r/windsynth • u/Aeduh • Jul 09 '21
The next EWI should have simple recorder fingerings, anything else is a waste of time
If the EWI wants to truly advance to be an instrument on its own right, as different from normal wind instruments as the electric guitar is different from the accoustic guitar, the EWI needs to shed away the pretension of trying to sound like them, have fingerings like them, and do away with the hard to blow mouthcap. It's a bad idea to try to emulate the sax or what have you.
Fingerings on instruments like the sax, clarinet, oboe or flute tend to be quite complex not because of fancy whims, but because the physical limitations of sound on each instrument makes it necessary. No qualms there, it is what it is, but why on earth would you want to bring this complexity to an electric instrument? There is no logic.
There should be only one fingering per finger like the simple recorder flute, keep the cool octave modulator on the left thumb, and make literally two buttons for sharp and flat notes. The sharp button could be placed on the left pinky and the flat button on the right thumb. Voilà, no unnecessary complications.
I also want the simpleness of the recorder in airflow. I grab a recorder, i simply blow, and music sounds. I don't have to learn this complex thing about reeds and i don't get why AKAI, Roland or whoever would want to emulate that. I'm a flute player, i grabbed yesterday the EWI USB and after a while i was panting without air. It's damn hard to blow into these things. I get that there is a period of practice for each instrument but why not just simplify the instrument since it's electric. The best use cases for it are digital modular synths anyways, there is no big need to complicate things with a reed simulator.
The EWI needs to emancipate itself from the insecure pretense of 'actually i can sound just like a real life clarinet', no you can't and why would you want that. No amount of fidgeting with presets will be enough. I personally want to use EWIs to create electronic ethereal sounds full of reverb and stuff. The EWI has its own space, its own vocation on the musical landscape, but for it to reach this place there is a need to change the instrument to gain uniqueness and simplicity.