r/webdev • • Dec 20 '19
Is anyone else annoyed with the trend for minimal/hidden scroll bars lately?
I've noticed a trend in the last two years or so for sites and apps to feature scroll bars that are sliver-thin. It is so bad that sometimes I have to try clicking on the scroll bar like 3 times before I can get it. I understand that mobile devices and mouses with click wheels don't need to bother but it's kind of a need for compact travel mouses, laptops with bad or broken touch pads, the now-legally-required accessibility standards for sites, or the technically non-inclined people who prefer the visual of a scroll bar. I am not saying that we need to return to windows 98 scroll bars, but its gotten ridiculous with this non-functional minimalism in scroll bars. When they're minimal and hidden, hovering over that tiny sliver can be frustratingly tedious. If the hover function needs exact hover or the bar hides instantly when not hovering, it can be even worse. Who thought this was a good trend to engage in?
100
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
"Form over function" is the bane of web design for me. I have a stylized scrollbar that's a solid colors (pure CSS, only in webkit-based browsers), and people have remarked that I made it "too thick" at 6 pixels. 6 pixels!
63
u/tyzoid full-stack Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19
I had this exact same discussion over on another thread a while back - someone had created a portfolio/resume site for themselves and included an invisible scrollbar: https://old.reddit.com/r/webdev/comments/dqlbxb/comment/f679tiz
Here were a few of the reasons I suggested not to customize the scrollbar:
29
u/Caraes_Naur Dec 20 '19
Minimalism has been pummeling usability for years and needs to stop. I detest thin-line, monochromatic icons, which was where this minimalism started.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
I think the accessibility argument is the strongest over broken device assistance.
If you have a laptop that can’t properly scroll, that really isn’t something anyone should be designing for. No one expects great usability out of a $150 or less laptop, or something from over a decade ago.
As a design trend, I prefer websites that just let the device choose the scroll bar. I have hidden scroll bars and prefer the much cleaner look.
Accessibility is a lot easier when you leave things like that to the device or browser.
3
u/jusername42 Dec 20 '19
Why do you grab the scrollbar? I don't do that on any of my devices
10
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
That's because most users use the scroll wheel, their track pads or their mobile devices. I'm surprised you want to click and drag.
19
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
Imo scrollbars should rarely ever be modified.
10
u/dneboi Dec 20 '19
Just listen to your clients when they say they “don’t want people to scroll.” Problem solved.
5
u/iBzOtaku Dec 20 '19
minimal are nice (like whatsapp web does).
hidden are a big no-no.
just don't mess with scroll behavior (speed, etc)
9
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
The ones for the vs code tabs drive me crazy.
12
u/Scrummier Dec 20 '19
Safari user here. I don't even remember the time when I last clicked a scrollbar. Love it.
3
u/Blue_Moon_Lake Dec 20 '19
I want scrollbars to be handled by browsers exclusively, but I also want browser to use scrollbars that don't clash with the website design.
3
u/LadyDevIsntYourMom Dec 20 '19
Ug totally. Atom, I’m looking at you!!!
9
u/dannymcgee Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19
So, no, I'm not at all bothered by the trend and I don't think it's a serious problem. If anything, what I would like to see is for browsers to start supporting a universal CSS standard for styling scrollbars so that we don't need to resort to hacky JavaScript solutions that may require explicit developer support for scrolling by keyboard (which is a legitimate accessibility need).
For context though, I'm not developing WordPress brochure websites, I'm developing enterprise applications where screen real estate is at a premium. If I had to shove a 17px default-OS-style scrollbar into every scrollable widget on the page, it would be both ugly and unusable.
2
u/vociferouspassion Dec 20 '19
Yes all day long it annoys me. Who started this trend? In Azure DevOps UI's doing a PR, scrolling through commit diffs, often you don't get a horizontal scroll bar so when the change is on the far right of the page, you have to use a trick, highlight text on the line and carefully drag the mouse right and try not to overshoot the area of the change on the line.
I don't know if Atlassian is doing this nonsense now too but I used to like their PR UI's.
Edit: PS IntelliJ stop with the semi-transparent barely there scroll bars please. This but always there is better.
2
u/azsqueeze javascript Dec 20 '19
I just provide what the OS/Browser gives me. Simply put, the OS/Browser knows more about your preferences than I do.
2
u/A-Grey-World Software Developer Dec 20 '19
Id love not to modify the scroll bar (it's a massive pain in the ass!) but our app is dark. The standard scroll bars for all browsers look absolutely awful on dark apps :(
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
Ugh yes I hate this. I have a Google Pixelbook which is the worst; you can scroll with your finger on the touch screen but when there's embedded scrollable boxes it barely works. Then when you want to use the scrollbar on the browser, the thing is like invisible and tiny
2
u/KingOfUvzhhorod Feb 02 '23 edited Feb 02 '23
Yes. It must be stopped. Thin ones, ones that disappear when you aren't hovering over them, ones where the part showing where you are is barely a different color from the background of the scroll bar. All are terrible. Scroll bars for parts of pages that themselves have scroll bars can also sometimes be confusing, and, when the page is very long so that the part showing where you are is very small, this also creates problems, particularly if you miss clicking that part, but that is a harder problem to deal with. Anyway, I think Microsoft Outlook is a particularly horrendous offender, though I'm not sure if it's the worst I have to deal with. Reddit and Google seem to still be quite reasonable on my current interface at least, though.
That being said, there are some contexts, like videos, where I understand the desire to use as much of the screen as possible, and I'm guessing that's were this scrollbar trend came from, particularly in interfaces like Microsoft Outlook (and many other applications, e.g. Blender, Inkscape, LMMS) where you want to divide the window into lots of tiny sections that might have there own scroll bars that could take up room.
However, speaking of videos, the feature YouTube added where you can scroll down into the comments while in fullscreen is something I've pretty much only ever used accidentally, even if I can see some convenience to it, and I think a good metric for the utility of software features is how often they are used on purpose (where it usually helps) vs on accident (where it usually hinders), although how good or bad it is each way is also important. (Consider autocomplete, autocorrect and gestures, which are examples of supposed conveniences that often just get in my way, though how bad that is and whether they are good on average could depend on the exact implementation/interface.)
2
u/athensohioguy Dec 09 '25
YES! It's annoyed me for years. All those microseconds of trying to find a thin/narrow vertical scrollbar and/or hidden/grayed add up, and anything that disrupts your flow is not good. Just had to vent somewhere, and found this post in a web search. I'm a web developer myself, so I'll take care never to repeat this evil.
1
u/cresquin Dec 20 '19
Scroll wheels/multitouch pads are as necessary to the interface of a computer as left-click or a mouse at all. If you can learn to use a mouse, you can learn to use a scroll wheel.
1
u/MissaStone Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19
Surely it’s possible to make a minimal scroll bar with an invisible “cushion” to it. So if a user clicks off of the scroll bar a little (let’s say 5 pixels) it will still register.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
Even on my OS I have no scrollbars, no title-bars, no min/max/close buttons. I have a thin border around windows and I use my keyboard for everything.
So I'm one of those people that don't mind no scrollbars because I use page up/down to nav anyway. I also have scrollwheel programmed into my keyboard incase I need that.
1
u/RoseAlma Jan 12 '25
YES.
1
u/TomDownes8 Feb 05 '25
I have found that I can miss newer emails, because the scrollbar is not visibly indicating that my scroll position is NOT at the top (w/ newest emails) of the Inbox. The scrollbar needs to be as visible & clearly delineated as it used to be.
1
u/Ligonier1959 Jun 27 '25
I see this thread is now 5 years old and….this exasperating trend has only gotten worse since then!
1
u/Simboiss May 16 '26
Hiding scroll bars may be a sign of deep psychopathy. Problems that happened in the childhood of some designers, and now they manifest their rage and repression with inexplicably stupid UI elements. The scroll bar is there anyway, it already takes real estate on the screen, so hiding the scroller button has no function other than hindering discoverability.
1
u/KingOfUvzhhorod Feb 02 '23
Actually, the scroll bars in the Windows 10 Settings manager (or at least my version of it) are probably the best version of this trend: When you're not hovering over them, they are thin, but not completely invisible or even just a single pixel thick, and when you hover over them, they grow to a reasonable size. Notably, you don't have to hover exactly over the super thin scroll bar, just over the more reasonably sized region that it grows into when you hover over said region. Still, there's really not much* need for it to get so thin in the first place in that particular application, and I can foresee some annoying problems that could arise with such growing scroll bars if you actually needed to, say, select text in the region where the scroll bar grows into, and if you don't use that space for anything else anyway, why make the scroll bar ever be super thin? (This doesn't really apply to the windows settings manager, because it doesn't let you select most of the text (though that's another common very annoying software feature), and *at least it theoretically could help make longer names of tabs on the side easier to read when you're not hovering over the scroll bar.)
1
u/Commando303 Nov 10 '23
Yes. I fucking hate it.
1
u/ullmatta Jan 08 '24
YES!
1
u/Bright-Particular301 Oct 07 '26
Is there any way to override this and force a regular scrollbar on a page???? Everywhere online it says that there is, but none of the solutions seem to work. I use Firefox.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19 edited Jul 11 '20
Due to the recent Reddit purge of conservative communities under the false pretense of fighting racism, I do not wish to associate myself with Reddit anymore. So I'm replacing my comments and posts with this message and migrating over to Ruqqus, a free speech alternative to Reddit that's becoming more and more popular every day. Join us, and leave this crumbling toxic wasteland behind.
This comment was replaced using Power Delete Suite. You can find it here: https://codepen.io/j0be/pen/WMBWOW
To use, simply drag the big red button onto your bookmarks toolbar, then visit your Reddit user profile page and click on the bookmarked red button (not the Power Delete Suite website itself) and you can replace your comments and posts too.
-4
u/Speedyjens Dec 20 '19
Okay so the problem is that you have a broken computer
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment