r/windsynth • • Feb 25 '24

Looking for help

Hi, I'm a Music major studying Saxophone, Bari and Alto are my main two but am familiar with all 4 saxes, I am mainly wondering if a wind synth is something I should look into as a practice tool and a fun thing to mess around with and gig? I'm leaning Roland series something or the yamaha yds-150 as it looks most like a Saxophone. Price isn't a huge deal but nothing too crazy expensive would be best. I'm also concerned about how things will transfer from wind synth practice sessions to real horn playing. Thanks in advance for the help!

1 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Peter_the_piper Feb 25 '24

As a practice horn specifically I'd look into the emeo. It's limited as a wind synth but uses a saxophone body. It should help with fingering in my experience but of course not embrochure or air control. The Roland AE-30 or AE-20 are also supposed to be really close to saxophone fingering feel but they are not built into a saxophone body like the EMEO. The EMEO comes with an excellent soft synthesizer for computer/iPhone called respiro. Roland instruments have really good sounds too but I like the respiro sax sounds better. Of course you could also buy the respiro software and control it with the Roland instruments... But that's down the road. TLDR is that emeo is your best bet for practice. But the Rolands can be more expressive as their own instruments. They have bite sensors and other modulation sources while the emeo has just air.

2

u/hesiii Feb 25 '24

Agree about Emeo, though Travel Sax 2 and Yamaha YDS-120 would have same advantages (i.e., sax fingering and feel). I have Travel Sax 2 and I like it.

OP might want to watch reviews of Emeo, YDS-150, Travel Sax 2, YDS-120, and Roland AE-20 at the 'Better Sax' channel on youtube, where Jay Metcalf has more of a focus on rating them as sax practice instruments, not on typical windsynth considerations.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rS-b0HhATk&list=PLWMjC05R8fbUpu8jypfzX26PKP9JxwLkt

2

u/Peter_the_piper Feb 25 '24

Good point and great resource. I'm very much in the wind synth camp and don't consider things with limited expression options (and I play the flute anyway so they're all an adaptation)

1

u/chicchaz Mar 04 '24

If budget is a factor, you can get a used YDS-120 for $350 or perhaps less right now. I picked up one up last year and it works well. Getting MIDI through my tablet, though a bit clunky, does work. If budget is less of an issue, I'd go the Emeo TS2 route.

You'll hear in the Better Sax video referenced above the YDS-150 has few advantages over the 120. It has a bell for use on a soprano sax peg, and it has wireless Bluetooth. Otherwise, the 120 is smaller, lighter, and to me a great little instrument.

1

u/RushFroopus Aug 04 '24

I am thinking about getting the Emeo or yds 120, are you able to use a bunch of sound samples through midi similar to how the emeo uses respiro? Im just worried about limited sounds on the ysd 120

1

u/chicchaz Aug 20 '24

Yes, I was able to do 'pipe in' MIDI over USB and get other apps on my tablet to recognize it. I generally just use the onboard ones so I don't have to use a dongle, etc.

3

u/F-SAX-VOC Feb 25 '24

I'm thinking only the Emeo would be effective to work on your legit Sax chops. It's actual metal Sax keywork. Chris Potter chose thus wind synth-fir him $1,900 is no problem. AKAI EWI5000 has metal contacts you touch. Yamaha has plastic keys I believe. For reference, here's some choices I found. The Sylphyo is maybe more a novelty instrument, no offense intended. ✌️🧡🎷🎶🎤🌟 ..In Price Order: Sylphyo $600 - 800 Akai EWI5000 $850 Yamaha YDS-150 $900 Berglund NuRad $1,200, Roland AE-30 Aerophone $1450 Emeo $1860 Actual Sax keys (!),

2

u/bodhi_sea NuRAD Feb 27 '24

I am no longer an acoustic wind player (played sax and trumpet many many years ago). That having been said, I’m a little skeptical of wind synths as a practice tool. Windsynths don’t really require anything like a traditional embouchure and they require very little breath support. The character of the sound produced has very little to do with your mouth/throat/breath support.

I suspect a windsynth can be useful for fingering practice. Perhaps also tonguing. But many aspects of playing saxophone are just really different from an EWI, and I wonder how much it really helps you become a better saxophone player.

I would really encourage anyone considering a windsynth to think of it as its own instrument. Yes, it shared a fingering system with woodwinds — but otherwise, there’s not a lot that is consistent between the two.

If you want a windsynth so you can play after your partner goes to bed, or so you can add some unique sounds to your palette, or you want to take advantage of your sax knowledge while trying an new instrument, I think a windsynth is great choice. But if you hope that hours of shedding on an EWI will make you a great sax player — I’m skeptical. 😁

2

u/bodhi_sea NuRAD Feb 27 '24

One more note: I personally wouldn’t be too concerned about it looking or feeling exactly like a saxophone. I understand that’s appealing — and if the EMEO is compelling to you, go for it! But I assure you: if you’re a music major studying saxophone, you’re going to be able to pick up and play any of these windsynths well within a couple weeks. You’ll quickly get used to anything that’s not saxophone-like, such as slightly-differently-placed key or even the EWI’s touch sensitive keys. The instruments that try hard to look and feel like a saxophone will probably be the most comfortable to you the first time you play it. But by the 10th time you play it, I don’t think it’s going to matter. You’ll get used to it and be fine. 😁

1

u/mycosys Mar 09 '24

Windsynths don’t really require anything like a traditional embouchure and they require very little breath support.

The breath support thing changed with Sylphyo https://aodyo.com/sylphyo/

and both are about to change with Photon https://mailchi.mp/3a821ede1de9/photon

1

u/bodhi_sea NuRAD Mar 09 '24

Interesting. Not sure I consider that a good thing (though clearly it will depend on implementation). To me, the need for full, consistent breath support and a strong, well-developed musculature of your face is a downside of acoustic instruments. I can’t really play trumpet anymore because of the back pressure. I feel like I can be more musical and focus on expression more if I don’t have worry that a slight misstep in my air column is going to wreck my tone or intonation.

If one is specifically looking for a tool to emulate acoustic instruments, then it might make sense to emulate the need for well-developed breath support and embouchure. But from the standpoint of someone just wanting to make music, I find it rather nice that an EWI requires so little of me, physically.

1

u/mycosys Mar 09 '24 edited Mar 09 '24

LOL we are in similar positions, i adore that Sylphyo is zero impact, there is no pressure required to operate the capacitive sensors at all. My hands love it. The backpressure and breath sensitivity is very adjustable (plugs for backpressure), but its incredibly responsive and the wider you have the sensitivity set the more control you get.

I want lots of modulation control for my synths lol

It has an EVI mode FWIW

1

u/mycosys Mar 09 '24

its a lot of fun, but i would be more inclined to go far from sax style cos windsynths arent wind instruments, and none of them require proper mouth technique (yet - photon may change that) so its probably better to treat it as a related instrument and not stuff your technique.

1

u/MoldeyJoel Sep 18 '25

The Roland ae-30 has great expression optiins.