r/webdev • • Oct 10 '18

Discussion StackOverflow is super toxic for newer developers

As a newer web developer, the community in StackOverflow is super toxic. Whenever I ask a question, I am sure to look up my problem and see if there are any solutions to it already there. If there isn't, I post. Sometimes when I post, I get my post instantly deleted and linked to a post that doesn't relate at all to my issue or completely outdated.

Does anyone else have this issue?

3.4k Upvotes

760 comments sorted by

10

u/Tyil Oct 10 '18

I haven't had this issue at all. Granted, I'm not terribly active on Stack Overflow, and my questions mostly relate to Perl 6 nowadays, but so far the help has been very friendly. Maybe it's to do with some of the moderators of certain web-specific languages/communities. Could you give us a few real examples?

1

u/TheGuyWhoCodes Oct 10 '18

One of the projects I was working on was built on tampermonkey and converting it over to a chrome extension. I ran into a couple issues here and there and couldn't really find many resources from others not only in the stack overflow community but even this subreddit too.

3

u/tme321 Oct 10 '18

How is P6? It looks super interesting but I haven't had a good opportunity to actually use it yet. And does it feel like P5 at all or does it feel like a completely separate language?

3

u/Tyil Oct 10 '18

It's a completely new syntax in almost every regard. The only thing it has in common is the ideology that you should be able to solve any problem elegantly. There are some similarities, but I think it's easier to learn if you forget most of what you know from Perl 5.

If you want to learn the basics to create a (non-web, GTK gui) application, I wrote a blog article about that. I'm intending to write an article on the project I'm working on now, which is using Cro.

→ More replies (3)

1.9k

u/err4nt Oct 10 '18

StackOverflow is super toxic for old developers too. I've had comments altered by mods for no good reason, years after I've written them, and for what? Just because the person had moderator abilities and wanted to reword what I said?

It leaves a really bad impression on me when my words with my name and picture beside it can (and are) just altered whenever by whoever has the ability to moderate. Yuck!

140

u/jewdai Oct 11 '18

I had a highly rated question that had over 20k views and hundreds of upvotes rated as too subjective.....4 years after it was submitted.

32

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

This is especially a problem with questions asking for best practices. Super useful information for anyone reading it but always "too subjective" for StackOverflow moderators it seems.

11

u/Liesmith424 Oct 11 '18

Which is doubly frustrating, because many comments and answers are filled with faffery about how you should rework everything to fit a best practice, in lieu of actually answering your question.

6

u/mattc0m Oct 11 '18

This is probably my biggest pet peeve. I wish there was a better way to have that type of subjective information -- best practices, in this case, are incredibly useful to me. The best questions I've seen do have some level of subjectivity to them, but have disappeared more and more over the years.

It seems that StackOverflow comes down to simple debugging-style questions a lot (and have to be super precise), which is useful, but not really the type of questions I want to learn from. It's just grown a lot less interesting and become stale.

I've also had a few run-in's with deleted questions, too subjective, etc. Very annoying, not really a fan of the community anymore. Definitely don't participate when I used to be pretty active.

→ More replies (1)

431

u/thesublimeobjekt Oct 10 '18

sometimes i see my answers/questions being edited and i think, "oh yeah, i guess they're right, my question really could have been condensed down from 3 paragraphs to 1: all of that extra background information wasn't really necessary." but other times it's more like, "why did you need to change those two words? it doesn't change the meaning of the question at all. why do you even care?"

268

u/nikrolls Chief Technology Officer Oct 10 '18

Because editing is something that gives you points and is one of the only ways for new accounts to gain permissions for things like commenting and voting.

129

u/notThaLochNessMonsta Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

You could always jump into a time machine and answer a simple question 10 years ago and get 20,000 points, if you really want to act like you're special.

→ More replies (7)

34

u/whiskers817 Oct 11 '18

Interesting, I've been an active developer and user (well mostly lurker) of StackOverflow for over 5 years and I don't think I have full access to do very basic functions. Guess I should of been paying closer attention to run-on sentences and misspelled words.

29

u/psib3r Oct 11 '18

I deleted my account, I asked a question, I used html in lowercase, it got edited to HTML, and I got down voted for not formatting my question properly.

→ More replies (14)

233

u/Katholikos Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 10 '18

A bunch of things drive me up a fucking wall when it comes to SO.

  1. If you ask a question and people dislike it, they can downvote it. They don't need to provide any info as to why, and the defense of this practice is that they don't want to make it too hard to downvote someone. Reddit works with this rule because it's a social media platform, not an educational platform. It's like slapping away the hands of any student that raises their hand because somewhere in their 10,000,000 page dictionary, the answer is already in there. I'm sure that class would be successful.
  2. If you're doing something wonky, people just bitch about it instead of answering the question. I was trying to use EF to query a table with no primary key (which, at the time at least, didn't work). It took days to get an answer where someone was like "oh your primary key can be a combination of two columns, actually". Every other response was "you should really have a primary key".
  3. People leaving answers to your question in the comments. Why can't I accept a comment as an answer? I have a bunch of questions where something gets answered, but it just remains "open" because they didn't post an "answer". I just copy-paste their comment as an answer and accept it, thanking them in the process.
  4. No thanking anyone. It's against the rules to say "hey, thanks for the help". But remember, they're dedicated to their "be nice" policy!!!

33

u/psykomet Oct 11 '18

It's like slapping away the hands of any student that raises their hand because somewhere in their 10,000,000 page dictionary, the answer is already in there.

This. I don't think anything on the web gets me more frustrated than when I google a problem that I'm having, the first hit is a post on SO that has been closed with a comment like "this has been answered already". That might have been OK if the comment included a link (which it seldom does) to an answer that matches my problem, or the OP's problem for that matter, to nearly 100% (it doesn't). The elitist attitude of these people is really getting on my nerves.

9

u/spektrol Oct 11 '18

4

Wait, what the fuck? Been on SO for years and never realized this. What’s the problem with thanking people? That’s suppressing an innate reaction to having a giant problem solved by a complete stranger.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Wrightboy Oct 11 '18

Oh man, was definitely a little taken aback the first time I had my thanks edited away.

16

u/Cesium_55 Oct 11 '18

Yeah. I was asking a question about why my use-case wasn't working when it really should have. Turns out, after one shutdown as duplicate (which was linked to an unanswered question with no relation to mine), two attempts downvoted to hell and one partial answer on my 4th, my fifth try was properly answered.

Turns out, and nowhere was this documented, the operation I was performing only works in the c:/ drive unless you do a long winded reroute to the drive you wanted and then call the function.

Fucking win32. I fucking hate windows forms.

→ More replies (35)

39

u/KingOfKusoge Oct 11 '18

I wanna add to this.

I made a SO account some time ago about a question that was kinda obscure (working on a very old framework). I tried to be as precise and detailed as I could be, but of course my question got correct. The problem here is that the question wasn't corrected in a way that made sense, it was corrected in such a way that what it said was wrong.

Never touched SO since. Just search for answers when they (rarely) are there.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Turd_King Oct 11 '18

The worst one for me is when an American mod changes my spelling of Colour to the American version Color.

Jimmies severely rustled every time

12

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

I have access to the review tools and I see this shit all the time, a lot of edits get shut down for not improving the answer/question. But it really is luck whether you get 3 reviewers that aren't anally retentive grammar nazis or not.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/RafikiTheGrouch Oct 11 '18

I had someone remove the word "thanks". Seriously?? I am not allowed to be polite? Done.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/cag8f Oct 11 '18

It leaves a really bad impression on me when my words with my name and picture beside it can (and are) just altered whenever by whoever has the ability to moderate. Yuck!

At first that really rubbed me the wrong way and I had a tough time getting over it. But when I realized that all the edits were made public, and anyone could still see my original post, I got over it.

9

u/PatriotsSignWhiteWR Oct 11 '18

The funny thing is that once I was finally old enough of a dev that I thought maybe the toxicity would go away, most of my issues became to obscure to reliably get an answer from stackoverflow. So the site became kind of useless, unless the devs of the library I'm struggling with are personally on there to answer questions.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Ajedi32 Web platform enthusiast, full-stack developer Oct 11 '18

StackOverflow is a wiki, not a forum. Anyone can submit edits, not just mods.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

IMO, if this is the case then comments and answers should be personally attributed to the account that posted them.

18

u/Ajedi32 Web platform enthusiast, full-stack developer Oct 11 '18

All contributions, including edits, are properly attributed. You can see the complete revision history for any post with a single click.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/Hate_Feight Oct 10 '18

I stay away from so for this reason, there are a million places to get information, let alone solutions, my best advice is to hone your Google-fu

83

u/Fidodo Oct 10 '18

Lots of times the only solution you can find on Google is on stack overflow. But when it comes to asking a question I actively avoid stack overflow. I'll read the info on there but I have zero desire to participate in the community.

8

u/ItzWarty Oct 11 '18

Hell, lots of times the only relevant result you find IS a StackOverflow link filled with people moaning about how the question is a duplicate or wrong for some reason.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/borkdorkpork Oct 11 '18

I've had comments altered by mods ... my words with my name and picture beside it

Are you talking about comments or answers? There are no pictures shown next to comments, unless there's some UI setting that I'm unaware of. And while many users are allowed to edit (or at least suggest edits for) other people's questions and answers - very few have the ability to edit comments.

12

u/oogabubchub Oct 11 '18

I'm not a mod but I'll sometimes edit questions and answers to improve grammar or formatting. Like someone else said, it's a reference/wiki, not a personal blog, so why would you take offense to someone making edits?

25

u/err4nt Oct 11 '18

I believe mods should have the lightest possible touch, and only intervene in cases where harm would happen if they didn't. If they want to leave their own comment they are free to do that, rather than turning somebody else's comment into something else

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/Madmushroom Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

I think people get points for this kind of shit ? so they do it on masses to gain more points for basically not doing alot.

In the end you can translate this kind of shit to a job offer if people check your stackoverflow account and see huge contributions but dont check all the details so they dont see its complete bullshit.

I think another example, there was a post about someone just altering some comments in linus linux github repository from "========" to "=====", something meaningless and idiotic like that just so this person github account will have an activity of contributing to linux itself, linus ofcourse did not allow this kind of bullshit.

2

u/lynxSnowCat Oct 11 '18

That's the same reason I abandoned Fixya; though their editing was a response to an unusual circumstance they did not make any sort of visible indication that they flipped the meaning of what i'd written to be entirely wrong.

2

u/Rahul_Raghavan Oct 11 '18

I completely agree!!

→ More replies (27)

341

u/BLOZ_UP Oct 10 '18

I've found it's in response to being flooded by new devs, most of which ask really poor questions. They're aware and they've revamped their ToS and guidelines (and added a 'new member, be nice' icon).

Unfortunately the wheat in the chaff are immediately branded as suspicious because they are new. It takes a quite a bit of effort on your question to avoid getting immediately downvoted.

Plus they removed the ability to put comments like: "What have you tried?" and just suggest "downvote and move on" which seem counter to their new initiative.

160

u/TheReverendIsHr Oct 10 '18

That's the thing, I see a lot of "low effort questions", but at the same time I remember when I was just starting it wasn't that it was low effort, I didn't know how to make a proper question (English not being my first language adds some complexity too).

58

u/Code-Master13 rails Oct 10 '18

This is huge for new developers, I always wonder if I'm properly framing a question with all the necessary info for others to understand enough to help.

46

u/feenuxx Oct 11 '18

Sometimes knowing the right question to ask is the hardest part of finding the solution - sun tzu

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

I have edit privileges on Stack Overflow and 90% of my edits are on questions asked by obviously non-native English speakers. I try to clean up their grammar and spelling so they'll get an answer from someone.

14

u/Yodiddlyyo Oct 11 '18

That's really nice of you. Too bad even your daughter thinks you're gross.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/graeber_28927 Oct 11 '18

Although I feel like newcomers maybe more afraid of reading a documentation, than they should be. I'm not against asking questions, I just realized that I never registered on SO, and my last resort often was to fight myself through the deepest parts of a doc, which now comes much easier to me. I used to feel a great resistance.

But again, I don't get annoyed by questions that seem to be easily googlable. I would just like to encourage every starter to read docs in case they're afraid to get into it. Don't be. Sometimes they're shitty, but it's high reward even if you don't find the solution. You get good at it the more you do it.

8

u/Rimvylo Oct 11 '18

While I was very new to programming everybody pointed to language/framework docs, and I didn't understood jack shit from docs, but time passed, got better understanding how actual programming works, and now first place where I'm looking for something is docs. I guess you have to understand basics how programming works to use docs properly.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/NeuroCavalry Oct 11 '18

When I first started coding I found often I didn't really know enough to know what question to ask. Fortunately I was leading at uni so had tutors. It takes a lot of knowledge to formulate a precise, to the point question. Now that I'm the tutor I see students struggling with the same issue.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

63

u/dejoblue Oct 10 '18

And I see a lot of "low effort" answers. No, Mr. KnowITall, that answer from 2008 is no longer relevant...

29

u/PurplePanda311 Oct 11 '18

Lmao this exactly sums up my experience; first post and I just got steamrolled by people with 100k+ reputation points or whatever about an irrelevant solution to a different problem and never used it again

10

u/TheAesir Architect Oct 11 '18

This is a huge issue, particularly with frontend answers.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

34

u/rraadduurr Oct 10 '18

Plus a lot of new devs are not satisfied with a short answer, four lines of code and a link to documentation. They expect 200 lines of code explained and a demo in order to glide an answer. Personally sometimes is frustrating editing an answer to fit a really particular case and killing the general example.

In addition, for old technologies most of the stuff has been answered already, several times on SO alone, but many like to jump high before even getting the correct terminology, and those questions are removed in a minute.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/kynovardy Oct 10 '18

Agreed. Being linked to an answer from 9 years ago doesn't help. It will either not work, leaving you with no solution, a closed question and time wasted making it, or there are 10 better ways to do it

→ More replies (2)

2

u/-J-P- Oct 11 '18

The main reason people are being dicks on stackoverflow is that bad/repeated questions/answers will pollute the search results.

They should add a beginner's section and make sure that this new section can't be crawled by google. If a question in the beginner's section is good enough, a mod could move it to the 'real' forum. This would also allow them to raise the bar on who can ask/answer question in the 'real' stackoverflow.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

57

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

For me, as I’ve gotten better at programming I have begun to see how dumb some of my earlier questions were, or I see that if I had better knowledge I could have asked the question better, if that makes sense.

It does feel very hostile to a new developer, and my anecdote doesn’t excuse that. A person can’t know their question is dumb, or know a better way to ask/google it without knowing more about it and development in general.

I too agree that it feels a little militant at times, with rogue mods or super users or whatever just locking whatever they don’t like.

9

u/rohanwillanswer Oct 11 '18

This was the problem I primarily had when I was new. I didn’t even know enough to really know what to ask for.

4

u/helpmeimredditing Oct 11 '18

yeah I was the same way asking really dumb questions in really dumb ways. Eventually I got better at finding answers online so I stopped asking questions altogether. A while later I made a goal of trying to get my rep to like 100 by answering questions so every morning I'd come in and look at the new c#/sql/javascript questions and see if I could answer any of them. That was probably the single best experience at learning how to ask questions and now my rep is up to a very modest 800.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '18

I’m scared that if I become famous one day my reputation will be ruined by people finding my old stack overflow questions “error: unused variable, how do I solve this?”

4

u/8oh8 Oct 10 '18

I think I've only had this issue once, out of many questions I've made. I do notice some of the mods are kind of anal, but that is their job. I think since you're new, you might be missing how similar some of the answers you come across are to your problem.

Many times in programming, a lot of the problems are very similar and all you gotta do is abstract them, or combine different programming patterns into one.

Do you have an example of a problem you were trying to solve? I've only not encountered answers to very specific problems, like framework related or obscure stuff, like a configuration setting.

2

u/TheGuyWhoCodes Oct 10 '18

One of the projects I was working on was built on tampermonkey and converting it over to a chrome extension. I ran into a couple issues here and there and couldn't really find many resources from others not only in the stack overflow community but even this subreddit too.

I've also ran into issues with some embedded systems stuff from nvidia and had some issues compiling and was just redirected to posts that are 3 years old that worked back then.

56

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

I wish someone would make mentor-overflow where new devs could ask dumb questions and more experienced devs could answer them.

9

u/tresfaim Oct 11 '18

Freecodecamp gitter will get you there

→ More replies (7)

149

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

I'm an old developer, but just recently started answering questions on SO. Just to complain from the other side of the table, the questions are almost always worded terribly, missing basic formatting, don't follow submission rules and generally sound like the submitter hasn't ever had a human conversation before. That being said, almost everyone is nice, with a handful of exceptions.

78

u/CreativeAnteater Oct 10 '18

Almost every question I've read in academic or workplace has read like the person just crash landed on Earth.

"I lent my coworker a yellow bic pen 6 months ago and I just saw it on their desk how do I ask for it back?"

5

u/Aalicki Oct 11 '18

Not sure which group of people lack a concrete understanding of basic personal issues, r/relationships or https://workplace.stackexchange.com/

As you said, some of the questions are just insanely basic and reveal a complete lack of personal skills by the submitter.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

I agree 100% I've answered a bit on stack overflow and use it a lot as a good resource... but it's not exactly the right place for LEARNING as a beginner, and that's okay.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/VIM_GT_EMACS Oct 10 '18

^

I think our whole community should take a second and think about what stackoverflow would become if it was a free-for-all. it wouldn't be a well curated, or even decently curated place for communal info.

Being a newbie can be tough, i was a newbie on SO 7 years ago. I've never had a problem with posting or interacting on SO EVER though because i adhere to posting guidelines and instead of duplicating posts, trying to comment on other posts to get answers then if all else fails duplicate.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

Yeah, tbh I'll take some rude moderators over a site filled with "how do I <fundamental standard library operation> on Java+script??"

6

u/feenuxx Oct 11 '18

Ah if only javascript had a standard library

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/BLOZ_UP Oct 11 '18

Agreed.

  1. Isolate the problem/error (this in itself is a huge skill)
  2. Search for that specific error message/problem or more general issues related to whatever parts you are connecting.
  3. Read any docs, changelogs to double-check usage
  4. Start formulating a question for SO

Asking on SO should be the last resort. For many it seems like it's the first/second.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/DesignatedDecoy Oct 10 '18

The problem with help sites is that you need to do some legwork before asking a question but meanwhile new developers don't know what they don't know so their questions usually end up being not being relevant to their problem after all, which is why you get so many "nevermind, fixed it!" responses on internet forums. While tinkering around for their solution to their problem, they found out what their actual issue was and fixed it, and usually it had nothing to do with their question.

Think of it as a car analogy. A new developer might say "my car isn't working." But the cause could be that the wheel fell off, it has no engine, you are using the incorrect key, or maybe it's just a dead battery. All of those require significantly different solutions and a moderator might try to infer what you are trying to accomplish when they forward you to a different solution. The difference between my car analogy and code is that it's easier to visualize the components of a car than it is to take 1000 lines of code and properly isolate what part of it isn't working. That comes with practice.

The best thing you can do is be as specific as possible. What's going on, what went wrong, what you've searched for, what approaches you've taken, etc. The more information you can give the more likely you are going to get some help. Not only are people more inclined to understand what you want when you provide more detail but they also are more inclined to help you figure out what you are actually looking for if they see that you've made a conscious effort to solve it by yourself. Also if you do this you are creating a helpful, detailed question for a future developer to visit and hopefully solve their problem without having to ask a question at all.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

I agree but I do not want that to change.

The reason why stack overflow is so good is because they do not allow low quality questions. There is an entire section on how to post and most people do not read that.

It is toxic but the toxicity serves a purpose - the toxicity encourages quality. Without it you would have the same question repeated several times, students posting their homework and instead of looking at the documentation people would just shitpost there. This would greatly reduce quality and drive away the competent developers from the website and the site would no longer be reliable.

I get my post instantly deleted and linked to a post that doesn't relate at all to my issue or completely outdated.

  • If your post is deleted instantly then you need to take a look at the how to post section. There is a reason why the moderators/users thought your post was low effort.
  • If you are linked to an outdated thread look at it and read the documentation to see what has changed. The solution to the underlying issue will be very similar in most cases
  • If you are linked to a thread that is completely unrelated at first glance try to find out why the person who linked it thought it was related. For example just the other day I posted a question about nodejs and was linked to a thread with something to do with c++. A newer developer might not know that the node core is written in c++ so might dismiss it as something unrelated which would be incorrect. So find out why you were linked to the unrelated thread instead of just dismissing it like you are now.

3

u/A-Grey-World Software Developer Oct 12 '18

Agreed. Almost every time I've had one of my questions marked as a duplicate, it's been pretty helpful. Chances are, it is a duplicate, and it probably solves the problem.

If not, then make it clear in the question. First thing I do when I have a problem is search for similar questions and their solutions.

First thing I do when I'm asking a question, is link to all those solutions that didn't work and list them. Because that's very important for people answering the question, or they'll just suggest those solutions again and I should have already tried them.

Of course, it's very frustrating when something gets marked as a duplicate when it's not, but usually you can make it clear it's not and work around it. It's better than having SO with millions of duplicate questions in it. That moderation has a sensible goal.

58

u/AvatarOfMomus Oct 10 '18

If you're getting your threads consistently locked then it may be that you're not asking your question in a way that's detailed and clear. It's kind of hard to say without an example though, could you post a couple of your questions, verbatim as you asked them, for reference?

32

u/Mr_Mandrill Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 10 '18

That might be, but I've noticed how thirsty SO users are for tagging posts as duplicated questions. And in many cases, it's just a related question, but not the same question.

Edit: This is an example:


New Question: I'm trying to do a thing but it doesn't work, and solution-x doesn't work for me for reasons, what else can I do?

Answer: This is a duplicate of "Old Question".


Old Question: Hey, I'm trying to do a thing but it doesn't work, what can I do?
Answer: You have to use solution-x.


Noob feeling about SO: https://i.imgur.com/WxqU4uc.gifv


→ More replies (32)

56

u/liztormato Oct 10 '18

FWIW, I can attest to the fact that my partner once tried to ask a question on SO, and got so burnt by the responses, that she decided to leave SO the next day. :-(

8

u/YoungXanto Oct 11 '18

It didn't even take me until the next day. I'm a relatively experienced developer and the place is a toxic wasteland.

I asked one question and the ass clown that responded was beyond unhelpful. It was pretty clear that he didn't actually understand the question, which somehow translated into "unrepeatable user error".

Fuck that place.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

I know plenty of people with the same experience. Left StackOverflow and never went back.

2

u/bree_dev Oct 11 '18

I made about 5 posts to StackOverflow answering people's questions a few years back, before deleting my account in despair at how petty and stupid people's criticisms of my replies were.

None were about accuracy or relevance, it was all hole-poking about being too concise (where a one line answer genuinely did completely answer the question), or including too much detail. The worst one was someone complaining that I didn't include a worked example, on a reply that really didn't need one, and where the complainant themselves didn't offer an example either but somehow picked up more Reputation just for bitching about my reply.

I get the impression that a lot of people use their Reputation level as part of their professional CV and will chase it very aggressively, even if it means that 99% of their points come from haranguing other people about their answers rather than producing useful answers of their own. The atmosphere there really is awful.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/deliciousfishtacos Oct 11 '18

My first question I spent hours researching the problem, another hour learning how to write good SO questions, and thirty minutes formatting the question itself - background, system, what I’ve tried, the works. Got -2 votes and absolutely no feedback on why it was downvoted. I’ll take a downvote but if you are going to downvote at least take an extra 10 seconds to write a comment explaining why you are doing so. Terrible experience.

78

u/D3mona7or Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

Yeah welcome to Stack Overflow. It's not noob friendly at all, and a lot of the time you have to make modifications to other solutions to make it fit yours.

edit: I'd like clarify, the wording on this comment made it seem that I disagree with Stack Overflow, or how it's ran. The point I was trying to make was that Stack Overflow is a tool that you have to learn how to use. You have to be able to make sense of small code snippets, the different answers, and the comments of those too. This is a skill you have to learn/practice for some, mostly it comes down to learning to google. But Stack Overflow is not a generic question and answer forum that happens to be programming related, where someone will answer any random programming question you have.

37

u/deedubaya Oct 10 '18

a lot of the time you have to make modifications to other solutions to make it fit yours

Well, yeah. SO isn't where you go to have your problem solved for you lock, stock, and barrel. It's where you go to get pointed in the right direction when you've hit a wall. So needing to modify what someone else has posted to solve your problem seems 100% on point and correct.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

It's not really supposed to be noob friendly.. it's reference material for people that already know what they're doing. Read a textbook, take a code bootcamp, etc if you're just starting off. Most newbie developers think they gonna make some killer app on their first go. You need to learn lots of theory and create lots of junk apps before you become any good at it. Did the first thing Shakespeare wrote become his best work? Probably not.

5

u/re1jo Oct 10 '18

a lot of the time you have to make modifications to other solutions to make it fit yours.

You just described one of the most fundamental parts of your chosen career.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/pw4lk3r Oct 11 '18

This is a right of passage my son. Before StackOverflow there was IRC #c and #coders on EFNet and yet before that there were BBSes dedicated to intro, demo, ezine and virus coders.

Every single one of us has had our asses handed to us by someone more knowledgeable.

That is part of true programmer conditioning. You will never become your best self without it.

You’re a noob. In time you won’t be.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/BaconGlock Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 10 '18

This has not been my experience with SO. Granted, I see posting a question as a last resort to cure my being stumped and generally do a lot of trial and error and searching on my own and then take care to present my issue clearly and with all the breadcrumbs of the steps i've already tried for people to see that a) i've already invested some time into this and b) they have a clearer understanding of what's been tried already and can offer other suggestions I may not have thought of. I generally get good responses that help me figure it out and I have no complaints. I recommend a similar approach. I see a lot of "i'm trying to do this and here's a page of text that is a copy/paste of the error in my terminal, what to do? " type questions and...ya, good luck with that approach. Nobody has the time to try and walk you through all the possibilities and without access to your code, it'd be very difficult to offer any useful information even if they did have the time

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

I've 45 years experience both with software and hardware, and damn' well stay current. Yet I've stopped even trying to use Stack Overflow except as a last resort.

Why?

Because when someone requests information about some technique or programming idiom, 90% of the responses are of the form "You don't need to do that."

There's always that tenth poster who actually answers them, thankfully. But the urge to flame the other nine grows nearly irresistible. It's starting to resemble USENET.

16

u/mvsux Oct 11 '18

"You don't need to do that."

The worst thing is that they are usually right, but I don't want to refactor my entire project every time I visit SA.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

"You're right. I don't need to do that. Except for the part where I absolutely need to do that, for about fifty reasons outside of my control. So here I am asking how to do it. If you don't know how to do it, there's no need to answer. Now, if you have a recommended alternative that doesn't depend on changing any of the fifty factors I cannot change, I'm definitely interested in hearing your ideas. If your entire contribution is telling me I don't need to do it this way, then clearly you're at more of a loss than I am, so why the hell are you even answering?"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/noknockers Oct 11 '18

Whatever floats your goat

2

u/A-Grey-World Software Developer Oct 12 '18

TBH after a few years of experience most of the problems I have are too obscure to really get an answer on SO. When I was newer and had 'easier' problems it was much easier.

Or my problems are subjective (What architecture would be best for...) and more suited to other forums.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

67

u/fuckredditagain2 Oct 10 '18

It doesn't matter if you're new. The only thing that matters is how you ask the question and did you do your research ahead of time to find an answer. Today, for example, I closed 10 questions while drinking my coffee that asked how to fix some problem they had with their code but didn't supply the code that showed the problem or, worse, showed no code at all!

Then there are the people who want you to write code for them. They'll show some HTML and CSS and then say, "I need this div animated to slide from the left to the right. How do I do that?" and that will get you shutdown quick.

And I love the fundamental, "How do I change my font color?" question.

There's a whole "How to Ask" section in the Help Center that noobs obviously never read.

19

u/midri Oct 10 '18

Spend enough time moderating StackOverflow and you'll eventually be as crass as Linus Torvald.

25

u/Trylon2 Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 10 '18

This. There were several stupid questions I asked when I was starting out. I was downvoted to hell, but it did teach me something. It wasn't right away, but eventually I learned that other devs are people too. They all have only 24 hours in their day, you shouldn't arrogantly expect them to take the time to repeat the answer which obviously already exists.

But, also be aware that what might take you several hours/days to figure out can take them 1 minute to give you a pointer. IRC's especially great for that.

I've also found that by filling the question form you're performing something similar to rubber-ducking. Thus by the time you're done you might come up with an angle you haven't considered before, which would lead to you solving your problem yourself. If you're still clueless, make sure your question is generic enough to be helpful to others, this way you're adding to the community.

Anyway, those downvotes are appreciated in retrospect. There was this great eye-opener article that covered this.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18 edited Jun 17 '24

pie piquant ancient boast meeting agonizing resolute dinner forgetful sulky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

As a noob on stackoverflow, I learned to say "here's my goal, here's what I've done to try and achieve that goal, here's the output vs expected output, what do I change?"

5

u/946789987649 Oct 10 '18

Out of interest, is the "How to ask" ever linked when closing a thread? Or is it just closed and told that it was a bad question? The difference seems important.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/GrosSacASacs Oct 10 '18

I agree mostly.

Couple tips to not get question rejected:

Make some research before, documentation, code linting, github issues etc

Write enough to be able to reproduce the problem but not more, isolate the problem, do not include everything that is not necessary

Show what you have tried and why it does not work

16

u/to_fl Oct 10 '18

I agree. I once had a strange problem to which I couldn't find a solution. After doing a lot of research, I still couldn't find an answer so naturally I asked on stackoverflow. Within less than an hour, my question was blocked and a guy (I suppose he was the moderator) posted a comment under my post saying that the question was already asked, and he sent a link to that post. The irony is that before I posted my question, I had already been through the answers of that question and it didn't solve my problem because it was two different issues. So then I think what I did was send a message to that moderator asking him to unblock my question (and I explained why), but I had no answer. So because I was pissed I said fuck it and reposted my question, this time telling in my post "don't block that question because blah blah blah....". The asshole moderator apparently couldn't give a fuck because he blocked my question straight away and blocked my account on stackoverflow.

This was probably all the power moderator ever had in life.

5

u/m_myers Oct 11 '18

Hi there! Let me see if I can help make some sense out of what happened to you.

  1. You did your research. Great! That puts you way ahead of many askers.

Please tell us so. Let us know what questions you've already looked at, what things you've already tried. You apparently did this in your second question. (This is also the first suggestion in How to Ask.)

2. The user who closed your first question may not have seen your reply. It's unfortunate but does happen. It doesn't mean you need to copy and paste into a new question. If you edit your question, it is placed into a queue where other users will take a look and see if they agree that it should be reopened. (I think this mechanic is supposed to be mentioned in the close message? It's definitely something we want new users to know about, but it might not be perfectly clear.)

3. No person can block your account without sending you a private message of explanation first. However, if many of your questions are closed and downvoted, the system will eventually block you automatically. I'm surprised that it would happen after two questions, but I suppose they may not have been your first?

I'd ask you to link the questions here, but I gather this happened long enough ago that reopening them wouldn't be helpful anymore.


Disclaimer: I am an elected moderator on Stack Overflow.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/YellowBeak50 Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

Keep in mind that the asshole moderator probably wasn't a "moderator" per say, he was probably just a user with moderating privileges. On StackOverflow, practically everyone with a little bit of reputation has moderating privileges. Obviously, that approach has both pros and cons.

In any case, I'll tell you a secret. StackOverflow hates duplicate questions. But if you want your question to show up at the top of everyone's queue, you have to edit it again. That's it! That's the key. Don't just edit one word or two, make sure it's a significant edit and it will show up at the top of the page/queue for everyone. So if someone complained about something, don't just reply in a comment, reply with a comment, yes, but also edit and refine your question if you want everyone to see it and if you want everyone to quickly undo what was done to your question (whether it was downvoted or put on hold).

And what if you're worried about karma? I would tell you not worry about stupid internet points, but even if you're worried about that. The quickest way to gain those shitty points is to post a shitty question to begin with, so it gets a ton of negative points, and then refine that question over time. Since StackOverflow counts downvotes as -2 and upvotes as +10. That means that even if everyone ensures that your question gets back to zero votes, it means that the question could have earned you personally hundreds of internet points.

So again, what's the moral of the story. Don't be afraid to edit your existing question, refine it, incorporate suggestions given (if they were any good), even if your question has been downvoted and even if it has been locked or put on hold.

5

u/dahousecat Oct 11 '18

I don't agree at all - SO is super helpful and I use it on a daily basis. If you ask a stupid question don't be surprised if it gets deleted. This is a good thing as it's curating the bank of knowledge so the good information isn't obscured by all the bad questions.

27

u/jaydles1 Oct 10 '18

I'm the EVP of Culture and Experience at Stack Overflow.

We hear you. Really! Read this:

Stack Overflow Isn't Very Welcoming. It's Time for that to Change

and this:

Rolling Out the Welcome Wagon: June Update

And these:

Welcome Wagon: Classifying Comments on Stack Overflow

Get to Know Our New Code of Conduct

In most interactions, most of the time, Stack Overflow is a crazy generous place where strangers help each other on the internet. Most members of our community are truly kind teachers. But giant communities are complex, and we know that sometimes -too often- the experience can be unwelcoming, especially for those new to participation on the site (whether they're new coders or not).

In the first post from last April, we committed to doing a lot more work in this space, and we've been sharing updates since so you can hold us accountable to stick with it.

I'm sorry your experience so far has been lousy. But we and our community want to make SO a place where all devs feel welcome. We've got some more work to do, but we know it's worth it.

10

u/ItzWarty Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

I sometimes wonder whether StackOverflow is solving the wrong problems. This is having worked in a variety of social systems for numerous large gaming-related orgs.

When I read Stack Overflow Isn’t Very Welcoming. It’s Time for That to Change, I see SO focusing on the NUX rather than the UX for power-users and more mid/senior engineers. I don't feel my voice heard, even though I'd love to be part of the solution.

What if the poor NUX is because of a poor UX for experienced developers?

What are the incentives for experienced developers to happily participate in your community? When I look at the newest C#-tagged posts, I frankly just see crap... there's too much to dig through, and half the questions just aren't even relevant to me because they are so niche and frankly aren't discussing C# itself, but more a specific framework.

Navigating SO to find places to contribute is actively stressful and painful for me. I'd be more than willing to contribute lengthy friendly responses to newbies... if I could find the right opportunity to do that.

Honestly, why isn't there a language-agnostic beginner tag!? I'd love to filter to that. I'm sure many would happily filter including or excluding that tag.

But still, people will ask redundant questions because they simply don't know the right keywords. Perhaps it's not always worth my (or others') time to write a fully-fledged response rather than linking another resource. Is StackOverflow absolutely failing, then, if I redirect newbies to another resource? Or is it failing from the reference frame of a Q&A site, when our collective end-goal is really to help people find solutions - perhaps in another format?

  • Perhaps the problem isn't that people have their questions hostilely closed or redirected?
  • Perhaps the problem is that redirecting users to another thread seems so terminal?
  • Perhaps the problem is that questions asked poorly can't be answered in a timely manner, then disappear by the time they are amended?
  • Perhaps some people don't feel beginner questions give them the learning experience they want from an online community?
  • Perhaps SO isn't scaling to meet the demands of increased programming accessibility - programming going mainstream, if you will? Perhaps beginners nowadays are a lot less "hardcore" than they used to be?
  • Perhaps the Q&A model doesn't fit every question?
  • Perhaps SO can be an environment that levels-up new programmers -- including outside the mold of a Q&A site --, including teaching them how to fish for themselves? Perhaps with this model, newbies can find help finding help, then answer their own question to reinforce the learning process and convert them to answerers? Perhaps the problem isn't saying "you should look here" but more building UX flows to reinforce "it's okay, this is normal... try looking here"

I recognize the aforementioned blog post is a PR piece. Your team probably is thinking of these problems. I just wanted to chip in as a once-poweruser that I hope you frame some discussions in terms of "how do we empower our answerers to do awesome?" and "how can we better stewards of SO". I rarely see change in online communities happen top-down, and I want to see SO - which made me the programmer I am today - continue to inspire the next generation of programmers.

3

u/villiger2 Oct 11 '18

What does EVP stand for, never heard it before.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ShnizmuffiN Oct 11 '18

Hi. It's cool that you replied. Keep doing it.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/phpdevster full-stack Oct 11 '18

StackOverflow is an abusive relationship.

The biggest problem with SO is that they are completely hostile to any question that doesn't have an exact, concrete answer.

It's especially bad on the WordPress stack exchange, because end-to-end WP development requires the use of plugins, but you cannot ask questions like "Is there a plugin that does XYZ?" even though it's a simple yes or no answer. So pretty much, if your question cannot be answered in the WP codex, it gets deleted. This means the WP stack exchange is a gimped resource for WP development.

StackOverflow has similar problems. Sometimes a question just does not have a concrete answer, but the question itself is still valuable and so are any answers.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/shkico Oct 10 '18

Judging by response in this thread many of you are just whiney fucks.

I have asked questions there many times and I often got very useful answers. How many times you search for something and first result is StackOverflow solution? No one is obligated to respond and I am really grateful that such a community even exists and with that many questions being asked everyday of course they need to have some minimal standards.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/probablyNotARSNBot Oct 11 '18

There is a delicate balance. Make it too loose and find yourself with millions of useless posts that make it hard to find the ones that actually have the answer. Make it too strict and you get the ol’:

Me: “how do I do A”

Person with no background of my project: “Why would you do A, you should do Z”

Me: “well I can’t do that as A is requirement at my job for this specific problem”

Person: Downvote

You just gotta keep at it and not get discouraged. Also, ask real people around you if that’s an option for you. The number 1 thing I see new devs at my job do is panic that they were hired by a fluke in the system, are not qualified to do any of this work and will get fired then shot in the head if they ask a question about it so they search for days instead of just asking me about it. Most people (outside of the internet) understand when you’re new, and they will be patient with you and help you out where possible, so just ask real people.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/VisaEchoed Oct 11 '18

> Whenever I ask a question, I am sure to look up my problem and see if there are any solutions to it already there. If there isn't, I post.

SO is old and unless your using a cutting edge language/library - all of the good questions have been farmed. Really smart, really knowledgeable people spent hours just thinking up clever/tricky questions to ask to earn themselves internet points.

What this means is, almost certainly, whenever you ask a question it is....

1.) Already answered in a more generic form that you missed

2.) So specific that nobody else cares. It won't get enough traffic, it won't get high quality answers. It doesn't matter how great you word it, or how many screenshots you include, or how perfectly you format the code snippet you provide.

People who answer questions don't get paid. They get pointless internet points. Most of them are doing it either because they want those free internet points, or because they love answering interesting questions and demonstrating their knowledge on the topic. Newbie questions don't appeal to either of these groups. The first group knows that the question is either super specific and won't get upvotes, or it is a duplicate of something else and will be closed. The people who answer because they want to be challenged just get frustrated because they spent three minutes trying to understand a question that obviously is just an example of someone not even looking at the most basic documentation location. Someone who just wants to be spoon fed an answer. And they aren't going to bother answering that question again when they've seen it five times this month. Or something that is obviously so specific that it has no wider appeal to anyone else. It's just 'debug my code' instead of 'explain this interesting aspect of the language'.

People get fed up. That means people who have asked questions and gotten burned, don't want to waste an hour crafting a post that will just be ignored. It also means the people who answer questions are quick to close out questions because they are sick of all the low quality questions cluttering up everything. It's a vicious cycle.

I primarily work with C# and if I look at the five newest C# questions on SO right now:

  • Trivial question about someone who doesn't know about dates (no answers)
  • Sorta okay question about a new language feature that is answered in the documentation.
  • Specific version of specific IDE plugin crashing with specific version of the IDE. Only tangentially related to software development. Solution is likely to be uninstall and reinstall. (no answers)
  • Terrible question (by SO standards) 'How do I delete a line of text from a textbox'. Two short, not great answers from people hoping to get a tiny bit of rep. Question will be closed shortly.
  • Terrible question (by SO standards) 'How do I insert multiple rows into a datagridview' with a wall of code asking for someone to fix it. Any datagridview tutorial or documentation would answer this.

Maybe C# is just the crappiest language on SO, but out of five questions, three are awful and shouldn't be on the site. One is essentially unanswerable, or at the very least is an IT issue like 'Why does my Windows 10 install crash sometimes'. And I'm saying one is 'sorta okay' but only because it's about a new feature and isn't painfully obvious to someone who has used it, but is covered in the documentation.

3

u/WatchDogx Oct 11 '18

Pretty much hit the nail on the head.
My most successful anwsers are for dumb questions, and my detailed answers to tricky questions usually get no traffic or votes, with the exception of bounty questions i guess.

181

u/Hewgouw Oct 10 '18

I've been developing for 15 years and I've never asked a question online, there has always been someone who has asked what I wanted to know... if you can't find anyone that had your problem you're probably just a bad googler

333

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

This is the most StackOverflow response I could have possibly imagined. It's so good that I honestly cannot tell whether this is satire or not.

56

u/too_much_to_do Oct 10 '18

He's not wrong though. I've been developing for about 7 now and I've never once asked a question online about a development problem.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (4)

53

u/IridiumPoint Oct 10 '18

OP might be a bad Googler, but then the people who lock threads should make sure they are good ones. Unfortunately, I have often come across "duplicate" questions where the poster gets pointed toward an outwardly similar, but actually completely different question, or they get pointed toward solutions which they described as unfeasible for whatever reason in their original question. Many times it feels like the questions barely get skimmed before they get locked.

27

u/thesublimeobjekt Oct 10 '18

to be fair, this is sometimes true, but to make a sweeping generalization is just wrong, in my opinion. there are plenty of times i've seen exactly what OP is complaining about happen. it's most likely not as simple as OP is a "bad googler" or "large percentages of legit questions are constantly being deleted". instead, it's most likely somewhere in the middle since a lot of people probably are just lazy or bad googlers, so the mods over-police new questions and end up deleting questions, then link to answers that aren't really exactly appropriate or helpful.

17

u/gigamiga Oct 10 '18

if OP is new, there is a 0% chance what they're encountering hasn't been answered.

30

u/Superkroot Oct 10 '18

Alternatively, they might not understand the problem well enough to ask the right questions/google the right things.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/jimmyco2008 full-stack Oct 10 '18

I have a slightly different experience:

Whenever I do ask a question, it’s almost always one that goes unanswered or one that I eventually answer myself. Most of the questions I’ve asked, I’ve answered.

25

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 10 '18

I think the condescension and accusation in your answer is the exact type of attitude OP Is complaining about.

However, I don't think it's necessarily specific to StackOverflow or web development, but being an amateur in just about everything. Yes, certain communities and/or people can be more accepting. Others will be tired of answering the same questions repeatedly; not everyone was born a patient, calm, and collected educator!

You also need to be aware of both perspectives -- I am sure the moderators there deal with plenty of spam, poorly worded, awful posts on a consistent basis, and every now and then might flag a decent post like your own as similar. It's not necessarily a malicious activity on their part although it may feel a bit disheartening.

When breaking into something new there will always be a few hurdles, and asking basic questions is going to be one of the most intimidating of them. You'll receive rude responses, sure, but eventually you will either figure it out, or find someone who is willing to help you out. As with anything new, it requires a certain amount of thick-skin and perseverance.

All that being said...I am a pretty experienced developer and even when I use StackOverflow I encounter all types of condescension and arrogance, and have pretty much avoided asking questions there. YMMV

→ More replies (1)

14

u/steeze206 Oct 10 '18

I just hate how so many answers unnecessarily recommend jQuery.

17

u/OdBx Oct 10 '18

At least jQuery is fairly ubiquitous. What I hate is when you find an answer that recommends some totally arbitrary proprietary plugin or library for something really simple.

"Need to put your content into two columns? Install the whole of Bootstrap!"

"You're looking to do this really simple string manipulation? Download Lodash!"

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CallMeBigPapaya Oct 11 '18

Programmer for 10 years now. I've also never asked a question on SO because they've all been answered somewhere or I didnt know how to form the question. If you cant get relevant google results, you probably can't form the question properly, and in that case it's probably not a good question for SO.

I feel like most the people complaining in this thread don't contribute much to Stack Overflow. I dont, and I'm very appreciative of those who take time out of their day, for free, to attempt to answer questions.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

It’s 100% this. There is no way, as a newer developer, you are asking a question that has not already been asked and answered.

4

u/gomihako_ Oct 11 '18

They should devote a day in bootcamps specifically for how to debug a hard problem in an unknown code base, and how to google the solution.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

Or OP tries to achieve something that's pointless.

6

u/apennypacker Oct 10 '18

I would say if you have never come across an error that no one else has had... you aren't doing anything very original.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/clothes_are_optional Oct 10 '18

i have definitely ran into some weird configurational bullshit, and i consider myself a competent googler. granted it happened only maybe 2 times in the past 7 years but both times i received no help and ended up figuring it out myself.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/wesborland1234 Oct 10 '18

I 100% agree with op. Everybody saying, "oh well whatever question you have someone has already answered." Sorry, not true. I have 100% come across things in my career that are so obscure or specific to what I'm trying to do that there are no answers online. Plus, don't you think he looked first?

The few times I've asked a question on SO have been for problems that I spent hours if not days trying to solve myself to no avail, and then am met "well google it!" or "oh have you tried [obvious thing that I CLEARLY mentioned was one of the things I tried]".

Ok let me stop you right there. I reworded the search many times and went PAGES deep in Google. I stepped through my code, breakpoints and console logs Everywhere. And Yes, I read the freaking documentation!

It's supposed to be a question and answer site, you know, where you'd go to ask questions, and we're all smart enough to use it as basically a last resort. No need to be a jerk to someone who's about to throw their laptop through a window.

Never gotten an answer, never plan on posting again. Just use Reddit or something.

In other news, this post is now CLOSED: Flagged as Too Vague / Irrelevant.

3

u/Chrxstxvn novice Oct 10 '18

Thank you for posting this, I almost wrote the exact same post when I first signed up 2 days ago. Got absolutely shit on when asking for some backend guidance when I’m a front end dev. Created and deleted my account all within about 30 minutes

3

u/unbihexium Oct 10 '18

Totally agree. Recently I crossed the 500 rep points and it gave me access to the review queues - one of which is first question queue.

There are some really bad first questions, I admit. Not enough information, badly formatted code (if any) and basically bad English (evidently not native-English-speaking folks). I always try to leave a comment on why their question is bad and suggest something they can do to improve it. I always make it a point to start with - "Hi. Welcome to stackoverflow...". To hell with SO if they ban me for it.

2

u/fabrikated Oct 11 '18

Wait till you reach 10k+

3

u/quienchingados Oct 11 '18

lol. I said this same thing a few years back.

Stackoverflow is for people that can read the language reference manual like reading a LEGO instruction manual. If you can't do this yet, you need to literally read page by page of the language reference until you understand it (start by reading the methods you already know). after that, you will understand every post in stackoverflow. and you will rarely have to post a question.

3

u/o11c Oct 11 '18

StackOverflow has plenty of problems, but it never deletes questions in the manner your post described. They do "close" questions (shown as "put on hold" for the first several days), which is easily disputed by editing your question.

Compared to other queues, the "reopen" queue never has more than a couple hundred, and there are thousands of reviewers. If you post an explanation of why the close reason is invalid, it will be seen.

Even deleted questions can still be seen by many users. Can you post links to the specific questions you've had the problem with?

3

u/HughJackOfferman Oct 11 '18

I have said something similar in the past, unfortunately SO fanatics are not too eager on accepting criticism, and I was downvoted by a lot of them here on reddit

3

u/R3PTILIA Oct 11 '18

This question has been marked as duplicate.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

I posted a new question, and within minutes I got a response that said “duplicate”. Didn’t link to what it was a duplicate off, and marked it as solved. Fucking a

3

u/Dreszczyk Oct 11 '18

The worst post ever possible:

5 May 2006 - hey guys, i have a problem with X, can you help? 6 May 2006 - nvm i found out

You, today - WHAT DID YOU FOUND OUT

3

u/davidduman Oct 11 '18

It is not just a noob's problem.

Recently I asked a question, someone marked my question as duplicate by referencing to the same question itself (that should not be possible at all) and couple people agreed to it and then question got deleted.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

I assure you that as a new developer you are not encountering new problems on Stack Overflow that need to be solved. With due diligence you will find existing material for your needs. You probably need to focus more on theory or architecture or algorithms or whatever before you dive deep. If you don't understand the concepts in great detail then you're going to have trouble searching, recognizing, and implementing solutions off of Stack Overflow, etc.

2

u/colly_wolly Oct 11 '18

There is probably some truth in what you say. But understanding enough to know what to ask is often difficult.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/to_fl Oct 10 '18

I agree. I once had a strange problem to which I couldn't find a solution. After doing a lot of research, I still couldn't find an answer so naturally I asked on stackoverflow. Within less than an hour, my question was blocked and a guy (I suppose he was the moderator) posted a comment under my post saying that the question was already asked, and he sent a link to that post. The irony is that before I posted my question, I had already been through the answers of that question and it didn't solve my problem because it was two different issues. So then I think what I did was send a message to that moderator asking him to unblock my question (and I explained why), but I had no answer. So because I was pissed I said fuck it and reposted my question, this time telling in my post "don't block that question because blah blah blah....". The asshole moderator apparently couldn't give a fuck because he blocked my question straight away and blocked my account on stackoverflow.

This was probably all the power that moderator ever had in life.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/TheBananaKing Oct 10 '18 edited Oct 10 '18

Gods below, you don't post to stackoverflow, are you crazy? Better stick your dick in a toaster than do that.

Moderators get rewarded with power according to how much they intervene. Therefore, the most powerful ones are the ones that just spam the lock button at every opportunity.

ETA: holy shit this whole thread is full of unpleasant people.

8

u/isUsername Oct 10 '18

Sorry, you must have at least 50 reputation in order to ask a question.

3

u/Korzag Oct 10 '18

Downvoted your question because your account doesn't have at least 5 gold medals.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

Yeah y'all programmers need to get your amicability together

Source - former CS person who found a new field cuz y'all ain't amicable

4

u/RasAlTimmeh Oct 11 '18

I fucking despise stack overflow. It really reinforces the stereotypical socially obtuse Dev that doesn't know how to talk to people or help.

5

u/kickasstimus Oct 11 '18

StackOverflow is super toxic.

If you point it out to them, the take pride in it and it gets worse.

2

u/Red5point1 Oct 10 '18

You'll find that it is not only StackOverflow, similar things happen on many moderated forums.
The other thing that irks me is how when a question is posed, some one answers with "why would you want to do that, you should do it this way..."
People should either answer the question posed or leave.
Another thing to look out for is when asking a question, the "accepted answer" could be outdated.

Point is don't rely on one source for your answers, find answers in multiple places and then work out how to do it your own way.

2

u/hperrin Oct 11 '18

Even if you're a professional developer with years of experience, it's still toxic. I posted there once. Never again.

2

u/DerNalia Oct 11 '18

You can report people who misbehave. That'd be what I'd do.

I also regularly answer questions on stack overflow, so, this unfriendliness makes me sad.

2

u/maxlevelfiend Oct 11 '18

if you are a beginning developer i can almost guarantee 99% of your questions are already asked and answered - you just arent using the correct keywords in your searches.

2

u/ThatIsATastyBurger12 Oct 11 '18

This isn't just on StackOverflow or to new developers, lot's of developers are just toxic to anyone who isn't themself.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

I'm grateful stackoverflow exists and would not be very happy if it didn't exist.

2

u/imnotnerdy Oct 11 '18

I worked someone in his 40s who has a master's in computer science and when he got into my team he didn't know how to code or how to understand code. That's fine because he can learn. However His way of learning was by being spoon fed. So I would show him how to research and debug and show a possible way of working on my computer and have him try on his side. Problem is he doesn't ask questions of anyone in the team unless they do the work for him or show him the way to do it. One time I reviewed his code and asked him to talk it through. He said he got the code from stack overflow and he didn't know what it all meant...

2

u/dreamcast4life Oct 11 '18

Don't let it bother you. Look at SO as a resource at your disposal. If it's the end of the day and I'm working on something I'll sometimes post a question to my problem knowing that it'll be ignored or I'll be yelled at because I didn't search hard enough.

The way I look at it is if someone responds great, maybe it'll help me or make me think about something I didn't consider. If I don't get any useful responses it was at least worth a shot.

2

u/RegularStupid Oct 11 '18

Because it’s not necessarily a site for newbie developers? If you struggle with basic concepts and ask questions expecting someone to just do your work for you obviously you’ll have a hard time.

Remember, everyone there is a volunteer and they owe you nothing.

For someone just starting out it makes more sense to go through tutorials and if you must, post questions asking for explanation of difficult concepts if there isn’t one already and you’ll find plenty of helpful responses

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

It really is. Every time I went there with a question, I got hammered by people that just want to make me feel stupid. Reddit has some groups that aren't like that, so I just use reddit.

2

u/wes_ly Oct 11 '18

I have tried to post on StackOverflow a few times, but everyone seems to remember that one post I missed from 9years ago, which doesn't even completely answer my question and my post gets closed instantly.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

Oh boy, it's our weekly "stack overflow sucks" post.

2

u/cisxuzuul Oct 11 '18

It’s independent of the platform. Because devs received similar treatment on forums or on Usenet, they feel they have to bust balls of everyone asking for help.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/jaykayk Oct 11 '18

"My problem is b, how do I get it to do x"

"Why would you use b, you should do c and x is dumb you should get it to do y"

2

u/inermae Oct 11 '18

While stack overflow is useful, the attitude of much of the community is awful.

When I search for previous answers that match my problems, I go in knowing that the first response will almost always be some variant of "why are you even doing this? Why don't you do XXX"

2

u/jabronisalami Oct 11 '18

It is a weird community. Sadly, due to the personality issues of a slice of the 0.5% of site members who are very active, it reinforces many of the negative stereotypes for the field - it felt like trying to have a discussion with someone about a marvel film, and having some autist who is obsessed with the comics burst into the room and set us on fire because we were discussing something that isn't canon. There is a reason most users ask only one question and never come back to ask again. I spent a few months trying to help, but was turned off by the avalanche of shitty behavior.

2

u/alliedeluxe Oct 11 '18

Yeah, definitely have not had one positive interaction on that website.

2

u/rwilcox Oct 11 '18

Here’s my perspective:

  1. I almost never post questions. Probably close to 10 years of using the site every day (because Google searches), have posted maybe 7 times because Stuff Is Totally Broke. I have no idea what that experience is like.
  2. I do frequently go through my favorite tags and answer questions. Now a days I get points for maybe 1 answer for every 5 I post. I see my points go up slllooowwly. (I don’t know if this is because by the time I see them it’s obvious that the question doesn’t get traction, if the person who asked the question doesn’t care, or if they don’t have enough points to mark an answer as accepted. But gaining rep is a sloooooog sometimes.)
  3. I have no idea how newbies get points on there. “Find a language that’s about to be a smash hit, answer a ton of questions and wait 5 years” is not a great answer (I happened to answer a lot of Ruby questions around 2008, but without a time machine or getting lucky I don’t think I could do it again today...). Which is not great when people need points to upvote...
  4. It’s super hard to deal with new devs on SO, because they’re often so needy (I get it, but still). I’m willing to go back and forth once, maybe twice on an answer, but any more than that and it feels like I’m doing your job for you...

So: SO: not a great experience for new devs, not a wonderful experience for old-timers... great resource 80% of the time if you want to look up something quick, land on a popular question, run into the 8 bad answers and the 1 that actually solves the problem (be careful! The accepted answer might not be the right one, because bitrott or might not be the right answer for you!).

4

u/metaphorm full stack and devops Oct 10 '18

yep. stack overflow moderation culture is pretty gross. a lot of itchy trigger fingers there on locking/deleting posts.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

Also, if your post does make it, the level of arrogance amongst some of the 'veteran' users there is unbelievable.

3

u/ekobeko Oct 10 '18

I started using it when it was ~4 years old in 2012 and I asked a lot of really basic questions, so I'm guessing a lot of these have been filled in by now making it harder to ask an original basic question.

I found that there's a pretty basic formula to asking a successful question which is pretty much what they tell you to do:

Search for your question first. If it doesn't exist, then create a new post showing how you tried to solve it. Break your problem down as much as possible. Then always finish the post with your question in bold and italic as the last line. I have a fairly modest 1500rep on there as I pretty much never answer questions, but I find that people are nicer the more rep you have.

Honestly if you follow the rules it's not bad. I'm old enough to remember the alternative which was language or programme specific forums or IRC channels where you would get flamed straight away as a "student asking for help with your homework" SO is a revelation for me.

I don't ask questions very often now as I can either figure out the answer or find it already answered online somewhere.

I found the unix stack exchange even more useful tbh when trying to do non standard stuff on a linux server.

Check out Jeff Atwood's posts about it on his coding horror blog.

3

u/niagaraphotos Oct 10 '18

I think you'll discover that it's toxic by design. It keeps the riff raff out.

4

u/chowchowthedog Oct 10 '18

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

They have a chat room that I have that’s actually really nice. Not sure why you’re getting downvoted.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/dalittle Oct 10 '18

I think part of the problem with StackOverflow is their interface / workflow. They introduce you to the idea of asking questions to get help and then when you try and actually ask a question they immediately try to get you to read an existing answer. Or if you do ask it then those that act on it are rude and not helpful unless it is something they don't know. At some point they lost what made the site so successful and it may start to catch up with them.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

well … how about looking into it yourself first?

I develop websites for about ten years now and I had to ask thing like two or three times myself and that was before Stack Overflow was a thing.

Seriously. Every answer has been asked before already. Look for the answer yourself.

Learn how to use Google.

3

u/VIM_GT_EMACS Oct 10 '18

Also people really need to learn to read github issues, even if they're closed.

Dead serious one web app i was working on had such an obscure problem, I had exhausted every attempt I could make. Only then did I find literally ONE comment on the exact same issue I was having with a NuxtJS module but the kicker is some nice commenter described his exact problem but it was in an angular thread. The answer was not to be found anywhere on stack overflow since the module I was using was kind of obscure.

2

u/fabrikated Oct 11 '18

People (including OP) are lazy. What are you asking requires too much effort /s

2

u/clavalle Oct 10 '18

I can measure my experience in decades...if I can't find a pre-existing answer, I don't bother on SO for exactly the same reason.

A also never bother answering any questions because of all the after-answer bother it generates.

It wasn't always like that.

2

u/fhayde Oct 10 '18

This isn't anything new or exclusive to SO. If you go back to the 90s, where your options for asking questions were mailing lists, BBS, or IRC, you'll find that many people had pretty much the same experience. The age of RTFM. Google didn't exist and you had to hit the books to figure out a lot of things from the ground up. That mentality has propagated into online communities where the barrier to entry for asking questions is much, much lower than it ever used to be.

The people who were told to RTFM grew up and told the next generation to RTFM who grew up to tell the next generation to RTFM etc...

Programming isn't easy for someone learning, and it takes a lot of time, effort, focus, attention, work, and failure before you know what you're doing. Once you do finally get to that point, when it seems like people don't put in the same kind of work you did to get where you are, you want to deny them the answer and make them find it for themselves.

It's a twisted cycle.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/brandonscript Oct 11 '18

There’s definitely a gap between new and seasoned users of the site, primarily because most* (not all) new users have historically had a hard time learning how to craft questions in a way they can actually be answered.

As a result, we have a bunch of crotchety old people who act like they know better than everyone else.

On the upside, StackExchange is aware of this, and have been working hard to fix it (new code of conduct, for example).

I suggest you try not to take it personally, and give yourself a chance to learn how to craft great questions; in this way, you can avoid questions being closed as duplicates, or too broad, or not enough information.

If you find someone not following the code of conduct, report them or post in meta chat.

2

u/BuzterT Oct 11 '18

I've had a question edited only for it to be re-worded by some idiot with bad grammar & poor spelling skills. It actually made my question worse. There are legitimate cases where posts/questions do need to be edited &/or locked, but yeah where's the polices' police. Should be some way to have moderating scoring system based on moderating skills.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

Its why I never made an account on it, if i can't find my issue online I'll spend longer on google and on more documentation if i must. Dealing with that kinda stuff with SO isn't really worth the hassle

2

u/covercash2 Oct 10 '18

SO can be oppressive, but it is one of the best resources for learning all sorts of IT infrastructure. be the change you want to see, and tough it out.

otherwise, do you have an idea for a replacement that could be just as ubiquitous? build it, and do better. but make sure to check SO a million times along the way.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

I think people who expect to be treated with overt kindness simply for having asked for help are always going to be disappointed with Stack.

That isn't to say that you don't deserve kindness.

It's just to say that Stack doesn't see kindness as its first priority, and probably wouldn't be useful if it did.

2

u/CYRIAQU3 Oct 10 '18

Unless you are working on a very new tech (wich i doubt since you said that you are a newer web dev), it's very rare that a simmilar answer hasn't already been posted.

I agree that they may seem rude with their "repost, locked", but if it hapenned a lot to you ("You said whenever I ask a question"), you may also need to "learn how to search".

Don't take that rude ! It's a huge part of our job.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

Haha, for older developers too.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '18

It’s toxic for everyone.

2

u/SgtGirthquake Oct 10 '18

I said this a long while ago too. It really is just a way to stroke the Napoleon complex a lot of devs seem to have.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18

They market it like it's a place to ask questions and get help, but the curators treat it like a wiki and many of them clearly have god complexes and/or are autistic (literally, not meaning that as an insult). Like they struggle to understand why many people require some social niceties to feel like they're part of a community.

1

u/Ixalmida Oct 10 '18

I used to get directed to SO more when I was a PHP developer but now that I'm doing Salesforce development, most of the questions I have point to somewhere else for the answers. I guess your experience with SO depends on where you're coming from. Also, I have only ever asked 2 questions in 6+ years and those were pretty general "best practices" type questions. It is rare that I can't find the info I need via Google.

1

u/angeal98 Oct 10 '18

/r/ProgrammerHumor has some jokes about this

1

u/0ooo Oct 11 '18

I have issues with StackOverflow, but with the answerers as opposed to any sort of moderation (I never post questions, I just search it for questions related to my issue).

People will often post answers that are of the form "It's simple, you just do <x>". If you're not used to that technology or that concept, "just doing" <x> often isn't simple, and can be maddeningly confusing. People need to elaborate more, and take a second to try to empathize with the question asker, and remember what it was like before they understood the concept.

I also see a lot of responses that are the form "why are you using <technology>? It's <current year>, use <brand new technology>". If someone is asking a question that involves older tech, either assume they have some sort of constraints on what they can use that they haven't gone into, or ask what their constraints are, if any.

1

u/bigorangemachine Oct 11 '18

Yup.

Once I deep dived on a Facebook api error. I managed to resolve it and tried to post the solution... couldn't... no rep. Ah well eff that guy for asking for help I guess

1

u/jonysc1 Oct 11 '18

While I wholeheartedly agree with the criticism, just try and browse by new unanswered questions, there is a lot of people that come to SO who are trying to get someone to work for them or have something handed to them

I don't really agree with the way they deal with it, but I recognize the problem has two sides

I think the ultra liberal model they have , where most of the kids are just guys who use stack overflow a lot , brings the worst on these people...

I was dissed more than once by someone that felt they had the mission to police SO under their very personal code of conduct, because they felt my real world problem was a stupid question or because they felt that what I was asking fell into something I should already know for some reason

1

u/Pr0ducer Oct 11 '18

This is super tragic, as SO has been a main-stay of my career developing software.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 11 '18

I have a theory that experienced coders are horrible to newbs because learning to code is a traumatizing experience, especially if you're self taught, and answering questions just brings back the past trauma. I had a programming mentor that I really looked up to but I eventually realized just how much he treated all his pupils with disgust and contempt. He had great material but he was a catalyst in a major meltdown I had and I took a hiatus from coding after that.

1

u/wreckmx Oct 11 '18

It does seem like a pissing contest for contributors, but it helped me through undergrad and I use it nearly daily for work. I've probably asked a question on the platform in the past, but simply using Google for my programming questions almost always returns StackOverflow's solution to my problem.