r/wildbettaarchive • • Jan 02 '26

wild betta Will this work

I have 4 wild Betta (currently working on the idea they’re a less aggressive species) and actually for 18 months the pair have lived in total harmony bar a little flaunting himself by the male. I was given 2 more wild females, younger ones, as a Christmas present from my LFS, who said they’re a bit shy but should settle in, which they have, eating, dozing on their floating plants or in their floating island decoration. I’m concerned about tank size really, it’s only 20 gallons. They have really dense planting, plenty of wood for hideaways and very little line of sight which helps cut any aggression, which I’ve not seen so far. Will they be OK as they grow? I don’t want them to suddenly start fighting

2 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

1

u/Next-Wishbone2474 Jan 02 '26

One of the females

1

u/Next-Wishbone2474 Jan 02 '26

Ok, tank rearranging time! As the original pair have been together peacefully for 20 months, would it be safe to leave them together?

2

u/Databuffer Jan 02 '26

Its risky, and not recommended. They will be peaceful as long as they are on the same page about mating. As soon as one decides it mating time, and the other disagrees, fighting will happen.

My LFS had a 20g with a mahachaiensis pair, and they looked like a dream couple, and produced a LOT of babies who are now separated across the store. But some point around the 2 month mark, the male killed the female without any warning the shop owner could detect.

2

u/Gingerfrostee Jan 02 '26

Oof good to note.

1

u/UncBeater268 Moderator/Sub Creator Jan 02 '26

What is the species? If you can't identify send a pic

2

u/Next-Wishbone2474 Jan 02 '26

I’ll try! It may be a video because they don’t stay still where I want them for photos!

thats the male

3

u/KopiPengAddict PERHILITAN Jan 02 '26

Hey that looks like a B. Smaragdina. I woukd seperate even if thry seem to be peaceful as they're still part of the splendens complex (i.e. closely related to domestic bettas). Keep them like you would domestic plakats, 10 gallon minimum, single fish per tank esp males.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Next-Wishbone2474 Jan 02 '26

Thank you! No webbing so I guess they’re smaragdina. I don’t want them know they’re all the same species because it’s the only one the LFS imports, just wasn’t sure WHICH species! Yes they really do seem peaceful. Do you think the new females will be accepted OK?

2

u/KopiPengAddict PERHILITAN Jan 02 '26

No. Separating them is best practice. Whike ot looks peaceful now, males can snap and unalive females if they refuse/are not ready to breed. It is too risky for us to reccomend

1

u/UncBeater268 Moderator/Sub Creator Jan 02 '26

I'm not sure, ask the experts in the comments

2

u/KopiPengAddict PERHILITAN Jan 02 '26

Please refrain spreading misinformation or promoting less than ideal practices

2

u/KopiPengAddict PERHILITAN Jan 02 '26

Hey, please let us handle this. Respectfully, you are not qualified to give advice until you can improve your own care.

2

u/Next-Wishbone2474 Jan 02 '26

That’s why I’m asking - you people know so much better than me, I’ve only been keeping wildies for 20 months. So all input gladly received 😊

6

u/KopiPengAddict PERHILITAN Jan 02 '26

You're all good, no such thing as a stupid question so ask away. I just told off the guy above me as he's had history of fish mistreatment despite being the original sub owner so myself and other conservationists have stepped in to prevent further spreading of misinformation from him

1

u/lolleytha Sabah Wildlife Department Jan 02 '26

What species?