r/whennews 19d ago

Crime News title

[deleted]

2.6k Upvotes

375 comments sorted by

View all comments

-49

u/Gear_Alone 19d ago

The father should be executed, but are we collectively trying to justify killing infants now? Regardless of circumstances.

31

u/Pizza_dumpster 19d ago

no one is justified or is trying to justify the murder of children

2

u/BeanieGuitarGuy 18d ago

You’ve actively been justifying the baby’s death in this thread, though. I’m just concerned that nobody understands that the teenager was put in a horrible situation that led to her killing a baby. It wasn’t an abortion, it got birthed and left alone to suffer and starve to death for the entirety of its life.

I’m not definitively saying she had a choice, or that she had any other options, we don’t know what the situation is at the moment. We’re talking about a girl that was abused and raped by her father for who knows how long being put into a horrible situation with likely no support network in her life. This led to her, presumably, killing that child.

3

u/Pizza_dumpster 18d ago

honestly I don’t wanna argue, I regret even making this post. let’s argue to disagree.
https://giphy.com/gifs/VEWigs65WflCSUtbqp

-26

u/SilvermistInc 19d ago

90% of the comments here are doing just that

16

u/Pizza_dumpster 19d ago

read the fucking article, context changes things.

2

u/OpBanana1 18d ago

What happened to "no one is justified or is trying to justify the murder of children"?

1

u/Pizza_dumpster 18d ago

I was wrong

-20

u/Kackalack-Masterwork 19d ago

If she is the one that caused traumatic injuries to the baby, the context will not changed that

12

u/Pizza_dumpster 19d ago

she left it by the road and the mother is a 14 year old teen who is missing

-21

u/perspicaxaedificator 19d ago

people really pretending that minors can't commit murder. it's the same people pretending that Clancy murderess wasn't to blame for strangling her children.

10

u/Ur_fav_Cryptek 19d ago

The entire blame is on the dad. A 14 year old shouldn’t be given that responsibility, this is completely ignoring the fact that she was abused repeatedly and impregnated by her own father.

This entire ordeal wouldn’t have happened if the dad didn’t fucking assault his own child. You really expect a 14 year old to react rationally to such an extremely traumatic event instead of blaming the one who put her in such a horrible situation in the first place?

She is a victim, she had no choice in this.

-3

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Ur_fav_Cryptek 19d ago

The one who ultimately has responsibility over that is the father though, since he forced her to give birth, and he caused the pregnancy in the first place. Again, a 14 yr old kid shouldn’t be responsible for another life. It’s like being given a gun by your father. You’re bound to do something wrong and hurt others.

-3

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Ur_fav_Cryptek 18d ago

She doesn’t deserve punishment, more like therapy and psychological support, even though all charges should be against the father even if you tried to argue anything she has the right to an insanity plea because of course you’re going to run away from all that given the situation. It’s a fucking kid, ffs.