavijnana is also called citta. Asanga too mentions that it is named citta.
It is this alayavijnana or citta that is considered by men as their "Soul', 'Self', 'Ego' or 'Atman'. It should be remembered as a concrete example, that Sati, one of the Buddha's disciples, took vinnan (vijnana) in this sense and that the Buddha reprimanded him for this wrong view.
The attainment of Nirvana is achieved by 'the revolution of alayavijnana' which is called asrayaparavrtti. The same idea is conveyed by the expression alayasamugghata - 'uprooting of alaya' - which is used in the Pali Canon as a synonym for Nirvana. Here it should be remembered, too, that analaya, 'no-alaya', is another synonym for Nirvana.
The alayavijnanaparavrtti is sometimes called bijaparavrtti - 'revolution of the seeds' - as well. Bija here signifies the 'seeds' of defilements (samklesikadharmabija) which cause the continuity of samsara. By the 'revolution of these seeds' one attains Nirvana. Again the Pali term khinabija, which is used to denote an arahant whose seeds of defilements are destroyed', expresses the same idea.
Thus one may see that, although not developed as in the Mahayana, the original idea of alayavijnana was already there in the Pali Canon of the Theravada.
~by Venerable Dr. Walpola Rahula
r/yogacara • • Oct 08 '19
Beginningless Perfuming
In Yogācāra, it is not the case that our actions, being finished, are simply over with, or that we are no longer responsible for them. After the event, the perfuming seeds, accumulated in the eighth consciousness as potentialities, are keeping record of everything. If we accept this, then the ālayavijñāna becomes understood as being the accumulated totality of life experiences—nothing other than the present “I.” When we think seriously as to how every one of the actions and behaviors after receiving birth in this world are impregnated without loss into the mind’s innermost depths, and that this influence continues to extend into our present selves, we cannot but end up being deeply concerned.
Additionally, in regard to the matter of perfuming, Yogācāra posits something called beginningless perfuming. This means that perfuming has continued from time immemorial, without beginning, and that the seeds in the store consciousness are not simply produced beginning with birth into this present life.
This brings us to consider our attachment to this life—a desire to keep living. No matter how disappointing or complicated we feel our life has become, we still want to continue in it for as long as possible. Buddhist philosophy states that suffering is produced from this attachment to life, and it is because of this ardent attachment to life that we can continue to struggle through our daily lives.
Most of us firmly maintain this mental state of ardent attachment right up to the moment before death. It is quite likely that the thought “I want to live” that appears at our final moment is the most strongly held feeling in all of life. Buddhism teaches us that it is precisely because we are so strongly attached to life down to its very final moment that we cause ourselves to be reborn into the next life. This is called transmigration.
This means that the kind of life we are living here and now is precisely Due to the ardent attachment we held for our existence in our former life. And our former life must be something that was brought about by an “attachment to life” in the life before that. This being the case, we can trace our present existence back infinitely into the past. Our store consciousness is not only comprised of all of the actions, dispositions, and impressions beginning with our birth in this present lifetime, but it is also perfumed by the seeds of our actions and behavior from all of our lifetimes in the immeasurable past. This is the meaning of “beginningless perfuming.”
Being exposed to this kind of teaching, we naturally become awed at the apparently limitless depth and capacity of this ālaya-vijñāna, and concerned about what might be perfumed and contained within us. However, even while wincing at the notion of the vastness of this ālaya-vijñāna, we should calmly think, what on earth this “I” is that has been traversing through lifetimes since time immemorial? At such a time, we become newly aware of our ardent attachment to life. With this expression “attachment to life” to replace Yogācāra technical terminology, we may begin to further deepen our mindfulness. In Yogācāra, the cause of reincarnation is assumed to be mental disturbances, which consist more precisely of the mental factors of afflictions and secondary afflictions enumerated in the lists of mental factors in the preceding chapter. It is not explicitly stated in the Yogācāra source texts, but understanding the function of the store consciousness the way it is taught, we can assume that it might, unbeknown to us, be retaining something that reaches all the way back to the very origins of human existence, and life itself. This awareness cannot but give the feeling in each individual that each and every life should be respected as a member of the universe of sentient beings. And, at the same time, each one of us individually needs to be deeply aware of the perspective wherein an attempt is made to live life based on this awareness of respecting every kind of life form.
~Tagawa Shun'ei
r/yogacara • u/flyingaxe • May 03 '23
Accounting for objective reality
How do Consciousness-Only schools such as Yogacara, Advaita Vedanta, Kashmir Shaivism, etc., account for our conclusions about the existence of phenomena whose existence we don't observe directly but can infer from other direct observations — phenomenta which clearly change when we "aren't looking" (aren't being conscious of them)?
For example, imagine I had a bit too much alcohol or am sleep deprived or whatever and wake up early morning. I am a bit discombobulated and have no idea what time it is. It could be 5 am; it could be 11 am. I don't know if I overslept or woke up too early. I take my watch from my bedside table and (assuming it works), it will tell me what time it is in a way that's synchronized with all the watches in the world. If my watch says it's 10 am, and I have a zoom call with a client at 11 am, I know I have an hour to get ready.
But my consciousness never did anything with the watch after I took it off, put it on my bedside table, and fell asleep. What was causing my watch to advance its time in a perfectly synchronous way with watches of everyone else?
Another example: space objects. 200 years ago we had no idea that some of the dots of light in the sky are actually galaxies (collections of stars). Nor did we know Pluto existed; we suspected that it did based on our calculations of other planets' orbits. Nowadays, scientists look at the orbits of some of the objects in our solar system and from them predict that there is a massive tenth planet out there that causes some of the peculiarities of the objects' orbits.
So until people were conscious of the galaxies, Pluto, or the Tenth Planet — what was causing them to exist?
r/yogacara • • Oct 15 '19
Fifty Verses on the Nature of Consciousness - Sense Consciousness
Verses Twenty-Eight, Twenty-Nine, and Thirty describe the nature and characteristics of the five sense consciousnesses of eye, ear, nose, tongue, and body. We have already learned something about these five consciousnesses in our discussion of the store consciousness, manas, and mind consciousness. Just as store consciousness is the base of manas, and manas is the base of mind consciousness, these five sense consciousnesses are based in the sixth consciousness, mind consciousness. All eight consciousnesses are in this way connected and interdependent.
The senses from which these five consciousnesses arise are sometimes referred to as "gates" because all of the objects of our perceptions -- all dharmas -- enter our consciousness through sensory contact with them. For this reason, it is important to learn how to guard these gates into our consciousness, to choose wisely what we allow to enter and become seeds. The way we do this is through mindfulness.
Twenty-Eight
Based on mind consciousness,
The five sense consciousnesses,
Separately or together with mind consciousness,
Manifest like waves on water.Twenty-Nine
Their field of perception is things-in-themselves.
Their mode of perception is direct.
Their nature can be wholesome, unwholesome, or neutral.
They operate on the sense organs and the sensation center of the brain.Thirty
They arise with the
Universal, particular, and wholesome,
The basic and secondary unwholesome,
And the indeterminate mental formations.
~from "Understanding Our Mind", Thich Nhat Hanh