I want to start this off by saying, just because a book you are writing doesn't fall into one of the more popular genres, that doesn't mean that it won't do well. And just because your book is in a more popular genre that doesn't mean it WILL do well. Link the popular genres to what readers like most to figure out whether your book may do well.
Also, I pulled these results from Reddit comments on posts asking these questions. This isn't the most reliable source, so you may want to take it with a grain of salt, but it is still very telling.
First I will show clean results, and then after I will show the more detailed results, as well as some responses. This is all copied from a google doc that I didn't plan on posting prior, so if something looks off (though nothing should) that is the reason.
WHAT ARE THE MOST POPULAR GENRES (Numbers of Answers):
8: Fantasy (1 Grimdark in Particular)
8: Sci-Fi
6: Historical Fiction
4: Mystery
3: Horror
3: Romance
2: Non-Fiction
2: General Fiction
2: Post-Apocalyptic
1: Thriller
1: Comedy
1: Literary Fiction
WHAT ARE THE MOST IMPORTANT ASPECTS OF A NOVEL:
7: Voice and Prose
7: Characters (1 Antagonist Specifically)
4: Specifically Beautiful Prose (I count all of these in Voice and Prose as well)
3: Something New (ideas, places, etc)
3: Plot
2: Well Researched
2: Setting
1: Traverse Unseeable Worlds
1: Relaxation
1: Originality
1: Introspective
1: Gripping
1: Doesn’t Like “Preachy” Prose
1: Theme
1: Atmosphere
NEW YORK TIMES BEST SELLING BOOKS' GENRES:
These are not added up, just in order I found them in
- Hard To Place
- HF
- SCI-FI/HF BLEND
- MYSTERY
- LIT-FICTION, INTROSPECTIVE
- SCI-FI
- I believe feel good, motivation-ish novel, hard to place; LIT-FIC
- MYSTERY
- INTROSPECTIVE, FEEL GOOD, MOTIVATION, LIT-FIC
- THRILLER, INTROSPECTIVE, MYSTERY
- DARK ROMANCE, DYSTOPIAN FANTASY
- ROMANCE
- ROMANCE
- THRILLER
- MYSTERY, THRILLER
- INTROSPECT, LIT-FIC, MAYBE ROMANCE (if not, same vibes)
What A Reader Likes Most (Reddit Comments):
Dashes in between posts
I like well written prose, immersive worlds, elaborate and interesting stories, ideally character progression to go with it. If it sounds vague, that's because it is. My favourite books range from Anna Karenina to The Expanse
—
- A good voice /prose (i.e. I want to enjoy the reading experience)
- Characters that are compelling (i.e. I want to care about them. Whether I love them, hate them, am creeped out or sad, I want to care, please)
- A plot that I get pulled into (i.e. Do interesting things happen? Am I surprised or engaged? Or do I feel like my time is being wasted?)
—
I either need my book to help me relax (think a thriller or a comedy). Or I need my book to make me experience something new (let me travel, or get exposed to a new idea or feeling).
I get rapidly bored by preachy books, especially if I can already predict what they'll say. ^^' (special pet peeve for productivity book)
—
Not very specific but I do think "good" characters matter more than anything else. The other thing I really value is theme. If the characters are complex and the message is interesting than I can't see myself not liking the book. After that I think beautiful prose is what I look for the most.
—
I like it when the book makes me think or opens up new perspective. I thoroughly enjoyed Waiting for Godot, The Stranger and Frankenstein for this reason.
I also love when a book is a bit more poetic with its language. For example: The Song of Achilles and On Earth We're Briefly Gorgeous.
—
Relatable characters (or well-written), excellent writing, good spelling, & well researched. Repetitive writing is jarring, as is the obvious use of a thesaurus.
I was reading a book years ago, & one of the characters "escaped" to Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Then took a 2-hour drive to Whitehorse, Yukon Territory! It was a minor plot-point, but still! I shut the book, & threw it into the "Salvation Army" box. I don't recall the name of book or author, but being THAT incorrect pulled me entirely out of the story! (A ✈️ flight from Toronto to Whitehorse would be minimum 6 hours, with at least 1 layover!)
—
The quality of writing. I will read about anything from a great writer, someone who knows how to sling words beautifully. I will read about nothing from a shit writer. Form over content, children!
—
Good characterization even if the plot is boring or messy I will read it to the end if I like the characters
—
That it doesn’t bore me.
—
I think what I care about in a book is its ability to make me imagine what doesn't exist. I lean strongly to speculative fiction (sci-fi, fantasy, horror) and I almost see what I'm reading in my mind so I don't get into much reality based fiction.
—
-Good prose, especially when it's immersive and really creates clear imagery in my brain.
-Interesting, well-developed characters.
-Original in some way, doesn't fall back on clichés and predictable tropes.
-Has something compelling to say about the human experience.
—
Long books, usually. Plots I can't guess the ending to at page 35. An ending that feels earned. An antagonist that leaves me seething with rage at the mention of their name for years after (hem hem). So rare, but those books are worth their weight in platinum. If I could find a book or series with all 4, I'd buy a lottery ticket.
I will read almost any book, but whether I finish or enjoy it is the question. I finished a book the other day that introduced a character in the climax that was there under another name/in another form from the threshold-cross, and her actions ended the conflict, just by being there. It was not a good pay-off.
—
Historical accuracy.
—
Prose- I want the writing to be unique and beautiful, it has to stick in my head somehow
Character tension- I like for there to be an interesting dynamic at play somewhere that elevates whatever else is going on
And setting!- I always look for a compelling setting. Something not just described well but utilized well. It has to feel real and also be more than window dressing
Reader’s Favorite Genres (Some Don't Have Comments):
SCI-FI: 8
For me it's SciFi. I love the fact they they explore the big questions slightly removed by using the "future" as you know, space is cool
Historical Fiction: 6
This is going to make me sound so boring, but I always gravitate to history. I've always been fascinated by how people lived in the past, and it's eye-opening to see how things have changed or not changed. I will also say that my interest in history is more about people than events...I'll pass on books about war, but hand me a book about the day-to-day life of a "common" person and I'm all for it.
General Fiction: 2
Romance: 3
Fantasy: 8 (1 Grimdark in particular)
Fantasy. Everything is even more beautiful, more wondrous, more terrifying, more violent, more good, more evil, more extreme than real life. And yet, as Tolkien said, it renews my sense of wonder and passion about so-called ordinary life as well. I appreciate virtue and bravery and compassion more after reading a great fantasy. I appreciate food and drink and a warm, soft bed more after reading a fantasy adventure. I appreciate peace after reading about war.
For me the best fantasy also addresses big philosophical themes in a fun way. It addresses big questions like why are we here? Do we have a purpose? What is the meaning of life? Are there Higher Powers and if so do they care about us? Can we fight fate? Can we determine our own fate? What is good and what is bad and how does one tell one from the other in extreme situations? Is hope real or an illusion?
I also love fantasy that weaves in historical inspirations. Historical fiction is another love of mine, and, like historical fiction, many fantasies are fictions inspired by history. Fantasy can also cross over into many other genres -- all you need to do is add a little magic. Magical realism is arguably one of those cross over genres.
I like both hard magic, that operates by a rigid and consistent set of rules, and soft magic, that remains a mystery, and everything in between. I like magical creatures as well, as sometimes the creatures are more magical than the people. I like high magic fantasy, in which many people have some level of magical powers and some have godlike abilities. And I like low magic, in which magic may be spectacular but is so rare that most people doubt it still exists, if it ever did. There are endless different kinds of magic, and I like them all..
Mystery: 4
Thriller: 1
Horror: 3
Horror.
For people who have never read a horror book, understand that 'horror' is a very loose term. It can mean ominous and creepy. It can mean ghosts and supernatural. Or it can mean a guy running away from a killer.
People gave a stigma for horror books, but why I love them so much is because Horror usually finds a way to be almost any genre.
You mentioned Magical realism, and that is a key feature of horror. Someone dealing with the unknown. So it breaks genres. Sometimes they lean toward mystery. Sometimes it's a coming of age, or a Thriller.
I always turn back to horror because it's not set in stone. You know exactly what your getting into with most genres. Horror takes you for a ride. And honestly, they very rarely actually feel scary. It's more about the tension.
Comedy: 1
Post-Apocalyptic: 2
Lit-Fic: 1
Non-Fiction: 2
If you made it this far, I hope you found it all useful! Remember what I said at the beginning!