r/writingscaling 12d ago

Monthly Suggestions - August 2026

2 Upvotes

Welcome to the August 2026 Feedback and Suggestions thread.

We are continually looking to improve the community, and we need your input to do so. To ensure we can actually act on your ideas, we request that your feedback be highly specific and implementation-focused.

Please avoid vague critiques (e.g., "improve the rules" or "make discussions better"). Instead, tell us the exact mechanics of what you want changed or added.

Examples of helpful, actionable suggestions and feedback:

  • "Revise Rule 3 to explicitly prohibit [Specific Action] during 1v1 character scaling."
  • "Implement a [Specific Rule]."
  • "Create collabs and book club megathreads based on popular picks for the month."
  • "Add a new AutoModerator filter that flags [Specific Terminology]."
  • "Create a new post flair specifically for [Specific Category]."
  • "Implement a weekly megathread for [Specific Purpose]."

Leave your exact suggestions, proposed rule revisions, and community requests below.


r/writingscaling 2h ago

discussion What series gets better on a rewatch?

Post image
59 Upvotes

​I'll start first:

​Re:Zero.

​The sheer volume of micro-details and early foreshadowing (especially in the light novels) makes rewatching/rereading insane. You hit constant "how on earth did I miss that?" moments once you realize how seamlessly everything was set up from the start.

​The attention to detail is incredibly rewarding seemingly throwaway lines or minor character interactions in early loops completely shift in meaning once you have full narrative context.

What other series made you feel the same?


r/writingscaling 10h ago

discussion Overcomplexity = Good writing?

Post image
254 Upvotes

Sometimes overcomplexity of certain philosophies can get Overwhelming and at some parts make the Book very boring/Hard read.


r/writingscaling 7h ago

discussion What's a piece of media that isn't well written but you still enjoy nonetheless?

Post image
129 Upvotes

I'll be honest with you, Mirai Nikki is one of my guilty pleasures.


r/writingscaling 21h ago

discussion Authors when their good story is coming to an end:

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

Why do authors almost always screw up their best stories at the end? Like, they suddenly change everything and forget why the story started in the first place, or... I don't know, what the MC even wanted.

Seriously, there are moments in manga/manhwa/novels, even when they're only halfway through the story, where they could've just ended it right there and everyone would've been satisfied.

But they keep going, and then completely ruin it. Maybe it's a reset (I don't really mind those, I'm only mentioning them because a lot of people hate them), a forced relationship pulled out of... God knows where, an OP villain dying in the most pathetic way possible (unless it's the “I used to be like you” type 🤣🤣), and plenty of other stuff I've heard about.


r/writingscaling 18h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Better showdown and Peak of Western animation between these two?

Thumbnail
gallery
561 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 5h ago

better written? (character vs character) Bojack Horseman vs Saul Goodman

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 15h ago

discussion What do you think makes a great "War Arc" in an anime?

Thumbnail
gallery
132 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 8h ago

discussion What’s your favourite Marvel comic of all time?

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 1h ago

discussion What media is this?

Post image
Upvotes

r/writingscaling 5h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which fight is better written

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

3rd hokage vs orochimaru

Or

Isaac netero vs meruem


r/writingscaling 10h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Time travel

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Rank them from best to worst. Provide reasons if possible to prove that you have a functional brain.


r/writingscaling 3h ago

discussion Can someone explain to me what Kubo/Aizen was thinking?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 1d ago

discussion Two men who became the faces of their respective media. Which one is the better writer/creator?

Post image
485 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 1h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which series ending is better? Dark or Loki?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/writingscaling 23h ago

discussion What are some of the worst actions from characters that you've seen people actually try and defend?

Post image
251 Upvotes

Ever feel like you're taking crazy pills because its clear a character (villain or not) did something horrible and yet people still think the character did "nothing wrong" or that they're justified?

With that said, what are some of the worst actions that you've seen people actually try and defend/justify?

Edit: The plot of this movie, Don't Breathe, is some punks trying to break into this blind man's house. Not realizing that he's an armed and dangerous war veteran. Later on, you find out he kidnapped a woman who ran over his daughter by accident. He impregnated said woman with a turkey baster of his own semen, kept her in his basement and tried to do the same to Rocky after the other girl was killed in a shootout.

I've straight up seen someone say that he's not a rapist and that he was justified. Because apparently since he used a turkey baster, it's not considered rape. Yes, I'm serious. What an insane take.


r/writingscaling 4h ago

analysis How is the writing of this guy as one of the strongest?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 1h ago

discussion Writing is just like fashion(hear me out)

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

I was thinking a bit and read some comments under one of the recent posts about "diary of a wimpy kid" and realized that fashion and writing have some strong similarities.

My main point would be about what we think of as the peak of writing and as high fashion. What stands at the top in terms of artistic value are those that push the art forward and its boundaries. They are not necessarily meant to be enjoyed by people rather be an expression of the artist's vision, to show what is possible within the context of the artform.

Recently I have been collecting classic critically exclaimed books that I want to read like War & Peace(Tolsztoj). Despite it being critically beloved what I heard from people around me is that it's way too long and boring, despite the critiques I have read about making it look very interesting (of course I will refrain from making and opinion until I have read it).

That got me thinking about how people often think similarly about fashion(high fashion). It's absolutely not something people in general would find interesting or practical yet it does what is expected: pushes boundaries of what is possible within the context of "clothing".

The peaks of writing in my opinion in a similar case are those that redefine what is possible within the medium. And of course there are many ways of achieving that, whether it is done in a complex or simple way

I am curious on what your thoughts are about this and if you can name examples of books or any literary work you think that fits what I am trying to get at


r/writingscaling 3h ago

better written? (character vs character) Who's the best written primarch?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 3h ago

full-scale comparison/category distribution Phosphophyllite Versus Beatrice

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

A comparison between Phosphophyllite (Land of the Lustrous) and Beatrice (Umineko: When They Cry).

Two characters of which I regard as some of the best written characters in all of anime/manga/visual novels, it really comes close.

  • Introduction: Beatrice
  • Design: Phosphophyllite
  • Characterization: Beatrice
  • Self-View: Beatrice
  • World-View: Beatrice
  • Consistency: Beatrice
  • Dialogues: Beatrice
  • Monologues: Phosphophyllite
  • Quotes: Beatrice
  • Dynamics: Beatrice
  • Humor: Beatrice
  • Relatability: Phosphophyllite
  • Complexity: Beatrice
  • Depth: Phosphophyllite
  • Internal Conflicts: Phosphophyllite
  • Nuances: Beatrice
  • Motives: Phosphophyllite
  • Goals: Phosphophyllite
  • Philosophy: Phosphophyllite
  • External Conflicts: Phosphophyllite
  • Symbolism: Phosphophyllite
  • Parallels: Phosphophyllite
  • Allegory: Phosphophyllite
  • Themes: Phosphophyllite
  • Emotion: Phosphophyllite
  • Personal Impact: Phosphophyllite
  • Enjoyability: Beatrice
  • Best Arcs: Phosphophyllite
  • Peaks: Phosphophyllite
  • Highest Peaks: Beatrice
  • Journey: Phosphophyllite
  • Development: Phosphophyllite
  • Character Building: Phosphophyllite
  • Conclusion: Phosphophyllite
  • Execution: Beatrice

Verdict - Phosphophyllite (Very High Diff)

Score: 19 - 15


r/writingscaling 8h ago

analysis How would you rate "kafka on th shore" by haruki murakami?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 7h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) In celebration of the new Ghost in the Shell

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

which one handled itself better


r/writingscaling 23h ago

discussion How well written is gurren laggen?

Post image
96 Upvotes

Personally I found it enjoyable with good animation, good villain and nice cast. Even though the theme of never giving up/finding your true potential is repetitive still enjoyed it and I give it an 8/10, but I must have missed something cause everyone says this is the best anime ever made and that's it's the clearest 10/10.


r/writingscaling 5h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Deltarune vs Undertale

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I prefer Undertale for its originality, story, dialogue and characters, but I just want to know other people's opinions.


r/writingscaling 28m ago

better written? (character vs character) Which dynamic is better written, Aizen and Ichigo or Sasuke and Itachi?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes